MaWWke YoWWr OWWn WW - Game Thread

[JaggedJimmyJay]

---

Members don't see this ad.

That means your list is too consensus-y and probably wrong.

Put me at your top villa spot and see what happens

I don’t think it means anything, really. I AM The Consensus!

Spoiler

jk

Maybe I’ll drop you to sate your thirst for blood and entrails

 

[supershorty]

*opens mason chat*

I dont understand what the people are talking about in regards to the cyndia quote eli5

*opens mason chat*

Cyndia quoted me but broke the quote, then chic quoted Cyndia thinking Cyndia had said what I said bc the quote was broken. Then I said no Cyndia didn’t say that, I did, which for some reason chic pushed back on instead of just searching my posts for any of the phrases in that post. Then I called chic a donut.

I like donuts though, tbf.

 

[Santygrass]

Maybe I’ll drop you to sate your thirst for blood and entrails

Such a betrayal pls. First boq putting dubz at #2 spot ignoring me and now this.

I can only trust in my biological daughter. Blood runs thicker than water

 

[JaggedJimmyJay]

It’s Day 0 and I have nearly 200 posts. I apologize to all of the players, to Jesus, and to Mother Earth.

 

[chicandtoughness]

What's villagey about the other four?

Very interested in your Clem read @chicandtoughness

genny has a total of 10 posts so far, so please quote the ones you feel are village indicative and explain why in 300 words or less.

genny always feels villagey to me off vibes. I also agree with her pushing back on you about Stagg feeling towny. (I also feel genny would ask for a village or 3p role lol but that shouldn't be indicative!)
samac good points that I agree with (can do more in-depth if wanted)
SAR just vibes. I think Peanut has a hold on me 🙁
Clem feel as if there would be more substance if sus. I guess he's on the lower end of villagey if I had to choose, just more "not sus right now"

Also going to move shorty up into villagey based on the past few pages.

I dont understand what the people are talking about in regards to the cyndia quote eli5

I got confused and thought Cyndia said it. Cyndia was quoting something shorty said (but the quote itself was broken so it looked like she said it, and when I ISO'ed her posts I thought it was pertinent to call out.

 

[supershorty]

It’s Day 0 and I have nearly 200 posts. I apologize to all of the players, to Jesus, and to Mother Earth.

Oh god if you have nearly 200, I don’t want to think about how many I have

 

[Santygrass]

*keeps talking in mason chat*

I think my n0 action will be on mayo probs unless I find a better target. Dw if I do I'll tell you

 

[chicandtoughness]

But with donuts and not bread.

 

[Animal Midwife]

genny always feels villagey to me off vibes. I also agree with her pushing back on you about Stagg feeling towny. (I also feel genny would ask for a village or 3p role lol but that shouldn't be indicative!)
samac good points that I agree with (can do more in-depth if wanted)
SAR just vibes. I think Peanut has a hold on me 🙁
Clem feel as if there would be more substance if sus. I guess he's on the lower end of villagey if I had to choose, just more "not sus right now"

Also going to move shorty up into villagey based on the past few pages.


I got confused and thought Cyndia said it. Cyndia was quoting something shorty said (but the quote itself was broken so it looked like she said it, and when I ISO'ed her posts I thought it was pertinent to call out.

I mean, you literally saw genny wolfsiding and killing people when you called her play villagey. She loves wolfing. That aside, I though you weren't going to use statistical probability of role choice to affect your reads.

Yeah, I would like to hear more about samac.

 

[chicandtoughness]

I mean, you literally saw genny wolfsiding and killing people when you called her play villagey. She loves wolfing. That aside, I though you weren't going to use statistical probability of role choice to affect your reads.

Yep, which is why I clarified it was off vibes.
I never claim my vibes are any accurate or good, just that they're there :')

 

[Animal Midwife]

Yep, which is why I clarified it was off vibes.
I never claim my vibes are any accurate or good, just that they're there :')

I just feel like the vibes would be adjusted after encountering contradictory information.

 

[Santygrass]

Animal Midwife : Town
sheltermed : Null
potentialsheltervet : null. But its psv so that makes it lean scum for her
Boquise : Betrayer . Null but would be one of the first I'd shoot if my first susses are wrong and he is still alive
dyachei : Villa
Cyndia : Ded
WildZoo : Lean sus , hoping she can shine and waffle my read
Stagg737 : Going to trust my mason read more than mine atm . So lean villa
chicandtoughness : Seems like the consensus sus. I am not there yet but keeping a close eye.
VeggieTrex : Null
Clem J : Lean sus for sussing me yesyes
Santygrass : Villa
genny : genny.
JaggedJimmyJay : Town
marmot : MARMOT IS PLAYING WTF I FORGOT. @marmot` notice me
Dinashadow : Low content but gth I feel this is Village Dina.
samac : Irked bt samac, when usually she shines as villa. Other people are villareading her so I am awaiting. But in my sus radar
Supershorty : My mason
SAR : Idk why so many people seem to trust her, but willing to sheep that feeling and go along with it atm
NateTheLesser : Null
mkg323 : Null again, dont remember anything from them.
holdthemayo : Also null but would kinda lean sus on them from now just purely by *vibes*. Maybe the last game on syndicate I played with them and they were super villagey is playing a part on me being irked and not seeing mayo shine villagey

 

[chicandtoughness]

I just feel like the vibes would be adjusted after encountering contradictory information.

Your point is taken and I will revisit my vibes accordingly. I think it would be equally questionable for me to be like "yeah okay totally I'm going to move her down to sus now because AM pushed back".

If anything I'm moving her to neutral/3p/idk

 

[Santygrass]

Your point is taken and I will revisit my vibes accordingly. I think it would be equally questionable for me to be like "yeah okay totally I'm going to move her down to sus now because AM pushed back".

If anything I'm moving her to neutral/3p/idk

genny tier is the way

 

[chicandtoughness]

I’m sorry you haven’t played more loud games tbh

Not pushing back, just asking for clarification. When you say loud in this particular instance, were you expecting for the role PM to be along the lines of "HEY YOU'RE DYING JUST FYI?"

While I continue through the backlog of questions, can folks plz share thoughts on Santy specifically?

 

[Santygrass]

I think santy is Villa. I can feel it in my bones

 

[holdthemayo]

*keeps talking in mason chat*

I think my n0 action will be on mayo probs unless I find a better target. Dw if I do I'll tell you

I'll be waiting. You know the place.

 

[WildZoo]

I can only trust in my biological daughter. Blood runs thicker than water

That phrase is actually "The blood of the covenant is thicker than the water of the womb"

 

[Santygrass]

I'll be waiting. You know the place.

We will have one wild night

 

[JaggedJimmyJay]

Santy’s SAR read is a smidge towny. A teaspoon. Not quite a dollop. Might expand later.

 

[WildZoo]

WildZoo : Lean sus , hoping she can shine and waffle my read

I'm unlikely to shine unless I get struck by lightning

 

[chicandtoughness]

I think santy is Villa. I can feel it in my bones

Solid reasoning 10/10.

 

[chicandtoughness]

@Cyndia I don't suppose you know anything about heart meds or coughing?

Was this a lucky guess? Is there a reason you asked her specifically instead of someone else?

 

[Santygrass]

I'm unlikely to shine unless I get struck by lightning

Wrong! When we are both Villa you always shone in my eyes, SPARKLING AND DAZZLING dubz to the rescue

 

[supershorty]

Was this a lucky guess? Is there a reason you asked her specifically instead of someone else?

Yes because the things specifically referenced someone who wasn’t here or that someone was missing, so I was interested in those who hadn’t posted very much

 

[supershorty]

*keeps talking in mason chat*

I think my n0 action will be on mayo probs unless I find a better target. Dw if I do I'll tell you

*opens mason chat*

I’m torn here between wanting to say I like night action and then feeling weird about saying that to my biological mother because Sporty is the one who likes incest, not me

 

[Santygrass]

*opens mason chat*

I’m torn here between wanting to say I like night action and then feeling weird about saying that to my biological mother because Sporty is the one who likes incest, not me

I think the answers is going to bed

 

[supershorty]

can folks plz share thoughts on Santy specifically?

Locktown mason buddy tbh
Unless I’m still here on D5

Then I am going to be very upsetti spaghetti with him

 

[supershorty]

But for now we are masoning

 

[chicandtoughness]

Yes because the things specifically referenced someone who wasn’t here or that someone was missing, so I was interested in those who hadn’t posted very much

Got it, makes sense.

 

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I think it’s a decent thing that Santy didn’t just glom onto the popular SAR town read. He sheeped, which I’m fine with, but he didn’t pretend to participate.

Yeah definitely Ha Ha SAR is so obviously town for sure I mean no kidding DUH

I understand that read not being super clear. It’s very vibe, even if I am reasonably confident about it.

 

[supershorty]

I’m torn here between wanting to say I like night action

for the record though I do actually like getting night actioned because 1 it's more interesting and 2 it helps me solve the game

so y'all stop town reading me and think I'm sussy and then do interesting things

... actually now that I think about it, that's the wrong approach because it's turned out to be a scum tell for me if I DON'T get night actioned
EVERYONE TOWNREAD THE DAYLIGHTS OUT OF ME AND THEN DO INTERESTING THINGS

 

[supershorty]

I got 5 night actions on me one night in Casino, that was a zippy night except I didn't get much time to analyze it before the wolves dayvigged me

 

[Santygrass]

Locktown mason buddy tbh
Unless I’m still here on D5

Then I am going to be very upsetti spaghetti with him

And it would be super epic cuz you would be upsetti with V!me , it would be a super dramatic end.

Scum make it happen dont nk my daughter or myself . Think of the CONTENT that would provide

 

[supershorty]

When you say loud in this particular instance, were you expecting for the role PM to be along the lines of "HEY YOU'RE DYING JUST FYI?"

Some sort of mention that you feel funny or something, yeah. On D0 in particular, yeah.

Zenge hasn't had a game with a D0 death or with a sort of insidious slower-moving thing like I got the vibe this was (with the 3 mod posts that preceded Cyndia dying) so I have nothing to actually base that on. Obviously when I got dayvigged in one of his games, I had no advanced warning, it was just like BLAM UR DED

 

[supershorty]

Scum make it happen dont nk my daughter or myself . Think of the CONTENT that would provide

GIVE ME AND SANTY THE ENDGAME THUNDERDOME I ROBBED MYSELF OF IN S9SF1

 

[JaggedJimmyJay]

I think my SDN town trope has been “okay reads but one wrong green” — if I’ve already fulfilled that trope, please point me to my wrong town read. Please and thanks.

 

[supershorty]

I think my SDN town trope has been “okay reads but one wrong green” — if I’ve already fulfilled that trope, please point me to my wrong town read. Please and thanks.

*points at self*

We're in the universe where I can't be too town or I'm gonna get NKed early and that will be a tragedy for everyone except all the people who don't like reading 20+ pages of thread a day, so obviously I am the sussiest toddler you've ever seen.

 

[supershorty]

that will be a tragedy for everyone except all the people who don't like reading 20+ pages of thread a day

translation: that will be a tragedy for absolutely no one except me, probably.

 

[samac]

So looking at the last two pages (and laughing a bit at realizing cyndia died) specifically at chic. I'm seeing what feels to me like a lot of deflection and ATE. I don't follow the logic of voting the way they are for mayor. First says no food village reads, then votes solely because sheeping AM. It could be just a lot of uncertainty in early game but it does feel a bit more like scum scrambling to find justifications to me. So I'd lean scum on that slot at this time

All the chic sus

 

[JaggedJimmyJay]

We can establish that the mafia are super lame if they immediately kill AM or shorty.

Guess they’ll just have to kill me.

 

[samac]

I'm gonna be honest I gave up around page 22. So here are reads, not ordered within blocks:

Villagey lean: AM, Clem, genny, samac, SAR
Neutral/potential 3p/I'm not sure either way: PSV, Boq, shorty
Sussy lean: dyachei, Dubz, Stagg, JJJ, mkg, mayo
Who are you/I haven't seen enough posts: sheltermed, Veggie, marmot, Dina, Nate

Mostly on vibes. Yeah, I know.


No particular comment, just wanted to highlight this for my reference.

How did I end up in village lean over shorty?

 

[samac]

We can establish that the mafia are super lame if they immediately kill AM or shorty.

Guess they’ll just have to kill me.

I also don’t want to die

 

[Santygrass]

Mafia cant kill shorty, they cant deny the CONTENT.
AM is a Pgo , mafia I tell you thats a bad idea.
So someone protecc JJJ and we are gucci

 

[JaggedJimmyJay]

when I try to advance the page on the bottom and accidentally like shorty dissing my post

 

[supershorty]

when I try to advance the page on the bottom and accidentally like shorty dissing my post

I was wondering about that

 

[Santygrass]

when I try to advance the page on the bottom and accidentally like shorty dissing my post

Skill Issue moment

 

[supershorty]

How did I end up in village lean over shorty?

BECAUSE I'M SUS, SAMAC

 

[samac]

I wish for someone to gift me a gun

*wills it into existence?*

 

[samac]

I'm gonna be honest I gave up around page 22. So here are reads, not ordered within blocks:

Villagey lean: AM, Clem, genny, samac, SAR
Neutral/potential 3p/I'm not sure either way: PSV, Boq, shorty
Sussy lean: dyachei, Dubz, Stagg, JJJ, mkg, mayo
Who are you/I haven't seen enough posts: sheltermed, Veggie, marmot, Dina, Nate

Mostly on vibes. Yeah, I know.


No particular comment, just wanted to highlight this for my reference.

Wait
Again
This feels like I’m reading the same list