Werewolf in the Garden of Good & Evil - Game Thread

[JustPaws]

---

Members do not see this ad.

I mean like you all can be happy you won but to try and say her role took skill is patently false. I'm out!

I don't speak up really at all but for someone easily offended, you are often rude.

I clearly used skill as the wolves didn't know I was a PR, or didn't feel threatened enough by me to night kill me, and I was also able to not get lynched. I also horded info just long enough to reveal to win the game, but left breadcrumbs on the thread so that my reveal after death could be solved.

Wins in WW are often village weighted. Even with my info I thought it was MSU, MsP and MJ, and hadn't even gotten mutts info yet so it could have gone very differently.

 

[JustPaws]

@ziggyandjazzy also if your reaction to my reveal had been "oh my God it's AM" after msu flipped village, you would have had a better chance of me lynching there next, as I started questioning AM hardcore in PM. But instead you questioned my info so there are always ways as a wolf to manipulate info. Probably could have gotten me to really screw up lynches and get myself lynched

 

[Animal Midwife]

We didn’t have a strongman?

I must have confused whatever actually happened with MsP's boosting then.

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

I don't speak up really at all but for someone easily offended, you are often rude.

I clearly used skill as the wolves didn't know I was a PR, or didn't feel threatened enough by me to night kill me, and I was also able to not get lynched. I also horded info just long enough to reveal to win the game, but left breadcrumbs on the thread so that my reveal after death could be solved.

Wins in WW are often village weighted. Even with my info I thought it was MSU, MsP and MJ, and hadn't even gotten mutts info yet so it could have gone very differently.

Once again, you're misinterpreting what I'm saying. Please go back and actually read. I said your ROLE had no skill, which it didn't, but your play did. Msu's role required skill, she had to select who she wanted info about. Your role literally just required you to exist, and get info. That's where a lot of our frustration was. You didn't have to select targets or anything, it was just handed to you.

@ziggyandjazzy also if your reaction to my reveal had been "oh my God it's AM" after msu flipped village, you would have had a better chance of me lynching there next, as I started questioning AM hardcore in PM. But instead you questioned my info so there are always ways as a wolf to manipulate info. Probably could have gotten me to really screw up lynches and get myself lynched

We did all the math, you are welcome to do it yourself if you want. It wouldn't have mattered if AM was lynched. We still would've lost. The game was mechanically over after d4.

 

[dolphin106258]

Once again, you're misinterpreting what I'm saying. Please go back and actually read. I said your ROLE had no skill, which it didn't, but your play did. Msu's role required skill, she had to select who she wanted info about. Your role literally just required you to exist, and get info. That's where a lot of our frustration was. You didn't have to select targets or anything, it was just handed to you.

We did all the math, you are welcome to do it yourself if you want. It wouldn't have mattered if AM was lynched. We still would've lost. The game was mechanically over after d4.

@Navilly stop telling people when the game is over!!! It sucks out the fun

 

[Navilly]

@Navilly stop telling people when the game is over!!! It sucks out the fun

But but but.... 🙁

 

[muttmanager]

I could have easily died with all my info, also wolves should know to split AM and I up if we are both village because we will figure it out and confide in each other.
#bestvillageblock #badasswooferstoo #sketchmasons4lyfe

Noted 😉

 

[dolphin106258]

Also you guys don’t know how many times I wanted to just shoot people before all the information was dropped. But wolves knew my name early so I honestly kept expecting to die so it made me want to at least use a shot.

 

[Coopah]

Also you guys don’t know how many times I wanted to just shoot people before all the information was dropped. But wolves knew my name early so I honestly kept expecting to die so it made me want to at least use a shot.

MVP

 

[PippyPony]

...On the subject of the "the game was mechanically over" thing...

Never underestimate the potential for people to throw out mechanics entirely and just lynch who they want. It's always a possibility.

At the very least, I hope this was some practice for village with following through on a clear process of elimination because of mechanistic clears, and practice for the wolves (particularly barks since first wolf outing) to try to talk their way out of a pretty dire situation.

Both of those factors are why I didn't just call the game when wolves asked me to the first time. Ain't over til the fat lady sings. (Although the second time, I would have accepted an otherwise paradoxical wolf suicide @Navilly )

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

@Navilly stop telling people when the game is over!!! It sucks out the fun

Lol I think I was the first person to say it though! I did the maths

Oh and we knew name but not role. We were afraid of a bomb

 

[dolphin106258]

Lol I think I was the first person to say it though! I did the maths

Oh and we knew name but not role. We were afraid of a bomb

You should always be afraid of the dolph very afraid

Muahahahaha

Lol but for real I was sad that I said my name or whatever when I got those night results because my name is obv very bad for the wolfies.

 

[PippyPony]

Oh and we knew name but not role. We were afraid of a bomb

This was a very fair assumption on the part of the wolves, given the other roles.

I could have done a better job of making it clear that the poppy block/protects were really high up in the order of operations.

Also, for the life of me I don't know why I didn't put at least one Bomb Diffuser in this game. Was one of those "well ****" moments right after we sent out roles. I probably should have had a wolf Asceticizer and a village Bomb Diffuser. Just one more thing I would probably do over haha.

Maybe someday in the far away future, I'll run this setup with a different theme and allllll of the tweaks

 

[Barkley13]

Also you guys don’t know how many times I wanted to just shoot people before all the information was dropped. But wolves knew my name early so I honestly kept expecting to die so it made me want to at least use a shot.

My first thought was to kill you but I don’t always think things through And then we didn’t want to mess with you

 

[dolphin106258]

My first thought was to kill you but I don’t always think things through And then we didn’t want to mess with you

Well darn. If you had killed me the night after you learned my name that would’ve been a huge bummer. But also lesson ALWAYS GO WITH YOUR GUT. Unless your gut is usually wrong...then don’t do that

 

[Stagg737]

A bunch of villagers also did a very good job. And there was excellent use of PMs to establish village blocks.

All in all, I would probably call it a draw if people (@Animal Midwife ) were to go about calculating win percentages 😉

There were village blocs? Lol. Everyone was PMing and using abilities and I'm just over here like *splash* *splash* *splash*

 

[Coopah]

There were village blocs? Lol. Everyone was PMing and using abilities and I'm just over here like *splash* *splash* *splash*

I was vanillager too. Typically when I'm vanilla I just go all out with the sketch because to me it doesn't matter if I'm mislynched.

 

[Lawpy]

I was vanillager too. Typically when I'm vanilla I just go all out with the sketch because to me it doesn't matter if I'm mislynched.

I support the vanilla Coops

 

[PippyPony]

Oh good grief I forgot a

View attachment 266084

The Beginning
Day One - Mutts lynched | No one has died
Night One - No one has died
Day Two - Miz lynched | Extinct: Passiflora edulis
Night Two - Extinct: Mixalot, Jasminum polyanthum

lol I did so well with updating this TOC... 🙈

 

[Animal Midwife]

My meltdown in this game seems weak in comparsion.

 

[WildZoo]

lol I did so well with updating this TOC... 🙈

I was like "Ooo gonna read all the writeups, pip has good writeups" but then...

 

[PippyPony]

~~~~~~~
I promise I will be a less flaky mod as the game goes along
~~~~~~

. . .

 

[PippyPony]

I was like "Ooo gonna read all the writeups, pip has good writeups" but then...

WAIT I WILL FIX IT FOR FLATTERY

 

[PippyPony]

Welp. Now I know why I didn't update the TOCs while the game was happening...too much shame over the lack of time to do justice to the write ups I had planned 😳

 

[WildZoo]

Welp. Now I know why I didn't update the TOCs while the game was happening...too much shame over the lack of time to do justice to the write ups I had planned 😳

It's ok because now I am reading all the posts

 

[acanthuroidei]

I loved this game.

 

[Lawpy]

I think this is the last game where i made it to end game and won. I keep dying or losing otherwise

 

[acanthuroidei]

I think this is the last game where i made it to end game and won. I keep dying or losing otherwise

You are always a winner in my book.