I'm not withholding anything. I'm trying to help you as a new player, as I've been helping all day. If you're going to take everything a veteran says negatively, I'll stop, thats fine.
There's a reason experienced players quickly arrived to the conclusion that it was probably a villager (with the caveat that there may be a 3rd party floating around which we don't know is a given, some games have, some don't).
Its because we recognized a pattern.
what do you think that pattern was? Why would that pattern make us think village instead of something else?