Cat's MeoWW - Game Thread

[PippyPony]

---

Members do not see this ad.

Are there certain roles that can be considered more village than wolfy?

PRs that is

Yes, but almost any role can be wolfy given the rest of the set up.

Tend to be village:

Innocent child
Masons
Affiliation seer
Ask-the-mod
Tracker
Protector


Probably in that order of most village to least.

 

[JustPaws]

Are there certain roles that can be considered more village than wolfy?

PRs that is

Roles can sometimes but not always be used to determine affiliation, why?

I want to say Finn doesn't like people solving via mechanics

 

[JustPaws]

Pm can definitely be village to share info but can be wolfy to pocket and gain/seek info

 

[Coopah]

So I hadn't really isoed Capri until you asked. Her train of thought naturally progresses but I don't really understand the pip vote since it seems jokey. I would personally hesitate to vote there when she has clearly said she will be gone most of the day, we aren't at end game.
I don't understand the Nav vote. I think his info is correct on me and so I don't think he is lying, but he is definitely interpreting it wrong/solving via a pattern that I don't think Finn would use based on her other games. I am also interested to see what he has to say today.

Wait what? Did I miss something when I died? I thought nav said he looked into you and thought you were wolfy. Has more come out on that front?

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

So what are your thoughts on barky voting kata D1?

I missed that. Let me go back to the tally. I’ve been operating solely on reads and feels this game.

 

[JustPaws]

Wait what? Did I miss something when I died? I thought nav said he looked into you and thought you were wolfy. Has more come out on that front?

He's still being really cryptic. I thought he knew my breed and had decided I was possibly wolfy but now I have no idea what he knows. Now he's just saying Capri and I got similar results. No idea what that means or if he's lying or telling the truth

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

So what are your thoughts on barky voting kata D1?

It’s neither here nor there for me. She was on it a bit later which is suspicious. And I’ve been known to purposely **** with VCA as a wolf so I don’t necessarily hold much stock in VCA.

 

[JustPaws]

It’s neither here nor there for me. She was on it a bit later which is suspicious. And I’ve been known to purposely **** with VCA as a wolf so I don’t necessarily hold much stock in VCA.

Do you think roids is village?

 

[Coopah]

Yes, I'm always happy to provide reasoning when people ask.

Coopah:
> Threw a lot of accusations out at people D1.
> Poor reasoning for initial D1 lynch.
> Didn't seem engaged/was a lazy player, especially when they didn't change their initial D1 vote even after saying they would change it if better info came up.

PippyPony:
> Your initial D1 vote on kata was interesting.
> Other players have posted as little or less than me, I'm curious why you chose to target me in particular.
> Some of the things you've said haven't made sense.

Funny you calling me a lazy player when I was actually playing and you dropped a retaliation vote and left.

 

[PippyPony]

@Coopah what are your thoughts on Dina

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

I missed that. Let me go back to the tally. I’ve been operating solely on reads and feels this game.

That's kinda weird to say when you accused me of voting for you when I never did

 

[PippyPony]

That's kinda weird to say when you accused me of voting for you when I never did

I dunno, I think that particular statement actually fits with her saying she's not paying attention to tallies lol

 

[Coopah]

Something is really bugging me regarding the Coops votes. I'm not sure what but gut feels are there's a wolf in the Coops wagon.

I would agree with you but I may be biased 😛

 

[Coopah]

I think it's weird that Mel/@Coopah wanted to vote elsewhere but then didn't change it.

I got pulled away, I was at clinic all day today

 

[Coopah]

@Coopah what are your thoughts on Dina

I think she's village

 

[PippyPony]

A PM opened with me and capri last night so I'm assuming she can open PMs with people. It may be stupid to come to that conclusion but it has me leaning her more village than wolf. It's technically an information gathering role and why would wolves need to gather information. They have the most information in the game.

I don't think this should be a village tick mark for anyone.

Wolves certainly need information -- it's why there are wolf seer-type roles. And wolf-village communication is the original reason why the Neighbor role exists.

There have also been variants of PM roles where they are linked to another wolf action to give wolves incentive to communicate. For example, talk to someone --> they are blocked the following night. Reminder that we still don't know what triggered Kata's extra kills.

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

Do you think roids is village?

I haven’t gotten wolfy feels from roids. Roids is in more of my middle pile. I don’t feel like either of our main lynches are wolves.

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

That's kinda weird to say when you accused me of voting for you when I never did

I thought you did yesterday? My bad.

 

[PippyPony]

That being said, all roles in a game should add up to a balanced set up, and considering that these mods had a minimum number of people they wanted to get for the game, they had roles/balancing locked before signups closed.

Therefore, I'd be skeptical if there were too many overlaps of similar types of roles. Wolves with a conditional extra kill that likely uses player data probably don't need a seer AND a PM role AND one or more communication/info gathering roles on top of that. At a certain point, it would be overkill.

 

[PippyPony]

Unlynch Acanth
Lynch Allie

I thought she said she would be around this weekend, and she's still missing in action.

 

[Coopah]

Anybody got a tally? Sorry still catching up all the way

 

[PippyPony]

I'm tempted to lynch @capri1722 because of a whole variety of factors, but I feel like her putting a contingency vote on me because she's pissed is kind of a bold move for her as a wolf

 

[allieh8607]

######lynch paws ######

For reasons, I think she should at least still be pressured

 

[allieh8607]

Also why don't any of the text formatting buttons work on my phone anymore... It is annoying af

 

[Lawpy]

Unofficial D3 Caturday Tally

Pipperoo (2) - acanth, Capri
acanth (4) - cubs, sporty, barks, MelCoop
MelCoop () -
Capri (1) - Lawpy
Dina (1) - Miz
Miz (2) - ZiggySARdust, Paws
Allie (1) - Pippy
Paws (1).- Allie

12/17 voting
@acanthuroidei you are leading

Missing: @Ms Procrastinator @dolphin106258 @genny @Dinashadow @Navilly

 

[Coopah]

Unofficial D3 Caturday Tally

Pipperoo (2) - acanth, Capri
acanth (4) - cubs, sporty, barks, MelCoop
MelCoop () -
Capri (1) - Lawpy
Dina (1) - Miz
Miz (2) - ZiggySARdust, Paws
Allie (1) - Pippy
Paws (1).- Allie

12/17 voting
@acanthuroidei you are leading

Missing: @Ms Procrastinator @dolphin106258 @genny @Dinashadow @Navilly

View attachment 271669

[/QUOTE]
Can I go back to being where I should've been when I actually voted?

 

[Barkley13]

I literally always think she’s wolfy. Always. I’ve started waiting to psychoanalyze her until other people start getting feels.

This is how I feel about you

 

[Lawpy]

Can I go back to being where I should've been when I actually voted?

Not sure, i just counted the post where you unlynched pip and lynched acanthy which was after the previous tally. Because apparently previous tallies didn’t account for your previous vote since you didnt unlynch 🙁

 

[Dinashadow]

Could you explain why you feel the way you do about coop/mel and cubs?

Because I've wolfed with Mel and can't think of a scenario where he'd allow AM to be NK'd N1. Yes it's WIFOMy but I feel strong enough about this that I'm willing to put them in my village pile for now.

Cubsy is neutral because I haven't seen anything that stands out to me as either wolfy or village. But it may be buried in between his cat photos lol. Why? Do you have thoughts on Cubs that I've missed?

 

[JustPaws]

######lynch paws ######

For reasons, I think she should at least still be pressured

Pressured how? I've been on thread discussing all day! Do you have any actual questions or are you just going to sit on this easy vote?

 

[PippyPony]

Guys I'm watching a Netflix show about cat shows on the recommendation of the mods & I feel like all of you should be made aware it exists

Catwalk: Tales from the Cat Show Circuit

Missed opportunity to call it "Tails from the cat show circuit" but still solid entertainment

 

[PippyPony]

Pressured how? I've been on thread discussing all day! Do you have any actual questions or are you just going to sit on this easy vote?

Ew you had been starting to make it up onto my village list, but the wording in this post feels hella weird to me

 

[JustPaws]

I haven’t gotten wolfy feels from roids. Roids is in more of my middle pile. I don’t feel like either of our main lynches are wolves.

So do you think barks is a wolf who voted for the wolf kata double kill instead of roids, who you think is village?

 

[JustPaws]

Ew you had been starting to make it up onto my village list, but the wording in this post feels hella weird to me

Then tell me how she's been pressuring me aside from getting me to spill my guts last night. This makes me want to vote for you.

 

[JustPaws]

You know what, my reads clearly are **** so far.
Unlynch Miz
lynch pippy
If pippy is village I will lynch roids tomorrow.

 

[allieh8607]

Then tell me how she's been pressuring me aside from getting me to spill my guts last night. This makes me want to vote for you.

You role name revealed and said you were a working breed if I recall correctly. Don't know how that equates to spilling your guts

 

[Lawpy]

You know what, my reads clearly are **** so far.
Unlynch Miz
lynch pippy
If pippy is village I will lynch roids tomorrow.

So you think Pippy bussed an extra kill wolf D1?

 

[PippyPony]

You know what, my reads clearly are **** so far.
Unlynch Miz
lynch pippy
If pippy is village I will lynch roids tomorrow.

...I said a single thing about one of your comments and you want me to die now?

I thought the exclamation point felt a little manufactured

 

[JustPaws]

It's crazy that pips thinks her position on that Lynch is the strongest. There were so many ways that it could have been flipped to any number of people

 

[JustPaws]

So you think Pippy bussed an extra kill wolf D1?

If she's a wolf she did it to create separation later. She likely never expected it to take off. It happened in the last three minutes of lynch

 

[JustPaws]

You role name revealed and said you were a working breed if I recall correctly. Don't know how that equates to spilling your guts

Then you haven't been paying attention if you are village

 

[Lawpy]

If she's a wolf she did it to create separation later. She likely never expected it to take off. It happened in the last three minutes of lynch

Ok so you’re going with that theory discussed before in D2.

 

[PippyPony]

It's crazy that pips thinks her position on that Lynch is the strongest. There were so many ways that it could have been flipped to any number of people

Lol you know what? You all can think whatever you want about that lynch.

I don't know what to do now because I don't usually have solid D1 reads, so honestly maybe it is better for me to die earlier

 

[JustPaws]

Ok so you’re going with that theory discussed before in D2.

Is there a better theory?

 

[acanthuroidei]

It's crazy that pips thinks her position on that Lynch is the strongest. There were so many ways that it could have been flipped to any number of people

Continuing this train of thought, if Pippy is a wolf who voted for a wolf D1 to point to for village cred later (not expecting the kata lynch to actually happen), once it started going, it would have looked so bad for her to change her vote. Once the the kata lynch gained momentum, a wolf that started that lynch really couldn't move off of it without gaining significant suspicion.

 

[Lawpy]

Is there a better theory?

It’s the only one that makes sense

 

[PippyPony]

Lmao although I do love how the least likely possibility is that I had a correct read on anyone

Thanks guys lol

Edit to add: and the most likely possibility is that I completely screwed over the wolf pack on D1. Tell me how you really feel lmao

 

[Dinashadow]

Lynch acanth

 

[JustPaws]

Continuing this train of thought, if Pippy is a wolf who voted for a wolf D1 to point to for village cred later (not expecting the kata lynch to actually happen), once it started going, it would have looked so bad for her to change her vote. Once the the kata lynch gained momentum, a wolf that started that lynch really couldn't move off of it without gaining significant suspicion.

No I'm not saying it was for village cred. Pippy often talks in woof chat about how to make it look like the wolves are interacting in non-wolfy ways vs avoiding each other.

 

[PippyPony]

No I'm not saying it was for village cred. Pippy often talks in woof chat about how to make it look like the wolves are interacting in non-wolfy ways vs avoiding each other.

This is dumb, and I hope for the sake of the village you continue to be better at other things than you are at interpreting my past wolf logic