Magical WW Signups and Game Thread

[LetItSnow]

---

Members don't see this ad.

***lynch dyachei***

It is time to make sure we aren't being played. STL claims not to have been converted, and two nights ago he was attacked, so that at least suggests some support for his claim.

But there isn't any reason to think Dy couldn't have been.

 

[LetItSnow]

And the numbers should be 5-1 or 4-2, right? There are 8 left with two supposed chaos. Or was the write-up total wrong (I didn't count players, just went with what the write-up said.)

 

[finnickthedog]

And the numbers should be 5-1 or 4-2, right? There are 8 left with two supposed chaos. Or was the write-up total wrong (I didn't count players, just went with what the write-up said.)

We also still have a neutral.

 

[SummerTheLynx]

***lynch dyachei***

It is time to make sure we aren't being played. STL claims not to have been converted, and two nights ago he was attacked, so that at least suggests some support for his claim.

But there isn't any reason to think Dy couldn't have been.

Aye, I can reverify tomorrow night and double check that BBC and DY have still not been converted if ye would like. "Have any non-villager, non-wolves been converted, by the conclusion of this night?"

Methinks I still have no reason to think either can be converted, but if you would rather want it verified, that's fine too. Methinks I also cleared all of fairytale fields after the first convert happened (but am not positive).

 

[dyachei]

***lynch dyachei***

It is time to make sure we aren't being played. STL claims not to have been converted, and two nights ago he was attacked, so that at least suggests some support for his claim.

But there isn't any reason to think Dy couldn't have been.

if you're going to lynch me, fine. But wait until tomorrow?

 

[heyyimhayley]

if you're going to lynch me, fine. But wait until tomorrow?

Why? Idk , I'm not confident on a convert choice at all and numbers aren't looking good for villagers, so you may be a better choice . Plus we still don't know why we're having 2 kills and supposedly there's only one wolf who is a convert left...

 

[dyachei]

Why? Idk , I'm not confident on a convert choice at all and numbers aren't looking good for villagers, so you may be a better choice . Plus we still don't know why we're having 2 kills and supposedly there's only one wolf who is a convert left...

theres a good reason but sharing it on open thread is stupid.

I haven't lied to you. STL told you that I hadn't lied earlier. There's no reason to lynch me when I'm trying to help.

And there's no reason to stop looking for a freaking convert when we know one exists. Quite honestly, this response makes me want to waffle back to you. Wolves are way more worried about chaos than anyone else.

 

[heyyimhayley]

theres a good reason but sharing it on open thread is stupid.

I haven't lied to you. STL told you that I hadn't lied earlier. There's no reason to lynch me when I'm trying to help.

And there's no reason to stop looking for a freaking convert when we know one exists. Quite honestly, this response makes me want to waffle back to you. Wolves are way more worried about chaos than anyone else.

Well I'm worried about losing another villager and then 2 more getting killed tonight

1 wolf
2 chaos
1 neural
4 villagers

So that would be 1 wolf and 1 villager left tomorrow if we lynch a villager today.

 

[dyachei]

Well I'm worried about losing another villager and then 2 more getting killed tonight

1 wolf
2 chaos
1 neural
4 villagers

So that would be 1 wolf and 1 villager left tomorrow if we lynch a villager today.

ok. But lynching me today is a bad time for everyone. And there's no guarantee wolves won't kill chaos overnight since we're starting to be a big problem for them. We still have 1 mislynch left. My goal is to help the freaking village that apparently still wants to kill me despite evidence otherwise.

 

[SummerTheLynx]

Well I'm worried about losing another villager and then 2 more getting killed tonight

1 wolf
2 chaos
1 neural
4 villagers

So that would be 1 wolf and 1 villager left tomorrow if we lynch a villager today.

If the mods ended the game with 5 people left and only 1 wolf in the game, I would be severely disappointed in 'em

The issue is that takin' out DY provides no new info fer me. I know DY is chaos, you know DY is chaos, it's not a surprise. I need to use stuff to start narrowing down wolves. I was going to use identifiers to narrow down wolves tomorrow (can the last wolf fly, can the last wolf swim, yada yada). I still would like to go that route, but if it puts people's minds at rest fer me to eliminate neutral and chaos as wolves, then I will do that.

 

[dyachei]

I've interfered with the wolves at least 2 nights, too. So I'm still doing **** behind the scenes. Lynching me today is a bad plan

 

[allyphoe]

I'm not confident on a convert choice at all

If STL, dy, and PBC are teaming up and playing us, the village is doomed regardless. And the consensus there is that the convert wolf is either you or me. So unless you can come up with some really compelling reason for someone else (and not just "IDK, so will vote for someone who's not a wolf"), you need to be voting for one of you and me. And so should everyone else be.

If you lynch one of us and we're village, assuming one convert still, then at close of day there are 3 villagers and one wolf, and if the wolves can be kept to one kill tonight then tomorrow the other of us gets lynched and village wins.

If you lynch one of the chaos/neutrals, and the wolves can be kept to one kill tonight, then tomorrow morning there are 3 villagers and one wolf, and everyone *still* has to decide which one of us to lynch, but we only get one chance to get it right.

I know I'm village, which is why I'm voting for you, but if everyone else thinks I'm wolfy, I'm okay with being lynched, because that leaves us with some chance of still having a vote tomorrow with which to pull off a village win. Voting for anyone other than me and you is a vote for a wolf win.

 

[LetItSnow]

If the mods ended the game with 5 people left and only 1 wolf in the game, I would be severely disappointed in 'em

The issue is that takin' out DY provides no new info fer me. I know DY is chaos, you know DY is chaos, it's not a surprise. I need to use stuff to start narrowing down wolves. I was going to use identifiers to narrow down wolves tomorrow (can the last wolf fly, can the last wolf swim, yada yada). I still would like to go that route, but if it puts people's minds at rest fer me to eliminate neutral and chaos as wolves, then I will do that.

My concern is that as best I know - we are all 100% taking your word and her word that you two aren't responsible for any kills and that you can win with villagers. I am unaware of a single bit of independent verification of that claim. You keep repeating it like it is accepted fact - but it isn't.

You verifying yourself and Dy is obviously pointless.

 

[LetItSnow]

I've interfered with the wolves at least 2 nights, too. So I'm still doing **** behind the scenes. Lynching me today is a bad plan

Did you interfere with the attack on STL two nights ago?

 

[SummerTheLynx]

The issue I have with me Hayley lynch is that why would she make an item that successfully would clear someone or risk exposing herself....

I do have issues with how ally used the item. I was the safest choice to pick as a wolf with that item. The feek gets to verify what I did (super mild cred), figure out more about how I am getting my info if she is a wolf, and avoid clearing anyone that isn't already cleared.

@LetItSnow ye are the skeptic left alive, am I missing something mighty here?

 

[LetItSnow]

The issue I have with me Hayley lynch is that why would she make an item that successfully would clear someone or risk exposing herself....

I do have issues with how ally used the item. I was the safest choice to pick as a wolf with that item. The feek gets to verify what I did (super mild cred), figure out more about how I am getting my info if she is a wolf, and avoid clearing anyone that isn't already cleared.

@LetItSnow ye are the skeptic left alive, am I missing something mighty here?

I don't understand what you are asking.

 

[SummerTheLynx]

Did you interfere with the attack on STL two nights ago?

The feek may have tried to like I have. But the attack would have been successful if it weren't for a couple of things, one of which is now gone thanks to that night (aka the attack worked)

 

[dyachei]

Did you interfere with the attack on STL two nights ago?

possibly? I've interfered 2 nights. once with gwen and once with kam I think. Would have to look back to see when

 

[LetItSnow]

The feek may have tried to like I have. But the attack would have been successful if it weren't for a couple of things, one of which is now gone thanks to that night (aka the attack worked)

Is there some reason you couldn't let Dy answer? The question was not addressed to you for a reason. Sigh.

 

[SummerTheLynx]

My concern is that as best I know - we are all 100% taking your word and her word that you two aren't responsible for any kills and that you can win with villagers. I am unaware of a single bit of independent verification of that claim. You keep repeating it like it is accepted fact - but it isn't.

You verifying yourself and Dy is obviously pointless.

Ally verified that at least I didn't kill last even in'. The night before, my eyes were heavy, so I assume someone knows I didn't kill that night. I can't verify anythin' on DY killing or not, I honestly don't know, but there would be no reason for her ta kill

 

[SummerTheLynx]

I don't understand what you are asking.

Why would the feek track me last night?

 

[LetItSnow]

Ally verified that at least I didn't kill last even in'. The night before, my eyes were heavy, so I assume someone knows I didn't kill that night. I can't verify anythin' on DY killing or not, I honestly don't know, but there would be no reason for her ta kill

I already know that you didn't kill two nights ago, and said so earlier.

There certainly could be a reason for her to kill. If the whole "win with villagers" claim is BS (and again, I am unaware of ANY verification of that claim), and if you look at that claim with skepticism, then suddenly it looks like you and/or her have done a good job of whittling this game down to a third-party possible win.

 

[dyachei]

I already know that you didn't kill two nights ago, and said so earlier.

There certainly could be a reason for her to kill. If the whole "win with villagers" claim is BS (and again, I am unaware of ANY verification of that claim), and if you look at that claim with skepticism, then suddenly it looks like you and/or her have done a good job of whittling this game down to a third-party possible win.

I interfered with kam and genny not gwen. Each the night before they were lynched looking back on my PMs.

So yes, I think that was the night STL was attacked. But my interference didn't work the way I initially thought it might.

 

[allyphoe]

I do have issues with how ally used the item.

I was told that the mods would pick someone at random for the item to be used on. You would not have been my pick - but neither would hayley have been, because I thought that raf was the convert. That's also why I picked raf for my PM choice for today.

 

[SummerTheLynx]

I already know that you didn't kill two nights ago, and said so earlier.

There certainly could be a reason for her to kill. If the whole "win with villagers" claim is BS (and again, I am unaware of ANY verification of that claim), and if you look at that claim with skepticism, then suddenly it looks like you and/or her have done a good job of whittling this game down to a third-party possible win.

Why would I tell ye that one of the converts didn't go through when I found that out if we were not able to win with villagers? I would have ye fixating even more on wolves if I did t tell ye that (making the trust in us inevitable as opposed to optional)

 

[heyyimhayley]

If STL, dy, and PBC are teaming up and playing us, the village is doomed regardless. And the consensus there is that the convert wolf is either you or me. So unless you can come up with some really compelling reason for someone else (and not just "IDK, so will vote for someone who's not a wolf"), you need to be voting for one of you and me. And so should everyone else be.

If you lynch one of us and we're village, assuming one convert still, then at close of day there are 3 villagers and one wolf, and if the wolves can be kept to one kill tonight then tomorrow the other of us gets lynched and village wins.

If you lynch one of the chaos/neutrals, and the wolves can be kept to one kill tonight, then tomorrow morning there are 3 villagers and one wolf, and everyone *still* has to decide which one of us to lynch, but we only get one chance to get it right.

I know I'm village, which is why I'm voting for you, but if everyone else thinks I'm wolfy, I'm okay with being lynched, because that leaves us with some chance of still having a vote tomorrow with which to pull off a village win. Voting for anyone other than me and you is a vote for a wolf win.

Unless we're both villagers? Are Finn and LIS really cleared or is this speculation?

 

[LetItSnow]

Why would I tell ye that one of the converts didn't go through when I found that out if we were not able to win with villagers? I would have ye fixating even more on wolves if I did t tell ye that (making the trust in us inevitable as opposed to optional)

... But you did tell us that?

All this pseudo-leprechaunese hurts my head.

 

[SummerTheLynx]

I was told that the mods would pick someone at random for the item to be used on. You would not have been my pick - but neither would hayley have been, because I thought that raf was the convert. That's also why I picked raf for my PM choice for today.

Did the mods specifically say they would? Or did they say it would be randomly picked? Or just that ye would get results? 'Tis important

 

[SummerTheLynx]

... But you did tell us that?

All this pseudo-leprechaunese hurts my head.

First post of yesterday me lad

 

[katashark]

Lynch Day 10 Tally
hayley (1) - ally
ally (1) - dy
dy (1) - LIS

Deadline 8pm CST

3/8 Voting

 

[allyphoe]

Did the mods specifically say they would? Or did they say it would be randomly picked? Or just that ye would get results? 'Tis important

Poppy Seeds: These enhance your dreams, and give you visions of clairvoyance. If you choose to consume these, you will watch the actions of another player in your dreams (the other player can be chosen at random by mods).

 

[SummerTheLynx]

Unless we're both villagers? Are Finn and LIS really cleared or is this speculation?

LIS is 100% clear. No wolves left with lynch avoidances as of the conclusion of last night.

The lad Finn took down kam after first convert. Would ballsy for a newer wolf, but not out of realm of possibility.

 

[LetItSnow]

As a total aside, I am highly disappointed at the lack of a phouka in this game. Pwca. Pooka. Whatever you prefer.

 

[heyyimhayley]

Poppy Seeds: These enhance your dreams, and give you visions of clairvoyance. If you choose to consume these, you will watch the actions of another player in your dreams (the other player can be chosen at random by mods).

Yeah, I had already made a tracking item so I made this one random.

 

[dyachei]

Yeah, I had already made a tracking item so I made this one random.

do you get to decide who the items go to?

 

[heyyimhayley]

do you get to decide who the items go to?

Yes

 

[dyachei]

Yes

then why would you consider lynching me today???

 

[heyyimhayley]

The lad Finn took down kam after first convert. Would ballsy for a newer wolf, but not out of realm of possibility.

Hmm, I mean you and I had already pretty much decided Kam was a wolf though, so it was likely she was going down anyway. I could see it being a possibility that she figured, well Kam will be lynched today or tomorrow, let me buy myself cred.

 

[heyyimhayley]

then why would you consider lynching me today???

I'm confused. I explained why I was considering it already.. what do my items have to do with it

 

[dyachei]

I'm confused. I explained why I was considering it already.. what do my items have to do with it

I received a useful item. I assumed you sent it. Is there another item maker?

 

[finnickthedog]

LIS is 100% clear. No wolves left with lynch avoidances as of the conclusion of last night.

Is this really a 100% clear though? You mentioned earlier in regards to hayley that wolves sometimes lose their abilities when converted. So if LIS was converted, it's possible it would be without the lynch avoidance.

LIS was someone that I was wondering about as a possible convert before genny went down because he seemed so preoccupied with chaos even while we had known wolves on the radar. I just assumed this morning when you stated it was probably hayley or ally that you had cleared him.

 

[heyyimhayley]

I received a useful item. I assumed you sent it. Is there another item maker?

I sent my item to Finn last night unless I was re-directed without my knowledge

 

[finnickthedog]

I sent my item to Finn last night unless I was re-directed without my knowledge

You were not redirected. I have it.

 

[dyachei]

I sent my item to Finn last night unless I was re-directed without my knowledge

I didn't interfere with you last night.

 

[dyachei]

so are there other items circulating?

 

[heyyimhayley]

so are there other items circulating?

Could be a mod generated item, right ? Considering PBC supposedly had an item affinity and item makers choose their targets, there had to have been non-item maker items in the game.

 

[allyphoe]

so are there other items circulating?

I got the Fire of Morpheus at the end of N5 for use N6. I sent you a picture with it, but a pointless picture because you are not who I thought you were then.

 

[dyachei]

Could be a mod generated item, right ? Considering PBC supposedly had an item affinity and item makers choose their targets, there had to have been non-item maker items in the game.

just seems weird since I don't think anyone else mentioned them?

 

[dyachei]

I got the Fire of Morpheus at the end of N5 for use N6. I sent you a picture with it, but a pointless picture because you are not who I thought you were then.

ok.

 

[dyachei]

I can confirm I received that.