MaWWke YoWWr OWWn WW - Game Thread

[samac]

---

Members don't see this ad.

Okay, I missed it in the reply. My feelings will continue to burn then.

I can’t be 100% of anything other than Dina is a tree stump but
I dunno
Last night sent me on a paranoia spiral
I crawled out of it
Now I’m crawling back into it

 

[Animal Midwife]

Yeet PSV

 

[dyachei]

fun fact: conversion was the reason I stopped playing as much on SDN to begin with

 

[samac]

now
Someone make a case for village santy other than the town/village thing

Cause what if santy/shelter

 

[dyachei]

now
Someone make a case for village santy other than the town/village thing

Cause what if santy/shelter

i can't make a case for you but my gut is saying shelter v

 

[Animal Midwife]

I will also say that the converter being converted is deeply depressing because it sounds like the stack in Number where Sporty was still allowed to kill on top of the other kills and conversions.

 

[marmot`]

now
Someone make a case for village santy other than the town/village thing

Cause what if santy/shelter

My guy says santy town

 

[Animal Midwife]

now
Someone make a case for village santy other than the town/village thing

Cause what if santy/shelter

Don't have one. There's nothing left for me.

 

[marmot`]

Ebwop: gut

 

[dyachei]

##vote clem

 

[dyachei]

My guy says santy town

who's your guy 😉

 

[Animal Midwife]

##vote clem

Actually yeah.

Unyeet PSV
Yeet Clem

 

[samac]

I don’t know whether to throw my gut out the window or not cause we haven’t flipped my top guts which is shelter and chic.
Though I don’t think they’re paired.

 

[marmot`]

who's your guy 😉

Sammy 😉

 

[Dinashadow]

Cults are probably my least favorite thing in all of Mafia.

It might be solvable in this game just by the "pick your own role" structure. Is there enough SDN precedent for cults for an SDN regular to choose it? I haven't seen them in my brief time here, and that may also apply to the Clem and Nate types, for example. The first necessary condition to request "cult leader" is to have "cult leader" in your brain.

Yes see stardew pt 1 and I think @samacs' noob game iirc

 

[Dinashadow]

now
Someone make a case for village santy other than the town/village thing

Cause what if santy/shelter

It's crossed my mind multiple times ngl

 

[samac]

Yes see stardew pt 1 and I think @samacs' noob game iirc

Numbers
10th anni was a differently flavored cult

 

[Santygrass]

Yeet PSV

Psv was prob the slot that was trying to push mayo the most, and mayo was retaliatory against them. I dont think they were cult buddies yesterday, and mayo would be a strange conversion target if scum!psv had all set up to push and diss mayo often

 

[samac]

It's crossed my mind multiple times ngl

He made a good case to pull me to veggie from shelter tbh but what if pulled off scuM

 

[marmot`]

Mostly my gut says santy is lovely and playing without him would be kind of a bummer

 

[Santygrass]

now
Someone make a case for village santy other than the town/village thing

Cause what if santy/shelter

You have only that to read me as villa after everything that happened yesterday samac? Really????

 

[Animal Midwife]

Psv was prob the slot that was trying to push mayo the most, and mayo was retaliatory against them. I dont think they were cult buddies yesterday, and mayo would be a strange conversion target if scum!psv had all set up to push and diss mayo often

As I said before, I'm not cult hunting but scum hunting.

 

[samac]

You have only that to read me as villa after everything that happened yesterday samac? Really????

You made a convincing argument on a town slot
You targeted me with an ability that was not great
Bleh

 

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Animal Midwife
Boquise
samac

Santygrass

chicandtoughness
dyachei
NateTheLesser
SARdoghandler
sheltermed
Stagg737

Clem J
marmot
genny
potentialsheltervet

WildZoo

I asked myself to try to organize reads. This list is purely about mafia and not mafia, so cults et al have no bearing. That could be anyone. This is where my brain took me, and yet I hate it for three reasons.

1) It's mostly an activity level counter
2) It hardly deviates from the status quo after what I perceive to be two bad status quo flips (mkg and Veggie)
3) It's day 3, and my yellow pile runs six deep.

I have a few methods in mind to try to resolve this, and I will work on them throughout the day. Perhaps I'll still end up at a list like this, but I kind of hope I don't. It just looks like it sucks.

 

[Santygrass]

As I said before, I'm not cult hunting but scum hunting.

I know, but scum hunting + Chop the leader can both be inclusive in my head

 

[samac]

As I said before, I'm not cult hunting but scum hunting.

I think it is worth a acknowledging possible interactions with mayo though because as we’ve seen ignoring the cult doesn’t work well.
So that could lead us to scum.

 

[marmot`]

yeet animal midwife

this is where my gut is at rn

 

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Yes see stardew pt 1 and I think @samacs' noob game iirc

Thanks. Let's carry this to its inevitable conclusion:

Can we think of any specific people that have been known to romanticize about cults or otherwise that loves the idea of conversion?

 

[Animal Midwife]

I know, but scum hunting + Chop the leader can both be inclusive in my head

Yeah.

 

[marmot`]

Jay can you explain ur confidence in your tr of am?

 

[dyachei]

i wish J were better at picking up my hints

 

[samac]

yeet animal midwife

this is where my gut is at rn

Why?

 

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Thanks. Let's carry this to its inevitable conclusion:

Can we think of any specific people that have been known to romanticize about cults or otherwise that loves the idea of conversion?

And just as importantly... anyone that has been vocal about hating conversion and wanting it to go away forever

 

[Animal Midwife]

I think it is worth a acknowledging possible interactions with mayo though because as we’ve seen ignoring the cult doesn’t work well.
So that could lead us to scum.

Yes, that's totally fair. I don't know how to view mayo's read when his posts were as obfuscated as possible. All I have is not chic and not PSV?

 

[Santygrass]

You made a convincing argument on a town slot
You targeted me with an ability that was not great
Bleh

PM opener is such a poopoo ability to try and **** with as scum tbh , probably a lot better targets as scum dont you think?


And yes, I made an argument because I believed in it, and still think shelter is town.

Like, I think you are missing a lot of nuance and reads that you should've had on me yesterday that I towned it up and it feels like you are now pretending to forget them all smh

 

[marmot`]

Thanks. Let's carry this to its inevitable conclusion:

Can we think of any specific people that have been known to romanticize about cults or otherwise that loves the idea of conversion?

Idk I'm new here

I could see clem going that route but I could also see him just letting his role rand

 

[Animal Midwife]

Why?

They're more than likely scum. I would be fine with a wagon there too.

 

[JaggedJimmyJay]

i wish J were better at picking up my hints

Picking up subtle hints has never been my strength, but when I get into analysis perhaps I will notice something.

 

[Santygrass]

And just as importantly... anyone that has been vocal about hating conversion and wanting it to go away forever

AM is a cult hater. I am too, probably SDN folks know more about who hates cults, but is probably a SDN local

 

[samac]

PM opener is such a poopoo ability to try and **** with as scum tbh , probably a lot better targets as scum dont you think?


And yes, I made an argument because I believed in it, and still think shelter is town.

Like, I think you are missing a lot of nuance and reads that you should've had on me yesterday that I towned it up and it feels like you are now pretending to forget them all smh

Lmao
I think PMer is a pretty ****ty target as village too. Go find scum and **** with them. Instead you ****ed with me.

“pretending to forget”
Okay santy
What I remember is you pulling me off my wagon.
What have you done out of your wolf range?

 

[JaggedJimmyJay]

AM is a cult hater. I am too, probably SDN folks know more about who hates cults, but is probably a SDN local

I figure the same.

If we can isolate "SDN person" and then eliminate "SDN people that hate cults", perhaps that leaves us with a reasonable suspect pool.

Plus Clem.

I don't know how he feels about cults, but he's Clem. He'll do anything for a meme.

 

[marmot`]

Why?

Their prodding rubs me the wrong way.

Like I get the impression that they're prodding more to look for easy angles to push, rather than to find wolves

 

[samac]

And just as importantly... anyone that has been vocal about hating conversion and wanting it to go away forever

FWIW coming from myself AM and I both hate conversions.

 

[samac]

Their prodding rubs me the wrong way.

Like I get the impression that they're prodding more to look for easy angles to push, rather than to find wolves

Have you played with AM before?

 

[JaggedJimmyJay]

FWIW coming from myself AM and I both hate conversions.

I believe that. I also believe dyachei wouldn't have chosen cult leader.

 

[samac]

(But I also did love getting taken into Zenges bone cult on the last day possible after villaging my heart out and the wolves being dicks)

 

[marmot`]

Conversions with restrictions can be fun, but I'm overall not a huge fan either.

But if I'm in a game with them I will certainly ask for said conversion, can't pass up that opportunity!

 

[dyachei]

I believe that. I also believe dyachei wouldn't have chosen cult leader.

absolutely would not. **** cults. I find out there are cults in MU games and out

 

[samac]

I can also say prior to my noob game Stagg was unfamiliar with cults if that means anything. He was my manator and didn’t know how to handle it.

 

[Santygrass]

Lmao
I think PMer is a pretty ****ty target as village too. Go find scum and **** with them. Instead you ****ed with me.

“pretending to forget”
Okay santy
What I remember is you pulling me off my wagon.
What have you done out of your wolf range?

Havent you read? I said that EXACTLY because you were PM opener I knew I wasnt targeting accidentally a doctor or something of the sorts and be a somewhat verifiable way to see my role working.

Im not going to go back and do a list of things, but I know that I was one of the people more involved and solving on thread, and by the way you were reacting I had the feeling you saw me as towny too. So now you only remember that?