HoWW I Met Your Mother: Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
images
 
Unofficial Lynch Tally

Dyachei 3 (BI, AshG, SOV)
BI 1 (Dyachei)
Wolves who have posted their wolf picture: 1 (dyachei).

Lame people who have not voted: 5? Really? 5! I voted, went to work, and came home already (admittedly short day today though)
 
Lame people who have not voted: 5? Really? 5! I voted, went to work, and came home already (admittedly short day today though)
On a similar note, I think honeytokki wins the record for surviving this far in a game without posting one single thing since mayor elections...
 
It would be interesting to have Ted as a wolf which Zen had mentioned before dying... Would STL do something unexpected like this? I don't know anyone very much to know :/ and might be a stupid question but @brightimpressio why is it "not the time to lynch Ted just yet"? Wouldn't that allow us to lynch Gwen who is alpha wolf? I am very confused...

Also, I have similar role as dyac so I am very hesitant to vote for Luke.. But I have no special role that "protects me" so that does sound fishy too..

/jumbledupthoughts
 
@Ashgirl thr night before zen had died he asked me on a date why I never talked on main thread. I explained because I have no special role that can help the villager or protect myself from dying, I was trying to keep a low profile to make wolves literally forget I was playing. As you can see I guess it worked somewhat. Haha. Now that we are down low in number though, I don't think this strategy will work anymore but at least I survived this long! 😛
 
It would be interesting to have Ted as a wolf which Zen had mentioned before dying... Would STL do something unexpected like this? I don't know anyone very much to know :/ and might be a stupid question but @brightimpressio why is it "not the time to lynch Ted just yet"? Wouldn't that allow us to lynch Gwen who is alpha wolf? I am very confused...

Also, I have similar role as dyac so I am very hesitant to vote for Luke.. But I have no special role that "protects me" so that does sound fishy too..

/jumbledupthoughts
I highly doubt that BI is a wolf, myself. She and MJ have been the reason we got several wolves, and BI mentioned to me that she can "prove" that she can't be converted, and I believe her.

Eventually, yes, we will need to lynch BI in order to kill Gwen. However, we just found a wolf today, so that's why she said "not the time to lynch Ted just yet." In many games, we have to kill all the wolves before the alpha anyways, so that's another reason.

I know you have a similar role, but last night when BI ability- seered Dy, it stated her ability was to "seer as Luke Mosby." Which means that she would be an unseerable wolf, as Dy has showed us in her picture.
 
@SOV uh... rawr?

@Ashgirl gotcha. for now I am voting to lynch dyac ubless someone has better plan :I
 
Everyone gathers around Dyachei, ready to off her, when she comes forward.

"Guys, I promise I am simply Luke Mosby. I don't know what Ted is talking about.... I am simply his innocent son!"

"Don't you think I would know my own son?! No, you know who you are? You are Tony Graffanelo! Who made that atrocious movie, which may have been number one in the box office for 5 straight weekends, but was full of lies and deceits! And you are the sole reason that me and Stella did not work. No, you are the main mechanism of heartbreak. You are the reason that we weren't able to work. Why I wasn't able to be happy? No, you sir must die."

Ted pulls out a gun, ready to pull the trigger, but Tony, being the martial artist extraordinaire, immediately knocked the gun from Ted's hands, and landed a front kick straight to his chest, pushing him backwards a good 5 feet, where he landed on the floor onto his back. Before Tony could pounce upon Ted, which would surely have ended him, he found a knife in his back. Tony looks at the person. "How could you....." but he was dead before he finished the sentence.

Dead is Dyachei, Tony Graffanelo, who was the unseerable wolf. The only way that she could be successfully seered is by Ted following the death of the mother.

There are 9 players remaining in the game. Lynch deadline is set for 10 pm. Plurality rules come into effect at 8 votes. Groups may not pm, but other pm means may be active today.....
Maclarens:
SHUT DOWN!
The Original Apartment/Puzzles:

8. honeytokki
9. Gwenevre
18. Cyndia
6. Ashgirl
23. HowIMetYourPet - Marshall
Robin's Apartment:
Sold to move in with Kevin. Leased out prior to Kevin’s death.
Barney's apartment:
Sold to move in with Robin
Lily and Marshal's House on Long Island:
Infested by bees which are unable to be warded off with no beekeeper present. Residents evacuate to nearest location (Ted's house on Long Island)
Ted's House on Long Island:

3. brightimpressio
26. Caia - Artillery Arthur Hobbs
34. StartingOverVet
The Lusty Leopard
lack of strippers resulted in the closing down of the lusty leopard!
Dead:
5. fancymylotus - Daphne
13. Tuckervet - Clint
22. ZVH - Patrice
24. Snow White96 - Don Frank
29. Chillbo Baggins - Carl Maclaren
20. ksmi117 – Victoria
7. Rogert – Lily Aldrin
11. NilocDent – Wendy
25. hedgiehog – Mickey Aldrin
28. Foxhunter – Quinn Garvey
27. Hammer2s – Linus
19. allieh8607 – Loretta

21. DocEspana - Doug
16. Jilary – Kevin
17. orca2011 - Brad
10. swingnsave - Marvin Erickson

30. devyn - The Blitz
2. Wildzoo - Ranjit
4. WillowLeaf - Judy Erickson
15. swiniazycie = The Captain

32. LetItSnow - Nora
12. ResoluteMike - James Stinson
31. DVMDream - Stella
1. Mad Jack - Tracy McConnell (The mother)
14. Zensing - Sandy Rivers

33. dyachei - Tony Graffanello

Night deadline is ASAP. Should be able to close in about 5 minutes.
 
Everyone gathers around Dyachei, ready to off her, when she comes forward.

"Guys, I promise I am simply Luke Mosby. I don't know what Ted is talking about.... I am simply his innocent son!"

"Don't you think I would know my own son?! No, you know who you are? You are Tony Graffanelo! Who made that atrocious movie, which may have been number one in the box office for 5 straight weekends, but was full of lies and deceits! And you are the sole reason that me and Stella did not work. No, you are the main mechanism of heartbreak. You are the reason that we weren't able to work. Why I wasn't able to be happy? No, you sir must die."

Ted pulls out a gun, ready to pull the trigger, but Tony, being the martial artist extraordinaire, immediately knocked the gun from Ted's hands, and landed a front kick straight to his chest, pushing him backwards a good 5 feet, where he landed on the floor onto his back. Before Tony could pounce upon Ted, which would surely have ended him, he found a knife in his back. Tony looks at the person. "How could you....." but he was dead before he finished the sentence.

Dead is Dyachei, Tony Graffanelo, who was the unseerable wolf. The only way that she could be successfully seered is by Ted following the death of the mother.

There are 9 players remaining in the game. Lynch deadline is set for 10 pm. Plurality rules come into effect at 8 votes. Groups may not pm, but other pm means may be active today.....
Maclarens:
SHUT DOWN!
The Original Apartment/Puzzles:

8. honeytokki
9. Gwenevre
18. Cyndia
6. Ashgirl
23. HowIMetYourPet - Marshall
Robin's Apartment:
Sold to move in with Kevin. Leased out prior to Kevin’s death.
Barney's apartment:
Sold to move in with Robin
Lily and Marshal's House on Long Island:
Infested by bees which are unable to be warded off with no beekeeper present. Residents evacuate to nearest location (Ted's house on Long Island)
Ted's House on Long Island:

3. brightimpressio
26. Caia - Artillery Arthur Hobbs
34. StartingOverVet
The Lusty Leopard
lack of strippers resulted in the closing down of the lusty leopard!
Dead:
5. fancymylotus - Daphne
13. Tuckervet - Clint
22. ZVH - Patrice
24. Snow White96 - Don Frank
29. Chillbo Baggins - Carl Maclaren
20. ksmi117 – Victoria
7. Rogert – Lily Aldrin
11. NilocDent – Wendy
25. hedgiehog – Mickey Aldrin
28. Foxhunter – Quinn Garvey
27. Hammer2s – Linus
19. allieh8607 – Loretta

21. DocEspana - Doug
16. Jilary – Kevin
17. orca2011 - Brad
10. swingnsave - Marvin Erickson

30. devyn - The Blitz
2. Wildzoo - Ranjit
4. WillowLeaf - Judy Erickson
15. swiniazycie = The Captain

32. LetItSnow - Nora
12. ResoluteMike - James Stinson
31. DVMDream - Stella
1. Mad Jack - Tracy McConnell (The mother)
14. Zensing - Sandy Rivers

33. dyachei - Tony Graffanello

Night deadline is ASAP. Should be able to close in about 5 minutes.

I count 8 players not 9.
 
Night deadline is ASAP. Should be able to close in about 5 minutes.
This sounds like MrsSOV and myself... whenever we say we are going to be in bed for just "5 minutes", it is ALWAYS a lot longer than that.

Oh yeah, standard: "Mod abandonment" line.
 
Nope, actually not the mods fault this time. Stupid inactive players. I needed one night action, one!

Night closed... Results pending...
 
Yesterday evening was a wonderful Thanksgiving dinner. Zoey cooked all day long for this, as well as the rest of the gang that is still alive, and certain other invited guests. Except for Robin, Robin was not very happy about this. So Robin decided to crash the party.

As she approached the door, she knocked, and Barney answered the door. "Sorry, you weren't invited Robin. But you know, the party is currently indisposed, if you want to have a little fun."

So of course there was tomfoolery of sorts, with drawing of sharpies, and hands in water, and the works. But when Barney left to go to the bathroom, Robin was nowhere to be found when he returned. Unfortunately, what he did find was a knife in Marshall's back. He checked for his pulse and he was completely dead.

Dead is HIMYP, Marshall, who could kill once, would automatically protect Ted each night, and could protect one other person each night.


There are 7 players remaining in the game. Lynch deadline is set for 10 pm. Plurality rules come into effect at 6 votes. Groups may not pm.
Maclarens:
SHUT DOWN!
The Original Apartment/Puzzles:

8. honeytokki
9. Gwenevre
18. Cyndia
6. Ashgirl
Robin's Apartment:
Sold to move in with Kevin. Leased out prior to Kevin’s death.
Barney's apartment:
Sold to move in with Robin
Lily and Marshal's House on Long Island:
Infested by bees which are unable to be warded off with no beekeeper present. Residents evacuate to nearest location (Ted's house on Long Island)
Ted's House on Long Island:

3. brightimpressio
26. Caia - Artillery Arthur Hobbs
34. StartingOverVet
The Lusty Leopard
lack of strippers resulted in the closing down of the lusty leopard!
Dead:
5. fancymylotus - Daphne
13. Tuckervet - Clint
22. ZVH - Patrice
24. Snow White96 - Don Frank
29. Chillbo Baggins - Carl Maclaren
20. ksmi117 – Victoria
7. Rogert – Lily Aldrin
11. NilocDent – Wendy
25. hedgiehog – Mickey Aldrin
28. Foxhunter – Quinn Garvey
27. Hammer2s – Linus
19. allieh8607 – Loretta

21. DocEspana - Doug
16. Jilary – Kevin
17. orca2011 - Brad
10. swingnsave - Marvin Erickson

30. devyn - The Blitz
2. Wildzoo - Ranjit
4. WillowLeaf - Judy Erickson
15. swiniazycie = The Captain

32. LetItSnow - Nora
12. ResoluteMike - James Stinson
31. DVMDream - Stella
1. Mad Jack - Tracy McConnell (The mother)
14. Zensing - Sandy Rivers

33. dyachei - Tony Graffanello
23. HowIMetYourPet - Marshall
 
You guys are really, really boring. :lame: I want more accusations!!!

@AshgirlI was trying to keep a low profile to make wolves literally forget I was playing. As you can see I guess it worked somewhat. Haha. Now that we are down low in number though, I don't think this strategy will work anymore but at least I survived this long! 😛

Yeah....I can't support just peacing out in the middle of games. Regardless of what the role is or what side you're on. Not showing up for almost the entire game is frowned upon and would get you mod-killed in some games. Just FYI.

***lynch honey****

The rest of you do what you want.
 
Last edited:
Well, considering that I was demoralized last night I'me fairly confident that Caia's still a wolf. That's where my vote would go if I could vote.
 
Well, considering that I was demoralized last night I'me fairly confident that Caia's still a wolf. That's where my vote would go if I could vote.

Interestingly enough, wasn't me. I literally cannot do anything.

I mean, when I'm obviously a wolf I'll just yawn and get on with life, but I don't like being lynched for something I'm not.
 
Interestingly enough, wasn't me. I literally cannot do anything.

I mean, when I'm obviously a wolf I'll just yawn and get on with life, but I don't like being lynched for something I'm not.
Do you know someone else who can demoralize then? According to your role, that's an ability pretty specific to you, which is why you can imagine BI would assume you're the one who did it.
 
Do you know someone else who can demoralize then? According to your role, that's an ability pretty specific to you, which is why you can imagine BI would assume you're the one who did it.

Yeah, I don't fault her for thinking that. When she said she couldn't vote I didn't connect the dots to being demoralized, tbh.

I'm considering whether someone can use dead people's abilities since I'm essentially, kinda dead (at least my role is). Or somebody stole my role while I was dead and that's why I'm now a nobody. Or Gwen simply inherited it, though I think it would have been nice if she could have inherited orca's role when she died and then maybe I wouldn't have died back then. Probably game breaking though.

You're free to lynch me just because, and I understand why, I just figured I'd be as honest as possible about everything.
 
I'm considering whether someone can use dead people's abilities since I'm essentially, kinda dead (at least my role is). Or somebody stole my role while I was dead and that's why I'm now a nobody. Or Gwen simply inherited it, though I think it would have been nice if she could have inherited orca's role when she died and then maybe I wouldn't have died back then. Probably game breaking though.
It's possible for that to happen, though a bit curious as to why they choose BI. I'm also not sure I would buy that Gwen inherited it though, unless she was able to do 2 actions last-night.

TBH (and this will be a bit of a ramble), I'm a bit lost as to what to do.

There are 7 players left.
1 wolf for sure.
1 traitorous wolf for sure.
1 neutral for sure.
2 villagers (assuming no converts).
And then 2 others, which I'm not sure what affiliation they belong to.

Let's say we lynch BI today. If the 2 others aren't villagers by chance (well we know Caia isn't a villager), wouldn't that be game over?

But if we don't lynch BI at some point, then the wolves win for sure it seems like.

:shrug: I'm just not sure who to lynch atm.
 
It's possible for that to happen, though a bit curious as to why they choose BI. I'm also not sure I would buy that Gwen inherited it though, unless she was able to do 2 actions last-night.

TBH (and this will be a bit of a ramble), I'm a bit lost as to what to do.

There are 7 players left.
1 wolf for sure.
1 traitorous wolf for sure.
1 neutral for sure.
2 villagers (assuming no converts).
And then 2 others, which I'm not sure what affiliation they belong to.

Let's say we lynch BI today. If the 2 others aren't villagers by chance (well we know Caia isn't a villager), wouldn't that be game over?

But if we don't lynch BI at some point, then the wolves win for sure it seems like.

:shrug: I'm just not sure who to lynch atm.

That's the problem when you have one specific player that has to die in order to kill another, there's never a good time to do it. It just needs to be done at some point because you know that Gwen is unlikely to off her.

I had completely forgotten about the traitorous wolves. Seeing as Gwen can't be lynched at the moment, I'm ok with lynching them too.
 
@Caia I haven't abandoned the game at any point. I've been following everyone's posts actively, but most of the time when I could post, it was something that multiple people had already mentioned in the thread so I didn't think it would be necessary for me to restate 🙁 I'm sorry if I came off the wrong way in my way of playing..
 
I'm sorry if I came off the wrong way in my way of playing..

*****
Rules 1-10 of WW: Don't apologize. The right response to @Caia was "Oh yeah? Well your brain has been absent all game."

Or maybe a yer momma joke, but that's kinda like going nuclear over a minor offense. Either way, she can handle it. 🙂

*****
 
Ok, guys. When Marshall got killed the second time it was revealed that not only was he still chaos, but that he had the same abilities he originally had (plus a new one). Odds are Caia is still a wolf and still has the same demoralizing ability. If she's a wolf and we don't get her it's probably game over.

@Ashgirl @honeytokki @StartingoverVet @Cyndia
 
I guess we can find out. Lynch Caia.
 
No one has said it yet, but the traitorous wolf is SOV, as seered by MJ Or BI I believe.
but at least not a wolf. I'm trying to get rid of all the neutral and chaos characters.. so ....

Lynch cyndia

I think that whole Honey showing up suddenly when ashgirl mentioned her is a bit suspicious. Have no idea what her role is in this game, or anything about her. that can't be good at this point, but from what I have heard of cyndia's role, that seems more like chaos to me.
 
No one has said it yet, but the traitorous wolf is SOV, as seered by MJ Or BI I believe.
but at least not a wolf. I'm trying to get rid of all the neutral and chaos characters.. so ....

Lynch cyndia

I think that whole Honey showing up suddenly when ashgirl mentioned her is a bit suspicious. Have no idea what her role is in this game, or anything about her. that can't be good at this point, but from what I have heard of cyndia's role, that seems more like chaos to me.
 
but at least not a wolf. I'm trying to get rid of all the neutral and chaos characters.. so ....

Lynch cyndia

I think that whole Honey showing up suddenly when ashgirl mentioned her is a bit suspicious. Have no idea what her role is in this game, or anything about her. that can't be good at this point, but from what I have heard of cyndia's role, that seems more like chaos to me.

I'm not chaos, I'm a villager. I've literally been protecting myself every night other than when I tried to stage a protest on ashgirl (which failed, it should have blocked her), and then setting up the convo since it was my last chance to use it.
 
but at least not a wolf. I'm trying to get rid of all the neutral and chaos characters.. so ....

Lynch cyndia

I think that whole Honey showing up suddenly when ashgirl mentioned her is a bit suspicious. Have no idea what her role is in this game, or anything about her. that can't be good at this point, but from what I have heard of cyndia's role, that seems more like chaos to me.
I really don't think Cyndia is where we should look right now. From the show, Zoey would sound choasy, but would anyone picture Robin being a wolf? This is an STL game afterall..

Someone demoralized BI last night and took away her vote. That was Caia's role, who claims to not have it anymore. I think we are more likely to get something lynching her than someone who could very well be a villager.
 
Top