Cat's MeoWW - Game Thread

[dolphin106258]

---

Members do not see this ad.

@dolphin106258 @Ms Procrastinator @genny
who are your wolf leans?

Trying to decide, I still haven’t really loved dina’s Content thus far and still have her in my sketchy pile, I’ve seen others points on Allie, so I’m reevaluating on that. Someone mentioned there being a wolf possibly on the coop lynch, and since Paws is village, and I know I am that only leaves acanth and cubs and idk how I feel about that. Everyone keeps saying Barks is village but I still don’t feel it, but am pretty sure I’m tunneling.

 

[PippyPony]

Acanth admitting her role like that doesn't make a lot of sense with her being a wolf.

@acanthuroidei I moved off of you yesterday because the more you talked, the more you sounded like a wrong stubborn villager, not a wolf.

@mizchiefmanaged if you have been reading my posts enough to know that I'm not pinging you as a wolf, you should know that I've been very grumpy about people basically saying I'm incapable of making a correct read as a villager, so if you're retroactively wolf hunting by looking for people claiming village cred from that initial vote, then it seems like you're making up reads.

@ziggyandjazzy is making sense with the backup role suggestion and I agree that people with active power roles should not share that level of information on the thread if possible.

If there was a backup role, then there is probably a wolf on that Kata vote.

I do love Turkish Vans...always been one of my favorite cats. So I'm happy to know they are in the game lol

I think @SportPonies should be investigated at some point.

I thought that Paws was claiming protector FYI, so that's why I moved off of Allie when Allie said she had blocked Paws. I thought the reason for the no kill was likely either protection or blocking, so a blocked protector meant it couldn't have been protection. But, beyond that one comment, Paws has not sounded very wolfy to me, so I didn't vote for her either.

Looking back, it sounds like wolves either withheld a kill or it was a night cancel based on the "it was a quiet night" comment.

@acanthuroidei you can lynch me if you want; I'm not a particularly useful villager so if you think a flip would be more useful, then as I said last night, I have a lot of cat pics prepared to unleash on dead chat.

I would, however, like to know what info you would get beyond discovering I am in fact a villager. Because right now, that's basically all the info I think you're going to get because I think I've been voting off of main wagons for the most part.

 

[dolphin106258]

Excuse me? Are you suggesting that last minute bandwagons work out in village's favor? because I can show you how the majority of times it does not.

Hmm Mel said this right before the flip, and at the time I didn’t think anything of it but I really haven’t gone back and reread what was going on right before and after Kata flipped. Really wish AM wasn’t dead because I feel like she understood something I didn’t.

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

Capri was... now backtracking some on that with the nav info in conjunction with paws and nav both flipping village.... which then leads me to...

Miz... who despite the info above is still going after capri saying that info is all suspect.... yet she's more willing to believe there are multiple wolves with multiple NK abilities? That seems odd... and then using that point to try to stir up suspicion on the other 4 kata voters who have seemed nothing but village to me except...

Pippy... who my initial tinfoil was about, but truly didnt make sense when you put the pieces together and consider the double kill wolf went down. But then if miz is actually right and somehow kata was the "least important" wolf (doubtful), then pippy shoots back up my list.

Also acanth, not totally sold on what happened there, but think there are better votes at this point. In fact...

unlynch allie
lynch miz until I can get a better handle on what shes selling

I speak from experience when I say that as a wolf I have bussed other wolves multiple days in a row right from D1. So I don’t put much stock into how people voting making them village or not. Could be WIFOM but idk.

I’m not sure if there’s wolves with multiple NKs or if there’s simply a mechanic that allows multiple NK, which is what ziggy was conjecturing. But from what I’ve seen of village so far we’re pretty OP so I don’t doubt wolves are a bit OP as well. So yeah, I do kinda buy that there’s multiple wolves with multi NK abilities.

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

Acanth admitting her role like that doesn't make a lot of sense with her being a wolf.

@acanthuroidei I moved off of you yesterday because the more you talked, the more you sounded like a wrong stubborn villager, not a wolf.

@mizchiefmanaged if you have been reading my posts enough to know that I'm not pinging you as a wolf, you should know that I've been very grumpy about people basically saying I'm incapable of making a correct read as a villager, so if you're retroactively wolf hunting by looking for people claiming village cred from that initial vote, then it seems like you're making up reads.

@ziggyandjazzy is making sense with the backup role suggestion and I agree that people with active power roles should not share that level of information on the thread if possible.

If there was a backup role, then there is probably a wolf on that Kata vote.

I do love Turkish Vans...always been one of my favorite cats. So I'm happy to know they are in the game lol

I think @SportPonies should be investigated at some point.

I thought that Paws was claiming protector FYI, so that's why I moved off of Allie when Allie said she had blocked Paws. I thought the reason for the no kill was likely either protection or blocking, so a blocked protector meant it couldn't have been protection. But, beyond that one comment, Paws has not sounded very wolfy to me, so I didn't vote for her either.

Looking back, it sounds like wolves either withheld a kill or it was a night cancel based on the "it was a quiet night" comment.

@acanthuroidei you can lynch me if you want; I'm not a particularly useful villager so if you think a flip would be more useful, then as I said last night, I have a lot of cat pics prepared to unleash on dead chat.

I would, however, like to know what info you would get beyond discovering I am in fact a villager. Because right now, that's basically all the info I think you're going to get because I think I've been voting off of main wagons for the most part.

Can you reword that? The part involving me? Just assume that until yesterday all I was doing was skimming to the best of my abilities.

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

D1 tracker
Nav (1) - AM
Mizzy (1) - lawper
acanth (1) - barks
AM (1) - SARzazzle
acanth (2) - barks, coop
lawper (1) - cubs
genny (1) - miz
AM (0) - SARzazzle
lawper (2) - cubs, SARzazzle
capri (1) - Nav
Kata (1) - pip
Sporty (1) - Mel
Mel (1) - Dina
Barks (1) - MsP
Mel (2) - Dina, genny
Barks (2) - MsP, dolph
genny (2) - miz, sporty
Sporty (0) - Mel
acanth (3) - barks, coop, Mel
Nav (2) - AM, kata
Nav (3) - AM, kata, paws
lawper (1) - cubs, SARzazzle
Mel (3) - Dina, genny, SARzazz
Coop (1) - roids
Paws (1) - allie
Nav (2) - AM, kata, paws
capri (0) - Nav
Paws (2) - allie, Nav
acanth (4) - barks, coop, Mel, kata
Mel (2) - Dina, genny, SARzazz
acanth (5) - barks, coop, Mel, kata, Dina
cubs (1) - capri
Mizzy (0) - lawper
Kata (2) - pip, lawper
Nav (1) - AM, paws
Kata (3) - pip, lawper, AM
acanth (4) - barks, coop, Mel, kata, Dina
Nav (2) - paws, Mel
acanth (3) - barks, coop, kata, Dina
Kata (4) - pip, lawper, AM, barks
Mel (1) - genny, SARzazz
Kata (5) - pip, lawper, AM, barks, SARzazzle

Looking at this again I feel lawper and Pip actually get the least amount of credit for the vote. pip for previous discussed reasons. lawper because when he voted for kata he made 2 votes on kata when there were still 5 on acanth. with only 4 minutes left. I'm not saying he is a wolf, but just stuff to consider for later

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

##unlynch miz
Lynch MsP###

 

[PippyPony]

And omg, I'm not asking for village cred from a single day 1 vote. It was initially my own interpretation that the lynch formed quickly enough that I personally was clearing the OTHER PEOPLE on that lynch, and it is a moot point anyways now because of the other factors going on.

I have just felt the need to defend myself against people who are saying I did something super careless as a wolf or have zero ability to interpret comments as a villager, because that's a bit of a bummer. But for the love of god everyone PLEASE MOVE ON AND FIND OTHER THINGS TO TALK ABOUT. I've purposefully done a lot of sketchy things this game but no takers on those things I guess lol

Like I said, if you think I'm a good info vote -- do it.

But if people lynch me based on only that one vote, I'm going to be hella pissed and will pitch a fit before it happens, and I guarantee you there will be wolves pushing the idea because it's something they can latch onto easily.

I told you I do not like being left alive as wolf bait and you will see me angry about it before I go down if I feel that's what is happening.

 

[acanthuroidei]

I would, however, like to know what info you would get beyond discovering I am in fact a villager. Because right now, that's basically all the info I think you're going to get because I think I've been voting off of main wagons for the most part.

I've been wondering if what you're doing is starting villager lynches, then moving off of them later so that you don't look like you voted to lynch a villager on the final tally.

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

And omg, I'm not asking for village cred from a single day 1 vote. It was initially my own interpretation that the lynch formed quickly enough that I personally was clearing the OTHER PEOPLE on that lynch, and it is a moot point anyways now because of the other factors going on.

I have just felt the need to defend myself against people who are saying I did something super careless as a wolf or have zero ability to interpret comments as a villager, because that's a bit of a bummer. But for the love of god everyone PLEASE MOVE ON AND FIND OTHER THINGS TO TALK ABOUT. I've purposefully done a lot of sketchy things this game but no takers on those things I guess lol

Like I said, if you think I'm a good info vote -- do it.

But if people lynch me based on only that one vote, I'm going to be hella pissed and will pitch a fit before it happens, and I guarantee you there will be wolves pushing the idea because it's something they can latch onto easily.

I told you I do not like being left alive as wolf bait and you will see me angry about it before I go down if I feel that's what is happening.

Is there anybody that’s actually lynching you based solely on that D1 vote?

 

[PippyPony]

Ah, lovely.

See above for comments about wolves continuing to analyze my position on that vote, because in the time I typed it out, multiple people commented.

When I flip village, lynch those people next.

 

[PippyPony]

I've been wondering if what you're doing is starting villager lynches, then moving off of them later so that you don't look like you voted to lynch a villager on the final tally.

I'm not afraid of people seeing me vote for villagers and I don't care how you think my votes look. I'm voting for people I think are sketchy.

 

[PippyPony]

Can you reword that? The part involving me? Just assume that until yesterday all I was doing was skimming to the best of my abilities.

I'm saying your logic sounds inconsistent -- if you have seen enough to get a read on me, you have seen enough to know what I've been posting about because people will not move on

 

[acanthuroidei]

@acanthuroidei you can lynch me if you want; I'm not a particularly useful villager so if you think a flip would be more useful, then as I said last night, I have a lot of cat pics prepared to unleash on dead chat.

I would, however, like to know what info you would get beyond discovering I am in fact a villager. Because right now, that's basically all the info I think you're going to get because I think I've been voting off of main wagons for the most part.

I think it would provide insight into the kata lynch, your votes on allie, and the suspicions you've been throwing at capri at the very least.

 

[dolphin106258]

D1 tracker
Nav (1) - AM
Mizzy (1) - lawper
acanth (1) - barks
AM (1) - SARzazzle
acanth (2) - barks, coop
lawper (1) - cubs
genny (1) - miz
AM (0) - SARzazzle
lawper (2) - cubs, SARzazzle
capri (1) - Nav
Kata (1) - pip
Sporty (1) - Mel
Mel (1) - Dina
Barks (1) - MsP
Mel (2) - Dina, genny
Barks (2) - MsP, dolph
genny (2) - miz, sporty
Sporty (0) - Mel
acanth (3) - barks, coop, Mel
Nav (2) - AM, kata
Nav (3) - AM, kata, paws
lawper (1) - cubs, SARzazzle
Mel (3) - Dina, genny, SARzazz
Coop (1) - roids
Paws (1) - allie
Nav (2) - AM, kata, paws
capri (0) - Nav
Paws (2) - allie, Nav
acanth (4) - barks, coop, Mel, kata
Mel (2) - Dina, genny, SARzazz
acanth (5) - barks, coop, Mel, kata, Dina
cubs (1) - capri
Mizzy (0) - lawper
Kata (2) - pip, lawper
Nav (1) - AM, paws
Kata (3) - pip, lawper, AM
acanth (4) - barks, coop, Mel, kata, Dina
Nav (2) - paws, Mel
acanth (3) - barks, coop, kata, Dina
Kata (4) - pip, lawper, AM, barks
Mel (1) - genny, SARzazz
Kata (5) - pip, lawper, AM, barks, SARzazzle

Looking at this again I feel lawper and Pip actually get the least amount of credit for the vote. pip for previous discussed reasons. lawper because when he voted for kata he made 2 votes on kata when there were still 5 on acanth. I'm not saying he is a wolf, but just stuff to consider for later

Hard disagree if you go back and actually reread the time surrounding the votes not just this tally. As much as I don’t like it there would be NO reason for wolf lawpy to do that.

 

[PippyPony]

I think it would provide insight into the kata lynch, your votes on allie, and the suspicions you've been throwing at capri at the very least.

Am I voting for Capri anymore?

No, because Nav flipped village and so did Paws.

So that's not particularly valuable info.

 

[dolphin106258]

lynch melcoop

I shall explain in many quotes, I’m sorry in advance but it’s helpful.

 

[PippyPony]

Hard disagree if you go back and actually reread the time surrounding the votes not just this tally. As much as I don’t like it there would be NO reason for wolf lawpy to do that.

This sounds like a wolfy Dolphin statement to me.

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

@cubsrule4e @dolphin106258 @Ms Procrastinator @genny
who are your wolf leans?

Pippy
Allie
Barks
Possibly acan

 

[acanthuroidei]

lynch melcoop

I shall explain in many quotes, I’m sorry in advance but it’s helpful.

I am very excited to hear about this. I agree with your suspicions, but the salty OldCoop versus wolfy MelCoop dilemma was too much for me to try unravelling right now.

 

[dolphin106258]

I think it would provide insight into the kata lynch, your votes on allie, and the suspicions you've been throwing at capri at the very least.

Man Pippy I’m gonna hate myself if you fooled me again, but I really disagree with this sentiment, I haven’t really thought Pippy had any suspicions about Capri, she had to discuss it just like anyone else as soon as Nav brought it up.

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

See above for comments about wolves continuing to analyze my position on that vote, because in the time I typed it out, multiple people commented.

When I flip village, lynch those people next.

So you're saying you think me, miz, or acanth is a wolf based off commenting on this? then why aren't you voting for any of us? this makes no sense

 

[dolphin106258]

This sounds like a wolfy Dolphin statement to me.

Boo to you. I’m not a wolf.

 

[PippyPony]

Pippy
Allie
Barks
Possibly acan

I'm at the top of your wolf list all of a sudden?

 

[dolphin106258]

Pippy
Allie
Barks
Possibly acan

Now this list makes me suspicious of you. Ugh.

 

[Lawpy]

Unlynch capri
Lynch mizzy

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

Hard disagree if you go back and actually reread the time surrounding the votes not just this tally. As much as I don’t like it there would be NO reason for wolf lawpy to do that.

LOL I DID go back and read. are you actually reading what I am saying? I didnt even imply he was a wolf. just saying his vote isn't THAT clearing due to the timing and count at the time

 

[PippyPony]

So you're saying you think me, miz, or acanth is a wolf based off commenting on this? then why aren't you voting for any of us? this makes no sense

Well, apparently I am incapable of speaking sense.

If you're village, then it seems you think wolves are dummies, and in my opinion you deserve to get snookered by them. So yes, I would like you all lynched when I flip village.

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

Dear god. All y’all are dum dums. And I mean that lovingly but still.

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

I'm at the top of your wolf list all of a sudden?

You've kind of always been

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

I’m a bad lynch y’all.

 

[Ms Procrastinator]

##unlynch miz
Lynch MsP###

Why?

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

Well, apparently I am incapable of speaking sense.

If you're village, then it seems you think wolves are dummies, and in my opinion you deserve to get snookered by them. So yes, I would like you all lynched when I flip village.

I think you personally need to take a break from this game.

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

unOfficialish D4 SAIL Lynch Tally

Capri (2) - dina, miz
Dolphin (1) - pip
Miz (2) - cubs, lawp
Acanth (1) - coop
Allie () -
pip (1) - acanth
MsP (1) - ziggySARdust
mCoop (1) - dolph

9/15 votes
Deadline: 10pm EST (~7 hours)

View attachment 271774

 

[WildZoo]

Officialish D4 SAIL Lynch Tally

Capri (2) - dina, miz
Dolphin (1) - pip
Miz (2) - cubs, lawp
Roid (1) - coop
Pip (1) - roid
Coop (1) - dolphino
MsP (1) - ziggySARdust

@capri1722 and @mizchiefmanaged you are winning!!
9/15 votes
Deadline: 10pm EST (~7 hours)

 

[WildZoo]

Omg stop that

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

Now this list makes me suspicious of you. Ugh.

Bring on the quotes!!! 😛

 

[dolphin106258]

Pippleton!! Didnt even realize you were playing! How art thou?

Did a slower read through thread and I have to be honest nothing is really standing out. Ziggy/AM business seems par for the course, or really ziggy and anyone she interacts with that way. Seems the active people are extremely active, and the non active people are non existent. Barks does seem unusually quiet though. 1/2 point on my radar. Miz also seems really quiet but I didnt note if she mentioned being really busy currently.

Also, if I happen to just disappear for a day or two over the weekend its because I lost power/internet from the incoming hurricane. Now back to hurricane party planning, no work tomorrow!!

This post was right after Pippy posted her vote for Kata and idk it just set off a lot of feels. She did that at like 5:30-5:40 btw.

Unofficial Day 1 Lynch Tally
Nav (1) - AM
miz (1) - Lawpy
acan (2) - Barks, Coop
AM () -
Lawpy (2) - cubs, ziggy
genny (1) - miz
capri (1) - Nav
kata (1) - Pippy
Sporty (1) - Mel

10/20
lynch close in ~2.5 hours

Then this almost two hours later where there is hardly any movement. Aka probs not any wolves in danger.

This weirds me out considering I can recall 2 separate games where you've been a wolf and asked somebody their reads on 3 different players.

And the fact that pippy seems confused about why you were asking makes me even more suspicious about it

lynch mel

I was kinda thinking the same thing tbh, but now it seems retaliatory for me to vote for him so that’s fun lol

Then Dina and sporty make these weird posts surrounding Mel and his comments to pip and if I go with pippy being village in this context it makes me feel worse about Mel and at least one of them.

Why do you care if it seems retaliatory?

Then you have pip comment at Sporty and they’re all around the same time in the interactions which just makes it feel weirder.

lynch mel

Hmm don’t remember why I quoted this.

Unofficial Day 1 Lynch Tally
Nav (1) - AM
miz (1) - Lawpy
acan (2) - Barks, Coop
AM () -
Lawpy (2) - cubs, ziggy
genny (1) - miz
capri (1) - Nav
kata (1) - Pippy
Sporty (1) - Mel
Mel (2) - Dina, genny
Barks (1) - MsP

13/20
acan, Lawpy, and @Melchizedek you are in the lead
Missing: Sporty, kata, acan, capri, allie, Paws, dolphin
lynch close in ~1 hour

Now we have this tie with still a little while to go but it’s much closer.

hmmmm

Unlynch Sporty
Lynch Roids

wanna see how this plays out.

Unofficial Day 1 Lynch Tally
Nav (1) - AM
miz (1) - Lawpy
acan (3) - Barks, Coop, Mel
AM () -
Lawpy (2) - cubs, ziggy
genny (2) - miz, Sporty
capri (1) - Nav
kata (1) - Pippy
Sporty () -
Mel (2) - Dina, genny
Barks (2) - MsP, dolphin

15/20
acan, you are in the lead
Missing: kata, acan, capri, allie, Paws
lynch close in ~40 minutes

by "this" I thought I was creating a tie between roids and barks but turns out I just broke the three way ties. meh.

Yes, you broke the three-way tie you were a part of.

Then Mel comes on and acts like he doesn’t realize he broke the tie because he was part of the tie. Big dislike.

what gives you the impression that this is a situation that wolves would be interested in influencing/swinging?

I think he asks zig this, again not liking.

Unofficial Day 1 Lynch Tally
Nav (3) - AM, kata, Paws
miz (1) - Lawpy
acan (3) - Barks, Coop, Mel
AM () -
Lawpy (2) - cubs, ziggy
genny (2) - miz, Sporty
capri (1) - Nav
kata (1) - Pippy
Sporty () -
Mel (2) - Dina, genny
Barks (2) - MsP, dolphin

17/20
acan and @Navilly, you are in the lead
Missing: acan, capri, allie
lynch close in ~30 minutes

Now with thirty minutes left Mel is out of contention and acan and Nav a confirmed villager are up.

that's all you got?

if like 4 people are tied it's just stats that there is a higher % there's a wolf there and it could be swung off them

so when have you seen him low content post when a wolf? if that's what you're insinuating




hmm a tie seems kinda interesting to me now. idk I know I just said it was stressing me out, but that was when there were 2 votes on many people

### unclench lawp
lunch Mel###

Then zig puts mel back in contention.

Unofficial Day 1 Lynch Tally
Nav (3) - AM, kata, Paws
miz (1) - Lawpy
acan (3) - Barks, Coop, Mel
AM () -
Lawpy (1) - cubs
genny (2) - miz, Sporty
capri (1) - Nav
kata (1) - Pippy
Sporty () -
Mel (3) - Dina, genny, ziggy
Barks (2) - MsP, dolphin
Coop (1) - acan

18/20
acan, Nav, and @Melchizedek you are in the lead
Missing: capri, allie
lynch close in ~15 minutes

Unofficial Day 1 Lynch Tally
Nav (2) - AM, Paws
miz (1) - Lawpy
acan (3) - Barks, Coop, Mel
AM () -
Lawpy (1) - cubs
genny (2) - miz, Sporty
capri (1) - Nav
kata (1) - Pippy
Sporty () -
Mel (3) - Dina, genny, ziggy
Barks (2) - MsP, dolphin
Coop (1) - acan
Paws (1) - allie

18/20
acan and Mel, you are in the lead
Missing: capri, kata
lynch close in ~10 minutes

Now with ten minutes left it’s just Mel and acanth up, idk if it truly is Mel, that’s the vibe I get, but I think the votes now should 100% be between them above others.

I think i’ll go with

Unlynch mizzy
Lynch katachomp

Then lawp does this with less than ten minutes left? No way does that look like a wolf move.

Unofficial Day 1 Lynch Tally
Nav (2) - AM, Paws
miz () -
acan (5) - Barks, Coop, Mel, kata, Dina
AM () -
Lawpy (1) - cubs
genny (2) - miz, Sporty
capri () -
kata (2) - Pippy, Lawpy
Sporty () -
Mel (3) - Dina, genny, ziggy
Barks (2) - MsP, dolphin
Coop (1) - acan
Paws (2) - allie, Nav
cubs (1) - capri

20/20
acan, you are in the lead
lynch close in ~2 minutes

Idk if all the wolves would vote together (probs not) but the last ones on acanth at this point with a pretty confidently sealed lynch are Dina, Mel and Kata.

Unlynch Nav
Lynch kata

Unlynch Roids
Lynch Navs.

My initial roids vote was because I thought I was creating a tie. I feel like this lynch is bad but Navs sounds like he needs to be relieved of his WW duties whether he is a wolf or not so I'm okay seeing him go.

Then Mel moves which is the only thing that maybe gives him a village tick mark unless acanth is also a wolf which like LOL at this point.

Ehh I didn’t like that

Unlynch acanthy
Lynch kata

###unlynch mel
Lynch kata###

Then barks and zig come on and seal kata’s fate which don’t look like Wolfy moves to me in context.

Hold on. What just happened. How did no one bat an eye at such a quick last minute wagon?
WTF y'all.

Then Mel flips out which also would a wolf do this when they know what’s gonna happen idk. But it didn’t give me good feels either way. If I wasn’t voting Mel I’d go for Dina, acanth or Sporty.

 

[dolphin106258]

Bring on the quotes!!! 😛

They are here. Sorry for the length.

 

[PippyPony]

I think you personally need to take a break from this game.

I am fine, thanks for your concern

Like my favorite animals, I reserve the right to swat and bite u after I have given some hisses as warning signals.

 

[dolphin106258]

LOL I DID go back and read. are you actually reading what I am saying? I didnt even imply he was a wolf. just saying his vote isn't THAT clearing due to the timing and count at the time

Well then idk what would be clearing, because pippy is the only one that voted very early so if that isn’t clearing, then by contrast super close last minute votes would be clearing which is you, lawpy, and Barks.

 

[ziggyandjazzy]

Well then idk what would be clearing, because pippy is the only one that voted very early so if that isn’t clearing, then by contrast super close last minute votes would be clearing which is you, lawpy, and Barks.

Go back and look again please. I said timing and count. When lawper voted for kata, he made 2 votes on kata, when there were 5 on acanth. Barks swung from acanth to kata, totally flipping the vote. so she is the most cleared (besides dead AM RIP) based on the voting imo. lawyer's isn't nearly as strong considering that 4 min before close, kata wasn't even in contention

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

This post was right after Pippy posted her vote for Kata and idk it just set off a lot of feels. She did that at like 5:30-5:40 btw.

Then this almost two hours later where there is hardly any movement. Aka probs not any wolves in danger.


Then Dina and sporty make these weird posts surrounding Mel and his comments to pip and if I go with pippy being village in this context it makes me feel worse about Mel and at least one of them.

Then you have pip comment at Sporty and they’re all around the same time in the interactions which just makes it feel weirder.

Hmm don’t remember why I quoted this.

Now we have this tie with still a little while to go but it’s much closer.




Then Mel comes on and acts like he doesn’t realize he broke the tie because he was part of the tie. Big dislike.

I think he asks zig this, again not liking.

Now with thirty minutes left Mel is out of contention and acan and Nav a confirmed villager are up.

Then zig puts mel back in contention.


Now with ten minutes left it’s just Mel and acanth up, idk if it truly is Mel, that’s the vibe I get, but I think the votes now should 100% be between them above others.

Then lawp does this with less than ten minutes left? No way does that look like a wolf move.

Idk if all the wolves would vote together (probs not) but the last ones on acanth at this point with a pretty confidently sealed lynch are Dina, Mel and Kata.


Then Mel moves which is the only thing that maybe gives him a village tick mark unless acanth is also a wolf which like LOL at this point.


Then barks and zig come on and seal kata’s fate which don’t look like Wolfy moves to me in context.

Then Mel flips out which also would a wolf do this when they know what’s gonna happen idk. But it didn’t give me good feels either way. If I wasn’t voting Mel I’d go for Dina, acanth or Sporty.

Just unpacked this a little bit. Mel has been on my feelz list from the beginning; not sure how much of that was initial bitterness about past games or not. I could get behind this. It makes logical sense.

 

[dolphin106258]

Just unpacked this a little bit. Mel has been on my feelz list from the beginning; not sure how much of that was initial bitterness about past games or not. I could get behind this. It makes logical sense.

What’s bothering me about it is just the fact that he moved off of acanth last minute which is why Kata was able to beat out acanth otherwise it would’ve been a tie.

 

[dolphin106258]

Go back and look again please. I said timing and count. When lawper voted for kata, he made 2 votes on kata, when there were 5 on acanth. Barks swung from acanth to kata, totally flipping the vote. so she is the most cleared (besides dead AM RIP) based on the voting imo. lawyer's isn't nearly as strong considering that 4 min before close, kata wasn't even in contention

I get this but why would lawp even vote there at all with like four minutes left. That just doesn’t make logical sense to me, sure vote for someone other than Kata, I could see that being constrewed as trying to offset something or look better in retrospect. But voting there just doesn’t make any sense when acanth was leading. Again I wouldn’t ever clear someone 100% off of one vote but I just don’t think with the other issues surrounding that vote I would put lawp in my list of sketchy people.

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

Putting this out there because I need to ‘clear’ someone for the sake of sanity.

If barks was the one who broke the tie towards kata on D1 I’m just going to call her cleared in my book. I hate hate hate voting patterns since it’s so easy to throw a wolf under the bus to look good but I do make a bit of an exception for breaking ties towards wolves. And I need to have someone on my more or less cleared list or I’ll go insane.

Dolphin is playing like normal dolphin to me. She went back and dig through pages of crap to find reasons why someone is sketchy and honestly, her reasoning makes logical sense. She’s in my village category.

Wolfy possibly in no real order:
Dina: has not been putting a lot of logic into votes or posts from what I’ve been seeing.
Cubs: I have reasons that I’m forgetting and now that I can actually ISO on my phone (thank god) I’ll go back and find quotes.
Melcoop: dolphin logic
Capri (if I go hardcore into WIFOM involving yesterday’s NKs, which I may be overdoing)
Genny I may just be tunneling.

 

[PippyPony]

Unlynch dolphin
Lynch cubs

 

[PippyPony]

Analysis is sounding more village; wolfy dolphin rarely pulls lots of quotes.

 

[mizchiefmanaged]

Meh. On reread I can’t find why exactly cubs seems sketchy to me. I’m backing off of that atm.

 

[PippyPony]

Meh. On reread I can’t find why exactly cubs seems sketchy to me. I’m backing off of that atm.

He's been here liking posts but not commenting, he's been sucking up to me a bit...I'm interested in some pressure there.