The WWatering Hole Bar Grand Opening - Game Thread.

[WildZoo]

---

Members don't see this ad.

How do you know it is her abiltiy? it could be someone elses? And even if it is her ability, she did have the most votes so we might have a dead villager on our hands anyways. What was I suppose to say? Nothing?

If she is a villager, which you believe she is, outting her ability without her permission (and basically going against what she wanted) is not a village move. It doesn't necessarily tell me anything about Genny, though I have been PMing with her and I feel a little better about her based on that and PBC's input. But it does make me side eye you more.

 

[genny]

That’s another wolf point for you.

I'ma add it to my collection. Someday I'll have enough to redeem for a secret decoder ring.

 

[PrincessButterCup]

So to clear things up: I was blocked (or jailed couldn't tell) last night. Could have been genny could have been someone who saw her post that and tried to mess things up.

Were you protected as well as blocked? If you were only blocked, I don't see how that would have affected anyone else's action on you, it would only prevent you from performing any actions yourself.

How do you know it is her abiltiy? it could be someone elses? And even if it is her ability, she did have the most votes so we might have a dead villager on our hands anyways. What was I suppose to say? Nothing?

For clarity: one thing happened to you last night, and that was being jailed/blocked. So here you're saying that either

- Genny announced she was going to act on you, and then didn't, thus that's not her ability, or
- someone else had devious plans to mess with Genny and that was their ability (which doesn't make sense unless you were also protected)?

Your response to this is strange.

 

[WildZoo]

Earlier you kinda implied that Snowy knowing genny's ability didn't clear genny. But now it seems like you think it maybe does?

The unlynch was unrelated to the thoughts that followed (see above). I don't in any way think snowy knowing genny's ability clears genny.

 

[DVMDream]

Since I have a dearth of posts, thereby making me suspicious, you must be ultra-safe since you have made 97 posts so far.

Um, that's not what I said and this post claiming that's what I'm implying is making me read you more wolf.

 

[SummerTheLynx]

Here's the issue I have with today, everyone has piled on genny early. Yes there were lots of reasons to go for genny, and I think it is a decent vote even though she is sketch balls always, but at least allow other people to accumulate a bit of votes (without a guaranteed wolf) to allow some back and forth discussions, defending, etc.) now we are at a point where everyone feels safe, so any votes on them don't really matter

 

[PippyPony]

Here's the issue I have with today, everyone has piled on genny early. Yes there were lots of reasons to go for genny, and I think it is a decent vote even though she is sketch balls always, but at least allow other people to accumulate a bit of votes (without a guaranteed wolf) to allow some back and forth discussions, defending, etc.) now we are at a point where everyone feels safe, so any votes on them don't really matter

Psssh "everyone"

 

[SummerTheLynx]

Psssh "everyone"

The royal everyone

 

[DVMDream]

Here's the issue I have with today, everyone has piled on genny early. Yes there were lots of reasons to go for genny, and I think it is a decent vote even though she is sketch balls always, but at least allow other people to accumulate a bit of votes (without a guaranteed wolf) to allow some back and forth discussions, defending, etc.) now we are at a point where everyone feels safe, so any votes on them don't really matter

I don't agree. I think AM's count is off and the voting is much closer than you realize. Also, only half of the players have really voted thus far, IIRC... so plenty of opportunities for discussion. And I don't think I've seen this thread go dead yet today, though wasn't here earlier but since I've been around there's been posting and talking. I mean we could always do the one vote for each player then stonewall each other until someone cracks.

 

[WildZoo]

Snowy did NOT say it sounded village, she said it could go either way. That’s another wolf point for you.

Ehhh she said:

Also if genny used her ability on me, not to give her ability away but if it's what I think it could be either affiliation but I think it's usually a village ability

Which is hedgey, but comes down as "I think it's village" in my opinion

 

[WildZoo]

Here's the issue I have with today, everyone has piled on genny early. Yes there were lots of reasons to go for genny, and I think it is a decent vote even though she is sketch balls always, but at least allow other people to accumulate a bit of votes (without a guaranteed wolf) to allow some back and forth discussions, defending, etc.) now we are at a point where everyone feels safe, so any votes on them don't really matter

No one should ever feel safe with anything more than 2 minutes left in the lynch...and even then it's iffy

 

[rabbott1971]

The Genny lynch seemed like a "throw it out there Day 1 and see what happens" thing that never had any good grounds but just wouldn't die. Suspicions on Snow sound more rational, my vote leans that way.

Um, that's not what I said and this post claiming that's what I'm implying is making me read you more wolf.

Pffft.

 

[Skimble]

It's a soccer reference - warning (yellow card) vs. being ejected from the game (red card)

Oh, I saw it as a Johnny Carson reference with the envelope, like a clairvoyant? I’ve rarely watched soccer.

 

[SummerTheLynx]

I don't agree. I think AM's count is off and the voting is much closer than you realize. Also, only half of the players have really voted thus far, IIRC... so plenty of opportunities for discussion. And I don't think I've seen this thread go dead yet today, though wasn't here earlier but since I've been around there's been posting and talking. I mean we could always do the one vote for each player then stonewall each other until someone cracks.

First, @Animal Midwife shota fired. Second, doesn't vote end in 4 minutes, or am I an hour off? It hasn't gone dead, but a lot of it hasn't been very serious discussions because the majority f players haven't really shown up (or did one post and peaced out). I am not saying one vote for each person, but at least allow 2 or 3 candidates to duke it out and see how they react

 

[PippyPony]

I'ma add it to my collection. Someday I'll have enough to redeem for a secret decoder ring.

^why I have a hard time voting for genny even when she's sketchy af lol

 

[Skimble]

Ehhh she said:

Which is hedgey, but comes down as "I think it's village" in my opinion

But she said it could go either way, which genny conveniently left out.

 

[WildZoo]

First, @Animal Midwife shota fired. Second, doesn't vote end in 4 minutes, or am I an hour off? It hasn't gone dead, but a lot of it hasn't been very serious discussions because the majority f players haven't really shown up (or did one post and peaced out). I am not saying one vote for each person, but at least allow 2 or 3 candidates to duke it out and see how they react

You're an hour off

 

[rabbott1971]

Second, doesn't vote end in 4 minutes, or am I an hour off?

Think there's still an hour or two.

 

[Animal Midwife]

I think AM's count is off is always on point and a thankless job.

 

[Skimble]

That was never actually a thing. I use emojis all the time. 🙂😉🙁😡😕😎😛😀😱😳🙄😵👽🤐☕😢😊😍🤢😴😏🤔🙈👍👎😍:troll:😏😆🤣

There, now I can say I’ve honestly used every sdn emoji. Also, what is the difference between and , like what do the red and yellow cards mean?

Snowy did NOT say it sounded village, she said it could go either way. That’s another wolf point for you.

Do you guys have any idea how long that took to do on my phone (while well hydrated on margaritas)?!

 

[DVMDream]

First, @Animal Midwife shota fired. Second, doesn't vote end in 4 minutes, or am I an hour off? It hasn't gone dead, but a lot of it hasn't been very serious discussions because the majority f players haven't really shown up (or did one post and peaced out). I am not saying one vote for each person, but at least allow 2 or 3 candidates to duke it out and see how they react

You are off by an hour.

And, where have you been then? Why call out a lack of participation or voting for multiple people when you really aren't present either. You do this and it is annoying.

 

[WildZoo]

Lynch snowy

 

[Animal Midwife]

***********************************
The Dead's Unofficial Lynch Tally

genny (6) - LIS, finn, Jil, Kam, allieh, DVMD
STL (1) - Ceke
Cyndia (1) - STL
allieh (2) - raf, Snowy
Ski (1) - Pippy
LOTF (1) - Ski
finn (1) - genny
Snowy (3) - PBC, Crayola, WZ
Ceke (1) - britzen

17/22
lynch close in 53 minutes
***********************************

 

[DVMDream]

And I'm going to stick with the genny vote, for reasons stated earlier.... if not lynched today, she'll be back up tomorrow and the next day and the next....at this point egg that needs to be cracked.

 

[SummerTheLynx]

You are off by an hour.

And, where have you been then? Why call out a lack of participation or voting for multiple people when you really aren't present either. You do this and it is annoying.

I have been on all day, feel free to go back and look through the posts, I probably have the most posts from today

 

[DVMDream]

I have been on all day, feel free to go back and look through the posts, I probably have the most posts from today

There's about an hour plus of when I got home and started posting and you posting your rant about people not being around. You definitely have not been here all day, not that I expect you or anyone else to.

 

[Skimble]

And I'm going to stick with the genny vote, for reasons stated earlier.... if not lynched today, she'll be back up tomorrow and the next day and the next....at this point egg that needs to be cracked.

I’m not usually big on the “cracking egg” thing, but I agree, this is probably an egg that needs to be cracked sooner rather than later as it’s a huge distraction at this point.

 

[DVMDream]

There's about an hour plus of when I got home and started posting and you posting your rant about people not being around. You definitely have not been here all day, not that I expect you or anyone else to.

4 hour gap to be exact which is when I was mostly posting and you (meaning STL since I'm quoting myself) weren't around. Again, don't expect you to be, but you make this rant regularly whether you are or aren't contributing, just drives me batty.

 

[genny]

unlynch finn
lynch snowy

 

[PippyPony]

No one else is curious about why genny would use a blocking ability on snowy if she was feeling like snowy was village? Cool.

(If it was protect/block, then sure, that'd make more sense, but...it sounds like that part is not clear?)

 

[TheGirlWithTheFernTattoo]

Just got back online, sorry for delay but I had some fam make an unexpected appearance after work this morning. Just happy I didn't miss lynch close.

Skimmed and I think I'm going to go for lynch Genny because her attitude around the lynch swap last night was weird. However, I do not think switching like that on its own was sketchy. Does she have a posting restriction? It's been a while since I've played but her posts seem much. Will cover more in my next few posts.

Now I'm going back and quoting/sharing thoughts. Be prepared for a lot of word vomit since I have 12 pages to go through...

 

[Animal Midwife]

***********************************
The Dead's Unofficial Lynch Tally

genny (7) - LIS, finn, Jil, Kam, allieh, DVMD, Fern
STL (1) - Ceke
Cyndia (1) - STL
allieh (2) - raf, Snowy
Ski (1) - Pippy
LOTF (1) - Ski
finn () -
Snowy (4) - PBC, Crayola, WZ, genny
Ceke (1) - britzen

18/22
lynch close in 30 minutes
***********************************

 

[Melchizedek]

AM’s count is correct
Modding from my phone official Lynch Tally

genny (7) - LIS, finn, Jil, Kam, allieh, DVMD, Fern
STL (1) - Ceke
Cyndia (1) - STL
allieh (2) - raf, Snowy
Ski (1) - Pippy
LOTF (1) - Ski
finn () -
Snowy (4) - PBC, Crayola, WZ, genny
Ceke (1) - britzen

18/22
lynch close in 30 mins

 

[genny]

No one else is curious about why genny would use a blocking ability on snowy if she was feeling like snowy was village? Cool.

(If it was protect/block, then sure, that'd make more sense, but...it sounds like that part is not clear?)

It was protect/block. Duh. Let's just get it all out there because I'm going to get lynched anyway. You'll see in about 30 minutes.

 

[Trilt]

15 minutes remaining

 

[PippyPony]

And I'm going to stick with the genny vote, for reasons stated earlier.... if not lynched today, she'll be back up tomorrow and the next day and the next....at this point egg that needs to be cracked.

I’m not usually big on the “cracking egg” thing, but I agree, this is probably an egg that needs to be cracked sooner rather than later as it’s a huge distraction at this point.

She claimed a power role that is going to be somewhat crippled in its functionality if she is a wolf. What if she's village? You wouldn't prefer to let wolves deal with her?

 

[genny]

 

[rabbott1971]

Lynch SnowshoeDog

 

[Animal Midwife]

***********************************
The Dead's Unofficial Lynch Tally

genny (7) - LIS, finn, Jil, Kam, allieh, DVMD, Fern
STL (1) - Ceke
Cyndia (1) - STL
allieh (2) - raf, Snowy
Ski (1) - Pippy
LOTF (1) - Ski
finn () -
Snowy (5) - PBC, Crayola, WZ, genny, rabbott
Ceke (1) - britzen

19/22
lynch close in 9 minutes
***********************************

 

[Skimble]

She claimed a power role that is going to be somewhat crippled in its functionality if she is a wolf. What if she's village? You wouldn't prefer to let wolves deal with her?

As long as she’s a top suspect, wolves won’t deal with her. So we can either lynch her and get info, or we can out out seer. I’d rather lynch her and be done with it at this point.

 

[SkiOtter]

Where tf is cake?! Supposedly it's 12:20 pm (aka middle of the day) in south australia, where her sdn says she's from.

 

[Crayola227]

If genny flips village I'll definitely be looking more closely at those who voted her, especially those leading the lynch. Some already seem sketch to me now.

I feel like the genny lynch was an easy bandwagon to start & hide behind.

 

[PippyPony]

As long as she’s a top suspect, wolves won’t deal with her. So we can either lynch her and get info, or we can out out seer. I’d rather lynch her and be done with it at this point.

Ok but what you're implying there is that you think there's a decent chance she is a village power role who is not going to get night killed if she remains under suspicion. You would rather lynch that for info than keep the ability in the game?

 

[Crayola227]

Where tf is cake?! Supposedly it's 12:20 pm (aka middle of the day) in south australia, where her sdn says she's from.

Her hours are pretty irregular, even accounting for her location.

 

[Melchizedek]

~ 5 MINUTES TIL LYNCH CLOSE ~

 

[PippyPony]

Crayola, you realize you are liking contradictory posts, yes?

 

[Melchizedek]

~LYNCH CLOSED~
Final Lynch Tally

genny (7) - LIS, finn, Jil, Kam, allieh, DVMD, Fern
STL (1) - Ceke
Cyndia (1) - STL
allieh (2) - raf, Snowy
Ski (1) - Pippy
LOTF (1) - Ski
finn () -
Snowy (5) - PBC, Crayola, WZ, genny, rabbott
Ceke (1) - britzen

19/22

 

[WildZoo]

Crayola, you realize you are liking contradictory posts, yes?

She does that every game

 

[finnickthedog]

Crayola, you realize you are liking contradictory posts, yes?

Crayola likes everything. It's refreshing, because I hate everything.

 

[SkiOtter]

Her hours are pretty irregular, even accounting for her location.

But still.... It's been 14 hours since she posted her contingency for STL. Which if I'm mathing correctly (though I'm not entirely sure I actually am) she put in her contingency at ~11:30 pm last night her time. So 14 hours later you would think she would have risen from the dead at some point