The WWatering Hole Bar Grand Opening - Game Thread.

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Go where? To bed? Yeah. You can join me if you like, we can cuddle :kiss:
Don't fall for it! She's illegal in all 50 states!
giphy.gif
 
I am still in catch up mode, but I keep seeing people saying me and PbC are clear. Remember later in game that me and PBC are both prime conversion targets. By everyone saying that me and her are clear, you are pushing their hand to convert one of the two of us (and I am hoping this post pushes back against that)

For the record, I am one of the people saying STL is village (though the above post did sketch me out a bit).

But also for the record, and STL can attest to this (while probably swearing at me), I always encourage lynching him mid- to late-game. 🙂
 
PBC didn't exactly have an ability that would be useful for wolves to have, and especially since STL was so transparent about it, I currently firmly believe he's a village. Also if he was a wolf, it would be a stupid move to admit to having performed the rez, since if pbc went down as a wolf, stl would definitely be up for lynch.

Anyways, like STL said, if people keep putting them forward as strong village, one of them's going to end a convert. So this has no bearings on how I'll feel later when convert hunting, but I believe they're not originals.

I really DON'T like this "don't put someone forward as a villager, otherwise they'll be converted" crap.

If we don't settle on likely villagers, we're just going to spend all day going 'round and 'round and randomly lynching people because everyone stays suspect.

Yeah. Settling on someone as very likely village makes them a potential convert. But we HAVE to settle on people who are village, just as the opposite of settling on people who are likely wolf. It's how you lynch wolves.

So anyway. I strongly disagree with you and STL and this "you're making me/him a conversion target" thing. Sure, that's true, but it's irrelevant.
 
Replying to you and Cyndia in the one post.

In regards to what you said, I didn't comment on whatever anyone else said because I haven't read any posts from before my first post of the day. I'm on my phone at work so just checking lynch development and noticed that so wanted to say something.

I think giving people strong villager leaning from something decently superficial is a really good way to have them get completely ignored up until convert hunting begins and thus get bit in the butt if they are a wolf. Especially since STL would IMO completely do that as a wolf to get the clearance he now has. I'm not saying he's wolfy, I have him as village lean, I just think both him and PBC are getting a bigger buffer than the situation deserves.

OMG. Nobody - least of all me - is CLEARING STL. (Or PBC.)

It's all just shifting people into buckets of likeliness. How else do you want to narrow in on who is suspicious?

STL isn't just a CONVERT risk; he's an INITIAL WOLF risk. All I'm saying is that from what I see of his play, voting, etc., I think he's <most likely> an initial villager.

Man. People are making a lot more out of this than makes sense. Which sends red flags up to me.
 
And seeing as the day cycle lynch is most likely headed straight for me, I don't really think at this point anything I say will make that much difference, but just for the record:

* My waffle off Genny and onto Britzen, and then later saying I wasn't sure about Genny.

As I've already explained I had figured Genny was going to be a definite lynch either day 1 or day 2. I noticed a certain change in the cadence of Britzen's posts which pinged my interest. I decided to put a lynch vote there as a way of at least giving people something to discuss, maybe a 'heads up, Genny is the more likely wolf, but she's getting lynched anyway so for another lynch cycle perhaps consider looking here as well'. The only reason I said I wasn't sure about Genny (at that point at least) was because last time I had seen her as a wolf she fought really strongly to claim villager affiliation right up until the last moment, she wasn't seeming to do that this time so it did give me momentary pause. I say momentary because after some time to reflect I had decided on lynching her. And we all know how that went (ie I haven't quite perfected the art of sleep lynching, yet).

* My waffling onto and off of other people.

I don't consider throwing out some names and getting a lie of the land from others to be 'waffling on and off people', nor do I consider it stretching. I've already said my game style is to go by intuition/feels first off, and often that's not something I can point to specifically - so I put out some names, let people know what my gut instinct is leaning me more towards, and then try to listen to, and analyse what others have to say. So yes it will mean an ever shifting life of 'wolf leans' but I did eventually stay with the person who at least turned out to be neutral and was also leaning towards the other persons most likely to have been wolves in my opinion, and the opinion of others it seems.

If lynching me gets the focus back on finding wolves, then fine, I'll take it on the chin. But I'll just reiterate again you will be lynching a villager, who, if nothing else, is at least participating as much as possible, and trying to do their best (even if my game style is a little, shall we say 'unique'). I would also suggest that if I am lynched then analysing the voting patterns afterwards might prove useful. I am an easy target for a wolf to shift suspicion onto, and away from themselves, simply because my game style does mean I am hard to read sometimes, and people do end up defaulting me to wolf (wrongly, again, this game). I would be suspicious of anyone leading the vote against me for that very reason - shift focus onto an easy lynch target, and people aren't looking at wolves.

Here's the thing.

Fact) You yourself say you have a game style that leads people to think you are a wolf;

Fact) You claim to want strongly to find wolves on behalf of the village;

Therefore ...

Wouldn't you adjust your play style to be a little less sketchy?

... just a thought.

And, the whole "evaluate people who lynch me" thing seems like an awkward move intended to scare people from voting for you. Especially from someone who just got done openly stating that their play style engenders wolf suspicions.

I'm personally happy to break this egg and find out if Ceke is being truthful or not:

contingent lynch Ceke
 
Now do we think wolves would stay off of the snowy lynch, not knowing she was neutral? Or jump on it knowing that it would be an easy series of events to flip as sketchy?

I think some of both. I think it's too hard to evaluate - some wolves, if they could easily find their way there, would vote it. Some would just throw other safe votes. Some probably threw an early vote and didn't bother moving. It's just too hard to tell.

If I were wolfing, this would have been a place I might throw a vote for another wolf, especially one I thought was likely to die soonish. Why not - build a little cred for later, maybe.

Bottom line, I'm not sure you can make much of it. But if you do, I'm all ears.
 
You did well, and it did fit nicely with the story narrative. Basically most Absinthe historians now believe that the ban came about due to a concerted effort from Wine companies, because Absinthe was serious competition, especially in the wake of the Wine industry recovering from a major crop devastation in the late 19th century (if memory serves me correct). Basically there was some sort of blight, or disease, that almost completely wiped out the wine industries grape crops one year; wine became scarce and people began to drink Absinthe as an alternative - and Absinthe became popular, so popular in fact that when the wine industry was finally starting to recover, there sales were still way down because Absinthe was 'the thing' of the Belle Epoque era. Because of its popularity it was also open to unscrupulous distilling practices, where poorer people and those who were alcoholics could buy cheap, and heavily adulterated Absinthe, which did have an effect on people's health. The wine industry seized on these incidents and used them to push this idea, to the medical community at the time, and basically anyone who would listen, that Absinthe was basically this evil poison that sent people completely mad, and cause all manner of ills in the world. Eventually they succeeded in their smear campaign, and Absinthe was gradually banned around the world.

Off topic, but one of the best parts about SDN games is that there's always these little weird areas of expertise that people have that are interesting to read about.
 
Excuse my salt, I'm tired of reading about the ****ing urinary system and it's making me grumpy

Eh. No excuse needed, because I thought it was a decent response. I felt like Pippy's comments about STL's Cyndia post were ......... just a little over-the-top. Kinda trying to start something where there isn't anything. I certainly felt like STL's comments were unusually crystal clear.

Of course, maybe that's a red flag. I usually can't understand STL. 🙂
 
What is an absinthe fountain? A small (usually glass) receptacle on a stand, with usually 2-4 spigots on either side, that is designed to drip chilled water into the absinthe at a steady rate in order to open up the botanicals suspended in the high level of alcohol percentage - the water is usually dripped over 1-2 sugar cubes.

This is an Absinthe fountain in action, the change in colour and opacity of the Absinthe is known as 'the louche'.



This (the info) is so cool. I almost feel guilty for wanting to lynch you. But not quite.

I've never had absinthe. Sorta on my "I should try that some day" list, but I never remember.

So does the constant cold water infusion (plus the bit of sucrose with it) change the flavor of the drink as you progress through it??
 
Super post will follow much later.

Just an observation, that it seems like this will be a heavy PM mechanic game, based on the roster changes AND mod mentioned in thread items distributed; I know I have received a PM box.

When the game mechanics are skewed heavily for PMs, often the thread goes kinda quiet, and it becomes even more difficult than usual to know who is quiet on thread but still active in game, vs people who are totally silent overall. Plus there is an extra element of he said/she said.

Not sure what to do with this at all....
 
How I am grouping players in my mind. I want to hear more from Fern, raf, dreamz, rabbott, kam, dubz. In my mind the quietest.

I feel like there is a pack at work (of course!)

My likes are plentiful and randomish, as are some other players too, I'm sure. I just reread all the pages! Looking at votes, quotes, likes, it starts to feel as though there are "sides" - I just can't tell which is the village and which the pack.

"Snowy - St. George Absinthe - If used right, absinthe is the muse of many an artist! If used wrong....well lets just say there's a reason you were illegal for nearly a 100 years. Snowy was neutral until converted."

Begs more questions about Snowy's relationship with the pack. I don't know what triggers conversion in Snowy's case - is this a specific WW mechanic or something special to this game? Serious question, I don't know, guys.

Here's how I'm reading and grouping players so far based on interactions with each other:

Not much experience with, few reads on
2. @TheGirlWithTheFernTattoo
18. @raf2769
24. @mmmdreamerz

Not very active, reason to be suspicious
4. @rabbott1971 - Gives me weird feels, just a little off from past play. Less reactive.
6. @Kam325 - Sneaky. Quiet.

Ambivalent, reads like themself for the most part, village lean
9. @Ceke2002 - I know Ceke well in general on this board, but not in WW. Everything that people find sketch or take issue with her, I can't say isn't just Villager Ceke. She could easily fool me and I'd have egg on my face.
11. @finnickthedog - more active, more playful than last time they wolfed in a game I was in. Someone else said they tend to be a more serious wolf.
21. @LadyOtheFarm
14. @WildZoo
5. @PrincessButterCup - Always suspicious of a rez, but my feelz early on said villager, let's hope that stays true.

Wolfy feels, in cahoots? Or just agree a lot?
8. @SkiOtter
12. @SummerTheLynx
1. @LetItSnow
17. @allieh8607
7. @DVMDream

LIS, STL, and DVMD feel like they are all on the same "side." I can't tell if this is just play style, friendship, Team Village, or just the way that wolf logic will blend in with good villager thinking. Allieh and Skiotter's logic seems to line up with this group, but the direct interactions aren't there for me to say they are all working together.

Wolfy
15. @Cyndia - she's playing more than I usually see, but fluffy. Uncommitted villager vs wolf in fluffy sheep clothing.
22. @britzen - besides Ceke, someone thought Britzen's logic was the same as theirs when they wolf.
23. @PippyPony - has a certain razor sharp logic that is pinging wolf for me.

Why group like this? Knowing who genny and snowy are, go back and reread all the pages. See what your gut says.

19. @Animal Midwife - Southern Tier Pumking Beer
20. @tartesos - Malibu "Rum"
13. @genny - Jack Daniels Whiskey
16. @Jilary - Strongbow Cider
3. @SnowshoeDog143 - St. George Absinthe
 
night-club.jpg
Last night Trilt and I were called back to the bar for an emergency. Turns out the drinks decided to have a post-game party after all the people left, and turned the oven into a dance club. As the drinks danced and danced, none of them noticed the heat rising, and those who did just assumed it was the general heat of sweaty, steamy bodies writhing on the dancefloor. Before they knew it, the oven was at boiling temperature and someone slammed closed the door! They banged hard on the door until the glass broke through, but this also leaked the fire from the burners into the kitchen and soon the whole thing was ablaze. Most of the drinks made it out, but unfortunately one didn't make it out....

11. @finnickthedog - Water - a versatile and dependable drink who only brought out the best in other spirits, Finn could submit a name each night in hopes of converting someone to village.

On a different note looks like it finally happened folks! After weeks of will they? wont they? drama looks like last night was the tipping point in a very special relationship between @LadyOtheFarm and @Cyndia. We'll see how long they last 😉

We had a really sketchy guy come in for the soft opening last night, and he brought a bunch of beer coozies, which is cool I guess? But they're all branded with some new brand of cigarettes? IDK weird, but ALL BEERS ARE UNLYNCHABLE TODAY DUE TO BEER COOZIE ITEM.

~It is now Day 4 Lynch Close at 2200 EST~


Roster


I’ll come out for ONE drink
1. @LetItSnow

Shots? SHOTS!

2. @TheGirlWithTheFernTattoo
4. @rabbott1971
5. @PrincessButterCup - Maker's Mark Whiskey

Awkward First Date
6. @Kam325
7. @DVMDream

What Happened Last Night?
9. @Ceke2002
8. @SkiOtter
10. @Crayola227

I Knew I Should Have Stayed Home
14. @WildZoo
12. @SummerTheLynx

Winos
17. @allieh8607
18. @raf2769

Whiskey Aficionados
22. @britzen

Trying to Recreate the College Days
23. @PippyPony
24. @mmmdreamerz

Listen, Are We Going to DTR Now?
21. @LadyOtheFarm
15. @Cyndia


19. @Animal Midwife - Southern Tier Pumking Beer
20. @tartesos - Malibu "Rum"
13. @genny - Jack Daniels Whiskey
16. @Jilary - Strongbow Cider
3. @SnowshoeDog143 - St. George Absinthe
11. @finnickthedog - Water
 
Okay seriously, did someone write my number on the bathroom stall or something? I keep getting these anonymous gifs, and they're getting slightly more and more creepy....

33wxxz4.jpg


fw6jch.jpg


2i8k6yu.jpg
 
So, just to clarify something about my ask-a-mod results from yesterday -- it looks like no lupine conversions after all, because of Finn's role. The message I got back kind of implied that it was making people good, but I didn't really think that could be a thing, so I chalked it up to mod flair.

But, that maybe means we did start with a higher number of bad guys than I thought. (Closer to 5 woofs instead of 4).
 
Was going to quote Crayola but realized everyone is tagged in her post, so am not quoting just in case that spams everyone.

Ok, just want to say that I get the paranoia thing to a degree, but personally tend to play it up a little bit for reasons that dubz called out (and for lulz). If this post is not an exaggeration, this is a little much. You have no one who you feel is acting villa? Really? Not trying to say this is woofy in origin or anything, just...woah.
 
I am interested in what blocking mechanisms may or may not be in play, because the only night we've had a double kill is the night we also had the rez. Makes sense to have the rez on night one, but I think it is possibly a little odd that there was the double kill on the same night. Before people flip their **** at me for fishing...not trying to out any village roles. But I am genuinely interested in whether anyone was blocked last night (or has been straight up blocked at all, actually).
 
So, just to clarify something about my ask-a-mod results from yesterday -- it looks like no lupine conversions after all, because of Finn's role. The message I got back kind of implied that it was making people good, but I didn't really think that could be a thing, so I chalked it up to mod flair.

But, that maybe means we did start with a higher number of bad guys than I thought. (Closer to 5 woofs instead of 4).

What was your exact question and results yesterday for the conversion question? I'm too lazy to find your post right now, but from what I remember you said there would be 1 conversion possible, and I feel like your info is false (or you're lying) if finns role could convert things, and if the neutral role could be converted.
 
What was your exact question and results yesterday for the conversion question? I'm too lazy to find your post right now, but from what I remember you said there would be 1 conversion possible, and I feel like your info is false (or you're lying) if finns role could convert things, and if the neutral role could be converted.
I was able to ask the mods 2 questions last night (seems like someone bought me a double! 😉😉)

I asked:
What is the ratio of players per faction in this game?
And
What is the maximum number of affiliation changes allowed in this game

The answers I got back were kinda drunk, but basically said:
- the ratio is 1/5 (aka 20%), with one chaos and one neutral
- there is one conversion
 
***********************************************************************
The Dead's Unofficial Lynch Tally

Cyndia (1) - Pippy
rabbott (1) - Ceke
Ceke (1) - LIS

3/18
lynch close in ~ 13 hours
***********************************************************************
 
What was your exact question and results yesterday for the conversion question? I'm too lazy to find your post right now, but from what I remember you said there would be 1 conversion possible, and I feel like your info is false (or you're lying) if finns role could convert things, and if the neutral role could be converted.
Yup would definitely like to see a response to this. Seems very sketch.
 
Mod results from last night made it seem that someone was maybe attempting to kill me last night but I was protected? Not sure, here is the snippet from results:

"Its a good thing too, because you get the ominous feeling somebody was watching you. You should probably thank who ever convinced you to go to another bar, but unfortunately you blacked out and forgot who."

A couple of things aren't adding up with cyndia/Dubz, and I want to figure out if it's because of the players or some misinterpretation from the mods. So I may be going in one of those two directions today...
 
What was your exact question and results yesterday for the conversion question? I'm too lazy to find your post right now, but from what I remember you said there would be 1 conversion possible, and I feel like your info is false (or you're lying) if finns role could convert things, and if the neutral role could be converted.
Yup would definitely like to see a response to this. Seems very sketch.
Did you consider the possibility that Finn could ONLY convert the neutral OR chaos, hence there is no contradiction to my info at all? Or are we going to immediately jump to me being dodgeball?

Honestly, converting one of the third parties would make a lot more sense than her being able to convert something lupine to something town.

The results I got were super drunk -- it was pretty hard to decipher what was being said. I believe we're not allowed to quote mod PMs at all, otherwise I would copy/paste and let you try to figure it out.

And I'm on my phone, so no -- I am not going to do other people's legwork for them and dig up my original post right now. (EDIT: thanks, Ski)

Believe me or don't, but consider that it would be somewhat stupid for me to share ask-a-mod results at ALL if I was a baddie -- which is one of the things I pointed out when my manatee was getting lynched for it. Like seriously, you both think the gains of a move like that would outweigh the risks?

Side eyeing dubz pretty damn hard right now for jumping there, despite having more ticks for her in the trustworthy column based off of the genny lynch.

(Sorry for the grump; just got utterly destroyed by my physio exam and am a little reactive right now).
 
Did you consider the possibility that Finn could ONLY convert the neutral OR chaos, hence there is no contradiction to my info at all? Or are we going to immediately jump to me being dodgeball?

Honestly, converting one of the third parties would make a lot more sense than her being able to convert something lupine to something town.

The results I got were super drunk -- it was pretty hard to decipher what was being said. I believe we're not allowed to quote mod PMs at all, otherwise I would copy/paste and let you try to figure it out.

And I'm on my phone, so no -- I am not going to do other people's legwork for them and dig up my original post right now.

Believe me or don't, but consider that it would be somewhat stupid for me to share ask-a-mod results at ALL if I was a baddie -- which is one of the things I pointed out when my manatee was getting lynched for it. Like seriously, you both think the gains of a move like that would outweigh the risks?

Side eyeing dubz pretty damn hard right now for jumping there, despite having more ticks for her in the trustworthy column based off of the genny lynch.

(Sorry for the grump; just got utterly destroyed by my physio exam and am a little reactive right now).
Hey Pip, don't ignore my follow up post 😛
I could see one way it might make sense but would like to hear what Pip says first 🙂
I'm chill with it. Your explanation is what I was thinking after rereading finn's role description.
 
Hey Pip, don't ignore my follow up post 😛

I'm chill with it. Your explanation is what I was thinking after rereading finn's role description.
"Hey look at this thing I said to hedge my stance on this so I look less suspect if it gets explained with reasonable logic"?

Nope, didn't ignore that, either. 😉
 
"Hey look at this thing I said to hedge my stance on this so I look less suspect if it gets explained with reasonable logic"?

Nope, didn't ignore that, either. 😉
🙄
More like "Oh I posted that first thing before I really thought it through, now I've thought it through but I'm not gonna answer a question directed at Pippy for her."
 
No need to be so snarky, I was just asking for clarification - I didn't consider Finn converting the neutral, but that makes sense (I automatically took it to mean converting wolves and actually wondered how the wolves would be kept in the game if they were converted to village). I also sent stl a message before realizing I'd been moved, so clearly I'm not mondaying well.
 
Also missed Ski's posts, but my thought was towards the more specific wording @PippyPony since there was some clarification about it yesterday after your initial post. The rules say no quoting mod PM's, so I take that to mean copy & paste is oki doki.
 
Think I'm treading water a bit today...feels aren't super strong in any direction. Keeping it to the top portion of my list.


3m - Can someone who is good at reading 3m weigh in here? I've just got a touch of feels.
Cyndia - Not entirely sure I agree with STL's interpretation of the ability or how she's used it. Pretty good info lynch. I'm still a little unclear on the discrepancy between her stuff and my stuff so might end up voting here since i know everything is on the up and up on my end.
Ceke - So like, idk, reading over some of her posts from yesterday I got this feeling of sincerity. I ended the day thinking "Oh jeez maybe she really is village." I may in fact be a sucker. I'm not going to tell anyone else not to vote for her...I just probably won't. I'm thinking some kind of really low power chaos at worst. Her ability is pretty useless for a wolf.
Rabbott - moving up in the world. Need to see more from him.
Ski - Idk. Just a feeling. Will be ISOing posts.
Cray - Snowy's lynch was unhelpful in deciding anything here. Again, keeping her up here because I'll just ignore her if I don't, and that could be bad.
BBC - I've decided I was tunneling due to grumpiness. Will keep an eye there, but moving to neutral zone.

I'm going to continue to reread and make adjustments, but this is where I'm at right now, which is pretty much...nowhere.
 
~Clarification on no quoting Mod PM’s: no using the quote function feel free to “copy/paste” what ever it is you are claiming we said. I feel like the quote function may be misused to imply a false sense of mod trustworthiness but copy paste feature is implied it may or may not be a direct quote~

What I’m saying what STL did is fine for example.
 
Last edited:
Think I'm treading water a bit today...feels aren't super strong in any direction. Keeping it to the top portion of my list.


3m - Can someone who is good at reading 3m weigh in here? I've just got a touch of feels.
Cyndia - Not entirely sure I agree with STL's interpretation of the ability or how she's used it. Pretty good info lynch. I'm still a little unclear on the discrepancy between her stuff and my stuff so might end up voting here since i know everything is on the up and up on my end.
Ceke - So like, idk, reading over some of her posts from yesterday I got this feeling of sincerity. I ended the day thinking "Oh jeez maybe she really is village." I may in fact be a sucker. I'm not going to tell anyone else not to vote for her...I just probably won't. I'm thinking some kind of really low power chaos at worst. Her ability is pretty useless for a wolf.
Rabbott - moving up in the world. Need to see more from him.
Ski - Idk. Just a feeling. Will be ISOing posts.
Cray - Snowy's lynch was unhelpful in deciding anything here. Again, keeping her up here because I'll just ignore her if I don't, and that could be bad.
BBC - I've decided I was tunneling due to grumpiness. Will keep an eye there, but moving to neutral zone.

I'm going to continue to reread and make adjustments, but this is where I'm at right now, which is pretty much...nowhere.

Gah, I'm annoyed I've been moved and can't message either of you. So - I gave stl exactly what my results were and my reasoning behind using it the way I did, he's welcome to copy and paste it with you if you want to see why I was a little confused.

Since I broke rules by messaging him by accident, I'll also post what I said to him on here - I didn't use it last night. If it's an active ability, I trust the results and it may have been mod flair. If it's passive, then I question if n2 meant something different.
 
Gah, I'm annoyed I've been moved and can't message either of you. So - I gave stl exactly what my results were and my reasoning behind using it the way I did, he's welcome to copy and paste it with you if you want to see why I was a little confused.

Since I broke rules by messaging him by accident, I'll also post what I said to him on here - I didn't use it last night. If it's an active ability, I trust the results and it may have been mod flair. If it's passive, then I question if n2 meant something different.
Reasons why I'm side eyeing whoever has the moving people ability...it's disrupting communication networks more than it's helping anything.

I'll just wait for STL to get back on. He may be able to explain things a little better, but right now I think mod flair may be the issue.
 
So two people killed N1
one person killed N2
one person killed N3 with potential protection from a kill of STL

sounds like the wolves could have an extra kill every other night or something of that sort?

I had an item last night that allowed me to get the night results of a random player, but I didn't know who the player was.
the results said: "You try to sit by yourself and play Quarters but women from the Bachelorette party keep coming up and asking for a top up. You grumble because the constant harassment is messing with your aim, and you miss, sorry no protection for you tonight."

(there is apparently another night result that the same person also got that hasn't been worked out by the mods yet, but I'll get that message too when it comes through.)

to me, it sounds like whoever's night results these are can protect, but wasn't successful last night. So that leads me to 2 possibilities:
either STL is lying about his protection or there is more than one protection mechanism out there in the game still
 
So two people killed N1
one person killed N2
one person killed N3 with potential protection from a kill of STL

sounds like the wolves could have an extra kill every other night or something of that sort?

I had an item last night that allowed me to get the night results of a random player, but I didn't know who the player was.
the results said: "You try to sit by yourself and play Quarters but women from the Bachelorette party keep coming up and asking for a top up. You grumble because the constant harassment is messing with your aim, and you miss, sorry no protection for you tonight."

(there is apparently another night result that the same person also got that hasn't been worked out by the mods yet, but I'll get that message too when it comes through.)

to me, it sounds like whoever's night results these are can protect, but wasn't successful last night. So that leads me to 2 possibilities:
either STL is lying about his protection or there is more than one protection mechanism out there in the game still
Quarters is a self-protection item. You choose a number and if it matches the item RNG you're protected (I think from all actions, need to double check that) for the night. Sounds like whoever's results you got was blocked, potentially due to the bachelorette party thing? Idk because my role wasn't affected by the party.
 
Quarters is a self-protection item. You choose a number and if it matches the item RNG you're protected (I think from all actions, need to double check that) for the night. Sounds like whoever's results you got was blocked, potentially due to the bachelorette party thing? Idk because my role wasn't affected by the party.
ah ok this makes sense. didn't realize quarters was a self-protection item. That makes me lean towards believing STL's protection, and back to the double kill every other night theory
 
OR there is a blocker in the game (possible based on WZ's explanation there) and the wolves have an extra kill every night, and on N2 one of the killing wolves happened to be blocked, so only 1 kill, and on N3 the killing target (STL) was protected, so only 1 kill.

but having 2 kills every night seems a little too wolf-leaning for the game.. so idk. but if there was someone blocked on N2, it might be interesting to know who that was.

if someone is able to block and they were successful at blocking a kill, would the blocker be notified about it?
 
but having 2 kills every night seems a little too wolf-leaning for the game.. so idk. but if there was someone blocked on N2, it might be interesting to know who that was.
Agreed

if someone is able to block and they were successful at blocking a kill, would the blocker be notified about it?
I believe typically blockers (straight block, not jailkeep) are notified of successful/not successful blocking, but not what other actions (if any) were performed on the blocking target, or what actions they successfully blocked.
 
Top