Sherlock WW Official Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Official Vote Tally:

ksmi117 - 4 (DVMD, HOH, SOV, SnS)
SnS - 3 (heylodeb, orcagirl, Jam)
holdonhope - 1 (ksmi)

Deadline is at 8 pm CDT. You have about 4 and a half hours to waffle, unless someone reaches plurality. 🙂
 
LetItSnow said:
Anyone know when the deadline is?

The contingent vote sitting out there is mine for Heylodeb. No reason to hide that anymore.

Now that Dyachei is dead, I have no insider info. And I haven't seen an item this entire game. If someone has the ability to move people, I'd love to take an internal transfer to a busier department. 😉

I'm not convinced on SnS. It doesn't seem as obvious as the Bobba Fett thing (I still can't believe people fell for that....).

But I'm waffling on Heylodeb, too. And Ksmi.

unlynch Heylodeb (contingent)

I'm torn between Ksmi, SnS, and HoH. And Jam.
Click to expand...

Deadline's at 8pm CDT. I trust Jam for now. The role seems to fit. Also it's beneficial to us yarders.
 
Ugh. Getting rid of SnS would mean I have no one to talked to.

Albeit I don't trust her at all right now.

PP did express suspicions to me about her.


Did people ever say when the lynch deadline was?
 
What is everyone's reason for ksmi again?
Bc she was a bomb dignity wolf in SW? I guess I'm not seeing the connection.
 
TigerWillow said:
What is everyone's reason for ksmi again?
Bc she was a bomb dignity wolf in SW? I guess I'm not seeing the connection.
Click to expand...

I am a little suspicious of ksmi because she always votes for me to be lynched (at least three times now) and never gives a real reason.
 
wldlfstdnt said:
I am a little suspicious of ksmi because she always votes for me to be lynched (at least three times now) and never gives a real reason.
Click to expand...

This... right here... I don't know if wld is or is not a wolf but everytime we have had something against someone who was a villager (wildcat, cfc) she voted for them, every other lynch has been wld... It is just weird to me.

Also, read her posts... she has not really been doing any strategizing until she was called out as suspicious..

That is what I have.
 
Sorry I've been voting for people I find suspicious?

My reason for voting for wld is this: Abney died and said "I guess I saw that coming". While we're not supposed to use what dead people say to strategize, I saw that to mean that she probably shared something with her group and that's what got her killed. Heylodeb has been cleared. So it'd be between nohika and wld as to who's the wolf. I think wld is more suspicious.

Philliab and I have discussed this in PMs. I just chose to not strategize a lot in the forum and I never have in games. And I do admittedly fixate on people that I find suspicious. I was convinced that Katie8 was a wolf in the Space WW lounge game and voted for her a few times. And I was a seer in that game.

There's been nothing to clear wld so I don't think it's a big deal that I've voted for her twice (yep, only twice - check your facts, people). I voted for CFC because of the no name thing. I voted for wildcat for the DVM being cray cray thing. I don't think I should be faulted for those. Most people voted for them too. I voted for wld twice. I didn't vote in the abber lynch because I wasn't here. The end.

If you want to be suspicious of me, at least say true things. Kthx.
 
wldlfstdnt said:
I know I am a villager and I do have a role. Also I know you were the one to use the aerosol on me. Thanks for that.
Click to expand...
It is true I used it on you. 👍

And you are welcome. :laugh:

I also used it on krist last night (and Dyachei too... Revenge is sweet Dyachei... suck on THAT!) .....but have since lost it. 🙁

It is a harmless item as far as I can see.
 
****************************************************
1 MORE SPOT IN SPEED WW - feckin sign up please!!!! kthxbai
****************************************************
 
Official Vote Tally:

ksmi117 - 3 (DVMD, HOH, SnS)
SnS - 3 (heylodeb, orcagirl, Jam)
holdonhope - 1 (ksmi)

Tied again? I am extremely entertained at the moment, just so you guys know. :meanie:
 
****
It was a fun itsn! I never had anything like that!

Torn by the Wind anyone?!
****
 
Ivorypolarbear said:
Official Vote Tally:

ksmi117 - 3 (DVMD, HOH, SnS)
SnS - 3 (heylodeb, orcagirl, Jam)
holdonhope - 1 (ksmi)

Tied again? I am extremely entertained at the moment, just so you guys know. :meanie:
Click to expand...


did you ever figure out what would happen in a tie?
 
As for the Abney thing, there literally has been little to no PMing in our group. 😳 A bit the first day, and some today, but most of it strategizing, nothing discussing roles or anything of the like.

I'm leaning towards SnS, but still not sure. Irene is very much her own self in the show, but she does fall in love with Sherlock and he does save her...so...
 
ksmi117 said:
My reason for voting for wld is this: Abney died and said "I guess I saw that coming". While we're not supposed to use what dead people say to strategize, I saw that to mean that she probably shared something with her group and that's what got her killed. Heylodeb has been cleared. So it'd be between nohika and wld as to who's the wolf. I think wld is more suspicious.
Click to expand...


As far as I know Abney didn't share anything with me. I attributed the "I guess I saw that coming" to in the meme thread because I posted things indicating I was frustrated. I think she thought I was mad that she voted for me. I was frustrated because I was silenced.
 
Okay for now I am going to say lynch ksmi. I am not 100% on that, but I am definitely suspicious.

I AM OFF TO VOLUNTEER! Till 6 pm pdt.

I might not (most likely not) be able to check on here.
 
Going with my gut

lynch SNS

I am no wolf. I am DI Gregson.. .I was told to beware of organization members because I have no powers.... seems off that you didn't know much about your role.

I am not going to be feeding info to you any longer!
 
Shrug. You'll find out you made a mistake if you lynch me. There's really not much I can say that I haven't already.



Sorry...distracted by the opening ceremonies...
 
Official Vote Tally:

ksmi117 - 4 (DVMD, HOH, SnS, wldlf)
SnS - 4 (heylodeb, orcagirl, Jam, TW)
holdonhope - 1 (ksmi)

Yep, still a tie and a little over three hours to go.
 
***
Somebody give me the link to the olympics!!!
***
 
Sorry to not post until now, but I had an unsuccessful meeting today with a potential graduate program adviser and have been kind of bummed. 🙁

I'm not really sure why people are voting for ksmi. I have been given no reason to not trust her at this point. She's been very open in PMs and strategy. Have I fully cleared her yet? No, because I haven't had any sort investigatory item. And yes, we did discuss wldlfstdnt (actually it was ksmi, dandy, and I), because her response to being lynched earlier was really strong. So of course we talked about it...and I am keeping an eye on you.

In regards to HoH: she hasn't really been communicating with the rest of us at all, or at least, not with me. I'm not sure if this is normal or not for her, but she's the one I trust the least in our group. Has she done anything that screams wolf to me, not yet. Also, I'm not sure what she was talking about when she said dandy mentioned heylo. I think it was mentioned in a PM, but I don't remember her saying anything specific enough to lynch on. Course I have no clue if dandy and HoH were PMing privately.

Most importantly...I'm suspicious of SnS. She clears PP and then PP dies. Here character is not necessarily a villager role, and she had to ask the mods. I've never had a villager role that required me to double check that I'm an actual villager. I did have a neutral role that I checked up on once, but SnS isn't claiming to be neutral. I'm also not sure it was a coincidence that TW was silenced today.

I do think they're something going on with SnS, heylo, HoH, ksmi. The voting pattern just doesn't add up to me. IPB, can you take a moment from your modding and work out that pattern for me? 😛

For now: lynch SnS

I'll be around to change it if something comes up.
 
Ugh. I've already voted for villagers this game in the lynch... I hate to feel like I might be doing it again.

Guess I'll get on the ...

lynch SnS

... bandwagon.
 
LetItSnow said:
Ugh. I've already voted for villagers this game in the lynch... I hate to feel like I might be doing it again.

Guess I'll get on the ...

lynch SnS

... bandwagon.
Click to expand...

Not just a feeling. Tis the truth 😛
 
I hate bandwagoning because it seems every time I do and it's a villager, some wolf uses it to make me look suspicious - it's happened twice thus far in this game with wildcat and CFC.

It's not my fault CFC didn't read her role PM. Like was said, it sucks to lynch a villager for an honest mistake, but it's worse to not lynch a wolf when they got caught in a lie. Wildcat, yeah, lynching based on DVM's raving was probably a mistake, but it was the first day of lynching and we had nothing else to go on. I like out chances with something to go on over us RNGing a wolf any day.

Any now I'm rambling. My point. I'm not changing my vote because it'll bite me in the ass. That's why I didn't vote for zany because I don't bandwagon just to bandwagon. And you bet your ass the wolves bandwagon on the villager votes when they can.
 
Aww Devyn your team just walked! They looked so happy and bouncy and green.
 
Official Vote Tally:

ksmi117 - 4 (DVMD, HOH, SnS, wldlf)
SnS - 7 (heylodeb, orcagirl, Jam, TW, Philliab, LIS, nohika)
holdonhope - 1 (ksmi)
 
LetItSnow said:
Eh. Maybe. I try to be more careful than that when I'm a wolf... It can be pretty obvious if you throw late votes on villagers OR wolves.
Click to expand...

Not all wolves are that careful. And I'm sure they fluctuate in and out with their bandwagoning. But if SnS isn't a wolf, I'd bet anything that a wolf or two bandwagoned to get her killed and one or two more voted for me to encourage people to vote for me if not this lynch, than the next one.
 
ksmi117 said:
Not all wolves are that careful. And I'm sure they fluctuate in and out with their bandwagoning. But if SnS isn't a wolf, I'd bet anything that a wolf or two bandwagoned to get her killed and one or two more voted for me to encourage people to vote for me if not this lynch, than the next one.
Click to expand...
I think if the wolves are experienced WW players, they would avoid bandwagoning at the last minute...

just my thoughts
 
actually, I can recall not voting at all for the bandwagons in HP...
 
ksmi117 said:
Not all wolves are that careful. And I'm sure they fluctuate in and out with their bandwagoning. But if SnS isn't a wolf, I'd bet anything that a wolf or two bandwagoned to get her killed and one or two more voted for me to encourage people to vote for me if not this lynch, than the next one.
Click to expand...

I'm not entirely positive, but I think you just used 59 words to say nothing.

Anyway, I'm sticking with my SnS lynch vote. I don't feel great about it, but I think it makes as much sense as anything I've heard.
 
It's just a feeling I have. I really hope I didn't mislead anyone. It's really the first time I've felt like I've figured something out in a game.
 
LetItSnow said:
I'm not entirely positive, but I think you just used 59 words to say nothing.

Anyway, I'm sticking with my SnS lynch vote. I don't feel great about it, but I think it makes as much sense as anything I've heard.
Click to expand...

Probably. Hence why I don't post much in these games. When I have no info about other people, I tend to ramble about nothing. 😳
 
Philliab said:
In regards to HoH: she hasn't really been communicating with the rest of us at all, or at least, not with me. I'm not sure if this is normal or not for her, but she's the one I trust the least in our group. Has she done anything that screams wolf to me, not yet. Also, I'm not sure what she was talking about when she said dandy mentioned heylo. I think it was mentioned in a PM, but I don't remember her saying anything specific enough to lynch on. Course I have no clue if dandy and HoH were PMing privately.
Click to expand...

Catching up on the thread and I wanted to respond to this. In pretty much every game I don't really talk privately. The only game I actually responded to pms was during Tortall and I was a wolf. In Mysterious Planet I literally never pmed with anyone. I personally don't really see the point in pming. Everyone talks so much on the thread that when I have to go through and respond to pms too I'm so behind that I don't know what's happening.
 
Plus people lie. If someone's off they'll likely be off on the thread too not just in pms.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
51K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
37K
Clem J
Clem J
WildZoo
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
2 3 4
Replies
159
Views
10K
samac
samac
kaydubs
Melee WW Game Thread-April 2024
27 28 29 30 31
Replies
2K
Views
30K
Sandy Dikson
Sandy Dikson
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mystery WW Signs Ups - Game Start May 25th
2
Replies
79
Views
3K
KayJayQueue
KayJayQueue
Top