WWhere There's a WWhisk, There's a WWay! - Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
lynch bryndi

It's actually the second post I quoted that is making me want to put my vote here. I could see the first maybe just be her misspeaking. But the second very clearly says she PMd Snowy after seeing the item had no effect... and she thought it was a seering item all a long I'm not seeing how that makes sense.
 
kaydubs said:
****
Work is annihilating me.

Im so tired, guise....
****
Click to expand...
Here's some cow gifs to get you through

reverse-1237466918_cows.gif

RecklessShimmeringGoldenmantledgroundsquirrel-max-1mb.gif
 
SkiOtter said:
okay but like, both items ive had have had the deadline be night close. so one person wouldve already been dead.
Click to expand...
Yeah so this is why I don't understand what's so confusing about wanting to wait until lynch close to use it? I use it before lynch close (as Pippy pointed out, on one of the people leading in votes), then what happens to all those votes? I waited until late in the day because I was hoping someone would peak my interest or give me more reason to suspect them. If I wait until after lynch close, then I have more information on people's role. What about that is so confusing?
PippyPony said:
That is also not at all what I was implying. I said you admitted in that post that you made a conscious decision to use the item on people who were not going to die anyways via a lynch.
Click to expand...
Because what would yield more info? We find out roles of two players in one day or one? I choose to find out info on two. Although I get your point now about choosing someone before lynch, because then if they were villager I could have said something or vice versa.

Fine, go ahead and lynch me, but I'll flip villager.
 
finnickthedog said:
But the second very clearly says she PMd Snowy after seeing the item had no effect... and she thought it was a seering item all a long I'm not seeing how that makes sense.
Click to expand...
I don't understand what doesn't make sense. I had the item on my own, and kept it to myself until after it was used.
 
bryndiana.jones said:
Yeah so this is why I don't understand what's so confusing about wanting to wait until lynch close to use it? I use it before lynch close (as Pippy pointed out, on one of the people leading in votes), then what happens to all those votes? I waited until late in the day because I was hoping someone would peak my interest or give me more reason to suspect them. If I wait until after lynch close, then I have more information on people's role. What about that is so confusing?
Click to expand...
okay so now youre deeeeefinitely saying that you knew it was a vig item...
and im saying that if you use it AFTER lynch close then you kill the second sketchy person that was in second place and not have to worry about the fact that one of the two people tied would get lynched, like you had said you were worried about.
 
finnickthedog said:
lynch bryndi

It's actually the second post I quoted that is making me want to put my vote here. I could see the first maybe just be her misspeaking. But the second very clearly says she PMd Snowy after seeing the item had no effect... and she thought it was a seering item all a long I'm not seeing how that makes sense.
Click to expand...
well now shes saying she thought it was a vig item all along so
 
bryndiana.jones said:
I don't understand what doesn't make sense. I had the item on my own, and kept it to myself until after it was used.
Click to expand...

What effect were you expecting to see? And given that Allie mentioned someone seeing into her soul, if you thought it was a seering item all along why didn't that seem like an effect to you?
 
I’ve been down for a Bryndy lynch since Day 2. I had chalked it up to the fact that I was tunneling, but the woof needs to go.

Unlynch Allieh

(I’ll be back. We’ll talk about this tomorrow)

Lynch Bryndy
 
SkiOtter said:
okay so now youre deeeeefinitely saying that you knew it was a vig item...
and im saying that if you use it AFTER lynch close then you kill the second sketchy person that was in second place and not have to worry about the fact that one of the two people tied would get lynched, like you had said you were worried about.
Click to expand...
I explained it to Pippy already but I'll try to do it again more clearly. I got the item, and the way I saw it was that there were a few people on my sketch list that I could use it on and their "true colors" (I took that as role) would appear. No one sent up any red flags through the day, so I was left with those I already thought were sketch (at the time, VA and Allie). Now its a few minutes until lynch close and I think "why waste this item on VA when (since he is leading in votes) I will find out his role and get that information in a few minutes" so I thought I could use it on the person next highest on my sketch list, Allie. I was hoping that seeing her "true colors" would mean confirming my suspicions she was a wolf.

finnickthedog said:
if you thought it was a seering item all along why didn't that seem like an effect to you?
Click to expand...
Because the item yielded no information. If it's a seer item isn't it supposed to tell the person who uses it the role of the person they use it on? Because that was my understanding. I used it on her, then I get a message saying the item didn't work because she was wearing something protective. So how can that be justified as having any effect on her?

Edit: spelling
 
Unofficial D6 Cookie Lynch Tally

pippy (1) - snowy
allie (1) - bryndy
kski (1) - sky
finn (1) - AM
bryndy (7) - Pippy, nokia, kski, Glam, finn, Mixy, cdo

missing: capri, LIS, KL, allieh

11/15

Deadline midnight EST (~1.5 hours)

8d126fbdc9796c927d4daa1f937ae566--dessert-quotes-cute-gift-ideas.jpg
 
I'm done defending, I have tried to explain my actions and thoughts multiple times over now. Lynch me and you all still will have failed at finding any wolves. Congrats.
 
Lynch Bryndy

It’s difficult to disregard the evidence posted today. Plus KSki’s tinfoil hat theory here makes sense to me:

SkiOtter said:
tiny tin foil hat time: bryndi is a wolf and was told to ask all her questions on thread to make her seem more noob instead of asking the pack so that people like mixy(?) would write her off as a noob villager because shes asking questions on the thread
Click to expand...

Also her last-minute defending (which it’s not really last minute since there’s still 90 minutes to lynch close) reminds me of my last-minute pleading in the noob game right before I was lynched as a wolf. Lots of “good job lynching a villager guys.”
 
bryndiana.jones said:
Because the item yielded no information. If it's a seer item isn't it supposed to tell the person who uses it the role of the person they use it on? Because that was my understanding. I used it on her, then I get a message saying the item didn't work because she was wearing something protective. So how can that be justified as having any effect on her?

Edit: spelling
Click to expand...
no youd more than likely see affiliation, not role. especially since mods said role names dont matter.
 
###lynch Bryndi####

after reading thru all that I missed today, I agree with everyone's assessment. I also find it weird that you would not equate "melting" with "killing".

(and sorry for not being around today. I know real life is not supposed to interfere...but it has big time today.)
 
capri1722 said:
When was this? Also what is meant by “role names don’t matter?”
Click to expand...
my mistake, they said role revealing doesnt matter, which could mean name OR ability. but if there were things like "burnt caramel corn" and "spoiled milk" as wolves, theyd more than likely have cover roles anyway.
Karabiner13 said:
  • You can role reveal if you want, but it won't help you terribly much
Click to expand...
either way, we'd have to know what things the mods dont like or they'd have to be super damning wolf role names (like above) but then would probably have cover roles.
 
PippyPony said:
Subdued rage quit?
Click to expand...
Right? This is weird to me. I don’t understand why she would be giving up so early. I might understand if it was mere minutes to lynch close but in the noob game you and the other wolfators were constantly telling us to keep fighting, even right before the deadline.
 
capri1722 said:
Right? This is weird to me. I don’t understand why she would be giving up so early. I might understand if it was mere minutes to lynch close but in the noob game you and the other wolfators were constantly telling us to keep fighting, even right before the deadline.
Click to expand...
Maybe she's village and over it? I still think there's too much confusion on this item and she needs flipping although I'd still like to hear from @SnowshoeDog143 before lynch closes to get their take on all of this considering they pm'd after she used it. I'd like to know their thoughts on the item, etc. Am thinking their thoughts can provide some useful analysis as to where to go no matter how she flips.
 
MixedAnimals77 said:
Maybe she's village and over it? I still think there's too much confusion on this item and she needs flipping although I'd still like to hear from @SnowshoeDog143 before lynch closes to get their take on all of this considering they pm'd after she used it. I'd like to know their thoughts on the item, etc. Am thinking their thoughts can provide some useful analysis as to where to go no matter how she flips.
Click to expand...
Yeah, I would be interested in hearing from Snowy as well.
 
Animal Midwife said:
Anyone else bothering you?
Click to expand...
I strongly feel like Mixy and Snowy are village. Glam I am leaning village. KL keeps jumping on lynch after lynch, and I believe she has more playing experience than I do. I have a hard time reading the vets, but I think Pippy, Nohika, and Finn need more attention tomorrow. Pippy and Nohika have gotten by without much, if any, questioning. C
 
Was reading back, and just wanted to address this before I crash for the night ...
SnowshoeDog143 said:
Lynch pippy
I have nothing on her and it's about the point in the game where I should pressure her more.
Click to expand...
LetItSnow said:
Especially in a game where no wolves have been found yet.
Click to expand...
SnowshoeDog143 said:
Does anyone have a reason to trust her?
Click to expand...
Figured this was coming at some point :laugh:

But, lemme ask you this -- why would anyone have a real reason to trust anyone in a game that has so far appeared to just be vanilla + items?

SnowshoeDog143 said:
Okay so here's my theory: Maybe the wolves are getting lucky and are newer to playing wolves and managing to get all of them to avoid lynch. But realistically, most wolves will bus another wolf under fire for village cred. Only very confident wolves would try for a "wipe out?" (I can't think of the word, but whatever means no wolves lynched) because that would mean not bussing when possible. We don't have a lot of players that play that confident of wolves and would coach the newb wolves to play similar (pippy, nohika... maybe kc but hydra makes me think less likely, maybe finn but haven't played with her enough). Pippy was a wolf when this happened just a couple games ago, so likely she would want another.. Plus she loves coaching newb wolves.
Click to expand...
Ok but this part is a little ridiculous.

1. That game was built in a way that was a bit unbalanced (sorry @Trilt but I think you yourself admitted it was an experimental structure?) Basically we had nothing stopping us from cleaning up. It wasn't a huge game, the wolf ratio was normal, but the village had no abilities at the outset and thus could not seer/track/otherwise investigate any of us. And frankly have maybe become a little too dependent on seering.

2. Actively trying for something like that again would be stupid. I might be cocky/conceited, but contrary to popular belief I'm not quite as bad as say, DocE or STL in that regard. Plus, see point 1. It's not like it was some magic wolfing technique -- it was luck + game design (+ ok, some hard work). Also, I was not the only wolf.

3. Pretty sure avoiding wolf lynches is the goal of all wolf teams across the world, not a novel strategy

4. I just came off a game where I coached 5 noob wolves...and was ****ing exhausted after it lol. Not like anyone needs to believe this, but fwiw I personally kinda feel like fellow wolfator Karabeans would have considered giving rng a little "boost" to cut me a break lol

In any case, there are still a lot of other people who are playing this game who are truly excellent wolves. I would advise against ignoring all of them 😛
 
If bryndi is a wolf, Snowy jumps to the top of my list. Probably followed closely by capri and you, who were late to jump onto this vote and basically voted as "yeah me too" votes.

If not wolf, then I would like to look at allie, and also probably mixalot for defending so many of bryndi's actions as village.

We are also hitting the point in the game when I agree it is worth pressuring some of the people who I know are strong wolves. LIS, nohika, finn, and KC all fit that criteria.
 
SkiOtter said:
we're also kiiiiinda concerned about LIS now because he keeps pocketing us,
Click to expand...

Give me a break.

1) If you really rezzed me, then you should know my affiliation. Sure, there have been mean-mod-tricks where they've had a villager rez a conversion, but that's .... stupid rare.

2) You're the one that started with the whole "you owe us" stuff! I'm just playing along.

This totally reads like you're just setting me up......
 
Sorry to do this a second time in the game, but there's a lot of posts to catch up on and I'm not sure when lynch closes (if it's still open).

Can someone give me a synopsis?

Is lynch open? Tally? Etc.

I don't even remember if I've voted yet.
 
LYNCH CLOSED, AND LOOK, A TALLY IS RIGHT HERE!​


Official D6 Cookie Lynch Tally

pippy (1) - snowy
allie (1) - bryndy
kski (1) - sky
finn (1) - AM
bryndy (10) - Pippy, nokia, kski, Glam, finn, Mixy, cdo, capri, KL, allieh

14/15
Missing: LIS

Deadline midnight EST

8d126fbdc9796c927d4daa1f937ae566--dessert-quotes-cute-gift-ideas.jpg
 
LetItSnow said:
Sorry to do this a second time in the game, but there's a lot of posts to catch up on and I'm not sure when lynch closes (if it's still open).

Can someone give me a synopsis?

Is lynch open? Tally? Etc.

I don't even remember if I've voted yet.
Click to expand...
Well, you hadn't voted, but lynch is closed now, so probably don't worry about it 😉
 
nohika said:
I mean. I don't generally play that confident of a wolf? I definitely have bussed other wolves and if they're being sketchy af, I call them out on it. It amuses me. And it helps build cred.

One of the better strategies for wolves imo is to primarily work independently, but use the wolf chat to collaborate. It helps ensure there's not enough overlap, things appear random/disconnected, etc. Not everyone is good at that or particularly subtle, but it's a fairly good strategy and pretty common in the more experienced wolves I've played with.

I don't think we've seen any bus-ing yet because no one has really needed to build that cred. I'm guessing wolves that have come up for lynch have ducked out of it so far, and I'd bet we have at least one wolf riding another one hard, so to speak, at least in theory.
Click to expand...

Holy sketchville.

So. One of the better wolf strategies is to work independently ... but not really.

And, we haven't seen a bus yet because no one has really needed to build that cred? Just how - exactly - do you know we haven't seen a bus yet????? Just because no wolf has been lynched doesn't mean that a wolf hasn't been bussed.

Unless, of course, you have some way to know for sure.

I'm gonna ride this one:

unlynch whomever
lynch nohika
 
LetItSnow said:
Sorry to do this a second time in the game, but there's a lot of posts to catch up on and I'm not sure when lynch closes (if it's still open).

Can someone give me a synopsis?

Is lynch open? Tally? Etc.

I don't even remember if I've voted yet.
Click to expand...
Lynch will probably be closed by the time I finish typing/posting this. Bryndy in the lead. Bryndy had a “boiler” item that claimed to “melt” someone and “show their true colors,” so she claimed she thought this meant it was a seering item. She used it on Allie the same night that Allie protected herself, so conclusion was made that the boiler was likely a vig item. That’s the basics of it.
 
capri1722 said:
Lynch will probably be closed by the time I finish typing/posting this. Bryndy in the lead. Bryndy had a “boiler” item that claimed to “melt” someone and “show their true colors,” so she claimed she thought this meant it was a seering item. She used it on Allie the same night that Allie protected herself, so conclusion was made that the boiler was likely a vig item. That’s the basics of it.
Click to expand...

Thanks for trying. Whether yer wolf or village, I do appreciate it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
27K
Clem J
Clem J
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
PokeWWon: A Wild Kanto Adventure - Champs Season 12 Practice Game Thread
87 88 89 90 91
Replies
5K
Views
44K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
supershorty
GGoats ThWWee: Here It GGoats Again - GAME THREAD
93 94 95 96 97
Replies
5K
Views
37K
vampyrica
vampyrica
Animal Midwife
Matrix - Game Thread
77 78 79 80 81
Replies
4K
Views
66K
samac
samac
kaydubs
Melee WW Game Thread-April 2024
27 28 29 30 31
Replies
2K
Views
23K
Sandy Dikson
Sandy Dikson
Top