WWildzoo Family Reunion - Game Thread

[PippyPony]

---

Members do not see this ad.

Spoiler: Night 3/Day 3

...










...






...











...

Are you literally just quoting every single post I've made in this game?

If this is your argument, then I might switch back to you because wtf

 

[Animal Midwife]

Are you literally just quoting every single post I've made in this game?

If this is your argument, then I might switch back to you because wtf

I always do this. Not finished yet. Please hold.

 

[PippyPony]

I always do this. Not finished yet. Please hold.

No you don't, and it looks like you are post padding.

 

[Animal Midwife]

No you don't, and it looks like you are post padding.

Yes, I do. I'm thinking and analyzing. I will converse with you once I'm finished.

 

[PippyPony]

Yes, I do. I'm thinking and analyzing. I will converse with you once I'm finished.

Lol ok.

Don't take too long, please -- I wasn't kidding about needing to be gone for school. We started exams again this week and I am slammed from now until Friday night

 

[Animal Midwife]

Lol ok.

Don't take too long, please -- I wasn't kidding about needing to be gone for school. We started exams again this week and I am slammed from now until Friday night

Do I have an hour left or less?

 

[PippyPony]

Do I have an hour left or less?

Less. I'm back in mandatory discussion classes at 1pm.

Why don't you just kill me, if you're so convinced? Why go through all this spoiler quote business?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Less. I'm back in mandatory discussion classes at 1pm.

Why don't you just kill me, if you're so convinced? Why go through all this spoiler quote business?

I wanted a thorough analysis discussion with you, but now I feel stuck because you're leaving soon.

I guess the gist was you never really did much vote for/supect finn/MJ after N2 and it stuck out as notable to me that you voted with them yesterday.

 

[Skimble]

I have pip in my pretty solid wolf category.

AM could be a convert for sure, and I’d be ok voting that way.

 

[Skimble]

Kill Skim

Today is my busy day with school and work so probably won't be around a ton. Hopefully will get back on before lynch close. Skim for reasons stating before. Lots of fluff, not much content. Don't like her position on the shelter lynch or much of her VCA in general.

If anyone is wondering.. no I'm not still supicious of stagg.. for obvious reasons.

My vca is usually pretty awesome when I’m a bad guy. Please go look at past games.

 

[Animal Midwife]

My vca is usually pretty awesome when I’m a bad guy. Please go look at past games.

What does awesome mean in this context?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Are you still suspicious of snowy for the vote or no?

Thinking on it.

 

[PippyPony]

I wanted a thorough analysis discussion with you, but now I feel stuck because you're leaving soon.

I guess the gist was you never really did much vote for/supect finn/MJ after N2 and it stuck out as notable to me that you voted with them yesterday.

Finn I had thought sounded a little sketchy at first, but I soft cleared after she defended Caiter pretty hard on the first day and Caiter stayed alive. Which, incidentally, is also why I am voting for Capri right now.

I think I laid out my concerns about MJ yesterday, as well as my reasons for not voting there. Would probably have gone there today if he had still been alive

And please explain to me why that vote was "notable." You're tunneling on all the people who have ever voted for dolphin, and I do not understand why. She was hella weird during the D1 voting and also felt very off to me in PM on the first day, and that is why I voted there yesterday.

I agree with you now that she is probably not villagery if both Finn and MJ were on that vote, but I did not have that information yesterday, so idk what you want from me on that one

 

[Animal Midwife]

Finn I had thought sounded a little sketchy at first, but I soft cleared after she defended Caiter pretty hard on the first day and Caiter stayed alive. Which, incidentally, is also why I am voting for Capri right now.

I think I laid out my concerns about MJ yesterday, as well as my reasons for not voting there. Would probably have gone there today if he had still been alive

And please explain to me why that vote was "notable." You're tunneling on all the people who have ever voted for dolphin, and I do not understand why. She was hella weird during the D1 voting and also felt very off to me in PM on the first day, and that is why I voted there yesterday.

I agree with you now that she is probably not villagery if both Finn and MJ were on that vote, but I did not have that information yesterday, so idk what you want from me on that one

It just felt fake and easy to vote for dolphin, idk. I will think on this.

 

[Skimble]

What does awesome mean in this context?

Meaning I often vote for bad guys and don’t often vote for the good guys who get killed.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Meaning I often vote for bad guys and don’t often vote for the good guys who get killed.

Okay, I guess I don't remember you being much of a busser unless the villager is near/already outted but I can check.

 

[dolphin106258]

I wanted a thorough analysis discussion with you, but now I feel stuck because you're leaving soon.

I guess the gist was you never really did much vote for/supect finn/MJ after N2 and it stuck out as notable to me that you voted with them yesterday.

I get the first part of this completely but why would Pippy vote with all of them like that?

 

[Animal Midwife]

I get the first part of this completely but why would Pippy vote with all of them like that?

Sometimes that happens. I really don't know why.

 

[Skimble]

Okay, I guess I don't remember you being much of a busser unless the villager is near/already outted but I can check.

I have no problems bussing.

 

[Animal Midwife]

I have no problems bussing.

Under what circumstances would you bus someone? Do they have to already be in the lead? Is other people just being suspicious yet not voting there enough? Something else?

 

[PippyPony]

It just felt fake and easy to vote for dolphin, idk. I will think on this.

Ok well, it wasn't fake -- I felt I had reasons to vote there, and so I did.

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

So tinfoil theory but Mj could’ve been the convert since it said snowy was killed but he was snowy/Elkhart. Maybe originally wolf as Elkhart. Idk if this makes sense

 

[genny]

So tinfoil theory but Mj could’ve been the convert since it said snowy was killed but he was snowy/Elkhart. Maybe originally wolf as Elkhart. Idk if this makes sense

Finn was Sandy/Elkhart (she changed her SDN handle). MJ was Snowy.

 

[Animal Midwife]

So tinfoil theory but Mj could’ve been the convert since it said snowy was killed but he was snowy/Elkhart. Maybe originally wolf as Elkhart. Idk if this makes sense

I'm betting the convert will be revealed as such.

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

Finn was Sandy/Elkhart (she changed her SDN handle). MJ was Snowy.

Oh ok disregard what I posted. I thought it was two different people

 

[Skimble]

Under what circumstances would you bus someone? Do they have to already be in the lead? Is other people just being suspicious yet not voting there enough? Something else?

I will bus in any circumstance where I feel it will benefit my faction.

 

[capri1722]

Actually, hold up

I do think AM is one of the best convert candidates, but I think I want to test something else out first

Unkill AM
Kill Capri

Are you testing my reaction?

Thank god. Now no one ever touch dolphin again.

?

Cait/Capri

Ooh maybe I should be CC

You're welcome again. I was Samurai not vig though. Now can we please

Kill Snowy

Remind me what the Samurai role is in this context? I tried searching for it but the only roles that came up were vig and various kinds of berserker.

Spoiler: Night 2/Day 2

...






...





...

...





...




...












...

Like 80% of these quotes push me more wolfy on Pip, and I usually read her as good guy anyway (often to my detriment).

I'm not done yet.

Ok but even an allusion to what you're building up to would be helpful. Just posting quotes with no explanation on why you chose to quote those posts is boring, disregarding whether or not it's sketchy.

Do they always say when someone has been converted? I find Finn's ability, as a villager interesting. So she could have been protecting the bad guys from things at night or preventing people from doing their actions?

Usually yes mods would indicate in the writeup if a dead bad guy had been converted. Also Finn was a jailer, which has properties of blocking and protecting. Protecting is, for obvious reasons, very good-guy but blocking can go either way, so IMO jailing can go either way.

Though MJ voted himself for mayor... but thats because he's mj haha.

MJ has also been somewhat successful in being mayor as a wolf so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

 

[Skimble]

Kill Skim

Today is my busy day with school and work so probably won't be around a ton. Hopefully will get back on before lynch close. Skim for reasons stating before. Lots of fluff, not much content. Don't like her position on the shelter lynch or much of her VCA in general.

If anyone is wondering.. no I'm not still supicious of stagg.. for obvious reasons.

Also, I know I don't have a lot of posts, but I feel like the posts I've made haven't been much fluff at all. I've had reasons for my votes, and I've stated my reasons for them.

 

[Karabiner13]

N6 Kill Tally

am () -
capri (1) - pip
snowy (1) - stagg
skim (1) - snowy

😏 Tie! 😏

3/11

Deadline 10pm est (~6.5 hours)

 

[capri1722]

My vca is usually pretty awesome when I’m a bad guy. Please go look at past games.

What does awesome mean in this context?

Meaning I often vote for bad guys and don’t often vote for the good guys who get killed.

I mean that's all pretty easy to fake when you're a bad guy, jussayin

I wanted a thorough analysis discussion with you, but now I feel stuck because you're leaving soon.

I guess the gist was you never really did much vote for/supect finn/MJ after N2 and it stuck out as notable to me that you voted with them yesterday.

I mean you can still post whatever you were gonna post, maybe the rest of us want to know what you were thinking.

Finn I had thought sounded a little sketchy at first, but I soft cleared after she defended Caiter pretty hard on the first day and Caiter stayed alive. Which, incidentally, is also why I am voting for Capri right now.

Not surprised. Ngl, I'm feeling a little defeatist after the writeup for reasons. Not to say I'm gonna self-vote and give up when you're the only one currently voting for me, but

Okay, I guess I don't remember you being much of a busser unless the villager is near/already outted but I can check.

I thought she had even used this as a defense in a recent game (that she specifically doesn't bus)? Or am I misremembering that?

Sometimes that happens. I really don't know why.

You and I would know this very well 😛

 

[Animal Midwife]

?

What?

 

[capri1722]

What?

I didn't follow your jump to "leave Dolphin alone"

 

[Animal Midwife]

I didn't follow your jump to "leave Dolphin alone"

Have you looked at my tallies yet?

 

[capri1722]

Have you looked at my tallies yet?

Kind of. I saw that you posted it. I appreciate you posting it because I like looking at them but until I learn how to do VCA they're not much more than just pretty to look at (for me).

Edit: Sorry, I didn't like how I worded that; I feel like I implied it's other people's responsibility to teach me VCA and it's not. Anyway I usually don't look super in-depth to tallies because it's hard for me to take anything away from them. They are satisfying to look at, however.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Kind of. I saw that you posted it. I appreciate you posting it because I like looking at them but until I learn how to do VCA they're not much more than just pretty to look at (for me).

Edit: Sorry, I didn't like how I worded that; I feel like I implied it's other people's responsibility to teach me VCA and it's not. Anyway I usually don't look super in-depth to tallies because it's hard for me to take anything away from them. They are satisfying to look at, however.

Well, night 5 had dolphin on the board and it was an interesting setup, if that helps any.

 

[Skimble]

I mean that's all pretty easy to fake when you're a bad guy, jussayin

Yes, I know. That's why I don't normally suck this badly when I'm a bad guy. Kinda my point.

 

[capri1722]

Yes, I know. That's why I don't normally suck this badly when I'm a bad guy. Kinda my point.

I meant that you can fake being bad at VCA as a bad guy. Or good too, I guess.

 

[capri1722]

Well, night 5 had dolphin on the board and it was an interesting setup, if that helps any.

So you believe that her having two wolves vote for her clears her? (Not here to dispute, just understand)

 

[Animal Midwife]

So you believe that her having two wolves vote for her clears her? (Not here to dispute, just understand)

Yes, why do that when she easily could have led the tally?

 

[Karabiner13]

N6 Kill Tally

am () -
capri (1) - pip
snowy (1) - stagg
skim (1) - snowy

😏 Tie! 😏

Missing: @Animal Midwife @dolphin106258 @ziggyandjazzy @johnnaboo @capri1722 @genny @Crayola227 @Skimble

3/11

Deadline 10pm est (~5 hours)

 

[Skimble]

Off topic... I passed NAVLE, nothing else matters.

 

[PippyPony]

Are you testing my reaction?

Yes. Totes. I'd also totally tell you & everyone else if I was doing a reaction test.

Come on, dude.

Ok but even an allusion to what you're building up to would be helpful. Just posting quotes with no explanation on why you chose to quote those posts is boring, disregarding whether or not it's sketchy.

qft

Yes, why do that when she easily could have led the tally?

Ok can you actually explain this to me, though

Here's N5

Night 5 Kill Tally
kc (7) - SAR, jboo, skimble, dolphin, snowy, am, genny
snowy (4) - cray, allie, stagg, kc, capri
MJ () -
dolphin (3) - Pip, finn, mj

Dolphin had 3 votes: two of them were villagers. She obviously was not going to vote for herself. KC had 7 votes. How do you get from "7-3 = a 4 vote difference" to "easily leading the tally," if 2 of the bad guys were already on that vote (or 3, if you're going with your theory about me)? idk, it just feels like a stretch to act like she was in imminent danger for days and days and that everyone who has ever voted for her is mega sketchballs

I mean, let's take a look at who was pushing her vote on previous days:

Night 3
dolphin (1) - allieh

Night 4
dolphin (2) - cray, allieh

What do you think of allie voting there 2 days in a row? Do you think those were fake votes? Didn't you have cray on your good guy list? What do you think of her vote?

And before you fly off the rails at me again about it -- I'm not voting for her today, and I actually agree with you that it's more likely that she is wolf based on those flips. I'm just saying that I don't understand your panic level, and to be blunt, I think there's a chance you're faking it to pocket her.

edit because I did the colors wrong

 

[Animal Midwife]

Ok can you actually explain this to me, though

Here's N5


Dolphin had 3 votes: two of them were villagers. She obviously was not going to vote for herself. KC had 7 votes. How do you get from "7-3 = a 4 vote difference" to "easily leading the tally," if 2 of the bad guys were already on that vote (or 3, if you're going with your theory about me)? idk, it just feels like a stretch to act like she was in imminent danger for days and days and that everyone who has ever voted for her is mega sketchballs

I mean, let's take a look at who was pushing her vote on previous days:

What do you think of allie voting there 2 days in a row? Do you think those were fake votes?

And before you fly off the rails at me again about it -- I'm not voting for her today, and I actually agree with you that it's more likely that she is wolf based on those flips. I'm just saying that I don't understand your panic level, and to be blunt, I think there's a chance you're faking it to pocket her.

I hope you mean wolf as in good or I will fly off the rails again.

Let me show you some progression tallies. Again, it's not just the last one that matters.

Night 5 Kill Tally
KC (4) - SAR, jboo, Skim, dolphin
Snowy (3) - AM, cray, allie
MJ (1) - KC
dolphin (3) - Pip, Finn, MJ

7/15
~6 hours until close

KC (4) - SAR, jboo, Skim, dolphin, Snowy
Snowy (3) - AM, cray, allie
MJ (1) - KC
dolphin (3) - Pip, Finn, MJ
~4 hours until close

KC (4) - SAR, jboo, Skim, dolphin, Snowy
Snowy (4) - AM, cray, allie, genny
MJ (1) - KC
dolphin (3) - Pip, Finn, MJ
~2 hours until close

KC (4) - SAR, jboo, Skim, dolphin, Snowy
Snowy (5) - AM, cray, allie, genny, Stagg
MJ (1) - KC
dolphin (3) - Pip, Finn, MJ
~1 hour until close

The final major difference was within an half hour until close.

Here's some bonus quotes too, if you'd like.

I wasn't thrilled about dolphin still sitting on the Caiter kill despite weak reasons to kill Caiter and a strong push from me that we should not. Just not sure why she was that attached to her kill vote. I hear that she wasn't feeling the SAR or Sporty lynch but like... she could have also swapped to someone else. The leading candidates are not the only options. Her sitting on the vote would have made more sense to me if she strongly felt SP and/or SAR were wolves and therefore wanted to save them by staying on another leading candidate, but the impression I got from her post was that she just largely didn't have strong opinions on them. Could also potentially vote here.

[...] feeling a little better about dolphin.

Although that said, this particular line...



...has me still keeping an eye on dolphin. Just not wanting to vote there yet because a lot of her responses before that were feeling wolfy even though I didn't get really get an answer per se.

kill dolphin

I'm in class and I honestly don't know when I'm going to be home tonight. Should be before night ends but might end up cutting it close.

I just keep coming back to this line...



It just sounds villagery to me. I put it on a back burner because I had started getting a wolfy vibe from several of her posts before that but it's been in the back of my mind.

Seems sound

Kill dolphin

 

[PippyPony]

I hope you mean wolf as in good or I will fly off the rails again.

it's more likely that she is wolf based on those flips

edit because I did the colors wrong

I think you might need a snickers

 

[PippyPony]

I hope you mean wolf as in good or I will fly off the rails again.

Let me show you some progression tallies.

Here's some bonus quotes too if you'd like.

Ain't nobody got time for that today, and I am saying I believe you, anyways. You're not helping your case in my mind by hammering it home even harder that you think she is a greenie.

Super easy to defend people whose affiliation you know, just sayin.

 

[Animal Midwife]

I think you might need a snickers

I'm still allergic, unfortunately.

 

[SkiOtter]

Off topic... I passed NAVLE, nothing else matters.

*******
I knew you would!!!! Congrats!!!

*******

 

[dolphin106258]

Ain't nobody got time for that today, and I am saying I believe you, anyways. You're not helping your case in my mind by hammering it home even harder that you think she is a greenie.

Super easy to defend people whose affiliation you know, just sayin.

This makes me think about Maze Runner 🙂 and it makes me happy.

 

[PippyPony]

Is anyone going to vote for anyone today?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Okay so after deliberating and sweating in PMs, I like this for the POE.

capri, Skim, Pippy, jboo +/- Snowy

Will

Kill Skim

for now since her argument is largely WIFOM