Official Doctor Who WW Redux Game Thread

Veterinary Science Graduate Programs from U. of I.
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Members do not see this ad.
StartingoverVet said:
That doesn't prove much. Throwing a fellow wolf under the bus.......oldest ploy there is. When I am converted it is what I try to get done right away. Doing it repeatedly.... that is more convincing.... Investigation... even more so.
Click to expand...
Then why don't you look at Allie too? She broke the tie for lupin.
 
TRH, investigating me does nothing to "prove" your ability. Everyone knows what my ability is and that it's now useless. I posted it on thread yesterday.
 
StartingoverVet said:
That doesn't prove much. Throwing a fellow wolf under the bus.......oldest ploy there is. When I am converted it is what I try to get done right away. Doing it repeatedly.... that is more convincing.... Investigation... even more so.
Click to expand...
Not to mention there was a hard core bandwagon for alors. I switched my vote off plurality to make sure she wasn't lynched and gave info on lupin when she wasn't really suspicious. That's pretty extremely for a wolf, IMO.
 
that redhead said:
Then why don't you look at Allie too? She broke the tie for lupin.
Click to expand...

Yeah, allie has not been exonerated yet.

TRH, you aren't the convert we are looking for from before. But last nights "investigation" can't prove you haven't been in the last 2 days. (that was more my point, just took me a while to get there haha)
 
I think I need to explain my ability a little bit more.

I am NOT able to determine if a person still has an ability. My role has nothing to do with assigning roles to people or determining if they still have them.

I can give the mods a character name - any character name. I have to guess half the time unless a name has been stated on the thread, claimed, or given to me. If the character was at ANY point part of the game, they will give me a description of that person's role. My investigation proved that at one point, swings's claimed character was indeed in the game. If she has been converted, there is NO way for me to tel that, because her original character would still "count" as being "part of the game design".

So really, my ability is also a bit useless at this point in time.
 
StartingoverVet said:
BTW, when I read that I was kind of confused. How do you have time to say you looked at it, but not what they were?
Unless there was some reason not to post it on thread that I don't understand
Click to expand...

Because I was typing on my dinky iPAD, which takes forever, and running to a meeting. I didn't have the time or inclination to type every little thing out. Now I'm at my desktop. I told TRH what I found. If you want me to repeat it here, sure. It doesn't really help us.
 
Received a message from the journal last night. I totally understand, and would agree that airing on the side of caution and taking everything that she said with a grain of salt is the best bet. It could be that she's trying to blind-side you too, so be careful.

Okay, after sorting through the posts, we've got a lot of conjecture (which is great!) so let's just sort it out for a minute. It's a confusing read for sure.
1) The Rory issue. Yeah, it makes sense that whoever Rory is isn't human as he's the Last Centurion. Just because he's able to maintain a concious hold over himself doesn't make him magically human again, however; if Rory was human to start, then there could still be room for a conversion and then using the Last Centurion as an excuse for the result. Does anyone know if Rory's participant came back human at some point and then non-human?

2) Boo! Sorry Samoa 🙁 Sad to see you go.

3) Dyachei - wolf or no? I agree with SOV that this should be something that we retain in the back of our minds for tomorrow. It could easily lead us to either one or two more wolves.

4) TRH hasn't given any wolfy vibes in the least and has been striving hard for the villager team. She's either a heck of a strategist, or she's telling the truth. I'm going with the truth until something further comes out.

5) Has anyone else considered the possibility that cuit votes for wolves for lynch every time, knowing that collectively we will avoid lynching that person? That'd be one heck of a cover-up. Pretty sneaky I'd say.

Anyways, there's my two-bits. I'll be seeing Catching Fire this evening so I won't be around for the time of the lynch. I'll send in contingency and I'll check in as best as I can beforehand to see if there's concrete reasoning to lynch someone.
 
WhtsThFrequency said:
I think I need to explain my ability a little bit more.

I am NOT able to determine if a person still has an ability. My role has nothing to do with assigning roles to people or determining if they still have them.

I can give the mods a character name - any character name. I have to guess half the time unless a name has been stated on the thread, claimed, or given to me. If the character was at ANY point part of the game, they will give me a description of that person's role. My investigation proved that at one point, swings's claimed character was indeed in the game. If she has been converted, there is NO way for me to tel that, because her original character would still "count" as being "part of the game design".

So really, my ability is also a bit useless at this point in time.
Click to expand...

Thank you! This makes me feel much better that lynching Swings may be the right choice. If you had "cleared" swings last night, I was going to pull out my hair, haha.
(still have an eye on dyachei, would be a GREAT convert, not just because she's a good wolf, but we all knew who she was the first 2 days and knew she would sonic as non-human no matter what)
 
holy crap I have a lot to catch up on
sorry for being MIA there's a huge storm here and it's messing with the internetz
reading now
 
wolfspeaker said:
I'm willing to let it go one night. Tomorrow, if it happens again, I'm lynching her.

The fact that swings knew she was on the short list last night and she still hasn't PM'd me at all, makes me even more suspicious. I'm lynching her today.
Click to expand...
1) I don't know what you mean by this
2) I'm in my lab finals week and I've been extremely busy so I wasn't able to read through anything last night


wolfspeaker said:
You were on at 10. I seez you.
Click to expand...
I was at school waiting for my test results but my phone wasn't loading the pages so I couldn't read.


Anyway, I honestly don't know why I would show up as non-human. I didn't look up my character so all this Last Centrion stuff is new to me and was not mentioned in my role description, but the people who actually watch the show would know better than I would. Also, samoa getting killed immediately after suspicion was brought up about me from him looks like a total set up imo and those would be some smart cookie wolves.

I have somewhat of a useful role. Lynching me won't get you a wolf.
 
that redhead said:
Huh. Lupin said she was last centurion leading to her role ability which would be more than just somewhat useful.
Click to expand...
I'm confused, Lupin was the centrion? Why was this even brought up being related to my role if it was her's?
 
TRH, when did you say Lupin's PM's changed a bit? Monday afternoon, Swings said she had successfully protected Lupin(said she got "You protect Lupin from any evil doers…" from the mods)
 
Okay, I'm back (gonna be patchy on access for most of this weekend since I'm in NYC but I'll try).

It's true my only role ability is pming, but my character is 100% human and I would welcome someone sonicing me or seering to verify. Only trh knows my actual role name, though I've told two others that I am a companion, and the wolves know that as well (since ec apparently seered me and was able to tell me that much).
 
swingnsave said:
1) I don't know what you mean by this
2) I'm in my lab finals week and I've been extremely busy so I wasn't able to read through anything last night



I was at school waiting for my test results but my phone wasn't loading the pages so I couldn't read.


Anyway, I honestly don't know why I would show up as non-human. I didn't look up my character so all this Last Centrion stuff is new to me and was not mentioned in my role description, but the people who actually watch the show would know better than I would. Also, samoa getting killed immediately after suspicion was brought up about me from him looks like a total set up imo and those would be some smart cookie wolves.

I have somewhat of a useful role. Lynching me won't get you a wolf.
Click to expand...

Why would you not look up your character, when you know nothing of the show?
 
wolfspeaker said:
TRH, when did you say Lupin's PM's changed a bit? Monday afternoon, Swings said she had successfully protected Lupin(said she got "You protect Lupin from any evil doers…" from the mods)
Click to expand...

This was N6. Do we really think the wolves would attempt to kill Lupin and then N7 convert her? Or would it be more likely to have converted swings N3 and Lupin N6?
 
Ugh had the busiest day today. Tried to get caught up really fast.. I think I'm going to lynch cyndia I guess because I think that just being able to PM as your ability would make someone a pretty good convert choice. If she became a wolf I highly doubt the mods would have taken that ability away. And I think I saw that no one has investigated her yet, right?

I also think it's fishy that FF hasn't been posting any votes on the thread- just contingencies...therefore she never really has to give a reason for her lynches...but she was cleared last night so *shrug* it's just a weird playing style to me
 
allieh8607 said:
I also think it's fishy that FF hasn't been posting any votes on the thread- just contingencies...therefore she never really has to give a reason for her lynches...but she was cleared last night so *shrug* it's just a weird playing style to me
Click to expand...

This is only my second contingency, and I sent it in as I wasn't sure if I'd be back to update my vote. The previous one was due to poor internet and I'd rather not get LIS'd. Using a resource that's provided isn't fishy, it's planning ahead. If you look back in the thread, you'll see that I've given reasons for lynching people. You just have to read them.

WhtsThFrequency said:
Right after Lupin went down evidently. But she'd make a great conversion with all the kefuffle surrounding that lynch. Plus the fact cuit keeps voting for her.
Click to expand...

Yeah, that's why I'm finding the whole predicament fishy too.

I'll keep my lynch please. You can take the contingency off mods. Thanks.
 
I have to go torture myself in a client interaction DVD review session, so Rojo will be closing lynch.

3 hrs left!

👽
 
WhtsThFrequency said:
Right after Lupin went down evidently. But she'd make a great conversion with all the kefuffle surrounding that lynch. Plus the fact cuit keeps voting for her.

Hmm

Unlynch SOV. Lynch Alors.
Click to expand...

We KNOW there was a conversion other than Lupin, and it happened BEFORE lupin's lynch. We do not know for sure if there was a conversion after lupin's lynch.
 
allieh8607 said:
Ugh had the busiest day today. Tried to get caught up really fast.. I think I'm going to lynch cyndia I guess because I think that just being able to PM as your ability would make someone a pretty good convert choice. If she became a wolf I highly doubt the mods would have taken that ability away. And I think I saw that no one has investigated her yet,
Click to expand...

True, but no one knew pming was my only ability other than trh (I think I mentioned on the thread that I had a more passive ability but that was it). Also as a still newish player, and without any useful abilities, especially when I'm claiming a human character which is easily checked, I would think I would be a terrible convert choice. Personally I would think wolves would go for someone with a useful ability, or especially a nonhuman character that wouldn't be cleared easily.

Anyways, I don't think swings is it (unless she is pulling a fast one over me in pms) so im not going to vote for her. I havent spoken to alors much recently so not sure on her.. Trh would make a good convert, but I think i still trust her.. I still think dyacheis role is easiest to fake proving, and as a nonhuman would make a good target, so I'm going to *****lynch dyachei******

May waffle of course. This boltbus wifi is so crap, having a hard time reading back through the thread so might have missed something useful that'll change my mind.
 
I believe swings said she used the sonic screwdriver on alors night 1 or 2 and FFM did it fairly recently. lynch swings
 
WhtsThFrequency said:
Right after Lupin went down evidently. But she'd make a great conversion with all the kefuffle surrounding that lynch. Plus the fact cuit keeps voting for her.

Hmm

Unlynch SOV. Lynch Alors.
Click to expand...
Haven't been converted. Still human. I have received 2 items finally! One last night and one for tonight.
 
I think we need to completely ignore cuit's lynch choice. She's been lynching alors for 3 days now. She'll probably vote for her until she dies.
 
Hey @SOV and anyone else that moved, have you noticed any "benefit" of moving that was promised in the description of the Tardis item? Because I haven't.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
Supernatural: Angels & Demons WW Game Thread
121 122 123 124 125
Replies
6K
Views
81K
GoSpursGo
GoSpursGo
WildZoo
Halloween Horrors WW Game Sign Ups [OPEN]
Replies
34
Views
357
GoSpursGo
GoSpursGo
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
66K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
SDN Fairgrounds - 10th Annual Noob WW Game
86 87 88 89 90
Replies
4K
Views
56K
katiemcat
katiemcat
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
48K
chicandtoughness
chicandtoughness
Top