Coop is sounding very genuine. i felt like that was the one person we could pretty safely vote but have been frozen today as I’m doubting that now. Without any info from mafia/wolf/alien/cult flips it feels like voting totally blind especially when even scum have reason to be genuinely scumhunting.
Like I said, you guys can have a club for "people who like to sus village!shorty." I'd just ask that as the inspiration for this club, if you ever get cool things like club jackets, I get an honorary one too since I'm the inspiration for the club's existence.
I never said that and I doubt Z did either, I think you’re misinterpreting us responding to your feeling about him being aggressive, I was saying that he is usually very assertive in his reads and doesn’t qualify or doubt them much (not a lot of maybes or counterpoints in his posts generally). His posts are content-heavy, very little to no hedging, but he’s a not a super high poster.
kaydubs wow reacted this so i think that means I need to go back to being responsible before i get in trouble...
I will have more input after I finish reading I'm just trying to frantically get everything read and comprehended before 9CDT
Ooo a tie
@supershorty You had this post in your ISO and said the bottom part gave you some feels but you didn't know why. It stood out to me too, and I think what felt weird to me was that she tried to sell us on getting rid of coop, but not by yeeting her. I kind of interpret it as a scum person trying to get someone (in this case, Coop) dayvigged so that she doesn't get the heat for misyeeting her. So the blame goes on the vig instead of her (Vis) for pushing the yeet. Just stood out to me because she was hypothesizing all of the ways to get coop killed without actually getting her hands "dirty" so to speak.Yeah I was thinking on it and pretty much the only roles I’m at all concerned about them wanting to be yeeted are judas and supersaint. Saulus and oneshot prince are beneficial for town to yeet (I mean. Better if prince gets nked by another faction. But can’t bet on that esp with how sketchy Coop is). Judas I could see deciding to bail on town, since they’re more powerful as mafia than town (can essentially be either [ability] town or [ability] plus 1x prince mafia), and at least if they get converted early then they can fully play for mafia instead of trying to play for town with the fear that it’ll eventually be counter to their wincon. Still, not something we can bank on and just never yeet a super scummy-looking player
It could be nice if, if it looks like she’s going to be yeeted and it looks like that’s her goal, she got dayvig’d so town doesn’t potentially have to use two yeets on her if she’s Judas or 1x prince.
... This feels like a cop out. I think sunny is scummy too but what the heck? You're basically in the lead??
So I shouldn’t vote for my top scum read because I’m in the lead with still over an hour to go? What?
... And what of chaos?
You're voting for someone not even in the board yet when you're kinda in the lead. Yeah there's an hour but that's not a lot of time. Tell us about how the other people on the board make you feel!
I feel pretty good about Chaos still. Kind of bothered by him saying he didn’t see cubs’s posts about the role/affiliation confusion being on purpose when he was allegedly searching cubs’s posts. But overall he feels village
Hmm. That didn't really bother me in the context of people thinking at the time that coop might have had a role that won with being voted out.
This in particular feels like it's really watering down that whole discussion...
I don’t know I’m wavering on everyone except my solid village reads. Where I’m at on cubs is that the AtE, “woe is me I’m always so maligned” attitude feels very manipulative and scummy. The way he makes me not want to vote for him despite my gut feelings, using a mix of AtE and offense against people suspecting him (it’s almost like negging but I don’t want to use that word for the irl scummy implications. I mean he criticizes the reads in such a way that I think makes people feel kind of stupid for even dare suspect him and feel put on the defensive and like you need to then get his approval. Might be just me idk) making it hard not to doubt yourself when suspecting him… it really gives me flashbacks to the end of madagascar when he was in my top 2 scumreads but I somehow convinced myself to vote for the person he wanted me to vote. But I wasn’t a player in RvB so I haven’t experienced village cubs from that perspective, maybe it’s the same no matter what aff he is.
Okay now that I've read all of shorty's ISOs, I like them. I felt like I got a better grasp and a good reminder of what each of the people had said in the game and their contributions. Also, I think she's fair in them and doesn't seem to stretch things or try to warp things to fit her viewpoint.
I'm confused, are you agreeing with me or disagreeing? Was the disagreement over statistics not a distraction?
This sounds so much like me...no wonder he's my grandchild
This is exactly why I posted it. Like people were kind of freaking out about thinking Coop was scum but that voting her out might somehow be Very Bad. So I looked through the wiki for all the possible consequences of voting her, concluded the only real threat that would make yeeting her inadvisable if she’s scum was if she’s Saulus (edit: I mean Judas), but that even if she’s a prince it would still be annoying to have to use two yeets on her, so if people are that concerned about her wanting to be yeeted then it could be a good strategy to use a village vig shot on her if one existed.
I'm disagreeing with you because I think that just calling that discussion a disagreement over statistics is neglecting a lot of the content therein.
I looked and I think I see what you mean. I'm going to go look at Madagascar, where she was village, to compare.
I dunno how to interpret things like that in multi-ball game
I don't either, but I'm leery of ties.I dunno how to interpret things like that in multi-ball game
Remember that time….Ties are fun for everyone
Are you looking at his scum game right now?
And ftr it’s posts like this that make me hesitant to yeet Coop today. This sounds like she is genuinely both frustrated with and encouraging me because she is worried about me being village and giving up and not giving village anything to work with on my way out. That’s a really village concern to have about your scum reads.
Can you link it here, please? I'd like to take a look too.
Sure, it's two different threads, I think this should take you to the ISOs. He started out in the past and moved to the future.
...did you just hammer
