PaWWsta - The Game that WWrites Itself (Game Thread)

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
I read the response as Veggie incorrectly thought samac was asking her whether matt (as a noob) would come onto thread and say what he said (whereas it seems like samac was asking whether Veggie - as a noob - would come onto thread with a potential packmate matt and say that quote).
Yeah I'm just not sure how she interpreted the packmate portion of the question then?
 
I mean, agree to disagree. D1 I voted for psv for being fluffy/also didn't like the fluff votes but didn't really explicitly state it until D2, D2 I posted my entire theory and susses based on the fluff train (it is literally only D2 this game), D3 I almost threw my theory out of the window bc PSV was town and I thought miranda was town based on the seer (I did not read the spoiler for Tomas, whoops) until I started questioning the church statement. Miranda was not town so I considered it again. My susses from D2 were still high but I found that veggie repeated a phrase exactly the same as miranda very incriminating. Then I died N3.
You missed my point, you didn't have the same "fluff voters = sus, not fluff voters = not sus" weirdness that you have here with matt. I get that your major suspicions started with the fluff voters, but the remainder of your reads were more nuanced and addressed more than just how players had treated fluff (see: reads on genny and zuri that I mentioned earlier).

That was at least how you presented them, I can't confirm or deny what was going on in your head at the time, just what was stated on thread.
 
Maybe I should’ve told shorty to sub me in at end of day after all if I was just gonna sub into a dead man walking.

I just got really excited about making my joke upon entry. 😅
You could have made it upon entry into the thread anyway lol since the thread is locked there wouldn't have been a bunch of posts in between the announcement of your arrival and your first post
 
Again, that's still falling into the all or nothing category which hasn't occurred in any of the games you've played.
I mean, imo, it happens all the time and goes unnoticed. I went to go look for evidence last game and already found evidence D1. Of the last game, no slithers voted for zuri D1 despite there being 6 votes. In fact, all the slithers either voted for genny or fluff. It's not the same exact analogy, but like wolves do group up sometimes & avoid doing things they think may make them look sus. Which in this case, I feel like defending matt would make them look sus due to the overwhelming feeling of the thread, whether matt is village or wolf.

Also, again, I'm not saying it's impossible, I just find it very unlikely compared to the other option (throwing sus on matt with everyone else).
 
I mean, imo, it happens all the time and goes unnoticed. I went to go look for evidence last game and already found evidence D1. Of the last game, no slithers voted for zuri D1 despite there being 6 votes. In fact, all the slithers either voted for genny or fluff. It's not the same exact analogy, but like wolves do group up sometimes & avoid doing things they think may make them look sus. Which in this case, I feel like defending matt would make them look sus due to the overwhelming feeling of the thread, whether matt is village or wolf.

Also, again, I'm not saying it's impossible, I just find it very unlikely compared to the other option (throwing sus on matt with everyone else).
I know that's untrue from memory alone. I distinctly remember that Poppy had voted for zuri. Not sure if more wolves were but that's at least one.
 
I know that's untrue from memory alone. I distinctly remember that Poppy had voted for zuri. Not sure if more wolves were but that's at least one.
*FINAL* Day 1: What Even Is A Vote Tally?

Santy ()
AM ()
chic ()
Nate (1) - mothy
Clem ()
PSV (2) - SOV, Wondalfy
SOV ()
Wiisp ()
genny (8) - DubZ, Clem, alley, PlumPoppy, Santy, wiisp, Nate, fluff
zuri (6) - SAR, Veggie, AM, genny, CaptNemo, zuri
Veggie ()
April (1) - Vis
fluff (5) - Zenge, PSV, April, chic, miranda920
mothy ()

23/24

missing: @HW_88

Vote closed at 9pm CST
 
I know that's untrue from memory alone. I distinctly remember that Poppy had voted for zuri. Not sure if more wolves were but that's at least one.
I double checked and it was Miranda, not Poppy apparently. My point still stands though.
 
Why are you only going by the final tally not not by the post and votes made throughout the cycle? Also, how is this doing anything but prove my point? The wolves were clearly not acting like a monolith even per the final tally.
 
Why are you only going by the final tally not not by the post and votes made throughout the cycle? Also, how is this doing anything but prove my point? The wolves were clearly not acting like a monolith even per the final tally.
Sigh I already explained why I find it very unlikely, not impossible. I already said it's not a perfect analogy, but sometimes wolves *do* do similar things. They're not a monolith, I already said they voted genny and fluff. By the end of day, none of them voted zuri. That was just my point. It's not perfect, I do not care it was not perfect. I don't have the energy to search the entirety of multiple games to try to support this point.

If they don't do similar things/have strats, then there is never a point in trying to find a wolf partner pattern, which I think is a little silly. In the noob game, they all decided to split their votes and avoid wagons, and zuri even said at the end that it was indeed a strat of theirs. I know it was the noob game. But I feel like strats are part of the game, the wolves are a team, are they not? And generally they try to not look sus. I don't think it's a stretch, with only literally 3 people left in the game who didn't sus matt (with me included, and I know I'm village, so literally 2 from my perspective), to maybe think it's more likely they would sus matt and "go with the flow."
 
Sigh I already explained why I find it very unlikely, not impossible. I already said it's not a perfect analogy, but sometimes wolves *do* do similar things. They're not a monolith, I already said they voted genny and fluff. By the end of day, none of them voted zuri. That was just my point. It's not perfect, I do not care it was not perfect. I don't have the energy to search the entirety of multiple games to try to support this point.
A wolf literally voted zuri though. And wolves were defending and shading different people not as a monolith. Like Santy defending fluff while Miranda and Zenge shaded her on D1, for instance.
If they don't do similar things/have strats, then there is never a point in trying to find a wolf partner pattern, which I think is a little silly. In the noob game, they all decided to split their votes and avoid wagons, and zuri even said at the end that it was indeed a strat of theirs. I know it was the noob game. But I feel like strats are part of the game, the wolves are a team, are they not? And generally they try to not look sus. I don't think it's a stretch, with only literally 3 people left in the game who didn't sus matt (with me included, and I know I'm village, so literally 2 from my perspective), to maybe think it's more likely they would sus matt and "go with the flow."
Where did I say no strategy was being used? Hint: I didn't. The wolves are a team, not a monolith who have to have identical reads and votes.

I watched the noob game. They often stacked to save partners. They even powerwolfed. A lot did openly suspicious things and got away with it to win the entire game. So no, still no evidence of this scenario you're describing.

Tell me right here, what evidence you have that wolves could not have both shaded and defended matt?

Also, are you familiar with WIFOM?
 
Tell me right here, what evidence you have that wolves could not have both shaded and defended matt?
I don't. It's impossible. I'm just saying what I think is unlikely/likely that I have explained. so many times. you obviously don't agree. That's fine, but I don't see the point in asking me things that are unprovable when we haven't even flipped a single wolf to inform our hunches.

Also, are you familiar with WIFOM?
I know what it means based on the definition given in the noob game.
 
I don't. It's impossible. I'm just saying what I think is unlikely/likely that I have explained. so many times. you obviously don't agree. That's fine, but I don't see the point in asking me things that are unprovable when we haven't even flipped a single wolf to inform our hunches.
Then if it's impossible, why are you not seriously considering it? I'm asking you to prove it because you said you've seen wolves monolith. I already proved you haven't.
I know what it means based on the definition given in the noob game.
Do you know how it could be applied to your theory?
 
Then if it's impossible, why are you not seriously considering it? I'm asking you to prove it because you said you've seen wolves monolith. I already proved you haven't.
I literally did not say that. Because I think it is UNLIKELY, which is why my least sus is my least sus. I never said it was impossible.

I form a theory, test it, if it's wrong, I go back and adjust. So far, 2/4 of the initial least sus (I'm obviously going to include myself) are village.

Do you know how it could be applied to your theory?
just go ahead.
 
I literally did not say that. Because I think it is UNLIKELY, which is why my least sus is my least sus. I never said it was impossible.

I form a theory, test it, if it's wrong, I go back and adjust. So far, 2/4 of the initial least sus (I'm obviously going to include myself) are village.
How will you test it in time?
just go ahead.
What do you mean?
 
Oh ffs, you can’t just make up snacks. That’s how you end up with peanut butter pickles. I previously stated my reasoning for voting Clem:



At least try to do a little research, eh?
What made you choose Clem specifically?
 
I spent a fair amount of time trying to go to sleep thinking about sporty/Matt.

It’s going to take an act of god to convince me that that’s not a wolf. Sportys entrance to the thread just solidified it for me.
I don’t like the thought of voting for a fresh sub but it’s going to take an act of god to convince me that’s not a wolf and since she said she’s not invested yet I’m going to go on and do it.

Unyeet veggie
Yeet sporty
Something about this post spooks me
 
How will you test it in time?
The longer the game goes on, the more people flip, including wolves. Which will continually inform it. Currently, there is nothing to say otherwise for the theory.

What do you mean?
Honestly I was getting frustrated and figured you would explain it no matter what I said. But generally, the only thing I can think of would be of doing it to look sus so others wouldn't think they're a wolf because why would a wolf do something sus. which fine, but I still don't think it's as likely
 
The longer the game goes on, the more people flip, including wolves. Which will continually inform it. Currently, there is nothing to say otherwise for the theory.
That's not a guarantee. You've never seen a sweep before. You have to be ready to reevaluate with every misyeet that was unexpected.
Honestly I was getting frustrated and figured you would explain it no matter what I said. But generally, the only thing I can think of would be of doing it to look sus so others wouldn't think they're a wolf because why would a wolf do something sus. which fine, but I still don't think it's as likely
I still don't understand why you think it's unlikely.
 
Work earlier, quiz and class soon, also found out my pharmacy is out of my ADHD meds which is not great. I can be on later around 8 Central
Wow that was a speedy response. Okay I will be around to talk with you then...unfortunate that it'll only be an hour before close but such is life.
 
bring it banana man

yes, I said I was willing to wait when there was just the 3p comments, and later mentioned the echo-y posts later, but i was more interested in clem yesterday so it is what it is. today hasnt really changed, but i definitely dont see her as compatable with wonda, who I think is a more interesting vote for today.
mkg are you sure you aren't wolfing with Veggie :thinking:
 
I still don't understand why you think it's unlikely.
I've already explained it plenty. Either it makes sense or doesn't to you, it makes sense to me. :/

Also, I've never seen a sweep, that's correct. But again, considering there are only 2 people in my "didn't sus matt" besides myself, I'll make adjustments as the game narrows/new information is revealed.
 
I've already explained it plenty. Either it makes sense or doesn't to you, it makes sense to me. :/

Also, I've never seen a sweep, that's correct. But again, considering there are only 2 people in my "didn't sus matt" besides myself, I'll make adjustments as the game narrows/new information is revealed.
Can you remind me who these two are? I've forgotten in all the back and forth.
 
Can you remind me who these two are? I've forgotten in all the back and forth.
mkg and genny. And it's less of "didn't sus matt" as "defended matt in some way." SAR was as well but they're dead
 
also friendly reminder I will now be unavailable until 8 pm (unless my class ends early, which it does sometimes)
 
Top