- Joined
- Apr 18, 2013
- Messages
- 73,401
- Reaction score
- 120,538
YesDo you know MJ's as well?
YesDo you know MJ's as well?
It does to me, and pip thought it did tooDid it seem okay?
It does to me, and pip thought it did too
Does it matter? Again, aren't we looking for a convert? Or are you trying to figure out who chaos might be?
I don't see how anything other than chaos could both redirect you and stop a lynch. Those aren't exactly abilities that go together.I'm really hoping there isn't a chaos because then that means end game is closer than I thought. Seeing allie had the same issue I did, I'm starting to worry if a convert would even have the ability to do that.
Alas, everyone is dead or invisible.We begin the night with ToeJam who has been mourning Earl and hating on cows since that gorgeous bovine fell on Earl and squashed him (#SketchMasons #TeamRocket). It seems, through her tears, she did not see (or hear) someone sneak up on her. Instead of a sneak attack, there was a challenge issued, and an epic boss battle began. However, AM didn't have much enthusiasm as she just wanted to have her Earl back and curse bovines. Her final words before she was slashed to pieces were: "Thatcan suck it!" Ded is @Animal Midwife - ToeJam (mason). May you be reunited in the Funkotron afterlife.
![]()
Elsewhere, it seems another bovine has taken to the skies (those poor cows!!!). @LetItSnow looked up just as it landed on his head squishing him. Ded is Liu Kang (vanillager). There were no fireballs or lightning bolts that followed this event, so one can only assume someone took offense at his statements of little bloodshed and bloodthirst on the mod-gods behalf (lotta creative flair....I think....)
![]()
It is Day 9. Lynch deadline is ~9pm Eastern.
****YOU MAY PM YOUR ROSTER FELLOW UNTIL LYNCH DEADLINE!!****
5 players.
Player Roster:
3. @WildZoo
4. @Mad Jack - FOUND!
5. @DVMDream
14. @SportPonies
18. @Teepster87
Character Graveyard:
1.@Crayola227-Pulseman (blocker)
2. @allieh8607 - Raphael/Raph (vanillager)
6. @Jilary - Dr. Ivo “Eggman” Robotnik (WOLF)
7. @Animal Midwife - ToeJam (mason)
8. @Cyndia - Ryu (vanillager)
9. @genny -Dinosaur Hunter from Jurassic Park (item maker)
10. @PippyPony - Ecco (chatterbox/PMer)
11. @vetmedhead - Raiden (ability/name seer)
12. @SnowshoeDog143 - Player #6 (WOLF)
13. @Melchizedek - Earl (mason)
15. @Frozenshades - Myau (even night tracker)
16. @britzen - Shao Kahn (WOLF)
17. @LetItSnow - Liu Kang (vanillager)
TABLE OF CONTENTS:
Game Start - Initial Post
Day 1: Mayor Results
Night 1: Pulseman/Crayola227 Death
Day 2: Shao Kahn/britzen lynched
Night 2: Sonic/DVMD Game Over
Day 3 TIE: Gambit/Teeps Ded
Day 4: Where Snowy/Player #6 + Ryu/Cyndia die but Teeps lives
Night 4: Where no one dies and DVMD lives
Day 5: Where Everyone Lives....STILL!!!
Night 5: Solo Round - Genny vs. Jilary
Day 6: Myau/FS gets lynched for being absentee (aka partying in NYC)
Night 6: Earl/Mel meets death by cow and Raiden/vmh just dies too
Day 7: Where Circling Gets You Nowhere
Night 7: Where Ecco/Piptastic Meets Her Untimely Demise
Day 8: Where We Say Our Final Farewell to Raph/allieh
Day 9: ToeJam/AM's Last Stand + Liu Kang/LIS Gets Cow Crushed
Dvmd, did you get any indication of a dead chat when you died? I didn't, but the does it seem like the day write up yesterday mentions them?
Or am I reading too far into this
I’d better go reread too.... (what did I write...)Yes to dead chat have no clue if they can participate, I was told to leave if I really want back in the game. I'll have to reread the write up.
Ok, so here is where I'm at:
To start, I'm assuming we have a convert (AM said we must, I'll take her word for it, and it makes sense to me), and to be extra cautious I'm assuming we have chaos messing with things since AM and Allie both had weird things happen to them and died village. If the convert is the one doing those things then great, one less thing to worry about, but I'd rather err on the side of caution.
If I'm right our numbers are currently 3:1:1. That means we have to lynch the wolf or chaos today. If we screw up and a villager gets killed overnight, it's 1:1:1 tomorrow and...I honestly don't know what that means. Probably a wolf and chaos win, maybe just chaos.
I think MJ is ok. Take that with as many grains of salt as you like, but his behavior (referring more to PM than on thread) has been classic village MJ. I can't technically rule him out as chaos but...I think that's low likelihood.
Sporty is still my top suspect. I could see her as wolf or chaos. On the off chance she is village and the game is still going tomorrow, teep would be clear. If she's chaos I don't think he is. She easily could have lied about seering him.
So if sporty is village, I think wolf has to be DVMD, and I honestly have no clue who chaos is. If she's chaos, DVMD or teep. Maybe DVMD and teep, one chaos the other wolf.
But I think our best chance today is lynching sporty.
Lynch sporty
Village is in trouble with that line of thinking...Ok, so here is where I'm at:
To start, I'm assuming we have a convert (AM said we must, I'll take her word for it, and it makes sense to me), and to be extra cautious I'm assuming we have chaos messing with things since AM and Allie both had weird things happen to them and died village. If the convert is the one doing those things then great, one less thing to worry about, but I'd rather err on the side of caution.
If I'm right our numbers are currently 3:1:1. That means we have to lynch the wolf or chaos today. If we screw up and a villager gets killed overnight, it's 1:1:1 tomorrow and...I honestly don't know what that means. Probably a wolf and chaos win, maybe just chaos.
I think MJ is ok. Take that with as many grains of salt as you like, but his behavior (referring more to PM than on thread) has been classic village MJ. I can't technically rule him out as chaos but...I think that's low likelihood.
Sporty is still my top suspect. I could see her as wolf or chaos. On the off chance she is village and the game is still going tomorrow, teep would be clear. If she's chaos I don't think he is. She easily could have lied about seering him.
So if sporty is village, I think wolf has to be DVMD, and I honestly have no clue who chaos is. If she's chaos, DVMD or teep. Maybe DVMD and teep, one chaos the other wolf.
But I think our best chance today is lynching sporty.
Lynch sporty
That's the other reason why I feel like it has to be sporty, I have similar reasons for thinking you're likely village.I agree on thinking MJ is ok. Based on the very few PMs he sent me. And because of that and based on what he's stated, I think you're likely village.
I’d better go reread too.... (what did I write...)
Revenge of the Cows
It's not me.I'm going off my rocker here. I dont know when a conversion would have occurred, but my gut is telling me to
lynch WZ
DVMD coming back the same manner that i did makes me think shes not a wolf.
MJ i have as village.
Sporty I'm still reading village. Outting themself as the vig doesn't make sense if they'd been a wolf. There'd be no reason for a woolf to ever bring it up, unless it was a slip up. I don't think this would be the case here because they'd been a bit reserved in making comments, and it's not like it was an off the handle slip up.
if its not WZ then id lean towards DVMD
How do you reconcile the fact that sporty just happened to attack Mel on the night AM was redirected? I know it seems silly that she outted the fact that she had killed him. I haven't quite figured that out either. But something stinks there.
I think you're stretching with that latter part...I don't think sporty ever mentioned the mods reminding her about it that night, and I'm not sure why you would think the mods would do something like that.Honestly, i can't definitively say either, but it could have just been dumb luck. Or (and I'm leaning this way) mods may have been looking for more blood, knew that Mel/AM would be at risk and reminded sporty of the vig kill.
Yeah the circumstances are fishy, but I don't think I'm reading sporty wrong
Mods DID remind me of my cow the day that I used it.Honestly, i can't definitively say either, but it could have just been dumb luck. Or (and I'm leaning this way) mods may have been looking for more blood, knew that Mel/AM would be at risk and reminded sporty of the vig kill.
Yeah the circumstances are fishy, but I don't think I'm reading sporty wrong
I think you're stretching with that latter part...I don't think sporty ever mentioned the mods reminding her about it that night, and I'm not sure why you would think the mods would do something like that.
But in any case if you believe that then I urge you to think through your options a little more closely. If you believe sporty than you should believe that she seered me n1 and I was village. Unless you believe I was converted prior to snowy stealing my ability (I can go into the reasons why that wouldn't make sense if need be), you know what my ability was. I can't be responsible for the weirdness that's been going on![]()
Actually, then I had no reason to lie about my ability at that time and there ya go, you still know what it was.What if you were converted after Snowy stealing your ability?
That doesn't help determine if you're a wolf now, though.Actually, then I had no reason to lie about my ability at that time and there ya go, you still know what it was.
No. I was saying that I can't be the source of the weirdness.That doesn't help determine if you're a wolf now, though.
Forgive me if I don't just take your word for it when you say you're village. I'm just not buying it.Frankly, if there truly are two anti-village left in the game, I'm doubtful one is MJ, so the last two have to be DVMD and you, Dubz.... because I know I'm village, and I know Teep's village.
No. I was saying that I can't be the source of the weirdness.
As far as whether or not I was converted, you can talk to MJ and DVMD about that. I think they'll back me up when I say that there are reasons why it would be pretty damn unlikely that I'm the wolf. And the same holds true for DVMD. It's unlikely that it is MJ for different reasons.
It's fun that you and teep are so sure about each other though. Wonder why that might be.
Forgive me if I don't just take your word for it when you say you're village. I'm just not buying it.
Dude. Look at it from my perspective. You were sketchy as hell about this situation. I know I'm village and I have pretty good reasons to think neither MJ nor DVMD is a wolf. From where I'm standing you're either a wolf or you're chaos, either way you need to go and at that point I can try to figure out how which way you flip affects my feelings on teep.
Perhaps because it puts you in a corner where your only options are to vote for the person you "cleared" or yourself?MJ and DVMD have both stated that they have reasons to believe I'm village. Why are you ignoring that?
The way I see it we've got a few different scenarios
One non-villager left:
Least likely scenario
Had to be someone who started the game with redirecting and lynch cancelling ability. Most likely options here would be one of the rezzes, unless a convert gained these abilities upon conversion. I think that's unlikely, but do with it what you will.
Two non-villagers left:
Two wolves - This would make it a wolf heavy game, but it is a possibility, so I'm including it. Could see it being sporty and teep right now. Teep seems especially too sure of sporty for it to just be based on his read. MJ is unlikely to be a wolf based on game design, so in this scenario he would be village. If he is, then DVMD is clear (not 100% mind you but...enough to not vote there). On the off chance he did come in wolf, it could be him and DVMD pulling one over on me, but I really think that's like...5% probability.
One wolf, one third party - I think this is the most likely situation. Basically anyone could be chaos at this point HOWEVER I don't think it's MJ - the whole point for him was that he was busy, I really don't think kaydubs would have given him a role that was anything other than village. One of the rezzes could easily fit the bill, weird stuff didn't happen until they came back. For me, sporty can't be village, unless she got bad info on teep, because that would only leave DVMD and MJ. DVMD could be third party. But again, I think mostly likely we're looking at sporty and teep here.
Welp, if you three are so sure I'm non-village and there's nothing I can say to convince you otherwise, may as well close the day cycle early, @kaydubs
Unless you'd swing for DVMD as chaos, @Mad Jack