SDN Reactions and Emojis WW Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
### AM ###

She likes to punish others for their playstyle, maybe she should get a taste of that for her self.

The way I was reading, you were making a big deal about your question, so I assumed your question came before that post, but I couldn't remember what it was, and no, being behind I didn't want to scroll up and try to find what was likely one of your vague questions, I figured if it was important you'd be willing to repeat what it was, because if I missed it maybe others had too.

You do this frequently where you are asked a direct question, and instead of just answering, you're snarky in some way. If you could take the time to answer with snarkiness, you could just make things clear for someone without it.

You did this earlier where this gamethread did not specify what the cycle was, it was in another thread and you expected that to have been seen and remembered when really that info belonged here so it was a fair question. Instead of replying with the answer, you were snarky.

Maybe I'm in the wrong this time, but it's something you do constantly.

I generally defend the way you grill people, but sometimes you cross a line.

And yes, I realize it's not a real yeet vote. I don't actually want to give the wolves an opening to push your misyeet, assuming you're village.

But maybe you do need to consider that if you keep up with oblique snarkiness instead of direct answers, enough villagers will have enough of you and vote YOU off the island for play style.
Two posts from hours ago is a big deal now? I have no idea how you came to that conclusion yet missed the question considering one of those two posts contained everything.

I'm starting to wondering if I'm pushing people you don't want me to today.
 
Sorting my reads now

Village leans
Mayo (strong)
AM (but with many ???s about possible mechanics)
WZ (weak)
Schools
TE (weak)

Neutral
Cray (willing to move to village later)
Zenge (nooby)
Kras

Need to read more to get a feel for
SAR
Doggo
Alley

Wolf leans (all are weak feels until I go back to read more)
Dina
Barks
Bread
 
Okay, So I'm not sure who I'm feeling is wolf or not. I really suspected sunshine last night and this morning really blew that out of the water, so now I'm rethinking my entire life.

I can say I have strong villager reads on AM, April, and Doggo.
Other people are mostly neutral or leaning on way or the other, but not really with good reasons. I sort

I don't follow the enigma or bread trains. A lot of it seems to be based on their interactions from previous games mostly which, while maybe relevant for behavior, are not this game.

It's been a busy day, and I don't have a lot of time tonight, but I'm definitely reading the thread and mulling things over. I'll have a better feel for who I'm leaning for wolf soon.
 
Two posts from hours ago is a big deal now? I have no idea how you came to that conclusion yet missed the question considering one of those two posts contained everything.

I'm starting to wondering if I'm pushing people you don't want me to today.
I have no problems with who you're pushing. I'm not particularly sus of mayo, but I see where you're looking on Bread, and that's all I can remember although I know you said who else you were looking at.
 
Okay, So I'm not sure who I'm feeling is wolf or not. I really suspected sunshine last night and this morning really blew that out of the water, so now I'm rethinking my entire life.
Welcome to your first night of WW!

Your whole post is giving me definite nooby villager vibes, making this note here that I should bump you out of neutral to weak village
 
I have no problems with who you're pushing. I'm not particularly sus of mayo, but I see where you're looking on Bread, and that's all I can remember although I know you said who else you were looking at.
How are you reading kras and Dina?
 
Unofficial D2 Yeet Tally
SAR (1) - AM
Zenge (1) - mayo
Enigma (1) - dubz
Bread (1) - Dina
kras (1) - Enigma

5/15
yeet close in ~27 hours
 
Okay, So I'm not sure who I'm feeling is wolf or not. I really suspected sunshine last night and this morning really blew that out of the water, so now I'm rethinking my entire life.

I can say I have strong villager reads on AM, April, and Doggo.
Other people are mostly neutral or leaning on way or the other, but not really with good reasons. I sort

I don't follow the enigma or bread trains. A lot of it seems to be based on their interactions from previous games mostly which, while maybe relevant for behavior, are not this game.

It's been a busy day, and I don't have a lot of time tonight, but I'm definitely reading the thread and mulling things over. I'll have a better feel for who I'm leaning for wolf soon.
I don't see where previous games were mentioned as a source of wolfiness for enigma?
 
How are you reading kras and Dina?
Dina I so far feel fine about. Don't remember why exactly beyond the fact I've found myself following or agreeing with their posts.

Kras, I agree with you I don't particularly love their playstyle. Someone earlier quoted them and made a pretty good case for sketchiness that I found persuasive. So slight wolf lean there.

I have to go run errands but I do want to come back and read more/again to try to pin down my wolf feels and what posts/exchanges led to my opinions. Off the cuff gonna say TE, vetschools. Please, dubz, you, kras, Bread. If I've said others and forgot well this is off my head.

I don't like to specify my village reads as much as I do wolf ones, because I think it draws wolf NK attention needlessly. In that if we all make a literal village list, then if the wolves are lazy tonight or scrambling for a NK they could just say "let's see who's on everyone's village list and kill the one with the most mentions" rather than them having to read closely to glean from *interactions* where the village bloc is. Ask me how I know this (hint when I've wolfed in wolfchat I've relied on village read mentions over analyzing the thread).
 
Fair to say if I don't name someone as wolfy I likely have them neutral/village. I'm sure I've already specified some I'm leaning village (like mayo) like if I'm asked or it comes up. Just saying why I don't strive always spell out who O think is v i l l a g e.
 
Dina I so far feel fine about. Don't remember why exactly beyond the fact I've found myself following or agreeing with their posts.

Kras, I agree with you I don't particularly love their playstyle. Someone earlier quoted them and made a pretty good case for sketchiness that I found persuasive. So slight wolf lean there.

I have to go run errands but I do want to come back and read more/again to try to pin down my wolf feels and what posts/exchanges led to my opinions. Off the cuff gonna say TE, vetschools. Please, dubz, you, kras, Bread. If I've said others and forgot well this is off my head.

I don't like to specify my village reads as much as I do wolf ones, because I think it draws wolf NK attention needlessly. In that if we all make a literal village list, then if the wolves are lazy tonight or scrambling for a NK they could just say "let's see who's on everyone's village list and kill the one with the most mentions" rather than them having to read closely to glean from *interactions* where the village bloc is. Ask me how I know this (hint when I've wolfed in wolfchat I've relied on village read mentions over analyzing the thread).
Disagree on the sharing village reads thing, especially with the uptrend SDN's had in general with better village play. For it to work, you can't only have only one or two people in your village bloc/list. You should have so many that wolves can't possibly kill them all before you win the game. Village stomps are largely due to collectively sharing an insane amount of (accurate) village reads.
 
Village
April - village niceness seems village
mayo - meta feels village
Barks - meta feels village
Doggo - seems to be earnestly wolfhunting

????
Dubz
Cray
AM
Bread - not enough to go on, but less jokiness has a slight woof feel
Zenge - noob sandwich, tbd
SAR - mostly absent so dunno
plz - unsure how much to read into explanations of being sick

Woof
Dina - weak wolf, don't like the vote, don't like the popping in and out with minimal logic
Enigma - I'm not sure I 100% buy the case being built here, but I can see the logic, and the defensiveness
alley - weak wolf, but seems like trying to play a derpclear angle and I'm not sure I buy it
 
I'm thinking I might move SAR to a very weak wolf lean, I understand people are busy but in her ISO half of her posts are fluff so she has the potential to contribute more but isn't
 
I don't see where previous games were mentioned as a source of wolfiness for enigma?
That was more about Bread. Sorry, I should have clarified that a little better.
 
Last night I tried to send Genny the poke in the eye emoji, to be funny, and my night result was that the message didn't get to her. Maybe that doesn't make sense with my theory here. I don't know, I hate when I go to use an ability and the recipient ends up dead I always wonder if the ability backfired somehow.
So to clarify are you saying definitively that your role is Village Emoji Giver?
 
So to clarify are you saying definitely that your role is Village Emoji Giver?
On principle I don't like this sort of questioning and I find it wolfy. But I may be too conservative. Yes, I am village and can give emojis.

You wouldn't happen to be PR hunting, would you?
 
I thought we weren't really supposed to bring up activity from other threads in a gamethread.
He accidentally posted game threads in a different forum. AM isn't trying to call him out or anything, just asking him to move his posts over from what I can gather

@holdthemayo once you get around to moving back over here, what emojis did you receive?
 
Aprilthearab said:
My impression of that role is that they kill anyone who tries to use an action on them so I don't see it completely out of the question if one of the villagers died at the hands of a PGO last night. I mean, would giving an emoji count as an action toward a PGO?

If I'm being honest, I wondered about PGO too. Mostly because one of Lawpy's drunk tinfoils was about a PGO in the last game. I think he likes the role.
 
He accidentally posted game threads in a different forum. AM isn't trying to call him out or anything, just asking him to move his posts over from what I can gather

@holdthemayo once you get around to moving back over here, what emojis did you receive?

I would actually like to hear from the people who sent them what they were.
 
???????????
Dina voted for shorty, which I didn't like
how does that connect with a slight woof read on bread?
I thought you mean Dina's vote today. Does said vote for him affect your reads surrounding the two?
 
Neither of them are posting enough to say

Are you gonna give any reads or just keep demanding them from other people?
I mean, I feel like starting a wagon on someone is pretty significant.

I gave reads hours ago, but nice try. If you want to hear more from Bread/Dina, you gotta engage with them.
 
How are you feeling about doggo and SAR? And who do you put in bread's pack?

doggo is slight village

SAR is overall neutral. Her posts didn't strike me as particularly wolfy though there wasn't a ton of game content in them. However if TE is village then it does move her up into wolfy territory for me. I could see her in a pack with bread based on their voting so either of them flipping would give me a better read.

So if bread is wolf then I could see kras, SAR, possibly Zenge, and probably someone who is currently on my villager list because that's how it works
 
I mean, I feel like starting a wagon on someone is pretty significant.

I gave reads hours ago, but nice try. If you want to hear more from Bread/Dina, you gotta engage with them.
A single vote does not a wagon make. and kinda hard to engage with folks who aren't here.

When? Yesterday? cuz I see no list from you since today started. Maybe instead of being belligerent and spreading your thoughts out across a dozen posts you could actually consolidate if you really wanna help village do anything constructive. Or ya know, just keep being a bully, whatever...
 
Want to look more into Dina because of that oddly defensive reflex she had to yeet me just because I said I hadn't seen her post yet.

I'm just going to post my feels on everyone before I categorize them, bear with me

Dina - Not liking their defensiveness D1 as explained before, wolf lean, but otherwise same as doggo

The reason I yeeted you after you called asked me for thoughts is because I've had past experiences of getting tagged very early game by wolves, so I figured it was a good place to start
 
Not caught up, but the exchange between Barkley and Dubz, makes a lot of sense to me and has me really sus of Bread & TE, and vetschools.

I gotta run, I hope to come back later and dig in more.

Do you guys think that the emojis have significance? Lawper made it sound like some are "good" and some are "bad," do you think there's a mechanism where someone receiving the "wrong" emoji or too many hurts them and explains the deaths?

Not trying to given the wolves more ammo revealing this tinfoil, but maybe it would be good to know.

Last night I tried to send Genny the poke in the eye emoji, to be funny, and my night result was that the message didn't get to her. Maybe that doesn't make sense with my theory here. I don't know, I hate when I go to use an ability and the recipient ends up dead I always wonder if the ability backfired somehow.

Or maybe the way that wolves kill is also by submitting an emoji? So maybe emojis can cancel or add up somehow?

If this is true, then maybe emoji sending could be used to confirm someone is village or wolf, I hope you can follow my thinking on that.

Maybe that wouldn't be baked in for game solving, a little too much like visuals on for Among Us.

Sorry not trying to get lost in mechanics talk, but I can't help but wonder.

If that mechanic was correct, does it seem reasonable for multiple people to get enough emojis to die N1? And I think if you killed genny it would have told you the emoji was received, but if she never even got it, I don't think it would be correct to imply it made an action... But maybe that's just semantics

I could be completely wrong but having hidden mechanics to the emojis just seems like playing with fire if only the mods know what they do. There are also a crap ton of emojis and the mods would have to decide what all of them mean. As usual, I appreciate tinfoils just because they're fun but I don't think it's correct


Drunk Lawpy tinfoil w/ mayo. It's not the number of emojis (unless they all received >3). But some emoji's are good and some are bad. Maybe Certain emoji's cause night kill each night.

*Tinfoil hat off*
 
A single vote does not a wagon make. and kinda hard to engage with folks who aren't here.
That's the exact definition of a wagon actually. Anyone that has, at least, one vote is a wagon. I think you're confusing it bandwagon or counterwagon.

You can tag them. They'll respond eventually if they care about being pro-village and solving the game. Dina is also on now though so break a leg.
When? Yesterday? cuz I see no list from you since today started. Maybe instead of being belligerent and spreading your thoughts out across a dozen posts you could actually consolidate if you really wanna help village do anything constructive. Or ya know, just keep being a bully, whatever...
Literally less than 12 hours ago. If you read from start of day until now, I've been giving leans on everyone.

You can stop picking fights and just read back for yourself because it's wasting posts on something that could be easily already solved. If you want to lurk and troll, that's your prerogative, but if "bullying" is telling people that I've already made reads before you got the chance to yell at me about them, then I can't help you.
 
That's the exact definition of a wagon actually. Anyone that has, at least, one vote is a wagon. I think you're confusing it bandwagon or counterwagon.

You can tag them. They'll respond eventually if they care about being pro-village and solving the game. Dina is also on now though so break a leg.

Literally less than 12 hours ago. If you read from start of day until now, I've been giving leans on everyone.

You can stop picking fights and just read back for yourself because it's wasting posts on something that could be easily already solved. If you want to lurk and troll, that's your prerogative, but if "bullying" is telling people that I've already made reads before you got the chance to yell at me about them, then I can't help you.
And what exactly is so hard about putting all your reads into one post so people don't have to ISO 4 pages to find them all?
 
And what exactly is so hard about putting all your reads into one post so people don't have to ISO 4 pages to find them all?
Don't you have something better to do than pick a fight with me every game and then call me a bully when I respond? Like maybe, talk to your wolf reads you said you've been waiting on? I'm deescalating because even I have limits for how many times you do this in 24 hours. Move on.
 
Don't you have something better to do than pick a fight with me every game and then call me a bully when I respond? Like maybe, talk to your wolf reads you said you've been waiting on? I'm deescalating because even I have limits for how many times you do this in 24 hours. Move on.
The fight picking is hardly one-sided here, and I'm not the only one to point it out, so maybe stop trying on the poor-pitiful-me act.
 
The fight picking is hardly one-sided here, and I'm not the only one to point it out, so maybe stop trying on the poor-pitiful-me act.
This is my last response to any post like this for this game. It's anti-village and pointless.
 
Top