CHOOSE YOUR OWWN - Game Thread

[deleted804295]

---

Members don't see this ad.

Cool cool, that’s great
you said you think we’re at lylo.
so that would mean you acknowledge we likely have two scum.

I'm very confused right now!
Everyone role claimed but there are people lying. I'm not used to making it to near endgame like this so I've never dealt with lying on this magnitude on SDN WW before.

 

[deleted804295]

I posted my thoughts throughout the thread.

Night actions:
N1 Wonder, not maf
N2 Kata, no results
N3 Bark, not maf

Based on the very little kata and sporty have posted this entire game (which has gone on for 4 days) I've been sus of them.

I was sus of Dubz until last night but now I'm no longer sus of them. I'm fairly certain I know their role based on context clues last night but I might be wrong.

@WildZoo

 

[deleted804295]

So Dubz claimed Judas.

That isn't even a town role wtf

 

[deleted804295]

I looked on mafia wiki and it says Judas is alignment changing

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 4 Lynch Tally
kata (2) - Suni, dubz
Sporty () -
Wonder () -
dubz (1) - Barks
Suni (1) - kata

4/6
@katashark is in the lead
lynch close in ~45 minutes
Missing: Wonder, Sporty

 

[WonderingStudent]

I looked on mafia wiki and it says Judas is alignment changing

if Judas is lynched, they become mafia wincon

 

[WildZoo]

I looked on mafia wiki and it says Judas is alignment changing

Yes, if i am lynched I switch to mafia
I tend not to be lynched so I figured it was a good vanilla-esque role, of my options. I'm town-sided as long as I'm not lynched.

 

[deleted804295]

That means there are 2 scum + 1 judas right now meaning town is tied with scum.

We mislynch and we lose.

Dubz - Judas
Kata - Hider claim
Barkley- Bloodhound (investigative) claim; said wonder and sport are village
Wonder- no claim
Sporty- no claim
Suni-cop

 

[deleted804295]

Would it be too early for @WonderingStudent and @SportPonies to claim?

 

[deleted804295]

Everyone has claimed thus far. Besides wonder and sport. Barkley claimed both are village but there's no reason why we need to believe Bark's role claim when Bark might also be scum.

 

[deleted804295]

@WonderingStudent what is your role?

 

[WonderingStudent]

I’ve been trying to decide the best time to reveal and with katas role reveal it seems like a good time

SO I’m the village bloodhound. My results so far
N1- 3m, not village
N2- wondering, village
N3- sporty, village

which leaves Sunni, dubz, and kata (who I’m eliminating based on role reveal)

Because I knew I would tunnel her otherwise so I wanted to settle it one way or the other

@CoffeeQuestionMark what posts of wonder’s bother you? I have her as neutral rn because her posts about numbers and info seem helpful but don’t say anything about affiliation

This post above is from D2. @Barkley13 didn't seem like you were going to start tunneling me? what about me would you have tunneled?

 

[SportPonies]

I don't think chasing roles is going to win the game. There are too many options. There are too many things to fakeclaim.
Dubz could just as easily claim Saulus - how are we to know the different? We don't, besides reading the game and tone.

 

[Barkley13]

This post above is from D2. @Barkley13 didn't seem like you were going to start tunneling me? what about me would you have tunneled?

I said neutral because I couldn't decide one way of the other. And because I felt like a lot of your posts were more mechanics based so that was a good lead to me side eyeing you for the rest of the game.

 

[WonderingStudent]

I figured she would die soon too if she was being honest and that would solve that question

We were pretty suspicious of 3m D1 (not really because of posts but because she would definitely pick a non-villager over a villager role) so why did you check her N1 when it was very likely she would be lynched at some point.

 

[WildZoo]

I'm also curious about the n1 investigation of 3m when Alissa seemed higher priority for barks personally, and 3m was not mentioned

Yeah I was literally about to point this out. Cubs I don’t want to tunnel you D1 but....

well don’t make me tunnel you D1

The person who said this same thing last game ended up being a wolf

Go ahead and lynch me guys. Ain’t gonna get you anywhere. Wish I had something useful to offer like “keep me alive because ____” But I honestly dont

Agreed that this is sketchy AND having a hard time believing it

I’m still content with my vote from yesterday. Alissa was acting pretty sketchy and I see she kinda explained the cubs vote but the whole “don’t make me tunnel you” to a joke cubs made that she said was a joke but didn’t sound like one and then how she ended up voting for him was weird. Plus she had some other sketchy posts

lynch alissa

 

[SportPonies]

I'm also curious about the n1 investigation of 3m when Alissa seemed higher priority, and 3m was not mentioned

3m seems like a logical investigative choice based on the general suspicion that was on her, so idk.

 

[WildZoo]

I don't think chasing roles is going to win the game. There are too many options. There are too many things to fakeclaim.
Dubz could just as easily claim Saulus - how are we to know the different? We don't, besides reading the game and tone.

And yet you angry reacted me for questioning barks roleclaim??

 

[WonderingStudent]

I don't think chasing roles is going to win the game. There are too many options. There are too many things to fakeclaim.
Dubz could just as easily claim Saulus - how are we to know the different? We don't, besides reading the game and tone.

Saulus doesn't have a NK option so how do you explain the two shots last night

 

[WildZoo]

3m seems like a logical investigative choice based on the general suspicion that was on her, so idk.

Yes but barks specifically investigated wonder n2 because she was afraid of tunneling her. So why not do the same with alissa n1?

 

[SportPonies]

And yet you angry reacted me for questioning barks roleclaim??

Saulus doesn't have a NK option so how do you explain the two shots last night

It was an example, not me stating fact.
Though, yes, not a good example because I didn't think about the NK thing.

 

[deleted804295]

Saulus doesn't have a NK option so how do you explain the two shots last night

You haven't role claimed yet.

 

[SportPonies]

I am inclined to also lynch kata.

 

[deleted804295]

There is 1 mason still alive. Is anyone going to claim it?

 

[deleted804295]

Okay SP 😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡

I get it 😡😡😡😡😡😡

 

[Barkley13]

We were pretty suspicious of 3m D1 (not really because of posts but because she would definitely pick a non-villager over a villager role) so why did you check her N1 when it was very likely she would be lynched at some point.

To know if it was actually going to be a good lynch or not

 

[SportPonies]

Me, probably:

 

[deleted804295]

Wonder has not role claimed.

We are near endgame and everyone else has.

Meaning if wonder is scum that makes Bark scum too since bark covered for wonder

 

[Barkley13]

There doesn’t actually have to be a second mason though unless I understood wrong?

 

[SportPonies]

Wonder has not role claimed.

We are near endgame and everyone else has.

Meaning if wonder is scum that makes Bark scum too since bark covered for wonder

I have not roleclaimed.

 

[deleted804295]

There doesn’t actually have to be a second mason though unless I understood wrong?

Yes there has to be.

 

[Barkley13]

Yes there has to be.

No there doesn’t

 

[WildZoo]

Yes there has to be.

No...there doesn't...if no one else chose a mason role SAR would have been on her own

 

[SportPonies]

There does not have to be a second mason. We all chose our roles so unless two people just so happened to choose mason, there was only one.
I already asked AM, and (paraphrasing), we could have started with any amount of masons this game.

 

[Barkley13]

It’s just that if two people picked that role then they would be able to communicate

 

[deleted804295]

No there doesn’t

Actually you're right. There doesn't just checked mafia wiki

 

[WonderingStudent]

It was pretty obvious that I was the other village mason since D1 imo.

 

[deleted804295]

So why are we clearing sport and wonder then???

Because bark told us to? Bark could be scum for all we know

 

[deleted804295]

It was pretty obvious that I was the other village mason since D1 imo.

Could you quote places where you or SAR may have hinted you were mason

 

[Barkley13]

This is fun because the 3 possible non-village have all made claims

 

[WonderingStudent]

Unless you're lying @Barkley13. Sporty hasn't claimed

 

[WildZoo]

Could you quote places where you or SAR may have hinted you were mason

It's what the whole sad react thing was about. SAR was trying to signal to me and I didn't realize she had removed it until it was too late.

 

[deleted804295]

Dubz - Judas
Kata - Hider claim
Barkley- Bloodhound (investigative) claim; said wonder and sport are village
Wonder- mason claim
Sporty- no claim
Suni-cop

 

[SportPonies]

I am inclined to choose to believe Barks' role claim because I'm not sure how easily the game is winnable if we do not.
Maybe she's lying. And then... yep. We're screwed.
But it seems more likely to me that she's not.

 

[Barkley13]

So why are we clearing sport and wonder then???

Because bark told us to? Bark could be scum for all we know

I mean sporty and wonder should both know they’re village which would point to the fact that I’m telling the truth because otherwise how would I know that

 

[WonderingStudent]

Could you quote places where you or SAR may have hinted you were mason

The whole mess with the sad react.

 

[deleted804295]

It's what the whole sad react thing was about. SAR was trying to signal to me and I didn't realize she had removed it until it was too late.

I completely missed that. Could you summarize please? She was sad reacting for what?

 

[deleted804295]

I sad reacted a post where Dubz indicated she might lynch Wondering as they were one of my strongest village reads at the time. I then removed the sad react because i thought people might overreact like wow gee exactly this

Okay

 

[WildZoo]

I completely missed that. Could you summarize please? She was sad reacting for what?

I had voiced suspicion of wonder

 

[SportPonies]

It's what the whole sad react thing was about. SAR was trying to signal to me and I didn't realize she had removed it until it was too late.

what about that indicated Wondering was mason? Did SAR drop hints in regard to her ability or am I missing something here.