WWho Goes There? - Game Thread

[Animal Midwife]

---

Members don't see this ad.

Dead is @Sunbodi Nancy Drew, village voyeur who could learn what type of night action was used on someone

​

Roster
4. @genny
5. @Ms Procrastinator
6. @Barkley13
8. @cubsrule4e
14. @SportPonies
16. @Cyndia

Dead
7. Doggo - village reporter
3. SAR - village parasite
1. dubz - village gravedigger
2. rocky - village peeping tom
15. Suni - village voyeur

 

[Animal Midwife]

It is now Night 3.​

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

Cyndia do you and your wolf partner mind killing me tonight? You'd be doing me a huge favor

 

[cubsrule4e]

I hate myself. And sorry MsP, I am the most logical NK choice tonight. At least I have one thing going for me.

 

[cubsrule4e]

It is now Night 3.

Yeah, I made mistakes, but life doesn't come with instructions. ​

Unfortunately, neither does an AM WW game.

 

[cubsrule4e]

Also apparently Nancy Drew is taller than me. Sick burn and instant karma for my @WildZoo joke.

 

[cubsrule4e]

Actually this 36 hour thing isnt so bad. I get a whole day to hide from the shame and embarrassment before I have to come back and do it again.

 

[genny]

Actually this 36 hour thing isnt so bad. I get a whole day to hide from the shame and embarrassment before I have to come back and do it again.

I’m at the paranoia stage where I think you and Ms P have been manipulating me this whole game, so that’s going well for me. I don’t know if it helps or hurts to have the extra time to mull it over.

 

[Cyndia]

By close, I was literally 100% sure we had bagged a wolf. I guess I'll be able to read Suni better in the future games now that I've seen how she plays, but I'm literally flabbergasted at the amount of inconsistencies/incorrect statements that she said. Time to reread/rethink everything again.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Night closed; results pending​

 

[Animal Midwife]

Dead is @Ms Procrastinator Inspector Gadget, village tracker who could learn whom someone visited

​

Roster
4. @genny
6. @Barkley13
8. @cubsrule4e
14. @SportPonies
16. @Cyndia

Dead
7. Doggo - village reporter
3. SAR - village parasite
1. dubz - village gravedigger
2. rocky - village peeping tom
15. Suni - village voyeur
5. MsP - village tracker

 

[Animal Midwife]

It is now Day 4.​

 

[Animal Midwife]

It is volo.​

 

[Cyndia]

Well.. for starters, everyone be super, super careful of yeeting. Don't do it until we've discussed for a while and you're 100% sure. It's only three to majority, and with volo it must mean there are 2 wolves. If we even put one incorrect yeet on the board, the wolves could theoretically pile on immediately after and win.

 

[Cyndia]

With Mrs P flipping village, I'm eyeing @Barkley13 after that weird inconsistency between them, as Mrs P must have been telling the truth.

You claimed vanilla earlier. I find that extremely unlikely.. what are your reads right now?

 

[Barkley13]

With Mrs P flipping village, I'm eyeing @Barkley13 after that weird inconsistency between them, as Mrs P must have been telling the truth.

You claimed vanilla earlier. I find that extremely unlikely.. what are your reads right now?

Except that we both could be telling the truth. Her results could have said I visited her while I didn’t actually visit her due to some third person messing with things. And I’m not sure why being vanilla is unlikely when it’s never been guaranteed that everyone is going to have an ability.

And as for reads I strongly feel that cubs is village so that leaves 3 people and last night I was convincing myself it’s you and genny

 

[genny]

Why am I so bad at this? I’m a decent lie detector in person, but that just doesn’t seem to translate for me here. It’s got to be Cyndia, right? There’s no way my d1 Barks and sporty pack was right.

 

[Cyndia]

Except that we both could be telling the truth. Her results could have said I visited her while I didn’t actually visit her due to some third person messing with things. And I’m not sure why being vanilla is unlikely when it’s never been guaranteed that everyone is going to have an ability.

And as for reads I strongly feel that cubs is village so that leaves 3 people and last night I was convincing myself it’s you and genny

Can you explain your reasoning behind strongly thinking cubs is village? Also your main reasons for genny and I?

 

[Barkley13]

Can you explain your reasoning behind strongly thinking cubs is village? Also your main reasons for genny and I?

His tone and his posts mostly plus how frustrated he was and how much he waffled with sunni yesterday. I just don’t see him being a wolf this game
And others have kind of talked about you and I said why I was suspicious of genny yesterday, along with POE for both

 

[SportPonies]

yeet Barks

liar liar pants on fire

 

[SportPonies]

Well.. for starters, everyone be super, super careful of yeeting. Don't do it until we've discussed for a while and you're 100% sure. It's only three to majority, and with volo it must mean there are 2 wolves. If we even put one incorrect yeet on the board, the wolves could theoretically pile on immediately after and win.

yeet Barks

liar liar pants on fire

lol I'm good at following directions apparently

 

[Barkley13]

yeet Barks

liar liar pants on fire

????????

 

[SportPonies]

@genny did you have any interesting night results?

 

[Barkley13]

how is it in the village’s best interest to vote without talking about anything?

 

[SportPonies]

unyeet Barks

 

[SportPonies]

But I stand by my vote choice.

 

[SportPonies]

????????

"I'm totally vanilla, yep 100%, no ability here" - Barks

 

[Barkley13]

"I'm totally vanilla, yep 100%, no ability here" - Barks

Yep that’s still true

 

[SportPonies]

cool story. You know lying doesn't help village, right?

 

[Barkley13]

cool story. You know lying doesn't help village, right?

Lol yeah that’s why I’m telling the truth

 

[Barkley13]

If I was a wolf why wouldn’t I just to with what MsP said yesterday about me investigating her? Why would I then bring attention to myself by claiming vanilla in a game where people were assuming everyone had a PR

 

[Cyndia]

Lol yeah that’s why I’m telling the truth

I was holding off on saying this until after Barks gave her more detailed reads, but I agree that she's a liar. I chose to look at Barks last night since she was on my list anyways with the inconsistencies, and since she was the only player to have claimed vanilla, I figured my role might actually provide useful information if she was lying.

I was told Barks and cubs visited someone last night. So what's the deal @Barkley13 ?

 

[Cyndia]

You keep swearing you're vanilla and have been trying to foist the blame on a nebulous third player that 'interferes' with results. It's not genny or cubs since they've revealed their abilities. That does also potentially leave Sporty, who has been flying under the radar for me and I don't know much about her. At this point in the game, more info is only going to help the village, so I want to know more from @SportPonies and why she's so sure of Barks being a liar right now.

 

[Cyndia]

Why am I so bad at this? I’m a decent lie detector in person, but that just doesn’t seem to translate for me here. It’s got to be Cyndia, right? There’s no way my d1 Barks and sporty pack was right.

I need to go back and look at your actual posts mentioning barks/sporty and if it was just a joke post or not, but that makes me want to move you to my more village pile. In general, I think currently genny is the only person I feel okay about. Cubs seems just like a confusing/chaotic villager role which I feel is possible after seeing what a confusing/chaotic villager role dubz had. But a result I haven't been watching cubs super closely all game, so I do need to go back and reread and make sure I haven't been ignoring any red flags.

I feel bad because I definitely tunneled on Suni most of this game which is frustrating. Things have been so chaotic and disruptive up until now, I think the wolves have had an easy time flying under the radar and it's time we put everyone in the hot seat.

 

[Barkley13]

It’s almost like the person who messed with results before did it to me again in case people tried to confirm if I was actually vanilla or not

 

[Barkley13]

I was told Barks and cubs visited someone last night. So what's the deal @Barkley13 ?

The deal is that I’m vanilla and village will lose if
I get yeeted today

 

[Barkley13]

It's not genny or cubs since they've revealed their abilities

Genny’s ability claim was weird tbh

 

[SportPonies]

It’s almost like the person who messed with results before did it to me again in case people tried to confirm if I was actually vanilla or not

who do you propose is messing with night results?

Also not buying that being an ability in this game, given the abilities that have flipped.

 

[SportPonies]

I'm a watcher. I watched genny last night. Barks (and cubs) acted on her.

 

[Barkley13]

who do you propose is messing with night results?

Also not buying that being an ability in this game, given the abilities that have flipped.

I already said genny’s ability claim was weird and not sure what cyndia is so it could be either of them.

and I think it makes perfect sense that AM would make it so you couldn’t fully trust night results

 

[Barkley13]

I'm a watcher. I watched genny last night. Barks (and cubs) acted on her.

Nope

 

[Cyndia]

Genny’s ability claim was weird tbh

Why do you think it was weird?

From what I recall, she was first to out the cubs thing and also outed the dubz thing, which essentially confirmed she could do what she said she could. She did take some time revealing all of the info, but she still shared everything with plenty of time left before close. That timing felt villagery to me as that's a good way to draw out people's responses and have more information to analyze afterwards.

 

[Cyndia]

I already said genny’s ability claim was weird and not sure what cyndia is so it could be either of them.

and I think it makes perfect sense that AM would make it so you couldn’t fully trust night results

I revealed what I could do and explained it yesterday.

 

[Cyndia]

I'm a watcher. I watched genny last night. Barks (and cubs) acted on her.

So this means there are a crazy amount of investigative type roles... Was sporty one that mentioned seeing cubs earlier? Also @SportPonies do you get any info on what they did or is it just whether or not they acted on her?

 

[Cyndia]

I'm kind of sketched out by these questions.
I don't think some people not saying things necessarily means that cubs was/was not in their results

Hmm. I went back through sporty's posts and didn't see any overt mentions to seeing cubs, but I did notice this post that was in response to two of Mrs P's posts probing about who saw cubs. It's feasible she was hinting at it but trying to not out herself as an investigative role. Still not entirely convinced and I really need to take a look at all of the roles revealed and role claims made so far.

I've got some meetings the rest of the afternoon so disappearing for a bit, but if anyone wants to write out a list of all the roles/claims, that would be amazing. As I said, this just seems like a crazy amount of investigative roles, and it might be helpful to really see it all laid out. I also still think with everything that's coming out, the odds of a vanilla villager in this game is low, and I'm not satisfied with Barks responses so far.

 

[Barkley13]

Why do you think it was weird?

From what I recall, she was first to out the cubs thing and also outed the dubz thing, which essentially confirmed she could do what she said she could. She did take some time revealing all of the info, but she still shared everything with plenty of time left before close. That timing felt villagery to me as that's a good way to draw out people's responses and have more information to analyze afterwards.

The whole idea that she can only choose one person to “stalk” the whole game seems weird. And I don’t really think saying it first is all that villagery or was it really beneficial how it led to other people basically claiming they had abilities

 

[Barkley13]

I also still think with everything that's coming out, the odds of a vanilla villager in this game is low, and I'm not satisfied with Barks responses so far.

That’s unfortunate
It’s a bad idea to partly base your suspicions just on thinking there shouldn’t be a vanillager in this game though

 

[genny]

I didn’t get any results last night. I’ve been vanilla since Dubz died.

 

[genny]

The whole idea that she can only choose one person to “stalk” the whole game seems weird. And I don’t really think saying it first is all that villagery or was it really beneficial how it led to other people basically claiming they had abilities

Thinking my role is weird is pretty funny coming from someone claiming to be the lone vanilla in a game full of PRs.

 

[Barkley13]

Thinking my role is weird is pretty funny coming from someone claiming to be the lone vanilla in a game full of PRs.

Maybe, but I said what I said 😛