- Joined
- Nov 5, 2019
- Messages
- 4,545
- Reaction score
- 5,600
AM if you had read my posts you would know. A quick ISO would solve this as I had already stated that I didn’t like her quick defense of amana.What tone?
AM if you had read my posts you would know. A quick ISO would solve this as I had already stated that I didn’t like her quick defense of amana.What tone?
I'm a little surprised only 33% of the roster is on here. What about samac?As for a list of that’s what we’re gonna do:
village vibes:
Genny
Cray (I think? Unless her pockets are incredibly cozy)
slight village lean:
Sunshine - but I need to see more power play similar to your D1 noob game
neutral:
Pippy (but has more village points than AM)
AM
Mel
Wolfy vibes:
Kras
April (as stated these last two are mostly feels for now but are subject
Amana
Give me a bit, my boss should be leaving in a bit and i will try and log into the forum on my work computer and start digging.Speaking of which
@The_Breadmann
It was this particular quote that kinda flagged me. Maybe it was the use of the word “poor” that kinda gave me off feels.Poor amana is just trying to get a feel for her first game and everyone is jumping on her already.
That's one post and she's not even voting there any longer. I asked what about her tone don't you like.AM if you had read my posts you would know. A quick ISO would solve this as I had already stated that I didn’t like her quick defense of amana.
@Animal MidwifeIt was this particular quote that kinda flagged me. Maybe it was the use of the word “poor” that kinda gave me off feels.
Samac I’d probably put with sunshine but below her. I should’ve actually looked at the roster when compiling this but I didn’t so things got missing. Would you like me to update this Animal Madame Wife?I'm a little surprised only 33% of the roster is on here. What about samac?
Retaliatory votes and poor communication are two things that bug me. Weren't you an English major? I would think "You didn't answer my question!" when no question was asked would bother you, too.Not sure how Zepp explaining "I was asking if you had any current reads" is not the same as asking for reads, but sure, let's waste posts having to re-ask obvious questions.
What are your reads?
Yeah, I see that post as pretty NAI.
Yeah, I'd prefer a fuller list. Because even the wolf reads are batting way below the minimum composition for a wolfpack.Samac I’d probably put with sunshine but below her. I should’ve actually looked at the roster when compiling this but I didn’t so things got missing. Would you like me to update this Animal Madame Wife?
Oh god this is awful.Retaliatory votes and poor communication are two things that bug me. Weren't you an English major? I would think "You didn't answer my question!" when no question was asked would bother you, too.
I'm leaning Sfl as my most suspicious.
Of you, pippy, AM, and Mel you are wolfy until evidence suggests otherwise. I have some ideas about AM that make me think not wolfy.
FTF seems lackadaisical and carefree; a little suspect but waiting for posts
I had noted some curious posts from April about Cray (especially when she said it seemed wrong to have a suspicious list already) but I'm not necessarily thinking wolfy.
Sloth, M#, and genny seem the most village to me right now.
Just because you don't agree, doesn't make it awfulOh god this is awful.
Can you walk me through why you have these reads (outside of FTF and April)?Just because you don't agree, doesn't make it awful
Speaking of PM partners, why hasn’t @Cyndia opened one with me? 🤔
I mostly dislike that it seems she is throwing around votes without giving much reasoning behind them. That mixed with fluff posts don't read as very village.so legitimately, what’s the evidence against kras other than changing up her vote? Which I will say is a bit different than the RNG point she did on the last game. I just ask because she’s my PM partner and I haven’t got incredibly wolf-y vibes. But this very well could be my own judgement clouding everything since we were masons together last time and we have a PM open again.
Not intentional, I vaguely remember those posts but not that you made them or that that was the wordDid you read the Saturday cartoon noob game? Because you are directly replying to me with my trigger word. Feels intentional...
I’m never a morning person. Or inherently grumpy. More like sometimes external things(people) get me frustrated.
I am likewise checking in between sessions of my interview day. Which I feel I am not wowing them 🆘
Pippy has a similar read of Cray. Does that affect anything?Cyndia im gonna leave in neutral. I think she is contributing some with her questioning of posts and her reasoning. However, i disagree with her read of cray. Dubz I'm gonna put SLIGHT village lean to but i need to see more content wise. dubz would be at the bottom of the slight village category. Coffee im having a hard time reading... i think village points?? hard to say exactly...Oh and i see i forgot meats in the list. So i would put meats in the need more from category. I think she said she was catching up so Ill hold judgement until then.
Joke voting this deep into D1 is either wolfy or lazy play, especially when we've certainly acquired more than enough sketchballs by now to place at least somewhere. It's not the vote changing, it's the near instantaneous hop on where she quotes someone else's post, tosses a yeet vote on that person, and then refuses to justify or engage furtherso legitimately, what’s the evidence against kras other than changing up her vote? Which I will say is a bit different than the RNG point she did on the last game. I just ask because she’s my PM partner and I haven’t got incredibly wolf-y vibes. But this very well could be my own judgement clouding everything since we were masons together last time and we have a PM open again.
Of your request, I have removed my quotes of FTF/AprilCan you walk me through why you have these reads (outside of FTF and April)?
This was a big thing in the dead chat. So I dunno if it’s really sus.
But in the post I quoted you specifically said vets.
It IS an answer. Just not the explanation you wanted, perhaps?
It was a serious question in that I wanted to see how Sloth answered it. It wasn't a serious question in that I (of all people) know that players can be wolves in back-to-back games. Sometimes 4 or 5 times in a row....![]()
Dislike.
So if you can't articulate why you're yeeting another player, that makes me think of 2 possibilities: 1) you're a wolf and can't come up with a response, or 2) you're a lazy villager who is going to be difficult to read because you won't put in any effort to make yourself easily identifiable as village.
Wait I don’t want to hinder our search, but should I never post “sociable posts”? The social aspect is why I like playing games, it’s a pandemic and I’m a suffering extrovert, and I’m going into human IM for a reason 🙁
so tbh I had her as my first wolf lean, but then other people started calling her out on her wolfiness too... so I actually waited for it to die down and then I was the first and only vote for her. Also like 75% of players have a yeet vote in right now
thank you for calling this out. I wanted to, but there seems to be this attitude here that noobs should give vets some reverence.
Where?
Well I was looking into cray cause they were acting a little CRAY but with their newest post, I am inclined to believe that their aggression isn’t all that uncommon. At first I was suspecting wolf, but I feel it would be reckless to draw so much attention to themselves, but again I am noob, also still processing everything that I have been reading lol.
They admitted that they were a little sloppy, and I don’t think that aggression and being active on D1 would be a very wise yeet choice. I am inclined to think they are doing their best to analyze what’s present and while CRAY I don’t think it deserves a yeet.
Okay, but why are the rest wolfy currently? We're as far from endgame as we'll ever be.Of your request, I have removed my quotes of FTF/April
For the veterans I listed (including you), I believe generally if multiples are left alive late in the game, at least one or more are wolves. Not necessarily that they have done anything wolfy, though if I were to narrow down the most likely at this point it'd be between Pippy (because she is the wolfiest wolf in sheep clothing when she wolfs) or WZ. In this case, and since you're asking, you have done one thing several times since the start of the game (I just double checked my count, apparently four times) to make me suspicious you are not a wolf.
Alright.M#'s
-->I guess I lost the follow-up to this but when WZ said breads wasn't in dead chat til the end, M# commented that he still probably read it, implying that the amount of time bread spread in deadchat wasn't really relevant, as long as he read it. Which I agree with. Also noting that he doesn't go on to defend Breads, just that the original comment WZ made is not a great one for determining suspiciciousness
This, and the first quote as well, I think demonstrates good attention to detail which I tend to associate with village.
Genny:
I feel that genny's sass is really resonating with me and I am supportive of her dislike of sfl's post
I would say we are sharing a similar wave-length right now, and I am village, therefore genny is probably village as well
She has been voting for her, for hours now, so I guess I'm confused about the bolded.SFL:
"Hinder our search" doesn't sit with me right
Despite having a wolf lean for amana, was not willing to vote for her as afraid to seem like "jumping on the bandwagon" (at least my interpretation of situation).
Fairly certain she meant Cray since she's one of the only people that hold very unorthodox opinions about noobs. But also is this statement AI?These two quotes go together. Sfl has also posted since and didn't answer Pippy. I feel like I haven't seen any of this reverence myself, especially nothing cray is last I checked one of the leading candidates and a vet. So, I'd like to know where she has gotten that idea, too.
Okay.Sloth:
Sloth hasn't posted a whole lot of content, but this post felt genuine to me.
Lie detector type roles are some of the greatest. I don't see a reason this had to happen.Day 1
![]()
A gunshot rang out.
Some players ran. Some ducked beyond humanoid or building shields.
One brave person moved cautiously forward to check the fallen comrade. Well damn.
Dead is @kraskadva , who was Murph from Interstellar, a village lie detector who was able to check another player's post three times throughout the game.
It is *STILL* Day 1. Vote/Yeet deadline is TODAY, at 10pm EST (9pm CST/8pm MST/7pm fantasyland).
29 survivors
Roster:
1. @Melchizedek
2. @Animal Midwife
3. @genny
4. @vetmedhead
5. @CoffeeQuestionMark
6. @SARdoghandler
7. @WildZoo
8. @Amanasoul
9. @Cyndia
10. @sunshinefl
11. @Matthew9Thirtyfive
12. @PhiloslothicalStudent
13. @Barkley13
14. @alissa14
15. @savethecows
16. @BigCats
17. @Viscernable
18. @Zeppelyn
19. @Crayola227
21. @samac
22. @Dr. ForgotToFlush
23. @alleycat03
24. @Aprilthearab
25. @vetschoolsletmeinplease
26. @The_Breadmann
27. @holdthemayo
28. @mmmdreamerz
29. @SportPonies
30. @PippyPony
Lost to the Abyss
20. @kraskadva - Murph from Interstellar, village lie detector
spectator-potatoes
Lawpy
Ski
WonderingStudent
supershorty
~*~*~*Table of Contents*~*~*~
It is a take on innocent until proven guilty, except it's guilty until proven innocent.Okay, but why are the rest wolfy currently? We're as far from endgame as we'll ever be.
Because she said she was holding her vote until less people were talking about her.She has been voting for her, for hours now, so I guess I'm confused about the bolded.
I mean I'd like to hear it from her not you and I don't know what you mean.Fairly certain she meant Cray since she's one of the only people that hold very unorthodox opinions about noobs. But also is this statement AI?
No. It would probably move coffee up. While I did agree with some of cray’s posts initially and thought some of her reasoning was fantastic, I largely disagree with her opinions on the noobs. I agree with Pippy when she said that sometimes having fresh eyes is beneficialPippy has a similar read of Cray. Does that affect anything?
I really don't like this post. You never said so much of an inch about kras up until now.Lie detector type roles are some of the greatest. I don't see a reason this had to happen.
day vigilante killing one of the greatest rolesUmmmm what just happened......
And based on this...I have to reevaluateDay 1
![]()
A gunshot rang out.
Some players ran. Some ducked beyond humanoid or building shields.
One brave person moved cautiously forward to check the fallen comrade. Well damn.
Dead is @kraskadva , who was Murph from Interstellar, a village lie detector who was able to check another player's post three times throughout the game.
It is *STILL* Day 1. Vote/Yeet deadline is TODAY, at 10pm EST (9pm CST/8pm MST/7pm fantasyland).
29 survivors
Roster:
1. @Melchizedek
2. @Animal Midwife
3. @genny
4. @vetmedhead
5. @CoffeeQuestionMark
6. @SARdoghandler
7. @WildZoo
8. @Amanasoul
9. @Cyndia
10. @sunshinefl
11. @Matthew9Thirtyfive
12. @PhiloslothicalStudent
13. @Barkley13
14. @alissa14
15. @savethecows
16. @BigCats
17. @Viscernable
18. @Zeppelyn
19. @Crayola227
21. @samac
22. @Dr. ForgotToFlush
23. @alleycat03
24. @Aprilthearab
25. @vetschoolsletmeinplease
26. @The_Breadmann
27. @holdthemayo
28. @mmmdreamerz
29. @SportPonies
30. @PippyPony
Lost to the Abyss
20. @kraskadva - Murph from Interstellar, village lie detector
spectator-potatoes
Lawpy
Ski
WonderingStudent
supershorty
~*~*~*Table of Contents*~*~*~
SO??? I'm not like you; I think vigilante day shots should be reserved for when there is hard-evidence someone is a wolf, or you have a suspected alpha.I really don't like this post. You never said so much of an inch about kras up until now.
Yeah, but then that means you have exactly one real wolf read and that kinda disappoints me.It is a take on innocent until proven guilty, except it's guilty until proven innocent.
Yeah, but that was a long time ago given how long she's been squatting on the soul vote now.Because she said she was holding her vote until less people were talking about her.
You don't know what I mean? Did you skip over that whole page of Cray defense?I mean I'd like to hear it from her not you and I don't know what you mean.
Having a strong opinion after the flip is useless to village. I don't care what your stance is on vig usage (even if the bolded historically leads to wolf losses), your reaction felt disingenuous because you had no horses in that race for over 30 hours.SO??? I'm not like you; I think vigilante day shots should be reserved for when there is hard-evidence someone is a wolf, or you have a suspected alpha.
day vigilante killing one of the greatest roles
I'm sorry to disappoint you.Yeah, but then that means you have exactly one real wolf read and that kinda disappoints me.
How does that negate the post?Yeah, but that was a long time ago given how long she's been squatting on the soul vote now.
Are you thinking I am referencing unorthodox opinions on noobs or AI? Because I know very well Cray's long standing opinions on noobs but I don't know what artificial intelligence is relating toYou don't know what I mean? Did you skip over that whole page of Cray defense?
It isn't useless to the vigilante who should learn to be more careful.Having a strong opinion after the flip is useless to village. I don't care what your stance is on vig usage (even if the bolded historically leads to wolf losses), your reaction felt disingenuous because you had no horses in that race for over 30 hours.
Fishing how? I’ve been unmoved by content from vis this farHi hello I'm officially catching up now. Flattered as always by the early attention, even without any effort whatsoever on my part! I've read through about page 10 and so far feel village on Cray, mayo train is uninspired but unsurprising, Amana feels very pure. Cray just feels like she keeps digging herself deeper into a hole and I feel that. I started a PM with Visc this morning and their first message to me already feels like fishing... so I think I'll be voting there.
vote Visc
not necessarily no. Some players can have abilities during the day.So like a 3P?
@Viscernable why are you playing with BigCats but not the rest of us?Hi hello I'm officially catching up now. Flattered as always by the early attention, even without any effort whatsoever on my part! I've read through about page 10 and so far feel village on Cray, mayo train is uninspired but unsurprising, Amana feels very pure. Cray just feels like she keeps digging herself deeper into a hole and I feel that. I started a PM with Visc this morning and their first message to me already feels like fishing... so I think I'll be voting there.
vote Visc
It doesn't. I'm just suprised it's being weighted so strongly over so many other things that are occurring.How does that negate the post?
AI means affiliation indicative.Are you thinking I am referencing unorthodox opinions on noobs or AI? Because I know very well Cray's long standing opinions on noobs but I don't know what artificial intelligence is relating to
"Careful" vigs have lost every village game for the past two years. Don't play wolfy unless you're a wolf.It isn't useless to the vigilante who should learn to be more careful.
Some actions can happen anytime. The apocalypse is realSo what happened here? Did a vigilante decide to attack her? Last game that stuff was only night actions. I’m confused.
Any other wolf reads from what you’ve read so far?Hi hello I'm officially catching up now. Flattered as always by the early attention, even without any effort whatsoever on my part! I've read through about page 10 and so far feel village on Cray, mayo train is uninspired but unsurprising, Amana feels very pure. Cray just feels like she keeps digging herself deeper into a hole and I feel that. I started a PM with Visc this morning and their first message to me already feels like fishing... so I think I'll be voting there.
vote Visc