WWho Goes There? - Game Thread

[SportPonies]

---

Members don't see this ad.

annnnd we're back.

Sorry, wanted to come back earlier and then literally everyone on this planet decided they needed to socially-distantly see me before I went back to school.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 2 Elementary, My Dear Yeet Tally
Suni (2) - cubs, genny
rocky () -
Cyndia (1) - dubz
cubs () -
MsP () -
dubz (2) - rocky, Barks
genny (1) - Suni

6/9
dubz and @Sunbodi are in the lead
yeet close in ~1.5 hours
Missing: Cyndia, Sporty, MsP

 

[SportPonies]

I am on page 10 so lol get ready for catch up.

Initial thoughts:
-Suni and cubs in village pile
-rocky sketch initially, but her reaction after yeet close "yesterday" seemed genuine....
-genny and Dubz mess = ????

 

[genny]

Why?

She's avoided my questions today, engaged in histrionics for no reason (to play to her village meta), and said she voyeured SAR but didn't mention seeing her die initially.

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

She's avoided my questions today, engaged in histrionics for no reason (to play to her village meta), and said she voyeured SAR but didn't mention seeing her die initially.

I say dubz. Do you really buy her PR?

 

[genny]

I say dubz. Do you really buy her PR?

I could go either way.

 

[WildZoo]

oh this is hilarious. dubz, you're going to love this. my role is stalker. i picked you to stalk because you usually live for a long time, and i could only stalk one person this game. after you're dead, i don't stalk anymore. so if you don't get lynched, i should see you visit tonight's NK too.

Oh damn, your stalker comment wasn't just flirting 😱

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

Yeet dubz even if she is telling the truth she's gonna keep ccorrupting results. How do we know she's not lying and will use this as the perfect excuse to kill people?

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

I could go either way.

Yeet dubz!

 

[WildZoo]

even if she is telling the truth she's gonna keep ccorrupting results

Not really. I don't appear instead of whoever actually did the killing, just in addition to. So someone tracking the actual killer would still see them doing the kill, someone watching the person who is killed would see me and the killer.

Why the heck would I make this up and not say I was just tracking SAR or something?

 

[genny]

Yeet dubz even if she is telling the truth she's gonna keep ccorrupting results. How do we know she's not lying and will use this as the perfect excuse to kill people?

How does she corrupt results? I'll follow her every night. She should show up at every kill. No one else needs to use their investigative role on her.

 

[genny]

If she is a wolf, she's probably not the only one.

 

[SportPonies]

Who do you think would kill SAR n1?

I don't think there was an answer to this, but I find it an interesting question so I still would like to hear an answer to it (once I go back and remember who this was aimed at)

Village Pile:

Genny

I like the repeat of this list, it made me lol

Why

Why

For the reason I stated in the above post. I think her reaction to the yeet ending seemed villagey.

Something about dubz‘s tone is making me think she’s sketchy

I quoted this to remind myself about it but I have nothing to say right now.

genny will be upset at the thoughts I am having right now

Care to share those thoughts?

 

[SportPonies]

sporty
Dubz

Sometimes I like being on the bottom, you know 🙁

 

[genny]

I don't think there was an answer to this, but I find it an interesting question so I still would like to hear an answer to it (once I go back and remember who this was aimed at)

i think that's one of the questions Suni avoided.

 

[cubsrule4e]

So you, barks, and sunny all have tracking/watching PRs plus there's an investigator? That seems kinda like a lot in such a small game.

We are using "investigation" as a catch all term for watcher, trackers, voyeurs, and other info gathering roles.

Edit: this post awaiting wildzoo approval

 

[SportPonies]

Literally what is happening on page 12

 

[Barkley13]

So you, barks, and sunny all have tracking/watching PRs plus there's an investigator? That seems kinda like a lot in such a small game.

Huh

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

We are using "investigation" as a catch all term for watcher, trackers, voyeurs, and other info gathering roles.

Edit: this post awaiting wildzoo approval

Oh. I meant as in seer

 

[SportPonies]

Page 13 question: what if literally everyone in this game counts as an investigative role and cubs shows up in all of them.

Page 13 tinfoil: What if woof cubs. And his claimed ability is just a modifier? That would be evil but also a clever wolf role.
I'm not going to run away with that tinfoil right now because he's still really sounding village to me, but it crossed my mind.

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

Huh

Sorry I meant doggo

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

Page 13 question: what if literally everyone in this game counts as an investigative role and cubs shows up in all of them.

Page 13 tinfoil: What if woof cubs. And his claimed ability is just a modifier? That would be evil but also a clever wolf role.
I'm not going to run away with that tinfoil right now because he's still really sounding village to me, but it crossed my mind.

Did you get cubs in your results?

 

[WildZoo]

So you, barks, and sunny all have tracking/watching PRs plus there's an investigator? That seems kinda like a lot in such a small game.

I missed this post before, the whole point of this game is tracking-type mechanics so I'm not surprised that there are many

 

[itsrocky]

Page 13 question: what if literally everyone in this game counts as an investigative role and cubs shows up in all of them.

Page 13 tinfoil: What if woof cubs. And his claimed ability is just a modifier? That would be evil but also a clever wolf role.
I'm not going to run away with that tinfoil right now because he's still really sounding village to me, but it crossed my mind.

kinda had a theory about cubs being some panopticon/big brother type role, but kinda sounded quacky in my head. And I feel like if that were the case we wouldn’t be seeing him.

 

[SportPonies]

I'm talking about choose your own
I didn't read much of the thread during stranger things

Well I'm sticking to the read, thanks.

Barkley is in this game???
😳

Villags Barkley usually has a lot to say

hmmm....

Please point to where I told anyone to vote for you

This post bothers me because suni didn't specifically say herself. I guess you can argue it's implied, but the quoted post is generalized.

...like what?
I don't see why I need to contribute to the sunny questioning when the conversation that happened was sufficient for me to place a read on her.
Unless you mean something that happened today, in which case, idk what to tell you because I've been busy. I'll finish reading the pages I missed later.

As of end of page 13 I didn't get a response from this @Ms Procrastinator

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 2 Elementary, My Dear Yeet Tally
Suni (2) - cubs, genny
rocky () -
Cyndia (1) - dubz
cubs () -
MsP () -
dubz (3) - rocky, Barks, MsP
genny (1) - Suni

7/9
dubz is in in the lead
yeet close in ~1 hour
Missing: Cyndia, Sporty

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

Did you get cubs in your results?

Besides everyone would have been like what the heck Cubs but only a few ppl said anything. Dubzs role isn't investigative. @SportPonies

 

[Cyndia]

This is a whole lotta hedge

Hedgey because I haven’t had time to read carefully today, and I don’t have a whole lot of concrete info, so these are my general feels and thought processes in what I’m thinking.

Genny seeing you is certainly more concrete however. I’d be happy to see either a dubz or suni vote right now. Gonna reread this whole day quickly since I’m still at dinner then vote (hiding in the bathroom to catch up lol).

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

I missed this post before, the whole point of this game is tracking-type mechanics so I'm not surprised that there are many

Oh. Didn't read

 

[WildZoo]

This post bothers me because suni didn't specifically say herself. I guess you can argue it's implied, but the quoted post is generalized.

Did you read her post prior to that one?

Why are you swaying others to vote for me if you're not voting for me?

This is very wolfy behavior. Put your votes where your mouth is.

Dubz is swaying people in a direction to vote but not voting there. This is very much like WWarriors where she told us where to vote every night and we blindly listened while she didn't vote there. So I'm also comfortable voting there.

 

[genny]

Day 2 Elementary, My Dear Yeet Tally
Suni (2) - cubs, genny
rocky () -
Cyndia (1) - dubz
cubs () -
MsP () -
dubz (3) - rocky, Barks, Sporty
genny (1) - Suni

7/9
dubz is in in the lead
yeet close in ~1 hour
Missing: Cyndia, Sporty

?

 

[WildZoo]

i believe Msp is the other vote on me

 

[SportPonies]

What in carnation is happening

 

[kaydubs]

What in carnation is happening

I told AM everyone would show up right about now.

IT’S A CURSE, I TELL YOU, A CURSEEE

 

[genny]

What in carnation is happening

i don't know. we're yeeting someone? maybe?

 

[cubsrule4e]

I told AM everyone would show up right about now.

IT’S A CURSE, I TELL YOU, A CURSEEE

Nope. I been here 3 hours. MsP included. We rock.

 

[genny]

I told AM everyone would show up right about now.

IT’S A CURSE, I TELL YOU, A CURSEEE

i don't think you've had enough wine.

 

[cubsrule4e]

I told AM everyone would show up right about now.

IT’S A CURSE, I TELL YOU, A CURSEEE

Carnation is for meat-only eaters. Tarnation is the word youre looking for!

ugh, wrong quote. this was for @SportPonies

 

[kaydubs]

i don't think you've had enough wine.

I don’t drink alcohol so you’re absolutely correct.

 

[genny]

I don’t drink alcohol so you’re absolutely correct.

omg how do you get through these wafflefests without killing everyone if you don't drink?

 

[genny]

Nope. I been here 3 hours. MsP included. We rock.

Sounds like something wolves would do.

 

[SportPonies]

Did you get cubs in your results?

Besides everyone would have been like what the heck Cubs but only a few ppl said anything. Dubzs role isn't investigative. @SportPonies

I'm kind of sketched out by these questions.
I don't think some people not saying things necessarily means that cubs was/was not in their results

Did you read her post prior to that one?

Yes

?

Actually can I repeat this ?

 

[genny]

Actually can I repeat this ?

but she fixed it

 

[SportPonies]

Carnation is for meat-only eaters.

It's also for me so I can be a buff girl

 

[WildZoo]

Yes

Then I don't understand your issue with my reply

 

[SportPonies]

I'm now caught up and thoroughly more confused than I was 5 pages ago.

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

Nope. I been here 3 hours. MsP included. We rock.

Listen to me very closely. I need you to kill your grandmother.

 

[cubsrule4e]

Sounds like something wolves would do.

Which is totally contrary to the point i made about wolves wanting to keep it quiet, but ok.

 

[cubsrule4e]

Listen to me very closely. I need you to kill your grandmother.

I might have to... but sunni has done nothing to dissuade me and theres 40 minutes left.

 

[SportPonies]

actually now I've spooked myself about cubs and have convinced myself he's a baddie. idk. I need to go back and ISO him I guess to decide if the sleepy read is to be trusted.

Guess it's already that time of the game I get paranoid!