CHOOSE YOUR OWWN III - Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Big agree. It's even in the interest of scum to take out all the other scum.
I've always thought it would be more fun to try to work with the other scum until the inevitable shootout at the end, but everyone else is all "No no, gotta look like I'm scumhunting!" Scum on scum violence is just so sad...
 
Big agree. It's even in the interest of scum to take out all the other scum.
Is it? It can be beneficial to, say, a SK to identify the wolfpack early and thus gain village cred but keep at least one wolf around to kill village.
I maybe haven't paid that much attention to the alien roles but I did look at my alien option before discarding it and iirc aliens aren't a killing faction so the priority might be different depending on the scum's wincon.
 
I did a few posts up. Basically: there are several possible scum factions in this game but my lizard brain enjoys knowing one particular faction is not a possibility for certain players. It does not mean I am opposed to the idea of them as scum.
can you explain your vote on me pls
 
Ponders StardeWW
Well see, I didn't mean to kill a scum AM, I meant to kill a village one.

And then Cult had to go and block the poor lonely wolf, very rude of them 🙁
 
Well see, I didn't mean to kill a scum AM, I meant to kill a village one.

And then Cult had to go and block the poor lonely wolf, very rude of them 🙁
I'm surprised the cult didn't try to block the mods, genny was displeased that the sword was of the parrying variety rather than the stabbing variety.
 
postcount.png

Um
 
I've always thought it would be more fun to try to work with the other scum until the inevitable shootout at the end, but everyone else is all "No no, gotta look like I'm scumhunting!" Scum on scum violence is just so sad...
Yeah, I hear that, but it seems like it would be hard/impossible for them to coordinate on thread. And since they can't do that, they might as well try and kill each other to keep themselves safe from NKs and to get some scraps of village cred.
 
I am still tickled by you trying to redirect attention onto Wonder.
Also I need to go to bed soon so I do not have the effort to currently piece together the thoughts I had earlier. Maybe tomorrow afternoon.
Redirect attention to Wondy… for being skeptical about her claim?

Because frankly at this point, I think the scum factions are trying to fixate on this topic a lot more intensely than it deserved attention especially when my explanations are actually more nuanced even before Lumi’s further explanations
 
Yeah, I hear that, but it seems like it would be hard/impossible for them to coordinate on thread. And since they can't do that, they might as well try and kill each other to keep themselves safe from NKs and to get some scraps of village cred.
Oh I know what is strategically sound, I'm just talking about fun 😛
 
Redirect attention to Wondy… for being skeptical about her claim?

Because frankly at this point, I think the scum factions are trying to fixate on this topic a lot more intensely than it deserved attention especially when my explanations are actually more nuanced even before Lumi’s further explanations
Yeah. The way you expressed your skepticism felt weird.
I also don't see your point about scum factions being fixated on this topic because our only confirmed scummite didn't talk about the goo after his fakeclaim debacle, iirc.
 
Yeah. The way you expressed your skepticism felt weird.
I also don't see your point about scum factions being fixated on this topic because our only confirmed scummite didn't talk about the goo after his fakeclaim debacle, iirc.
I’m talking in the context of scumhunting not confirmed scum. Because I’m seeing several concerns pretty much rehashing the same thing that scum factions can pretty much casually sheep along and look productive. Not saying it’s you because your thoughts are actually original but i’ve seen a few instances from others focusing on it that’s making me wary
 
I’m talking in the context of scumhunting not confirmed scum. Because I’m seeing several concerns pretty much rehashing the same thing that scum factions can pretty much casually sheep along and look productive. Not saying it’s you because your thoughts are actually original but i’ve seen a few instances from others focusing on it that’s making me wary
Who in particular?

Or...whom?
 
Anybody feel any kind of way about WO2 now? I'm still struggling to have any thoughts.
I feel zero ways about them. I felt zero ways about them in ??? (whichever game the mods posted a fake writeup to make it seem like we hadn't caught the last wolf when we had, maybe Globe?) so I have no clue what scum!O2 would look like since they don't have an established meta that I can think of, aside from being enigmatic.
 
I feel zero ways about them. I felt zero ways about them in ??? (whichever game the mods posted a fake writeup to make it seem like we hadn't caught the last wolf when we had, maybe Globe?) so I have no clue what scum!O2 would look like since they don't have an established meta that I can think of, aside from being enigmatic.
Would I do that :thinking:
 
Maybe you with your towel comment. :thinking:
great now all I can think about is Zenge asking genny what a towel item did in my LaWWpy game and her responding with "What do towels do? Zenge, I'd hate to be your roommate" and now I've set myself off giggling so hard that I forgot what I actually wanted to do.
 
I feel fine about True not being a wolf. He might be some sort of something else but confident he wouldn't bus Chaos like that.
I need to check Zenge vote patterns.
True not being partnered with Chaos means true isn't a wolf. I already said the possibility of him being other scum, but knowing he isn't wolf is a useful data point and far from not meaning anything.
Ditto for Zenge if he voted for Chaos but I still need to check that.
In the grand scheme of the game? That's one less scum faction True and Zenge could be.
To be clear, I am not saying either should be read as 100% village. I'm well aware this is a multiball game and either one could be alien, goon, or SK. But I am saying I don't believe either one is a wolf, which means that eliminates one possibility from the scum soup.
So I guess it isn't ~that~ important because it's possible Chaos didn't even have any packmates. All I'm trying to say is it helps me brain to pencil in that neither of them is a wolf.
Trust me, I'm not giving them any cred other than "not in a pack with Chaos". I still have some concerns about True and not concerns about Zenge.
I’m confused why, out of the 7 people on the Chaos vote, you made these posts focused on me and True, but ignored the other 5 players who voted for Chaos?
 
I’m confused why, out of the 7 people on the Chaos vote, you made these posts focused on me and True, but ignored the other 5 players who voted for Chaos?
I kind of thought that was obvious
 
I’m confused why, out of the 7 people on the Chaos vote, you made these posts focused on me and True, but ignored the other 5 players who voted for Chaos?
Because you two are the ones that stood out in my mind as being vehemently anti-bus, aka highly unlikely to vote a packmate particularly in that situation.
 
Quotes are kinda broken, sorry

No you’re correct, just the first post you made I thought you were representing it as if they hadn’t had a specofoc reason and were just vaguely trying to trick scum. Why does their reason for lying strike you as particularly scummy?
I think lying in general as a villager is scummy unless you have a very good reason to lie, like only sharing part of your pro-village ability. Lumi trying to play 5D chess and start off the game with a giant lie did not sit well with me
And I really think we should yeet genny
I’m interested in this
Not particularly, because there could be wolf watchers out there waiting for this exact scenario.
Seems to be incredibly specific and not that likely. Possible, but not probable imo.
that genny is not playing until tomorrow. sorry to disappoint. this genny does not feel like taking anything seriously at the moment.
I’m sorry serious bizness genny can’t join us yet. I’m willing to give you a little bit of time, but I would like to see some reads and a bit more content.

A soul for a soul then I guess. Still makes more sense to me to at least have the option rather than potentially tying ourselves to voting him two days in a row if we don't have to. And it's a fairly small risk that a scum watcher would exist. 🤷‍♀️
Yee, Dubz said it basically how I would’ve said it. Risking the very small chance of a wolf watcher to not fire off a vig shot is incredulous to me
Another scenario I could see is potentially being a 1 shot townie or something that is functionally similar to Judas, or some other role that gains from being yoten.
Not possible, this is what I discarded and there’s only 1
 
Wait why am I not listed as anti-bus? Displeased 😢
I've never played with scum!You and my only frame of reference is you repeatedly beseeching people to bus you if they wolf with you in the future, so...
Did you vote for Chaos? Maybe I should actually look at the wagon.
Wait wait, sleep.
 
Well see, I didn't mean to kill a scum AM, I meant to kill a village one.

And then Cult had to go and block the poor lonely wolf, very rude of them 🙁
Wait, AM was scum in stardeww?

Anybody feel any kind of way about WO2 now? I'm still struggling to have any thoughts.
I have zero feelings about him and plan to iso him tomorrow
 
Because you two are the ones that stood out in my mind as being vehemently anti-bus, aka highly unlikely to vote a packmate particularly in that situation.
Oh.

I guess I’d believe that’s a thing True would say, as he does take after the Dubz!School of wolfing.

No idea if Lawpy would bus but I really doubt it.

I’m not sure about genny in this situation but I haven’t been concerned with her being scum.

Likewise with MK, I’m not sure what her bussing habits would be but I’m feeling good about MK.

I’d hope I raised WO2 better than to bus 😡
 
Top