- Joined
- Jun 9, 2012
- Messages
- 461
- Reaction score
- 5
Whoo!!! Loved the writeup too, hedgie.
"I'm Shaun." You can't be Shaun. "Fine I lied. I'm really Sally but she's not very nice." Lied again I'm definitely Sally. "Really I'm Tony but he's seriously a villager." Try again FFM. How about you're Greg, the most awful probation worker, which is certainly saying something and the wolf who could seer roles.
Tropic isnot an original wolf. No) idea ig convert or not, but not an original.
Im going to
#### lynch devyn### slight suspicion
Tropic isnot an original wolf. No) idea ig convert or not, but not an original.
Im going to
#### lynch devyn### slight suspicion
I am quite curious as to how you can be sure topic is not an original wolf....
Well crap. I sleep in and wake up to this. It probably won't make a difference now but here's my defense. I went to open house this weekend. It's an 8 hour drive. Drove down Friday, at open house all day Saturday, drove back Sunday. That's why I wasn't so active earlier. Combined with the fact that I am "Gary who sadly has no special powers". I haven't been active at night at all which makes it hard to speculate on things during the day. I'm still not good at jumping on people and speculating during the day.
So there's my defense. But honestly if you lynch me you'll only lose a villager, one who's not familiar with the show. So probably not a bad choice.
Solely based on what Tropic said her Role PM was from Hedgie, and the fact that it was identical to GUH's and mine(except for name, obviously). Even though he's short tempered, the fact that Gary was killed by Tony, makes me believe that Gary would be a villager.
Here's where she said it.
And how the heck do I have the most posts? 😕 Didn't think I had posted THAT much. Not bad while working 70 hr weeks.![]()
Also, what are people's thoughts on #ers of wolves left? Do we think there are originals? Converts?
So you don't know for sure that Tropic is clear. Yes, I know what she said on the thread and for that reason people have backed off, but I also know a lot more about other people in the game, basically we are getting to the end of the game and we are at the point where there is probably only one original wolf left and conversions (if there even is one original left, if dyachei was a wolf that would be 4 originals that we have found so far, which seems about right for this size of game).
I am still filtering through all of the information that I have but I am starting to think that we may be looking for only conversions at this point, that is what I am guessing.
No, that is why I didn't say she was clear, just that she wasn't an original. 👍
Again, you don't know that. You are assuming that, which is fine, but you can't say someone is NOT on original wolf just based on what they post in the thread. Well, you can, if you want, just probably not the best idea.
Tropic was also told that TRH was being blocked N7. Another reason why I do not think she is a wolf.
Not sure how this clears her, unless the wolves could pick and choose who attacks. And this now brings up something else that I am not going to discuss in the thread.
I never said it clears her. Why do you keep thinking I say that she's been cleared? 😕
The night TRH was blocked, there were no kills. IF Tropic was a wolf, I'm sure they would have had someone else do the kill, knowing that TRH was going to be blocked. (assuming they could decide who did the killing each night)
I do not believe that Tropic was a wolf before N8,
Tropic was also told that TRH was being blocked N7. Another reason why I do not think she is a wolf.
I will confirm that I was told TRH was to be blocked that night. I will also say that there is a reason for you to be confused, DVMD. I can't say any more.
Well... the only two people that could have told you they were blocking TRH would be wld or WS... I doubt it was wld based on her posts in the thread prior to that info coming out, which would mean it would be WS... but WS has no role and trusts you because you both had the same role PM... so something does not add up here.
I have had VERY limited communications with all my groups in this game.
Sent from Bob
So, you did not tell tropic that you were blocking TRH on N7? That is what I am guessing this is saying.
That leaves WS... but WS has no role, so what gives? Am I the only one that finds this odd?
So, you did not tell tropic that you were blocking TRH on N7? That is what I am guessing this is saying.
That leaves WS... but WS has no role, so what gives? Am I the only one that finds this odd?
I've already told you I can't tell you any more and you speculating openly on the thread is not helping matters.
Well now actually I've decided not to go down without a fight.
Why does it implicate me that I knew TRH was blocked ahead of time? As WS said, that should if anything help my case, since if I was wolfy and if the game mechanic worked this way I would've tried to get another wolf to make the kill. I know that's a lot of ifs but I still don't see how I'm actually implicated here. Other than the roles not adding up (which there IS an explanation for that is not mine to reveal), what is here that is wolfy? Why can't we go after someone who's been quiet this whole time? Lupin, wldlf?
Well now actually I've decided not to go down without a fight.
Why does it implicate me that I knew TRH was blocked ahead of time? As WS said, that should if anything help my case, since if I was wolfy and if the game mechanic worked this way I would've tried to get another wolf to make the kill. I know that's a lot of ifs but I still don't see how I'm actually implicated here. Other than the roles not adding up (which there IS an explanation for that is not mine to reveal), what is here that is wolfy? Why can't we go after someone who's been quiet this whole time? Lupin, wldlf?
How is my speculating not helping? It is an honest speculation and well-founded. And you simply saying, "I can't say more" does not help. It makes me think there is something to be hidden here. You have said that you have no role at all, so you weren't blocking TRH, WS said the same, so she was not blocking TRH.. there were 4 people in that group that night... 2 of you "without any abilities" and one who has already said she did not tell you that, the only other person was TRH and I know TRH was not blocking herself.
So, I am curious as to how two role-less people were able to say someone was blocked.... 😕
You answered your own question, the roles don't match up. Basically, WS would have had to have been blocking TRH, WS has no role. WS trusts you based simply on the fact that you both have the exact same role PM. So in order for this trust to be founded, WS would have to not have a role. If WS did indeed "block" TRH then she is lying about her role and also lying about how she is able to trust you. Makes sense, right?
I can't say more because I would rather get lynched than lose someone's trust. It's better for the game if I get killed rather than reveal what I know.
Well now actually I've decided not to go down without a fight.
Why does it implicate me that I knew TRH was blocked ahead of time? As WS said, that should if anything help my case, since if I was wolfy and if the game mechanic worked this way I would've tried to get another wolf to make the kill. I know that's a lot of ifs but I still don't see how I'm actually implicated here. Other than the roles not adding up (which there IS an explanation for that is not mine to reveal), what is here that is wolfy? Why can't we go after someone who's been quiet this whole time? Lupin, wldlf?