I think you are mixed up - last yeat, I had several friends interview at both campuses. All but 1 of the Tucson interviews were done by 4th yr students. I was hoping this changed. Phoenix even uses the dean to interview.
disclaimer: my sister is in a grad program for library studies and once finished and employed, most libriarians are considered faculty. They do a lot more than our HS librarians.
I last year I also had several friends interview at both campuses in addition to me, and I never heard of anyone who was interviewed by a student. Now that I am a student in Tucson I know even more people who interviewed here (and were accepted) and I have heard nothing about interviews by students. I myself was interviewed by the head of admissions or the king of admissions or something like that. I don't think students are common interviewers in Tucson, because I don't remember anyone at my interview saying something like, "awww man, my interview is with a student? No one else is interviewing with a student? Damn..." Which is something I assume would have come up. All that said, I'm not saying it doesn't happen on occasion where they need a student to fill in and do an interview or two, its just that I've never met anyone in person who had it happen. Even if it does, don't be worried. The student will be a) properly trained (although maybe nervous) and b) very understanding having been in your shoes just a couple of years earlier. Also, I think I can say with confidence that if a student interviews you, their feedback to the committee positive or negative will be treated the same as feedback from any other admissions committee person.
Anyways, I'm not sure if your friends were just by chance some of few interviewed by students, but we have more than ample admissions staff/faculty members here to where almost every interviewee should be interviewed by a faculty member. Plus, 4 year students are busy during the fall doing away rotations, preparing residency applications, going to residency interviews, etc. Although I remember Pitt used 4th years, so it wouldn't be unheard of but it also wasn't the only interview. Last year applicants to both campuses had one interview at each campus, but that may change this year with the new separate applications.
Also, I do want to point out that I wasn't taking a shot a librarians by any means. I know that at this level they have to have at least a basic understanding of what we're doing, so they can help us with literature searches and organizing things in a way that would be logical to us.
No, Lrk isn't mixed up. Every single person that I know that interviewed at Tucson, including yours truly interviewed with PhD/MD faculty. I did interview with Dean Flynn at Phoenix. Several of my current classmates interviewed with the librarian, who yes, is considered to be a pretty integral part of the staff of the school (if not faculty).
That seems to mirror what I had heard about the process last year. I think I interviewed with the assistant dean or the special assistant to the dean in Phoenix.
At a school like Phoenix with a smaller class size and also a smaller campus, I'm not surprised that the librarian is an integral part of the staff. I'd assume she does a lot more than standard "librarianing." Still, even if she was "just a librarian," if they have her interviewing people, her input would be treated just like any other admissions member's input, just like I said about student interviewers above.
Never heard of applicants being interviewed by students at the school. I don't even think the students are involved in the admissions process. Well, except for just being around to give us tours, answer questions, and eat lunch/breakfast with us. 😀
Yup, and when the students are with you on tour or at lunch, we really are just there to "be around." We really aren't secret spies out to ruin your chances at getting accepted. Although if you are a really, really big jerk then we might have to make an exception, but if you just like let a fart slip out we won't report it...
My Tucson interview was with a fourth year med student. I didn't know the librarian interviewed people at Phoenix. That's pretty cool, actually. One of them leaves copies of the NYTimes crossword puzzle for me. It's very sweet. Make friends with the librarians wherever you go.
The interviewers in Phoenix are pretty stellar, if I do say so myself.
Well, there you go. We found some one interviewed by a student in Tucson, so I guess it does happen from time to time. Until I read it here on SDN, I had heard nothing of the sort at either campus. Still, as I said before, don't let that throw you off or feel like you're chances are shot because "they won't care what some student says." If they have a student doing interviews as a fourth year, you can bet that person was hand selected for a reason and that their input will be considered equal to and other ADCOM.
I asked around and didn't find other SDNers at today's workshop. Maybe you are "cleaning up your social image", as suggested by the HR people today.
The information from Phoenix was awesome. Some segments were more informative than others, but the first opening segment on the new process by Tara was intimidating/exciting/informative/and on. I have to say the Phoenix campus progressive attitude to making the process more sound is impressive.
It's disappointing to find out the mock interviews next by the other office won't "mock" the new format. Oh well. Practice is still practice.
I'd suggest following that "cleaning up your social image" advice. While I highly doubt they would check on every applicant, it is not at all unreasonable to think that they might check on the select few they consider for an acceptance. Honestly, I don't think they'll be like, "wow, we were going to accept this guy/gal until we saw that one picture of them drinking alcohol on facebook," but if you have a whole bunch of them and/or pictures of you or attractive young ladies half naked they may reconsider. Still, its so freakin' easy to change your privacy settings on facebook that you'd be silly not to just do it for the 9 months you spend applying to medical school.
As for SDN, they apparently check this thread occasionally and have identified people from here, but those people were already accepted. Really, this thread, unless it gets way off topic, doesn't ever really have controversial stuff come up. Its mostly "just submitted by secondary," "yay I got an interivew," "awww man I met shep at my interview...he's not as big as his pictures in last year's thread make him look," etc., so if you're staying on topic even if they do identify you it won't be for anything bad. Unless your relevant topic was how much you hated the school, in which case you probably aren't interested in attending it anyways so it doesn't matter.