I mean sure, it's potentially telling that AM wasn't subbed back in, because if they were drawing from dead people, she was the first villager dead. As in, she may have already had spoilers that Coop did not, and spoilers would not really matter if Coop was subbing back in for a wolf.
On the other hand, AM hates wolfing and Coop does not, so it may have been offered and declined.
Basically, there could be multiple options and therefore it's probably best not to use it.
Personally I'm trying to ignore those thoughts when they pop up, because I feel like
@finnickthedog would hiss at me so bad for using mod choices for affiliation seering, and
@Caiter92 seems like a kitten who might spit if asked to deal with this kind of silliness.