Once Upon A Time WW Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
bbeventer said:
Oh yea, I was just pointing out that I think someone else made the final blow. Put the nail in the coffin, before someone killed SOV who was trying to kill swings.
Click to expand...

Definitely qualifies as an interesting night.

The only remaining player from SOV's list that we have no role info or vouching for (now that swings is dead and LIS roleclaimed as huntsman...for the third time) is dyachei, so she's the logical choice for Cora. lynch dyachei.
 
Agree, EC. She has to be Cora.

lynch Dyachei
 
NStarz said:
Agree, EC. She has to be Cora.

lynch Dyachei
Click to expand...

Ditto. lynch Dyachei

Ok, everyone pay attention, because this doesn't happen often.

SOV: I'm sorry for hounding you about being a villager-supporting neutral. Turns out you were telling the truth and I was wrong.

And as far as who killed swings, my read on the write-up is that both SOV and arrow-person did. I think it was just the mods way of resolving both of them attacking swings on the same night, and either would have succeeded.
 
lynch Dyachie its the only thing that makes sense right now.
 
Current lynch tally:
dyachei 4 - EC, NStarz, LIS, bbeventer

Votes: 4/14.

Deadline 2 PM EST.
 
Lynch dyachei.

I agree that we're looking for Cora, and that she's the most likely candidate, but we also know we're looking for 2 converts.
 
cuitlamiztli said:
Lynch dyachei.

I agree that we're looking for Cora, and that she's the most likely candidate, but we also know we're looking for 2 converts.
Click to expand...

How do we know there are 2? There could have been a failed wolf attack...
 
Lynch dyachei

Have a few other suspicions, but dyachei is at the top of my list. If I recall in the show, once you are dead, the person controlling your heart no longer has power, so maybe it was some kind of mercy killing of FML to prevent her from betraying her group
 
LetItSnow said:
Uh. I just realized something.

If we assume Fancy died because Swings died ....

.... that means there was no wolf kill last night.
Click to expand...
If that's the case, and we don't assume artistic license for the writeup, shouldn't the player whose heart swings ripped out tonight also have died? Unless she can only "hold" one heart at a time... which would indicate that fancy was a wolf kill.

Was anyone notified that their heart was ripped out?
 
Current lynch tally:
dyachei 6 - EC, NStarz, LIS, bbeventer, cuit, tuckervet

Votes: 6/14.

Deadline 2 PM EST. Lynch will remain open until plurality is reached and a defense is given.
 
tuckervet said:
If her heart was stolen, she would be controlled by someone else as long as she was still alive
Click to expand...
Okay. But she is still listed as black on the dead player list, so I'm inclined to think that this heart being stolen business = more of a vote or power being controlled deal than her switching allegiances like you seemed to be implying.

Of course, this is all speculation unless someone else did get their heart stolen last night and can tell us what that means.
 
*****************
epic. This was soooooo much fun
GO WOLVES!!!

images


*******************
 
cuitlamiztli said:
Okay. But she is still listed as black on the dead player list, so I'm inclined to think that this heart being stolen business = more of a vote or power being controlled deal than her switching allegiances like you seemed to be implying.
Click to expand...

Agreed, that's how I took that as well. I was feeling iffy about LIS after he blurted out inferences he made from SOV's post earlier... But I can't see why he would throw another wolf under the bus like that either by claiming to be the huntsman (unless they together decided that swings was a lost cause, and LIS did that to take suspicion away from himself or something... But I think that's overthinking it)

So... ***lynch dyachei***
 
LetItSnow said:
Ok, everyone pay attention, because this doesn't happen often.

SOV: I'm sorry for hounding you about being a villager-supporting neutral. Turns out you were telling the truth and I was wrong.
Click to expand...

*********************
Actually it is getting to be quite the habit for you, isn't it?

:laugh:

**********************
 
AlorsOnDanse said:
Ill wait for dyachei to explain themselves.
Click to expand...

this is an interesting way for you to post it, since Dyachei PMed you and me yesterday to role reveal... A little bit of a late gasp, but, the role is one that is on SOV's list, and as far as I know, know one else is claiming that role... does it mean it doesn't exist in the game? I dunno

Ugh, I know about 3/4ths of what the remaining people are claiming, and, of course, no one is claiming Cora.

I know who killed Rump last night. They seemed to be genuinely not a wolf, and actually had me ask around to several people if he should even do it... and there were mixed feels out there, some villagers I spoke with thought they should wait, others thought they should go for it... I left the decision in their hand while giving the towns opinions, and they decided to go all stab-y mcgee on Rump. I know someone can confirm that it was them that did it... I did mention that Rump was potentially doing something valuable for the villagers last night, but I admit that I was a bit skeptical of him. I'm glad we got the good deed from Rump BEFORE he was stabbed.

I think I also know who "else" killed Swings last night... makes sense for their role title, albeit they never told me their role skill. I agree, though, that she was going to have died from just Rump it seems...

I just woke up and need to look over the lists of people. Someone is using a bogus alibi and we need to see through it. I think it might be time to make a player roster
 
Ugh, I'm not Cora. I'm milah. And I've been AWOL this game (and I'm sorry mods) because real life decided to step in and suck. It's been hectic to stay caught up and work and deal with the personal life so the game got away from me.

Anyway, I didn't trust SOV being on the villager side so I didn't want to out my role. But I'm not a wolf. And I have no clue who to lynch. I think we're being played by someone
 
unlynch dyachei
I'll have to think about this, may go back to this vote for now but willing to delay the plurality lynch and consider other options
 
Current lynch tally:
dyachei 8 - EC, NStarz, LIS, bbeventer, cuit, Minnerbelle, Hedgie, TRH

Votes: 8/14.

Plurality reached, defense given, you have until 10 AM EST to waffle.
 
Escalla said:
Current lynch tally:
dyachei 8 - EC, NStarz, LIS, bbeventer, cuit, Minnerbelle, Hedgie, TRH

Votes: 8/14.

Plurality reached, defense given, you have until 10 AM EST to waffle.
Click to expand...

mods, I'm asking for you to extend this because I don't think the majority of players will be back on by then. Again, I'm sorry I wasn't able to contribute more to this game but I want a chance to have other players see my defense
 
dyachei said:
mods, I'm asking for you to extend this because I don't think the majority of players will be back on by then. Again, I'm sorry I wasn't able to contribute more to this game but I want a chance to have other players see my defense
Click to expand...

I will give you an extra hour. Deadline extended to 11 AM EST
 
lynch minner

her's is definitely the most obscure and random role of those claimed, which makes me think it is the most likely to be an alibi... nothing concrete on this, but I wanted to get a vote in and while I'm not sure Milah would be in the game, she's probably more likely than Paige... will think about it, but looks like i'll be thinking about it more for the next lynch...:laugh:
 
Well, it definitely looks like killing SOV was a bad idea. He was right about swings this whole time......so I'm going to trust his list and lynch dyachei.

I'm not really convinced the Huntsman is good either, tbh.
 
thedrjojo said:
Oh, and Mods, that's soo not nice keeping EC in a group all by herself... she is all lonely there...
Click to expand...
Puppy-Dog-Eyes-s.jpg


thedrjojo said:
lynch minner

her's is definitely the most obscure and random role of those claimed, which makes me think it is the most likely to be an alibi... nothing concrete on this, but I wanted to get a vote in and while I'm not sure Milah would be in the game, she's probably more likely than Paige... will think about it, but looks like i'll be thinking about it more for the next lynch...:laugh:
Click to expand...

Based on Dwin's results about Minner, though, that role makes sense. I'm willing to accept it. Need to think a bit more on dyachei.
 
#### lynch LIS ####

For now. Should get a brief chance to check in before deadline.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Current lynch tally:
dyachei 8 - EC, NStarz, LIS, bbeventer, cuit, Minnerbelle, Hedgie, FF
Minnerbelle 1 - rojo
LIS 3 - dyachei, TRH, Dwin

Votes: 12/14. Roll Call: Alors, tuckervet

Plurality reached, defense given, you have until 11 AM EST to waffle.
 
**********
I appreciate you all killing Henry's crazy adoptive mother...but now he's all alone! ::sniff::

It's ok, Kid....Operation Cobra all the way!

Can you tell death bores me? wld...where are those pretty gifs you were posting? 😍

**********
 
thedrjojo said:
any info on the request I made yesterday?
Click to expand...

If you mean the most recent question/suggestion, there was some info but nothing strong. Nothing to make me change my vote, so I'm going to follow your lead and lynch minnerbelle
 
I'm sticking with my vote for dyachei. I don't think Milah is a very sympathetic character anyway, and unlikely to be included as a villager.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
SDN Fairgrounds - 10th Annual Noob WW Game
33 34 35 36 37
Replies
2K
Views
17K
indysadventures
indysadventures
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
53K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
38K
Clem J
Clem J
WildZoo
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
2 3 4 5
Replies
214
Views
13K
indysadventures
indysadventures
kaydubs
Melee WW Game Thread-April 2024
27 28 29 30 31
Replies
2K
Views
31K
Sandy Dikson
Sandy Dikson
Top