The WWalking Dead-Game Thread

[StartingoverVet]

---

Members don't see this ad.

Are you saying he's like DocE or STL where if he doesn't deliver a wolf by d5 we should lynch him?

I am more known for grand schemes than wolf hunting... but I usually get lynched or killed early so if I survive it is usually because I am busy and don’t get noticed.🙂

 

[WildZoo]

I got yelled at for making almost this exact post in my first game on SDN.

That's the difference between me and you 😉

 

[WildZoo]

I am more known for grand schemes than wolf hunting... but I usually get lynched or killed early so if I survive it is usually because I am busy and don’t get noticed.🙂

That post was referring to cheezit. I'm familiar with your style sobsob, wouldn't call you an STL or DocE. You're your own brand 😉

 

[WildZoo]

Unlynch whoever Lynch snowy

 

[Melchizedek]

That post was referring to cheezit. I'm familiar with your style sobsob, wouldn't call you an STL or DocE. You're your own brand 😉

are you...?

...are you trying to pocket me?

 

[WildZoo]

are you...?

...are you trying to pocket me?

Is it working?

 

[WildZoo]

are you...?

...are you trying to pocket me?

Actually I'm just trying to justify lynching you in a few days 😀

 

[Melchizedek]

Is it working?

Spoiler: Huge Picture

 

[WildZoo]

Spoiler: Huge Picture

...I need this

 

[Melchizedek]

Actually I'm just trying to justify lynching you in a few days 😀

Lynch Allie and you won't have to.

 

[JustPaws]

Lynch Allie and you won't have to.

You seem... Very certain
I will
Lynch Allie
But if she's village I'm going to Lynch you next.

 

[WildZoo]

Unlynch snowy Lynch Allie

Lynch Allie and you won't have to.

I dunno, didn't we just discuss your love of bussing

 

[Crayola227]

Just got back from dinner, in car to grocery store, so I'm lost and have no idea where to go.

I'm going to vote

###lynch Mel###

Because I feel like he's doing more to confuse than help. He usually does both any game, but the balance seems towards confuse more than help this game, and the balance is often more telling than the fact he's doing both.

 

[Skimble]

I have to kind of admit, I'm a little annoyed how this lynch is going. I was given crap yesterday for voting allieh because she's an "easy target" now people are voting her and I'm not sure I totally understand the reason. She said something earlier today that made me suspect she was village, though I admit I could totally be wrong.

 

[KCgophervet]

Unlynch snowy
Lynch allie

Have not forgotten Snowy. Willing to see where the allie thing goes though.

 

[JustPaws]

I have to kind of admit, I'm a little annoyed how this lynch is going. I was given crap yesterday for voting allieh because she's an "easy target" now people are voting her and I'm not sure I totally understand the reason. She said something earlier today that made me suspect she was village, though I admit I could totally be wrong.

Yesterday I thought she was an easy lynch, but Mel seems certain and based on allies previous post this am, I'm going for it

 

[allieh8607]

Yesterday I thought she was an easy lynch, but Mel seems certain and based on allies previous post this am, I'm going for it

Which post?

 

[Skimble]

Yesterday I thought she was an easy lynch, but Mel seems certain and based on allies previous post this am, I'm going for it

Which previous post of allieh's has you suspicious?

 

[dpmd]

Yeah, I don't know that I want to join this bandwagon. I was tempted to lynch mel earlier but didn't want to be doing it just because he questioned me. This sudden certainty of his is rubbing me the wrong way though so I will go ahead an do it

lynch mel

 

[Melchizedek]

Because SOV claiming Vanillager, and KC soft claiming Daryl just helps wolves narrow down who they'd like to take out on mere suspicion of abilities. I'm of the opinion that Vanillagers should help keep the smokescreen up and make it confusing for wolves, not make it easier by claiming.

I don't really get where the confusion is coming from regarding role names and role abilities. There are both in this game. I was told someone stared deep into my soul last night so there's at least that, plus people asking for items which to me means that they are either related to another item or an ability.

I didn't shut down collaboration, I shut down willy nilly role/ability revealing. I can see what SOV is saying about this being a vanillager game with rotating items, and therefore talking roles/abilities doesn't matter. However, we've only seen one person flip. While I believe that theory should certainly be on the table I am not apt to put stock in it until I have more data points, and until that theory is proven I think it wise that we stop being callous about revealing.

I'm going to sit back and let people put 2 and 2 and 2 together.

 

[Skimble]

I'm going to sit back and let people put 2 and 2 and 2 together.

I thought of this, but I'm confused why allieh, and not me?

unlynch mel
Lynch allieh

 

[Animal Midwife]

Yeah, I don't know that I want to join this bandwagon. I was tempted to lynch mel earlier but didn't want to be doing it just because he questioned me. This sudden certainty of his is rubbing me the wrong way though so I will go ahead an do it

lynch mel

Why is it rubbing you the wrong way?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Unofficial Day 2 Lynch Tally: Everyone’s Rabies Titers Adequate!?
SOV (1) - Pippy
allie (5) - Melby, Paws, WZ, kc, Skim
Melby (3) - genny, Cray, dpmd
greeney (2) - AM, SOV
Weim () -
Snowy () -
KC (1) - Snowy

12/16
Deadline at 10:30p Eastern (1 hour)

 

[bryndiana.jones]

I think Weimy and Dubz have had some influence on these mods...

I would say we were inspired, there are some elements in this game that are different than the ones Mixy and I have played in the past, we hope you enjoy them!

 

[Melchizedek]

I thought of this, but I'm confused why allieh, and not me?

unlynch mel
Lynch allieh

+1 for skimble trying to get pressure on someone because this smattering of votes is annoying
-1 for skimble because her second part to her reasoning had me going "....what?"

lynch weim because I'm not about to make an 11 way tie and I historically have a hard time reading her

On re-reading I don't like this. It sounds like a wolf pointing out something easily twisted as sketchy to galvanize a lynch, but then choosing to stay on a joke vote to avoid coming under scrutiny the next day.

Lynch Allieh

There was no re-reading involved. These were my thoughts after seeing Weim flip. I phrased it like it was a new thing that just occurred to me because I wanted to watch how people reacted to a vote on Allieh.

 

[JustPaws]

I thought of this, but I'm confused why allieh, and not me?

unlynch mel
Lynch allieh

What? Now I don't understand. Why would Mel being certain and Allie's post lead us to lynch you?

 

[Skimble]

What? Now I don't understand. Why would Mel being certain and Allie's post lead us to lynch you?

Not what I was saying. Mel understood what I meant.

 

[genny]

I'm going to sit back and let people put 2 and 2 and 2 together.

unlynch mel

 

[JustPaws]

Not what I was saying. Mel understood what I meant.

I get it now

 

[WeimMama]

Soooo I didn’t realize I had been rezzed until like 1 minute ago so I’m reading today now. If anyone wants to get me with a readers digesst version holla at me.

 

[Skimble]

Soooo I didn’t realize I had been rezzed until like 1 minute ago so I’m reading today now. If anyone wants to get me with a readers digesst version holla at me.

allieh is a wolf.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Soooo I didn’t realize I had been rezzed until like 1 minute ago so I’m reading today now. If anyone wants to get me with a readers digesst version holla at me.

It's only 4 pages. I think that's digestible in >30 minutes.

 

[dpmd]

Why is it rubbing you the wrong way?

Because he was acting earlier like he wasn't sure about her and then all of a sudden made it sound like he was sure.

 

[Melchizedek]

for those still not getting it:
I am a vanillager, thats why I got grumpy with SOV revealing and letting wolves know there are vanillagers, because:
1. Vanillagers shouldn't reveal and act as wolf-fodder if there are power-roles
2. Now the wolves know there are vanillagers and can claim vanillager.

I believe that SOV's theory RE: vanillagers with rotating items is right because I got a Seering item yesterday. I seered Allie last night because of the hedgey vote while casting suspicion on Skimble. Allieh is a wolf. I waited this long to come out with all this because I wanted to watch voting patterns instead of just letting everyone bandwagon on to Allieh and clamming up with no further discussion.
FOR THE LOVE OF GOD IF YOU HAVE THE SEERING ITEM TODAY/TONIGHT DO NOT CLAIM. (Yes I'm taking a leaf out of SOV's book here and pre-emptively telling people to keep quiet.)

 

[SportPonies]

Massive post time. Quoting as I read, so I apologize if I repeat things that are addressed later on.

Cray bouncing in to drop a single lynch vote and then leaving without any commentary at all is also a little odd to me

On day 1? Doesn't seem that odd to me

Finally, if anyone has any arrows they'd like to pass me I'd be greatly appreciative. I have a feeling this may be an interesting item game.

Likewise

I agree on items. I find it incredulous that my character has no role ability...therefore I assume no one has abilities until I learn otherwise ...ps if you do have a role just shut up...we will find out eventually without you outing yourself,

This made me feel weird, but I've never played with SOV. Just read off to me.

Interesting thought, tin foil hat idea, what if the game starts low on wolves/zombies and the number increases as we lynch? Could be RNG if they rez zombie vs new survivor?

I was wondering this myself.

Mmmmmaybe. The phrasing is vague enough, and I would expect a villager could be more specific about what they want.

I'm not feeling the theory of Pippy making vague question to blend in, just based on my role. But I've been wrong about her before.

No one is standing out to me yet today. Could the real wolves please stand up?

Idk, mom usually has more to say than this

She would be a have to be a convert. Wouldn't you rather look for originals?

I feel like I'm the only person that hates how this argument is brought up every time we have a rez. But I'm gonna say it again anyway. I hate this argument.

I agree that we don't particularly have any suspicions to justify lynching weim right now, but man oh man, I will take a convert down if I think they're wolfy, even if we still have originals left

/steps off soapbox

Prevet: where cute zombie animals are what you look for while playing the walking dead werewolf. I like it here.

Just quoting this because I'm waiting to see if I see more from dpmd

(Almost done catching up, on mobile so it's taking a bit)

 

[Animal Midwife]

Because he was acting earlier like he wasn't sure about her and then all of a sudden made it sound like he was sure.

Isn't that interesting to you so early in the game though?

 

[Animal Midwife]

for those still not getting it:
I am a vanillager, thats why I got grumpy with SOV revealing and letting wolves know there are vanillagers, because:
1. Vanillagers shouldn't reveal and act as wolf-fodder if there are power-roles
2. Now the wolves know there are vanillagers and can claim vanillager.

I believe that SOV's theory RE: vanillagers with rotating items is right because I got a Seering item yesterday. I seered Allie last night because of the hedgey vote while casting suspicion on Skimble. Allieh is a wolf. I waited this long to come out with all this because I wanted to watch voting patterns instead of just letting everyone bandwagon on to Allieh and clamming up with no further discussion.
FOR THE LOVE OF GOD IF YOU HAVE THE SEERING ITEM TODAY/TONIGHT DO NOT CLAIM. (Yes I'm taking a leaf out of SOV's book here and pre-emptively telling people to keep quiet.)

I appreciate this. It's the best usage of information.

 

[allieh8607]

allieh is a wolf.

Incorrect.. I'm the Governor and I can make a kill attempt some time during the game if I have bullets for my gun, which I do not.

 

[dpmd]

Because he was acting earlier like he wasn't sure about her and then all of a sudden made it sound like he was sure.

Which he is now saying was on purpose (though how that ties into questioning me about my vote I don't see)?

 

[Crayola227]

But if that is the case here and everyone we lynch/any wolf kills end up as zombies we are rapidly going to be overrun with zombies so there must be an aspect we are missing.

This is basically what I've been saying all along, but I'm not good at using few words or making sense.

This game is likely like the show, the real fight isn't against the zombies, the whole planet is basically zombies. Anyone the village or the wolves kill, likely turn into zombies. We should focus elsewhere.

 

[JustPaws]

for those still not getting it:
I am a vanillager, thats why I got grumpy with SOV revealing and letting wolves know there are vanillagers, because:
1. Vanillagers shouldn't reveal and act as wolf-fodder if there are power-roles
2. Now the wolves know there are vanillagers and can claim vanillager.

I believe that SOV's theory RE: vanillagers with rotating items is right because I got a Seering item yesterday. I seered Allie last night because of the hedgey vote while casting suspicion on Skimble. Allieh is a wolf. I waited this long to come out with all this because I wanted to watch voting patterns instead of just letting everyone bandwagon on to Allieh and clamming up with no further discussion.
FOR THE LOVE OF GOD IF YOU HAVE THE SEERING ITEM TODAY/TONIGHT DO NOT CLAIM. (Yes I'm taking a leaf out of SOV's book here and pre-emptively telling people to keep quiet.)

Incorrect.. I'm the Governor and I can make a kill attempt some time during the game if I have bullets for my gun, which I do not.

Mel what were your results that made you think wolf?

 

[WildZoo]

...I know I talk about being bad at picking up subtlety but like...come on guys. People don't usually specifically tell others to lynch someone d2 for no reason.

for those still not getting it:
I am a vanillager, thats why I got grumpy with SOV revealing and letting wolves know there are vanillagers, because:
1. Vanillagers shouldn't reveal and act as wolf-fodder if there are power-roles
2. Now the wolves know there are vanillagers and can claim vanillager.

I believe that SOV's theory RE: vanillagers with rotating items is right because I got a Seering item yesterday. I seered Allie last night because of the hedgey vote while casting suspicion on Skimble. Allieh is a wolf. I waited this long to come out with all this because I wanted to watch voting patterns instead of just letting everyone bandwagon on to Allieh and clamming up with no further discussion.
FOR THE LOVE OF GOD IF YOU HAVE THE SEERING ITEM TODAY/TONIGHT DO NOT CLAIM. (Yes I'm taking a leaf out of SOV's book here and pre-emptively telling people to keep quiet.)

Just to clarify, this was def an affiliation seering item, yes?

 

[Crayola227]

I'm going to sit back and let people put 2 and 2 and 2 together.

um, or if it's obvious to the point you're going to quote and then tell us it's obvious, can you just tell us? I feel like I'm missing something here

 

[Melchizedek]

Copy and paste from mod PM Mixy said:

Allie is a wolf.

waiting to hear from Mods if quoting mod PM is allowed in this game cuz I didn't see it in the rules.

 

[Crayola227]

There was no re-reading involved. These were my thoughts after seeing Weim flip. I phrased it like it was a new thing that just occurred to me because I wanted to watch how people reacted to a vote on Allieh.

OK, this is one of those little plot things you do that make no sense to me.

 

[allieh8607]

for those still not getting it:
I am a vanillager, thats why I got grumpy with SOV revealing and letting wolves know there are vanillagers, because:
1. Vanillagers shouldn't reveal and act as wolf-fodder if there are power-roles
2. Now the wolves know there are vanillagers and can claim vanillager.

I believe that SOV's theory RE: vanillagers with rotating items is right because I got a Seering item yesterday. I seered Allie last night because of the hedgey vote while casting suspicion on Skimble. Allieh is a wolf. I waited this long to come out with all this because I wanted to watch voting patterns instead of just letting everyone bandwagon on to Allieh and clamming up with no further discussion.
FOR THE LOVE OF GOD IF YOU HAVE THE SEERING ITEM TODAY/TONIGHT DO NOT CLAIM. (Yes I'm taking a leaf out of SOV's book here and pre-emptively telling people to keep quiet.)

Ok wolf seer, glad you guys are so concerned with my one time kill that you felt the need to come up with this item plot despite others blatantly asking for weapon ammo as well. What was the name of the item? It's awfully convenient that the person who has the item tonight cannot even corroborate the item because duh...they'd be dead meat.

 

[Crayola227]

Copy and paste from mod PM Mixy said:

Allie is a wolf.

waiting to hear from Mods if quoting mod PM is allowed in this game cuz I didn't see it in the rules.

OK, posted before I saw this. Makes it pretty clear.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Ya know... this situation feel familiar...

 

[dpmd]

Isn't that interesting to you so early in the game though?

Before he claimed the seering, no because he could play things off whichever outcome he had (allie as wolf or not wolf). I didn't see it as too risky a thing for a wolf to do.

 

[WildZoo]

I appreciate this. It's the best usage of information.

Wow why u no compliment me like this when I did the same thing with my info on pippy last game