StardeWW Valley - GAME THREAD

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Yes. Exactly the 3 of us are wolfing together and you caught us when she flips.
This feels manipulative, Shelty.

Also, honestly she doesn’t feel right. The vanilla claim doesn’t help.
Vanilla claim don't help. What is a wolf to do? I do feel less good about sporty being wolf after seeing end of D1, bc it feels like beating a dead horse (groan). But she still feels the most wolfy bc of a post I have yet to get to (I will post when i get there)

PSV does feel like a noob statement more than manipulation.
I just wolfed with her, felt manipulative.
Hmmm
PShelty has felt weird but I've never seen them as not a wolf so I wasn't going for them tonight (also I apologize Shelty I forgot your pronouns >.<)


Let it be known that I'm very confident you're a villager.
I need to hear more before I can take this on reads alone. I'm not fishing for PR info
Looks Like We Better Get To Work - D1 Tally

D0221FA5-0959-4BA9-B434-FF6669AAF944.png


samac ()
DubZ (1) - Bob
genny ()
Zenge (1) - genny
AM ()
cubs ()
stoaty ()
Sporty (3) - Zenge, samac, Dana
kdswg (3) - AM, Sporty, PSV
Barky ()
Dana (5) - Barks, True, kdswg, stoat, Dubz
True (1) - samac
Bob (1) - cubs

@Dana_May_B you are in the lead

14/14 voting
Missing: none

Vote closes at 9pm EST (8pm CST/6pm fantasyland) on Thursday, 2/3 (~1 MINUTES)
Wow. 5 people sure that neutral feel person was the right vote. Last minute waffle by Dubz (I guess she wouldn't do that as a wolf). I don't see how Dana was more sus than sporty. I guess I had confirmation bias since I knew who was voted off. I'm not sure what to take away.
Why are you so damn sure on sporty?

Misread her SUPER wrong last game so I spent the entire rest of the game in deadchat noticing her more than anyone else (out of guilt). I have a better feel for her than most of you.

I could be wrong but I don't think she's a wolf this game.
I get you feel like you can read her better than you can read other people. But surely you don't mean you can read her better than people that have played with her 20+ times??
 
I get you feel like you can read her better than you can read other people. But surely you don't mean you can read her better than people that have played with her 20+ times??
No, I just meant I have a better feel for her than I had for other people. A lot of my posts were rushed last night, things got a little hectic.
 
Finding it a little... is the term "pingy"? That Bob coasted through Day 1 almost invisible and has now shown up to toss lots of judgement around.

Though I guess a wolf would have been around last night in case they needed to defend themselves?
 
Finding it a little... is the term "pingy"? That Bob coasted through Day 1 almost invisible and has now shown up to toss lots of judgement around.

Though I guess a wolf would have been around last night in case they needed to defend themselves?
Irl Bob is a super busy human. In another game, AceHydro and WorthlessO2 were under constant suspicion for needing to be at work and popping up at odd times, but it matched their schedules. And indeed, they were village.
 
Finding it a little... is the term "pingy"? That Bob coasted through Day 1 almost invisible and has now shown up to toss lots of judgement around.

Though I guess a wolf would have been around last night in case they needed to defend themselves?
Activity NAI
 
Irl Bob is a super busy human. In another game, AceHydro and WorthlessO2 were under constant suspicion for needing to be at work and popping up at odd times, but it matched their schedules. And indeed, they were village.
Ah, that makes sense.
 
Irl Bob is a super busy human. In another game, AceHydro and WorthlessO2 were under constant suspicion for needing to be at work and popping up at odd times, but it matched their schedules. And indeed, they were village.
How are you reading True?
 
Did ya murder me wolves?
If so I wish I could see wolf chat as the results roll in.
😈
Hmmm
Do I get to guess?
we are waiting (more genny posts is always good)
Still reading this as casual purchase of hookers. Coveted, coveted hookers.
You're doing it wrong. You aren't supposed to purchase hoes. Hookers, yes. Hoes, no.
I did the math too.
I did the math as well. I came up with.... I am not going to live long enough to recoup my investments
 
How are you reading True?
Goodness, well, he seems like a dorky villager to me. I'm more concerned that if Dubz were a wolf, she'd pocket me via good vibes with True.

I'm wildly swinging between "is Dubz a wolf? She would be mutually exclusive with Sporty. If Sporty's a wolf Dubz isn't a wolf. If Sporty's a villager, is Dubz a wolf? Her interaction with AM felt v/v."
 
The comment that really pinged Samac, @Zenge142 , is NAI to me-- the one where True jokes that she must have a PR. I was thinking it to myself as I was reading the thread, it seemed pretty clear from her "huh? But this is role madness" certainty. That, or she's wolfy and fishing for PRs. But I'm not putting money on that second one.
 
Irl Bob is a super busy human. In another game, AceHydro and WorthlessO2 were under constant suspicion for needing to be at work and popping up at odd times, but it matched their schedules. And indeed, they were village.
Thanks and true. But I am the first to say you should push and vote low posters. Wolves like to fly under the radar. I try to contribute when I can. Not making end of day votes is not the norm for me, but likely will be more normal going forward. I only play on my phone at night and can't keep up on phone
 
The comment that really pinged Samac, @Zenge142 , is NAI to me-- the one where True jokes that she must have a PR. I was thinking it to myself as I was reading the thread, it seemed pretty clear from her "huh? But this is role madness" certainty. That, or she's wolfy and fishing for PRs. But I'm not putting money on that second one.
Yeah, I probably shouldn't have said it in case the wolves weren't thinking on the same wavelength, but a vanillager wouldn't be so surprised by someone else saying that they're vanilla.
 
Remember how badly True softed being a bomb in the last game? He's going to chase me around for putting this in the thread but:

I'm very sure that when True wolfs, he's going to impulsively say something equally loud/obviously fake on the thread and it'll be like "huh, you are a wolf, aren't you."
 
Yeah, I probably shouldn't have said it in case the wolves weren't thinking on the same wavelength,
Yeah, if you are village, just because you catch something like that doesn't mean the wolves did, so it's better to just leave it. Who knows though, maybe Samac is a bomb and it was all part of her master plan.
 
the only thoughts going through my head in those final 30 seconds after stoat's vote were whether or not i should role reveal. i figured it would have been too late to change any votes anyways. im just so frustrated that my play has to come down to a tie AGAIN. this is literally what i wanted to avoid.
Just noted the change in Dana's profile pic!!!!! ROFL
 
Yeah, if you are village, just because you catch something like that doesn't mean the wolves did, so it's better to just leave it. Who knows though, maybe Samac is a bomb and it was all part of her master plan.
Clearly she's going to be the Alpha Villager
 
but Zenges, my french fries 🥺
Covid is causing supply chain problems Dubz. From the high and mighty microchip farmer, to the lowly Billionaires using minimum wage workers to build rockets to get them off this plant, we're all making sacrifices...supposedly.
 
Does she? Does she really?
Here’s some quotes I pulled from last game:
Solid analysis and contributions. Explanations for her votes are more fleshed out.

After ISOing her posts this game there’s nothing really similar.


What about these sound the same to you? I feel there’s a pretty stark contrast between one and the other both in terms of analysis of content and reasoning for vote placement.
Ok I read these and also looked at the rest of sporty's posts from this game. I see the difference you're talking about. I guess I'm just not sure if it's a slam dunk or if it's because she showed up relatively later in the WW day here. But I could see the argument that she still should have been able to make the more analytical posts from what she did read. Idk. Some of her frustrated posts feel more like village Sporty to me. She didn't get as mad at me as she did in Casino. Brain going in circles.
 



Night 1

“Keeper of the sacred cha-…you get the point.”

Many townsfolk rushed to the store, hoping to beat out their fellows on purchases of items. One person was particularly triumphant and full of glee. She filled out the order form, ignoring the glares and disappointed looks she received.

Orders poured in for different crops (seems everyone is an aspiring farmer! EXCELLENT!) and the store clerks were kept hopping well into the night.

Most returned home to sleep to restore their much needed energy but a whispered conversation or two could be heard. Or were those crickets?

The sun rose (a little slower than the townsfolk might have preferred cause the narrators seemed to be all a bustle). The townspeople gathered to trade discussions about their crops. An exclamation of concern came from one. "I was just on -- and I saw -- and -- please, just come quickly!!"

Only several yards from the store, a large pit had appeared overnight. At the bottom was a still figure. Despite efforts of the crowd to wake her, there was no response.

Dead is
@samac, a village conversion protector.

1643990727525.png


“There are many mysteries around us. You must be patient if you wish to discover them.”

12 players remain.
1. @potentialsheltervet
2. @Animal Midwife
4. @kdswg
5. @Zenge142
6. @genny
7. @WildZoo
11. @Truenamer
13. @Barkley13
14. @SportPonies
15. @cubsrule4e
16. @bluestoat
18. @BobLoblaw78

Sent for a train ride out of town:
3. @Dana_May_B, village jailer
8. @samac, village conversion protector


It is now Day 2. Vote closes at 9pm EST (8pm CST/6pm fantasyland) on Saturday, 2/5/2022.

2 days of spring remain.
 
Last edited:
So basically nothing is safe and I should vote with my feels *nods to self* Perfect takeaway!
I default to: If I am uncertain (always) take out the lowposters (unless one of them is Bob)
also I like how I said I had several people I didn't want to yeet.

....and we yeeted one of them.

I know. I'm just sad about it.
icky
I should have self-voted if I'm gonna have to deal with this from you for the rest of the game.
ickier
Ah I just realized that I'm destined to suffer until endgame now since I'm outted vanilla.
The ickyest. This was the one post that made me want to contingency yeet.
 



Night 1

“Keeper of the sacred cha-…you get the point.”

Many townsfolk rushed to the store, hoping to beat out their fellows on purchases of items. One person was particularly triumphant and full of glee. She filled out the order form, ignoring the glares and disappointed looks she received.

Orders poured in for different crops (seems everyone is a aspiring farmer! EXCELLENT!) and the store clerks were kept hopping well into the night.

Most returned home to sleep to restore their much needed energy but a whispered conversation or two could be heard. Or were those crickets?

The sun rose (a little slower than the townsfolk might have preferred cause the narrators seemed to be all a bustle). The townspeople gathered to trade discussions about their crops. An exclamation of concern came from one. "I was just on -- and I saw -- and -- please, just come quickly!!"

Only several yards from the store, a large pit had appeared overnight. At the bottom was a still figure. Despite efforts of the crowd to wake her, there was no response.

Dead is
@samac, a village conversion protector.

View attachment 349578

“There are many mysteries around us. You must be patient if you wish to discover them.”

12 players remain.
1. @potentialsheltervet
2. @Animal Midwife
4. @kdswg
5. @Zenge142
6. @genny
7. @WildZoo
11. @Truenamer
13. @Barkley13
14. @SportPonies
15. @cubsrule4e
16. @bluestoat
18. @BobLoblaw78

Sent for a train ride out of town:
3. @Dana_May_B, village jailer
8. @samac, village conversion protector


It is now Day 2. Vote closes at 9pm EST (8pm CST/6pm fantasyland) on Saturday, 2/5/2022.

So that means conversion is in play. Nice. Real nice. The good news is that we can't fully eliminate anyone and all you fools are back to square one with me.
 
Ok I read these and also looked at the rest of sporty's posts from this game. I see the difference you're talking about. I guess I'm just not sure if it's a slam dunk or if it's because she showed up relatively later in the WW day here. But I could see the argument that she still should have been able to make the more analytical posts from what she did read. Idk. Some of her frustrated posts feel more like village Sporty to me. She didn't get as mad at me as she did in Casino. Brain going in circles.
That's the main issue I have, is the "analysis" is severely lacking and just doesn't have the cutting edge that drives fear into the hearts of wolves. She's frequently wishy-washy, giving herself room to backpedal. And like on the one hand in her defense, I'm not expecting her to have solid, concrete reads on anyone, (Cubs for example, since that got brought up), but there's a matter-of-factness in her cadence in Bowwling, that's lacking in her PbPa here.

Can you explain what you mean by the bolded?
 
The question remains, why did they not wait and convert samac???
Conversion could have some requirement or qualification; this game even has "seasons", so there could be all sorts of weird triggers for the wolves.
 
Top