Back to Basics WW: A Cycling Edition - Game Thread

Started by Karabiner13
Veterinary Science Graduate Programs from U. of I.
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Browse articles Compare schools My application plan Read Interview Feedback
Practice for interviews Ask an Advisor
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
WildZoo said:
Once a player has a a majority of votes, lynch ends. So like, if there are 9 players, lynch ends once one wagon hits 5 votes, even if the deadline isn't for another like 10 hours.
Click to expand...

Also, lylo is like 10x more serious because one misvote can let the entire wolf team maj in a minute. (That is, if it's on at lylo.)
 
jaboo said:
Neither gave me results either. I got zero results this game. Fml.

Also, nice job with liking literally all of my posts until I called you out for pocketing and then you stopped :laugh:
Click to expand...
I actually wasn't intentionally pocketing you hahaha

I was intentionally pocketing AM & cray.

I just wanted to give you more of a chance to play 😉

Edit: but then it was end game and so I had to act like you were suddenly mega suspect
 
Yeah wolf chat hit page 2 or 3 within 2 hours of us getting it haha

And I did just want to publicly apologize for being particularly absent this game. I was actually genuinely more busy than I expected to be the last few days (thus the single post yesterday that Capri pointed out), between packing and moving.

Super grateful it was a quiet game so I could keep up, but also holy crap I’ve never played such a quiet game...

Also, I felt mega guilty for the Capri lynch because I think I would have even lynched myself today if I were in your guys’ shoes 😛
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
PippyPony said:
This sounds like my wolfing nightmare

Never should I be relied upon for quick votes
Click to expand...

lol Don't worry it's coordinated. No rapid voting happens until all wolves are available. Just have to double check that it's not mylo instead or something.

Makes it a little easier though if votes are locked too.
 
Animal Midwife said:
lol Don't worry it's coordinated. No rapid voting happens until all wolves are available. Just have to double check that it's not mylo instead or something.

Makes it a little easier though if votes are locked too.
Click to expand...
Locked votes is so scary lol
 
SkiOtter said:
Okay but like what is MyLo and how is it different from lylo
Click to expand...

MyLo is Mislynch or Lose and is technically what happened yesterday. (Which is why there was a night cycle instead of the game ending instantly.) During mylo you traditionally can choose to No Lynch and gain and extra cycle of evaluation to go into lylo. That's near non-existence on SDN though so it's not really that different that lylo mechanically.

Ways it can be used outside of No Lynch to enter lylo include there being a PR to protect/block against a kill, wolves not submitting a kill (lol who does that), a wolf and a villager dying in a tie, using lynch avoidance abilities, or wolf being killed at night. So mostly, just relying on a successful PR usage which is often hit-and-miss (or just non-existent) at that point in the game anyway. And that's why it's rarely announced.
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
WildZoo said:
I said this in spec chat. Or dead chat. One of those. But in a more typical setup I would likely have put this game at 3 wolves (and I think kara would agree) to keep it between a 1:4 and 1:5 ratio. Was interesting to see how a game with a MU setup would run here though. Theoretically an open setup, basic game would be more difficult for wolves...except that when it seems a majority of the village was very busy, and the most active player was a wolf, well...they don't necessarily need complicated mechanics to hide behind in that scenario. Hard for village to win relatively inactive games.

In case anyone was curious, we did one of the Matrix 12 setups, RNG chose D
View attachment 238777
Click to expand...
Ah ok, cool.

Yeah, I think I would have put this at 3 wolves and maybe nerfed the ninja wolf somehow. Tough to have an untrackable wolf, and 4 wolves was a very big wolf pack for a game this size.
 
On the inactivity -- I am probably in the minority here, but I also find it very difficult to WOLF when there is low activity. I prefer to operate by spinning things around on villagers, but in order for me to do that, the village has to be around & saying stuff.

Was also very concerned that people would realize we were yet again lynching a villager because the last day was so inactive.

Wolves would have been around to defend their own, given that it was lylo.

And @Animal Midwife -- I actually did think you were joking about lynching the lurkers at the beginning lol

I think it leads to villager lynches more often than it leads to wolf lynches
 
PippyPony said:
Ah ok, cool.

Yeah, I think I would have put this at 3 wolves and maybe nerfed the ninja wolf somehow. Tough to have an untrackable wolf, and 4 wolves was a very big wolf pack for a game this size.
Click to expand...
Yup. We chose to make no alterations to the setup, just to see how it would run. But yeah, a ninja basically negates your tracker, so becomes probably the most important wolf to kill.

MU (and mafiascum too i think) tend to run their games closer to 1:3 pretty much always. Almost all their basic setups are between 20 and 25% wolves.
 
For anyone who is curious, I did the kills every night to avoid the tracking, except for N2 when we used genny's 1x strongman to kill bryndi.

Mods -- would the kill have been stopped on bryndi if we had another wolf do the kill?

I don't generally think of bodyguards as being able to protect themselves, but otherwise the only use case I could see for the strongman kill is if the tracker role revealed and we wanted to get past the bodyguard.
 
Oh, going back to this set up -- I think this could have been better balanced by having a village blocker instead of a bodyguard.

We actually thought for a while on D1 that we were dealing with a block, before genny pointed out I read the intro post wrong haha

But blocker would have made it more difficult to have me do the kills every night, and so may have forced us to think more strategically about who should do the kills on which night.

Also would have made PR hunting a much higher priority; as it was, I only called Bryndi (probably would have killed her N2 even if she had not revealed) and I was kind of loosely looking for the masons without much success.
 
PippyPony said:
Interesting, I bet that leads to a lot more bus strategies.

Do you think that is that because people are not as familiar with the other players? More familiar?
Click to expand...
I'm not sure, the games are so ridiculously active on MU that I haven't managed to read through even one, let alone enough to get an idea of the player culture. Haven't ever played over there either.
Maybe @Animal Midwife has a better idea?
 
PippyPony said:
On the inactivity -- I am probably in the minority here, but I also find it very difficult to WOLF when there is low activity. I prefer to operate by spinning things around on villagers, but in order for me to do that, the village has to be around & saying stuff.

Was also very concerned that people would realize we were yet again lynching a villager because the last day was so inactive.

Wolves would have been around to defend their own, given that it was lylo.

And @Animal Midwife -- I actually did think you were joking about lynching the lurkers at the beginning lol

I think it leads to villager lynches more often than it leads to wolf lynches
Click to expand...

Contrary to popular belief, I do get stuck on ideas that have been refuted to lynch mainly villagers. I generally need tobe reminded every game that it's a fallacy otherwise I tunnel.

I was also hoping my meme would cause rage and spur discussion, but it was too late at that point, I guess.

Definitely agree on the low posting and wolfing though, it only makes me want to hide with the village and never post.

WildZoo said:
I'm not sure, the games are so ridiculously active on MU that I haven't managed to read through even one, let alone enough to get an idea of the player culture. Haven't ever played over there either.
Maybe @Animal Midwife has a better idea?
Click to expand...

Balancing-wise, I have no idea. But if it gives an idea of posting/analyzing content there versus here, I'm considered a low-poster. I weirdly found this game very balanced? The roles canceling each other out made it very vanilla-ish. Definitely more designed for heavily analysis rather than getting lucky with a result. Perhaps, dyachei would actually know how to adjust the ratios because she mods a lot there.

MafiaScum setups may align more with the type of posting that's here though as much as I enjoy the MU ones. Not sure if this actually answered the question or not, but that's my two cents.
 
PippyPony said:
Oh, going back to this set up -- I think this could have been better balanced by having a village blocker instead of a bodyguard.

We actually thought for a while on D1 that we were dealing with a block, before genny pointed out I read the intro post wrong haha

But blocker would have made it more difficult to have me do the kills every night, and so may have forced us to think more strategically about who should do the kills on which night.

Also would have made PR hunting a much higher priority; as it was, I only called Bryndi (probably would have killed her N2 even if she had not revealed) and I was kind of loosely looking for the masons without much success.
Click to expand...
Yeah looking through the matrix more closely, I'm not too much a fan of the balance in general. At least in my opinion it favors woofs, but I also think they go for a more 50/50 balance whereas I tend to want things to be more difficult for the wolves. It was used for the season 3 championship games so theoretically balanced decently but there may have been more restrictions on the roles that we didn't know about (for instance I definitely would have put restrictions on the ninja)
 
WildZoo said:
Yeah looking through the matrix more closely, I'm not too much a fan of the balance in general. At least in my opinion it favors woofs, but I also think they go for a more 50/50 balance whereas I tend to want things to be more difficult for the wolves. It was used for the season 3 championship games so theoretically balanced decently but there may have been more restrictions on the roles that we didn't know about (for instance I definitely would have put restrictions on the ninja)
Click to expand...

Yeah, that was specifically made to be a tougher version of this MS setup because it was a Champs game. Maybe that would work better for us?
 
Animal Midwife said:
Yeah, that was specifically made to be a tougher version of this MS setup because it was a Champs game. Maybe that would work better for us?
Click to expand...
Yeah I'm probably going to use either that one or this one if I even get 9 players for the next game
 
WildZoo said:
I kinda want to run a game with plurality rules...been a while since we've had one with that...might make for some quick cycles :heckyeah:
Click to expand...

I contemplated that for this game but the biggest complaint that happens when we try plurality over here is those that work and can't get on until the evening not being able to vote because if they vote too early they might cause plurality and then by the time they can get on, lynch is closed because of plurality. That and as Dubz knows, even modding I wasn't around enough that I would have been able to close once plurality hit

WildZoo said:
Yup. We chose to make no alterations to the setup, just to see how it would run. But yeah, a ninja basically negates your tracker, so becomes probably the most important wolf to kill.

MU (and mafiascum too i think) tend to run their games closer to 1:3 pretty much always. Almost all their basic setups are between 20 and 25% wolves.
Click to expand...

It was me being lazy and not wanting to figure out my own set-up. Definitely wanted to adjust this set-up but decided to see how it went. Definitely good starting point for future games as long as I tinker with the set-up

Animal Midwife said:
Balancing-wise, I have no idea. But if it gives an idea of posting/analyzing content there versus here, I'm considered a low-poster. I weirdly found this game very balanced? The roles canceling each other out made it very vanilla-ish. Definitely more designed for heavily analysis rather than getting lucky with a result. Perhaps, dyachei would actually know how to adjust the ratios because she mods a lot there.

MafiaScum setups may align more with the type of posting that's here though as much as I enjoy the MU ones. Not sure if this actually answered the question or not, but that's my two cents.
Click to expand...

I can see the roles balancing each other out but my only problem with the tracker/ninja was it essentially gave the tracker a role with no purpose. I hate making roles that have no purpose just to make roles. But RNG said D and I just wanted a quick set-up without too much messing around so here we were

Thanks for playing all! Now you've heard about Pelotonia and got to here me reminisce a little about the 2 times I've rode. Seriously considering training this next year so I can finally ride the 100 miles. It happens the 1st weekend of August every year. Didn't think I'd have the time off or the time to train with moving and starting a new job. Managed to have that whole weekend off (including Fri) which I thought was a funny coincidence considering I didn't ride this year. Anyone has recommendations for inexpensive yet good indoor trainer, let me know 🙂

I will be running more basics games with open or semi-open set-ups. Hope we can get more discussion, post analysis, and vote analysis going. And my version of basics just means it forces you to consider posts and votes rather than mechanics. It doesn't necessarily mean the roles will be basic
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Karabiner13 said:
I contemplated that for this game but the biggest complaint that happens when we try plurality over here is those that work and can't get on until the evening not being able to vote because if they vote too early they might cause plurality and then by the time they can get on, lynch is closed because of plurality. That and as Dubz knows, even modding I wasn't around enough that I would have been able to close once plurality hit
Click to expand...
I'm probably insane to attempt it but we'll see how it goooooes
 
Lawpy said:
Pippy-genny-Sporty wolf combination is seriously deadly. Combining this with good power wolfing effectively seals a well-deserved wolf win. Congrats!

Another game, another power wolfing and another reason to become active and start power villaging :watching:
Click to expand...

Huh. Surprised genny and pippy were wolves. That never happens. They are strict always-village kids.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

apoptosis09
JaWWs WW - Summer SWWashers Series #1 - GAME THREAD
22 23 24 25 26
Replies
1K
Views
31K
Clem J
Clem J
katiemcat
TWWilight (game thread)
25 26 27 28 29
Replies
1K
Views
22K
Clem J
Clem J
Zenge142
Zenge's Casino 2: WWhat HaWWpened To All That MoWWney?! - WW Game Thread
128 129 130 131 132
Replies
7K
Views
122K
mkg323
mkg323
WildZoo
Supernatural: Angels & Demons WW Game Thread
121 122 123 124 125
Replies
6K
Views
188K
GoSpursGo
GoSpursGo
kaydubs
Snack WWars (Game Thread)
55 56 57 58 59
Replies
3K
Views
97K
katiemcat
katiemcat