CHOOSE YOUR OWWN III - Game Thread

[WildZoo]

Advertisement - Members don't see this ad

i would prefer to go last because mine will be the most dramatic.

I'm intrigued enough to consider humoring you

 

[Viscernable]

@WonderingStudent
@alleycat03
@holdthemayo
@Zenge142
@Viscernable
@mkg323

We are (or...I am...I can't tell if genny is actually in favor or not) discussing a potential mass role reveal since there is a real possibility that today is VoLo. It would be cool to get thoughts from everyone.

I think I’m down for this. Haven’t given a ton of thought to the mechanics of when to massclaim, since we usually have fully closed games here, but considering the deathrate I agree I wouldn’t be surprised if tonight is our last chance.

 

[WildZoo]

I would prefer to go last because I don't trust the rest of you...

Mayo pls. You have to go like, at least 3rd

 

[genny]

I would prefer to go last because I don't trust the rest of you...

pretty sure we all voted you first already

 

[WildZoo]

@WonderingStudent @holdthemayo
It is time. I don't think anyone is in strong disagreement that the two of you should reveal first, other than perhaps yourselves.

 

[WildZoo]

Who knows when mkg will show up again...we may have to skip her and suffer the consequences

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 3 Yeet Tally
Wonder (2) - Zenge, dubz
mayo (1) - mkg
alley () -
genny (1) - Vis

4/8
yeet close in ~2.5 hours

 

[alleycat03]

i'm thinking about voting alley or vis

This makes me upsetti spaghetti

 

[genny]

This makes me upsetti spaghetti

i like spaghetti.

 

[holdthemayo]

@WonderingStudent @holdthemayo
It is time. I don't think anyone is in strong disagreement that the two of you should reveal first, other than perhaps yourselves.

I feel like myself is the only agreement that matters in this.

I'm frankly uncomfortable that you have been pushing for me to reveal since I joined the game.

 

[alleycat03]

well vis is trying to kill me, and alley was defending chaos.

Bro how many times do I have to tell the thread that I thought the best course of action was to wait for a vig to get rid of him in case he was telling the truth about being Judas? I wasn’t defending chaos, I was saying that it was better for a vig to take him out.

 

[genny]

I feel like myself is the only agreement that matters in this.

I'm frankly uncomfortable that you have been pushing for me to reveal since I joined the game.

oh come on, what's the worst that can happen?

 

[genny]

Bro how many times do I have to tell the thread that I thought the best course of action was to wait for a vig to get rid of him in case he was telling the truth about being Judas? I wasn’t defending chaos, I was saying that it was better for a vig to take him out.

at least 3 more times

 

[holdthemayo]

oh come on, what's the worst that can happen?

If I were scum, I could easily lie and make something up, so perhaps I have a reason for being this way.

Maybe I'm just obstinate.

Could be both

 

[WildZoo]

I feel like myself is the only agreement that matters in this.

I'm frankly uncomfortable that you have been pushing for me to reveal since I joined the game.

That is misconstruing the situation. I asked you to reveal which card was used for your affiliation when you joined, which the rest of us had all already done at that point.

Now I am asking you to reveal because there is a solid chance that if we get this vote wrong and scum kills overnight, the game is over. And I am not the only person here agreeing with the course of action. So please.

 

[WildZoo]

Like I am begging you to work with me here if you're village

 

[holdthemayo]

Anyway, I'm fine with Wonder or MK tonight.

Vote MK

 

[alleycat03]

I would prefer to go last because I don't trust the rest of you...

Doesn’t everyone want to go last?

 

[genny]

If I were scum, I could easily lie and make something up, so perhaps I have a reason for being this way.

Maybe I'm just obstinate.

Could be both

pretty sure you can make something up if you're village too.

 

[alleycat03]

Like it sure seems like it’s the most popular choice. I don’t have anything to hide so I’ll go at any point. But I agree that POE members should go first logically

 

[genny]

Doesn’t everyone want to go last?

i promise it will be more fun if i go last

 

[WildZoo]

i promise it will be more fun if i go last

Omg were you the goo all along

 

[alleycat03]

i like spaghetti.

Me too, but I don’t like your sus of me

 

[alleycat03]

i promise it will be more fun if i go last

If you’re goo and you goo’d everyone except for me I’m gonna be so sad

 

[holdthemayo]

pretty sure you can make something up if you're village too.

??? to what end?

 

[alleycat03]

I feel like myself is the only agreement that matters in this.

I'm frankly uncomfortable that you have been pushing for me to reveal since I joined the game.

That’s not true. She asked for you to share your affiliation card, which shorty asked everyone else for within an hour of the game thread opening. I think that request was quite reasonable

 

[genny]

??? to what end?

if you have a village role that gets utility from being attacked by wolves/mafia, that's the kind of lie i can condone.

 

[holdthemayo]

That’s not true. She asked for you to share your affiliation card, which shorty asked everyone else for within an hour of the game thread opening. I think that request was quite reasonable

I still don't even understand what this means.

 

[alleycat03]

at least 3 more times

1. I wasn’t defending chaos, I wanted a vig to take him out.

2. Chaos should’ve been taken out by a vig, which is what I advocated for. NOT defending him.

3. I thought chaos could’ve been Judas, so a vig would’ve been the best choice to kill him. I said a vig should shoot him, which is not defending him.

4. Pew pew chaos not defending him

 

[genny]

I still don't even understand what this means.

i keep wishing your pic is gif, and zoidberg finally eats the pigeon

 

[WildZoo]

I still don't even understand what this means.

Did you ask the mods? Like if you ask them "what role was used for my affiliation" they should be able to tell you. I said this earlier today.

 

[Viscernable]

I still don't even understand what this means.

Have you asked the mods which cards your aff and role came from yet?

 

[genny]

1. I wasn’t defending chaos, I wanted a vig to take him out.

2. Chaos should’ve been taken out by a vig, which is what I advocated for. NOT defending him.

3. I thought chaos could’ve been Judas, so a vig would’ve been the best choice to kill him. I said a vig should shoot him, which is not defending him.

4. Pew pew chaos not defending him

so if you're not in chaos's pack, we're looking for 2-3 mafia?

 

[alleycat03]

I still don't even understand what this means.

Whatever role you have was created by 2 cards. If Stagg had been around, he would’ve picked 2 cards out of 3. One card for affiliation (village, wolf, mafia, etc) and one card for ability (mason, cop, JOAT, etc).

We have been requesting that you share your AFFILIATION card only.

Now we are discussing that everyone reveals their ability as well since we could be at marvolo

 

[WildZoo]

@Zenge142 hi lurky

 

[alleycat03]

so if you're not in chaos's pack, we're looking for 2-3 mafia?

Couldn’t chaos have a wolf partner? And there be mafia? Or an alien is still around?

 

[alleycat03]

@Zenge142 hi lurky

Smh Zenge, don’t you know you’re only allowed to lurk on D1???

 

[Zenge142]

@Zenge142 hi lurky

Hi, Just catching up. Glad to see the thread is a little more active finally

 

[alleycat03]

Also I’m big mad that we’ve correctly yeeted both days and could still lose the game to scum. That upsets me.

 

[WildZoo]

Hi, Just catching up. Glad to see the thread is a little more active finally

You're welcome 😛

 

[genny]

Couldn’t chaos have a wolf partner? And there be mafia? Or an alien is still around?

no one cares about aliens anymore. that's so yesterday. did you read anything i posted today about looking for mafia OR wolves, but not both?

 

[WildZoo]

Couldn’t chaos have a wolf partner? And there be mafia? Or an alien is still around?

There's a bunch of possibilities, though it seems likely only one killing faction left based on the single kill last night, unless another kill was prevented. But if it was a block then you'd think someone would have said something already, and if it was protection I'd kinda have to wonder what the heck they were doing n1 lol

 

[alleycat03]

@WonderingStudent Are you here and ready to reveal?

@holdthemayo hi what are you planning on doing? Are you going to reveal?

 

[alleycat03]

no one cares about aliens anymore. that's so yesterday. did you read anything i posted today about looking for mafia OR wolves, but not both?

I don’t get why you think it could be one or the other. Cubs didn’t kill as SK last CYO because he wanted people to think there was only one killing faction. So I’m not ruling out that possibility either

 

[alleycat03]

There's a bunch of possibilities, though it seems likely only one killing faction left based on the single kill last night, unless another kill was prevented. But if it was a block then you'd think someone would have said something already, and if it was protection I'd kinda have to wonder what the heck they were doing n1 lol

Another kill could’ve been prevented OR some scum chose to no kill? Isn’t that still a possibility?

 

[genny]

I don’t get why you think it could be one or the other. Cubs didn’t kill as SK last CYO because he wanted people to think there was only one killing faction. So I’m not ruling out that possibility either

so what i'm hearing is that the POE should be broader than i'm currently thinking it is. and everyone is sus.

 

[alleycat03]

Or there’s scum out there that can’t kill for some reason (like true did actually have an alien partner, which seems unlikely) or there was a trade off with using an ability meant that scum couldn’t kill that night (something about the bloodsucker/stump ability said they couldn’t kill and stump on the same night, so there could be another similar role like that?)

 

[WildZoo]

Another kill could’ve been prevented OR some scum chose to no kill? Isn’t that still a possibility?

Why the heck would scum choose not to kill?

 

[WildZoo]

Or there’s scum out there that can’t kill for some reason (like true did actually have an alien partner, which seems unlikely) or there was a trade off with using an ability meant that scum couldn’t kill that night (something about the bloodsucker/stump ability said they couldn’t kill and stump on the same night, so there could be another similar role like that?)

The only instance where the bloodsucker trade-off applies is if it's paired with an alien.

True could have had a partner, yes, I mentioned this earlier. There's still a killing faction remaining in that case though.

 

[alleycat03]

so what i'm hearing is that the POE should be broader than i'm currently thinking it is. and everyone is sus.

Yep, that’s pretty much what I’ve decided. CYO makes forming a village bloc so difficult