MaWWke YoWWr OWWn WW - Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Cult is dead and game is still going, so I'm back at >50% chance that there's at least a wolf or a small pack.

Current concerns, why do Dy and Shelther have multi-night kills? Multi-kill vig is possible, but I've never seen an every night vig in village.

Still want to see Clem flip for the same reasons.

This is nice. I would have distrusted even an IC if the cult was still in play.
This is why I didn't want to reveal or hint too hard. In Noobs in space there was a player who was IC, revealed, and then I converted her to wolf. It was a mess. @WildZoo has very fond memories of that game.
 
So we still have kills only accounted for by claimed vigilante shots.

The game is not over with the cult destroyed. Something is amiss in these claims. I'm not sure what other kind of anti-town faction there could be.
We yeet
Shelter
Then if I’m wrong Dy
Then if I’m wrong you

I think it’s the first though
 
It was passive on Genny’s part so there wasn’t a “you’ve turn to cult result”
I got turned because I tried to Pm her because she sad reacted me asking you and I was like “I’m neutral she’s probably scum but I’ll pm her anyway heh”
AND LOW AND BEHOLD MY PM WAS CULT CHAT
PMs bad
 
she similarly threw me under the bus in a prior game. Where she was the original cult member. Not as blatantly as this time though 😭 and she let "everyone" win.



Since dya sounds hesitant to do a full reveal I guess I won't either unless necessary. But basically I asked for something where I can be useful behind the scenes, because I am typically terrible with reads, primarily over the first few days, and contributing in thread in general (ask anyone) so this role has allowed me to create a collective poe from the experienced players and then choose someone to kill every night off that. Of course there is still some problem solving of my own, mainly that I have to decide if I trust the reads of others and then I had to narrow down the list. I'd say it's been generally successful!

WHAT THE ****
THREW YOU UNDER THE BUS?
WE PM’D AND WORKED TOGETHER
I DIDNT TRY AND GET YOU OUT AT ALL
AND PUSHED FOR AN EVERYONE WINS WINCON INSTEAD OF ONLY MY FACTION
WHICH I ONLY NEEDED 1 MORE CONVERT TO OBTAIN
 
she similarly threw me under the bus in a prior game.
I'll just add that she wasn't trying to get me voted off in that game. That's what I meant by not as blatantly. We just had a pm open for days where I thought we were game solving together and then she turned out to be a cultist lol
 
WHAT THE ****
THREW YOU UNDER THE BUS?
WE PM’D AND WORKED TOGETHER
I DIDNT TRY AND GET YOU OUT AT ALL
AND PUSHED FOR AN EVERYONE WINS WINCON INSTEAD OF ONLY MY FACTION
WHICH I ONLY NEEDED 1 MORE CONVERT TO OBTAIN
I added to my statement!
 
Cult is dead and game is still going, so I'm back at >50% chance that there's at least a wolf or a small pack.

Current concerns, why do Dy and Shelther have multi-night kills? Multi-kill vig is possible, but I've never seen an every night vig in village
They exist. I've had the glory of being one for 1.5 cycles.
.Still want to see Clem flip for the same reasons.
Yes, he's not trying.
This is why I didn't want to reveal or hint too hard. In Noobs in space there was a player who was IC, revealed, and then I converted her to wolf. It was a mess. @WildZoo has very fond memories of that game.
Yes, I remember that. Conversions are the bane of my life.
 
@samac told me before our PM closed that Clem supposedly tried to open a 3-way PM with her and Shelter, but later Shelter said no one acted on her that night despite Clem telling Samac that he was in a PM with shelter. Where part of my Clem/Shelter reads are coming from.
 
she similarly threw me under the bus in a prior game. Where she was the original cult member. Not as blatantly as this time though 😭 and she let "everyone" win.



Since dya sounds hesitant to do a full reveal I guess I won't either unless necessary. But basically I asked for something where I can be useful behind the scenes, because I am typically terrible with reads, primarily over the first few days, and contributing in thread in general (ask anyone) so this role has allowed me to create a collective poe from the experienced players and then choose someone to kill every night off that. Of course there is still some problem solving of my own, mainly that I have to decide if I trust the reads of others and then I had to narrow down the list. I'd say it's been generally successful!
Other people's POEs are embedded into the mechanics of your role? Like, your kill choices are based entirely upon POE consensus in the thread?

Just making sure I understand you.
 
Cult is dead and game is still going, so I'm back at >50% chance that there's at least a wolf or a small pack.

Current concerns, why do Dy and Shelther have multi-night kills? Multi-kill vig is possible, but I've never seen an every night vig in village.

Still want to see Clem flip for the same reasons.


This is why I didn't want to reveal or hint too hard. In Noobs in space there was a player who was IC, revealed, and then I converted her to wolf. It was a mess. @WildZoo has very fond memories of that game.
I will say his PM with me is called BLT chat
So it’s at least sandwich themed
 
Other people's POEs are embedded into the mechanics of your role? Like, your kill choices are based entirely upon POE consensus in the thread?

Just making sure I understand you.
No. My role is just a nightly kill. The consensus was what I used for my own poe to choose who to kill.
 
she similarly threw me under the bus in a prior game. Where she was the original cult member. Not as blatantly as this time though 😭 and she let "everyone" win.



Since dya sounds hesitant to do a full reveal I guess I won't either unless necessary. But basically I asked for something where I can be useful behind the scenes, because I am typically terrible with reads, primarily over the first few days, and contributing in thread in general (ask anyone) so this role has allowed me to create a collective poe from the experienced players and then choose someone to kill every night off that. Of course there is still some problem solving of my own, mainly that I have to decide if I trust the reads of others and then I had to narrow down the list. I'd say it's been generally successful!
Also according to everyone else MaYo WaSnT pOe
 
No. My role is just a nightly kill. The consensus was what I used for my own poe to choose who to kill.
Here's my concern.

You asked for a role that "can be helpful behind the scenes". You received a role that kills every night.

I asked for a town vigilante, the literal killing role. I received kills every other night.

Something seems borked in account. And I'm not complaining about Zenge, to be clear.
 
Here's my concern.

You asked for a role that "can be helpful behind the scenes". You received a role that kills every night.

I asked for a town vigilante, the literal killing role. I received kills every other night.

Something seems borked in account. And I'm not complaining about Zenge, to be clear.
THANK YOU
 
I think having two every other night vigs plus a full village vig would be pretty op for village if the other "team" (3p or wolf) has none

Usually what I see is 1 vig equivalent per side but idk what zenge has done to balance this game specifically
 
Because Clem's still in my POE.
But AM
That’s fine, he can be in the POE. But there isn’t a single thing he done that warrants a yeet over proven killing power. Only reason I pushed it so hard yesterday was an alternate to genny
 
I think having two every other night vigs plus a full village vig would be pretty op for village if the other "team" (3p or wolf) has none

Usually what I see is 1 vig equivalent per side but idk what zenge has done to balance this game specifically
We can also toss Boq's one-shot vig into the casserole.
 
But AM
That’s fine, he can be in the POE. But there isn’t a single thing he done that warrants a yeet over proven killing power. Only reason I pushed it so hard yesterday was an alternate to genny

What exactly have I done that warrants a yeet? Eliminate the cult?
 
But AM
That’s fine, he can be in the POE. But there isn’t a single thing he done that warrants a yeet over proven killing power. Only reason I pushed it so hard yesterday was an alternate to genny
I disagree.
 
Pls if you all want me to shut up let’s take shelter out today.
Please.
Otherwise I’m going to die tonight and lose because she’s going to shoot me because I won’t shut up.
Please.
 
I will hold off on Clem until I hear of another sandwich. If we get additional sandwich confirmation, that will be important to me.

Marmot was a jester, but I tend to doubt they lied about their sandwich.
 
What exactly have I done that warrants a yeet? Eliminate the cult?
Shoot every night, make claims that hehe I don’t understand repeatedly though you’ve played longer than me, have shaky reads

Youre scum shelter.
 
GOD DAMMIT SANTY GIVE ME THIS
SHELTER
SHELTER
NOT CLEM
SHELTER
I could do it too . But if shelter town I think we can force them to shoot PSV and go pew pew through the PoE
 
This is why I didn't want to reveal or hint too hard. In Noobs in space there was a player who was IC, revealed, and then I converted her to wolf. It was a mess. @WildZoo has very fond memories of that game.
I have no regrets
 
Pls if you all want me to shut up let’s take shelter out today.
Please.
Otherwise I’m going to die tonight and lose because she’s going to shoot me because I won’t shut up.
Please.
I'm not going to shoot you.

I am literally at the village's disposal. I will shoot who everyone wants me to shoot.
 
What exactly have I done that warrants a yeet? Eliminate the cult?
To be clear, you are a legendary slaughterer of cultists, and I shall forever hold you in high esteem because of that. This doesn't, however, clear you of being a serial killer (or even wolf).
 
I could do it too . But if shelter town I think we can force them to shoot PSV and go pew pew through the PoE
Please santy, temporary cult buddy, she will kill me tonight because she knows she’s going down tomorrow. And I will lose.

She’s shooting within the Poe for village cred
 
Shoot every night, make claims that hehe I don’t understand repeatedly though you’ve played longer than me, have shaky reads

Youre scum shelter.

Shaky reads is exactly why I wanted this role
 
Pls if you all want me to shut up let’s take shelter out today.
Please.
Otherwise I’m going to die tonight and lose because she’s going to shoot me because I won’t shut up.
Please.
Dy can protect you
 
Dy can protect you
I don’t understand not going for her.

Cult is dead.
Remaining scum should have killing power.
It’s one of those 3

I feel like I’m in criminal minds shouting about AM I’m big text and I just got written off and killed and she won.
 
Shoot every night, make claims that hehe I don’t understand repeatedly though you’ve played longer than me, have shaky reads

Youre scum shelter.

Yeah, no, ask Zenge, ask WZ, ask AM, anyone who mods. I am constantly asking basic questions. I don't know definitions of ****. I may have been playing for a longer time than you, but I haven't played as many games or as consistently as you. Again ask anyone on this forum.
 
Top