Cat's MeoWW - Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Meh I think it's poor practice to allow someone to sub in for someone else who has already been in the game (sorry mods) for a variety of reasons. for one, coop was originally the item maker and new what item/items she had made. that info could be extremely useful to the wolves. when I was subbing in as a wolf, pip considered allowing mixy to sub in (she had already died) but thought better of it since mixy had had PMs with people and other useful info upon death that might not have been fair to bring back.



also, flavor cop: Flavor Cop - MafiaWiki I wonder if nav was trying to draw a NK?
To be fair, although it grates me to admit it. Old coop is dead and I am unable to reveal information to anyone about my past life, on thread, in PMs whatever.
 
Wolves were scared enough of Nav's ability they killed him last night, even though he didn't vote. I assumed his role was something more like a parity seer and I would imagine they did as well. this really makes me think capri is a poor vote, but I could be wrong about this. I would like to hear from her @capri1722
 
Lynch Allie

Now that Paws is gone and confirmed village idk why we aren’t more concerned/questioning of what happened with Allie blocking and the no kill. As opposed to Capri but maybe I’m just off this game, besides Capri being here less idk what about her play has been sketchy.
Um because allieh did the blocking of paws, and paws is dead?
 
Ok then tell me exactly how you are supposed to play a game with zero info? I know wolves lie but statistically speaking there are more villagers and villagers don't lie about their roles ... Oh wait
This sounds a bit like old coop logic here...I didn’t like acanth lying last game either but it doesn’t mean they are here. Also I was alive longer in that game to have to deal with that trauma. :laugh:
 
Ok then tell me exactly how you are supposed to play a game with zero info? I know wolves lie but statistically speaking there are more villagers and villagers don't lie about their roles ... Oh wait
Oh snap!
 
Um because allieh did the blocking of paws, and paws is dead?
Uhm Paws was quite suspicious of Allie surrounding the blocking. Since there was still a no kill how do I know allie is even the blocker. Or she isn’t a wolf blocker or like idk questions?!?!?
 
Officialish D4 SAIL Lynch Tally

Capri (3)
- lawp, dina, miz
Dolphin (1) - pip
Miz (1) - ziggySARdust
Roid (1) - coop
Allie (1) - dolphino
Pip (1) - roid

8/15 votes
Deadline: 10pm EST (~8.5 hours)

tenor (6).gif
 
Ok then tell me exactly how you are supposed to play a game with zero info? I know wolves lie but statistically speaking there are more villagers and villagers don't lie about their roles ... Oh wait

If a tree falls in a forest, does it make a sound?

If a direct quote someone just used is quoted back at them and they either forgot they said it or it doesn't fit their agenda anymore so they trash their own wisdom, does that make it wrong? I think not.
 
Uhm Paws was quite suspicious of Allie surrounding the blocking. Since there was still a no kill how do I know allie is even the blocker. Or she isn’t a wolf blocker or like idk questions?!?!?
I see your point
Also don’t act like my logic is so flawed when you’re voting acanth Bc you’re still salty about a past game..
I'm not voting there because I'm salty lol I'm voting there because she had a freaking lynch avoidance and people are somehow just cool with that?!
 
can anyone remember who jumped on the "test nav's info" besides allie?



So are people just going to ignore this when voting for capri? cool? cool.
@Lawper @mizchiefmanaged
Yup. It would be a great wolf move for Capri to kill the person who she knows is village after Nav said that. His information doesn’t necessarily sway me one way or another and I can see the way it would be a smart wolf move.
 
I see your point

I'm not voting there because I'm salty lol I'm voting there because she had a freaking lynch avoidance and people are somehow just cool with that?!

You THINK I had a lynch avoidance. That's not established fact. I'll point out I said it was a Lynch Cancel for any easily-manipulated readers.
 
I see your point

I'm not voting there because I'm salty lol I'm voting there because she had a freaking lynch avoidance and people are somehow just cool with that?!
using a Lynch avoidance (or a lot of roles) as a reason to Lynch someone is lazy play
 
Uhm Paws was quite suspicious of Allie surrounding the blocking. Since there was still a no kill how do I know allie is even the blocker. Or she isn’t a wolf blocker or like idk questions?!?!?

I could maybe get behind this. She also said shed be much more active over the weekend but her activity didnt really improve that much. Im now pretty hesitant about a capri lynch because of the nav info and him and paws both flipping village. Miz would be my other suspect right now.

lynch allie
 
If a tree falls in a forest, does it make a sound?

If a direct quote someone just used is quoted back at them and they either forgot they said it or it doesn't fit their agenda anymore so they trash their own wisdom, does that make it wrong? I think not.
Dude that's why I phased it that way. "Any chance you could just trust me?" Like I know it's not going to happen but a subtle hey, we should drop this conversation because I can't say anything else without giving the wolves more info so can we not? Then you jump all over me, again
 
Yup. It would be a great wolf move for Capri to kill the person who she knows is village after Nav said that. His information doesn’t necessarily sway me one way or another and I can see the way it would be a smart wolf move.
Interesting point but I think she was killed for her ability, not to prove capri isn't a wolf and this is making me side eye you so much harder
 
using a Lynch avoidance (or a lot of roles) as a reason to Lynch someone is lazy play
Cool just freaking cool I'm tired of being called lazy because I think differently than other people. I know we've butted heads before zigs and I respect you even if I don't agree with you, but like any chance you could lay off with the personal remarks?
 
Cool just freaking cool I'm tired of being called lazy because I think differently than other people. I know we've butted heads before zigs and I respect you even if I don't agree with you, but like any chance you could lay off with the personal remarks?

Evaluating someone's play is the whole point of this game. Calling your play lazy is different than calling you lazy.
 
Cool just freaking cool I'm tired of being called lazy because I think differently than other people. I know we've butted heads before zigs and I respect you even if I don't agree with you, but like any chance you could lay off with the personal remarks?
Im sorry I didnt mean this as a personal remark but I can see how you would think that.

could you consider that some roles may be sketchy but can still be village? iirc in the dogs game (or actually maybe a different game?) there was a villager who had a Lynch avoidance. and then there was miz with the Lynch cancel as a villager. so it's def possible
 
Evaluating someone's play is the whole point of this game. Calling your play lazy is different than calling you lazy.
You've called my play lazy for what exactly? I was on and playing and contributing and you retaliatory voted twice, that was your whole content. Ok imma take a walk because I'm clearly too annoyed to play properly
 
Other possibility guys, crazy I know. There is a protector in the game and stopped the first NK. I am notorious for hating blockers and generally want them dead. However I don’t think Allie is a wolf. Why would she come out with that information if she’s a wolf?
 
Im sorry I didnt mean this as a personal remark but I can see how you would think that.

could you consider that some roles may be sketchy but can still be village? iirc in the dogs game (or actually maybe a different game?) there was a villager who had a Lynch avoidance. and then there was miz with the Lynch cancel as a villager. so it's def possible
Yes, but I also believe in a natural dichotomy of things. I can't say more sorry
 
@allieh8607 assuming you are blocker, who did you block last night and why? might help us rule one of the killers out

Also, based off the way allie came out with that info, it doesnt feel super wolfy. like if I was a blocker and I blocked someone on a night with no kill, I would understandably be suspicious of the person I blocked
Girl you need to get out of your mother****ing tunnel.
point taken
 
I would also be interested in looking into those on the Kata vote. The second NK last night makes me think there are multiple wolves with multiple NK abilities. So as OP as kata did seem at first glance maybe she was actually the least valuable wolf?
 
I see your point

I'm not voting there because I'm salty lol I'm voting there because she had a freaking lynch avoidance and people are somehow just cool with that?!
Hmm okay, I’m not in agreement on it but I see the point behind your lynch, it was coming across more you were frustrated with acanth, not the fact that they had a sketchy role. I have had a lynch avoidance as a villager at least once and it just makes me more wary of voting for people with an outted ability like that.
 
I would also be interested in looking into those on the Kata vote. The second NK last night makes me think there are multiple wolves with multiple NK abilities. So as OP as kata did seem at first glance maybe she was actually the least valuable wolf?
Did you see my post earlier? paws could've been killed because she shared her role name. but that's purely conjecture
 
Other possibility guys, crazy I know. There is a protector in the game and stopped the first NK. I am notorious for hating blockers and generally want them dead. However I don’t think Allie is a wolf. Why would she come out with that information if she’s a wolf?
Hmm true.

Unlynch Allie

While I try to think.
 
You've called my play lazy for what exactly? I was on and playing and contributing and you retaliatory voted twice, that was your whole content. Ok imma take a walk because I'm clearly too annoyed to play properly

That was directed at OldCoop. You are now MelCoop.

This is the problem with using dead players as substitutes. I can't figure out if you're still salty from our interactions as OldCoop or if this is wolf play as MelCoop. This shouldn't be something I should be having to figure out, the game is complicated enough as it is without that.
 
I missed that. Do you think she was mod killed?
No. there were extra kills in their previous dogs game if wolves could guess or knew what dog group people's breed was. I could see something similar here?? but idk it's just a guess and I'm not sure I have seen a lot of the same mechanics used. maybe they had a copy cat wolf or something who could take someone's role upon death? I really have no idea
 
PLEASE DO NOT SHARE YOUR ROLE NAME (acanth, delete part of this ASAP)
now that I think of it, this could be the way that both paws and nav were killed the same night. Paws shared hers. for anyone who doesnt know, the mods ran the dog game and extra kills were given certain times if they knew the dog group someone was in

@mizchiefmanaged
 
No. there were extra kills in their previous dogs game if wolves could guess or knew what dog group people's breed was. I could see something similar here?? but idk it's just a guess and I'm not sure I have seen a lot of the same mechanics used. maybe they had a copy cat wolf or something who could take someone's role upon death? I really have no idea
Interesting. That was before my time. That’s a really interesting theory.

Edit: but then it’s interesting to me that they would have a wolf with a specific extra NK role.
 
I would also be interested in looking into those on the Kata vote. The second NK last night makes me think there are multiple wolves with multiple NK abilities. So as OP as kata did seem at first glance maybe she was actually the least valuable wolf?

so who is the most likely in that scenario for you? Still pippy? Or are you thinking one of the people who has assumed village cred?
 

Capri was... now backtracking some on that with the nav info in conjunction with paws and nav both flipping village.... which then leads me to...

Miz... who despite the info above is still going after capri saying that info is all suspect.... yet she's more willing to believe there are multiple wolves with multiple NK abilities? That seems odd... and then using that point to try to stir up suspicion on the other 4 kata voters who have seemed nothing but village to me except...

Pippy... who my initial tinfoil was about, but truly didnt make sense when you put the pieces together and consider the double kill wolf went down. But then if miz is actually right and somehow kata was the "least important" wolf (doubtful), then pippy shoots back up my list.

Also acanth, not totally sold on what happened there, but think there are better votes at this point. In fact...

unlynch allie
lynch miz
until I can get a better handle on what shes selling
 
Top