There's a WW in Michigan Game Thread

Veterinary Science Graduate Programs from U. of I.
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Members do not see this ad.
kcoughli said:
Are you able to pm with FTB? On my phone so not super easy to check roster. I'm just surprised you're going to bat for her so strongly based on one? post.

If she's chatting with you via pm and you think shes not wolfy based on that, at least that's something.

From the information available on thread though I find it pretty suspicious to vouch so strongly for someone based on so little. Options are a wolf who knows FTB is village and is trying to buy cred for herself when FTB flips that way, a wolf trying to save another wolf who's absent and not able to defend, or mason villager.

The majority of those options aren't great, so I'm actually considering switching to you.

I would like to hear from the players who haven't shown up or who have been minimally participating.

Sent from my [device_name] using SDN mobile
Click to expand...

Why the mention of mason?
 
Melchizedek said:
This slipped right past me until I read Dy's post calling it out. I called Dy alarmist and aggressive but I have never played with her before so I can't really speak to Dy's typical volume of posts or "a lot of talk for Day 1" and looking back at my posts I'm having trouble where you think I implied as such.
This bothers me because the rest of your logic I actually really like and was following well 🤔
Click to expand...
I read it as being overly talkative, but I may have misinterpreted it because I was reading her as being too vocal for how I remembered Dy playing. I also hadn't realized she hadn't played here in so long so just assumed you'd played with her before and were seeing what I was seeing.

Sent from my [device_name] using SDN mobile
 
johnnaboo said:
Unlynch Jilary

Lynch kcough

I can't really wrap my head around why kcough deflected. And those who are pointing fingers at others and citing nit-picky things seems like grasping at straws to me.
Click to expand...
Please elaborate. What did I deflect? I've been trying to hunt down inconsistencies in what people are saying or claiming I've been saying.

Sent from my [device_name] using SDN mobile
 
Ok. I knew that post would do this.
I am village. I know I haven’t played in a while but do the old timers really think I would post to post as wolf? I prefer to lurk or drive lynches.

Idk y’all. I should not be posting at 2am.

To save my booty.
***lynch Pippy***
And I am about to listen to loud rock music and get laid so I won’t be back to defend myself/don’t have anything better to say.

Oh, and I’m in Duluth! Yah sure you betcha!


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
 
Unofficial Day 1 Lynch Tally
kc (1) - Cray
DVMD (1) - Sporty
Coop (2) - AM, SoFlo
Kara () -
AM () -
vmh (1) - Coop
greeney (2) - Fern, Kara
Fern (2) - vmh, genny
Pippy (3) - staffy, dy, FTB
3m (1) - Snowy
Jil (1) - jboo
Teep (1) - allie
SoFlo (1) - kata
dy () -
allie (1) - lyra
Cray (1) - cowgirl
Sporty (2) - 3m, DVMD
FTB (3) - Pippy, kc, Paws

23/28
lynch close in 2 hours
 
kcoughli said:
Please elaborate. What did I deflect? I've been trying to hunt down inconsistencies in what people are saying or claiming I've been saying.
Click to expand...

Crayola227 said:
In trying to paraphrase you in listing all the names in the "face off" I added in my comments in /backslash/ as my own joking commentary on it, to explain that I may not be getting all the names involved right, because per your own post there's like 4 people. I should have been clearer that was my own editorializing of the sitch and not yours.

I still find the statement "weird that dy pointed out Pip's subtle backing of staff but not allie's blatant backing of greeny" to be the statement that set me off.

Now that we've raised one another's hackles,

lynch kcough

Because I still find what I feel like is nitpicking this way.... sorta forced and more wolfy than villagery. I could be wrong. I'm willing to back off if anyone in the queersome 4some or anyone commenting on them, starts to seem more off.
Click to expand...

kcoughli said:
I'm tempted to switch to you right now but don't want to get to retaliatory and see bad intentions just because of bias.
Click to expand...

kcoughli said:
This is reading so very much like "wolf trying to be helpful but not actually contributing anything useful".

Yeah I gotta go here

###unlynch dy###
###Lynch FTB###
Click to expand...

This whole exchange just rubbed me the wrong way.
 
Crayola227 said:
TLDR upfront:
36 hours no sleep. Miss the obvious on my best days.

Long version:
I did just say, "oops, mistake," about the lynch vote wording mistake. The rest of the "defensiveness" was me actually responding to someone about players interacting in the game. For all that I'm reactionary and inflammatory, I'm really starting to feel that KC is misunderstanding not only me but others as well, to a point that I can't figure.

Honestly, I didn't get into the nitty gritty detail of the crazy jumble in my brain (can you believe it? I'm holding back...). I read Finn's mod post and something about the wording and example of the rule on how to place a lynch vote made me go, "Cool, I can save typing a word! Bold name should do it, not sure what +/- "lynch" adds. And to think, all those times we're typing "lynch" it's just for good measure! I wonder why everyone does that when you can...."

I'm going on 36 hours no sleep right now, and if you checked my posts, you'd see that was so. So that was a great "lightbulb" moment.

Lol, why would I purposefully do that as a wolf? So the answer is honest mistake of course, and I think it's silly to think such a slip is a good data point on affiliation. I mean, I get looking for anything out of the ordinary... but common sense, please.
Click to expand...
I appreciate the explanation.

The KC vs. dy stuff feels like villagers misunderstanding each other to me. I'm also not thrilled about FTB being in the lead (at least as of the last tally) since she (?) hasn't played in quite some time and hasn't been on to defend herself that I've seen.
 
kcoughli said:
Anyone want to check roster and figure out who hasn't checked in yet?

I could be persuaded to switch to an inactive, this has been a really long day cycle to not have checked in at all yet...

Sent from my [device_name] using SDN mobile
Click to expand...

I think allie and Teep are the only ones. Others have posted, but not lynched.
 
johnnaboo said:
I just mean that people dissecting each other's vernacular to look for wolf tactics doesn't make much sense to me. I think reading in between the lines so to speak is a better way of figuring out someone's behavior. But that's just me.
Click to expand...

Actually looking at what people say is exactly how to find wolves. I find it odd that you see that as nit-picking. That is typically how wolves are sussed out and found. Not to mention it is Day 1, very little to go off of.
 
SoFloGryffindor said:
And why would i tell you my reasons?
Click to expand...
Because the game's pretty boring if you just vote for people without explaining why you think they're sketchy? Unless you actually know something that you don't want to put out on the thread, it's more helpful for the village to reason through things together. If it's a random D1 vote, just say so.
 
johnnaboo said:
This whole exchange just rubbed me the wrong way.
Click to expand...
One part was an exchange with Crayola. When I'm a villager, I tend to read people who think I'm sketch as sketchy (because what innocent villager would see me as sketch, it must be a woof plot against me!). I know this about myself so I try to give people who think I'm sketch the benefit of the doubt, because I'm often wrong as a villager too. But it's hard to not read into what they're saying too much.

The last part you quoted wasn't related to anything I'd said before. The post from FTB just set off all my Spidey senses and was enough to convince me to switch that way.

Sent from my [device_name] using SDN mobile
 
LyraGardenia said:
Allie has posted. On my phone so too lazy to quote, but she made that post along the lines of "that seems normal for greeney, but not that I'm defending her."
Click to expand...

Okay, guess it is just T e e p then.
 
DVMDream said:
Actually looking at what people say is exactly how to find wolves. I find it odd that you see that as nit-picking. That is typically how wolves are sussed out and found. Not to mention it is Day 1, very little to go off of.
Click to expand...

Huh, ok, good to know. Also (I feel like a broken record here but) I’m a noob so I didn’t really know that. Will keep that in mind going forward.

Agreed, it’s just D1 so it’s hard to say anything with certainty.
 
kcoughli said:
Are you able to pm with FTB? On my phone so not super easy to check roster. I'm just surprised you're going to bat for her so strongly based on one? post.

If she's chatting with you via pm and you think shes not wolfy based on that, at least that's something.

From the information available on thread though I find it pretty suspicious to vouch so strongly for someone based on so little. Options are a wolf who knows FTB is village and is trying to buy cred for herself when FTB flips that way, a wolf trying to save another wolf who's absent and not able to defend, or mason villager.

The majority of those options aren't great, so I'm actually considering switching to you.

I would like to hear from the players who haven't shown up or who have been minimally participating.

Sent from my [device_name] using SDN mobile
Click to expand...

No, I am not PM'ing with FTB and per the roster can only PM Cowgirl, which I have literally just now opened, since you reminded me, and I usually make use of it. I haven't heard back yet, but I only just did it.

Eh, as a villager I really have nothing to lose going to bat for someone I think is village, unless I'm wrong or I get killed for it. It's more important I speak my mind and look out for village, than myself. Wolves have more to lose by putting down firm stakes in the sand. Wolfing 101 is to be very careful about coming off like you're informed minority.

I have my own logic. This goes into what I wanted to tell LIS. I have peeves, that usually relate to what I think are "bad" reasons to vote for someone, and that's when I go nuts. Admittedly in WW there's rarely hard data to go on, so I go nuts often. Still, I don't like it when someone is considered "wolfy" when they are doing what they do every game as a villager (why I'm not going for greeny), when the noobs are likely just being nooby (greeny, staff, johnaboo (his defense swung me)), or someone makes an actual thoughtful contribution (FTB).

In my opinion I can't take FTB's comment as more wolfy than Gryf's silly flippancy or DVMD's "tradition" throwaway vote on Sporty. Some of those things might have some element that makes them "off," but it's clear which are more useful. It doesn't prove that FTB's village either, and I can actually see why people might think it's wolfy, but I don't like the thinking. This early in game, I'd rather look at other players contributing less or doing things that I find more worrisome than a comment helpful on its face. I don't want to be wrong by lynching an insightful villager, if that's what we have with that comment.

Hence why I'm saying I'll come off you to save FTB. I don't like the FTB lynch. I have reason to think you're sketch, but in the scheme of things I think it's worth keeping both of you around a night and offing someone else instead as a trade off. Silent/inscrutable players are my sacrificial lambs of choice if I have to come off my top sketch choice to save someone I think is more valuable than the lamb.
 
Unofficial Day 1 Lynch Tally
kc (2) - Cray, jboo
DVMD (1) - Sporty
Coop (2) - AM, SoFlo
Kara () -
AM () -
vmh (1) - Coop
greeney (2) - Fern, Kara
Fern (2) - vmh, genny
Pippy (3) - staffy, dy, FTB
3m (1) - Snowy
Jil ()
Teep (1) - allie
SoFlo (1) - kata
dy () -
allie (1) - lyra
Cray (1) - cowgirl
Sporty (2) - 3m, DVMD
FTB (3) - Pippy, kc, Paws

23/28
lynch close in 1.5 hours
 
Crayola227 said:
DVMD's "tradition" throwaway vote on Sporty.
Click to expand...

Let's clear this up fast. It hasn't been a "tradition" for me to vote SP. I did it once early game at some point (heck I couldn't even tell you when) and SP claimed then and there that I "always vote for her."..... and well, it became a friendly thing. I put it in as a joke and if I find reason to move it during Day 1, I do. Go look at last game... I don't think I even voted for her Day 1.

What is more odd here, is that SP has voted for me in the same "spirit" and you don't have her listed in your write up here. Why not?
 
Animal Midwife said:
Who said I dropped it? I'm not done with SloFlo if that's what you're implying.
Click to expand...
Okay, I feel better that its still on your radar.

Animal Midwife said:
Why the mention of mason?
Click to expand...
#SketchMasons4Lyfe

kcoughli said:
I read it as being overly talkative, but I may have misinterpreted it because I was reading her as being too vocal for how I remembered Dy playing. I also hadn't realized she hadn't played here in so long so just assumed you'd played with her before and were seeing what I was seeing.

Sent from my [device_name] using SDN mobile
Click to expand...
But.....
Melchizedek said:
Whaaaat? So first Staff is wolf for nooby as hell comment and now Pip is wolf for pointing out is was a nooby comment?
I haven’t played with Dyachei before but this seems alarmist even for me >:|
Click to expand...

Your inconsistencies are piling up KC
 
Crayola227 said:
No, I am not PM'ing with FTB and per the roster can only PM Cowgirl, which I have literally just now opened, since you reminded me, and I usually make use of it. I haven't heard back yet, but I only just did it.

Eh, as a villager I really have nothing to lose going to bat for someone I think is village, unless I'm wrong or I get killed for it. It's more important I speak my mind and look out for village, than myself. Wolves have more to lose by putting down firm stakes in the sand. Wolfing 101 is to be very careful about coming off like you're informed minority.

I have my own logic. This goes into what I wanted to tell LIS. I have peeves, that usually relate to what I think are "bad" reasons to vote for someone, and that's when I go nuts. Admittedly in WW there's rarely hard data to go on, so I go nuts often. Still, I don't like it when someone is considered "wolfy" when they are doing what they do every game as a villager (why I'm not going for greeny), when the noobs are likely just being nooby (greeny, staff, johnaboo (his defense swung me)), or someone makes an actual thoughtful contribution (FTB).

In my opinion I can't take FTB's comment as more wolfy than Gryf's silly flippancy or DVMD's "tradition" throwaway vote on Sporty. Some of those things might have some element that makes them "off," but it's clear which are more useful. It doesn't prove that FTB's village either, and I can actually see why people might think it's wolfy, but I don't like the thinking. This early in game, I'd rather look at other players contributing less or doing things that I find more worrisome than a comment helpful on its face. I don't want to be wrong by lynching an insightful villager, if that's what we have with that comment.

Hence why I'm saying I'll come off you to save FTB. I don't like the FTB lynch. I have reason to think you're sketch, but in the scheme of things I think it's worth keeping both of you around a night and offing someone else instead as a trade off. Silent/inscrutable players are my sacrificial lambs of choice if I have to come off my top sketch choice to save someone I think is more valuable than the lamb.
Click to expand...
This was very helpful, thank you.

I honestly don't agree with some of the logic but at least I can understand somewhat where you're coming from.

I'm also ok with sacrificing players who aren't playing. Doesn't mean they are wolf or village but if they're not helping the village then they should go.

I'm not super satisfied with FTB s response, but at least she came back and responded. I hadn't realized her post was so late last night.

###unlynch FTB###

Have a feeling there's a few lurking wolves enjoying the village on village action.

How long until close? Anyone have an updated tally?



Sent from my [device_name] using SDN mobile
 
Melchizedek said:
Okay, I feel better that its still on your radar.


#SketchMasons4Lyfe


But.....


Your inconsistencies are piling up KC
Click to expand...
Reading and skimming on my phone. Didn't mean to put words in your mouth, honestly only even mentioned you last night because I try to give credit where credits due (didn't mean to parrot pip yesterday, just never saw her post).

I'll make sure to leave you out of it next time.

Sent from my [device_name] using SDN mobile
 
Melchizedek said:
My vote could go here. This is weird as all hell. Cray, you know how to lynch vote properly and instead of just saying oops I made a mistake, she get defensive.

If Cray has already responded to the above point, can someone condense her defense, I don't have the willpower to parse out her posts right now (not meant to be inflammatory towards you Cray, your posts do tend to be prolific.)
Click to expand...

I think a weird brainfart moment like this is more village like to do. Wolves tend to read over their posts more often and not draw that much attention to themselves. But I'm not good at reading cray, I had her as solid village the game she was a wolf.

Kc is all over the place for me. She is very active, but I don't know if I should take that as she has time off and is excited to play ww since she hasn't for awhile or excited to be a wolf-more active. I feel like its the former for now though. I'm not really getting the votes for ftb, idk his comments just haven't seemed sketch to me. The other top candidates are coming off as noob or usual first lynches who haven't said anything significant to ping my radar yet. But I'm also just skimming because I got to get back to work soon. Could still stay on 3m. Her two posts so far I are really random if I remember right. I'm going to vote pippy today. She hasn't been defensive yet even with being a leading lynch candidate which is more like her wolf self then her village self. Also didn't like her defense of staffy being a noob, reminded me too much of that other game (I know pips you gave an explanation for why you strongly defended paws that game, but I could see you doing that again if they were a noob in your pack)

Unlynch 3m
lynch pippy
 
SnowshoeDog143 said:
I think a weird brainfart moment like this is more village like to do. Wolves tend to read over their posts more often and not draw that much attention to themselves. But I'm not good at reading cray, I had her as solid village the game she was a wolf.

Kc is all over the place for me. She is very active, but I don't know if I should take that as she has time off and is excited to play ww since she hasn't for awhile or excited to be a wolf-more active. I feel like its the former for now though. I'm not really getting the votes for ftb, idk his comments just haven't seemed sketch to me. The other top candidates are coming off as noob or usual first lynches who haven't said anything significant to ping my radar yet. But I'm also just skimming because I got to get back to work soon. Could still stay on 3m. Her two posts so far I are really random if I remember right. I'm going to vote pippy today. She hasn't been defensive yet even with being a leading lynch candidate which is more like her wolf self then her village self. Also didn't like her defense of staffy being a noob, reminded me too much of that other game (I know pips you gave an explanation for why you strongly defended paws that game, but I could see you doing that again if they were a noob in your pack)

Unlynch 3m
lynch pippy
Click to expand...

Pippy literally wasn't a candidate until FTB poofed out of here.
 
SnowshoeDog143 said:
I think a weird brainfart moment like this is more village like to do. Wolves tend to read over their posts more often and not draw that much attention to themselves. But I'm not good at reading cray, I had her as solid village the game she was a wolf.

Kc is all over the place for me. She is very active, but I don't know if I should take that as she has time off and is excited to play ww since she hasn't for awhile or excited to be a wolf-more active. I feel like its the former for now though. I'm not really getting the votes for ftb, idk his comments just haven't seemed sketch to me. The other top candidates are coming off as noob or usual first lynches who haven't said anything significant to ping my radar yet. But I'm also just skimming because I got to get back to work soon. Could still stay on 3m. Her two posts so far I are really random if I remember right. I'm going to vote pippy today. She hasn't been defensive yet even with being a leading lynch candidate which is more like her wolf self then her village self. Also didn't like her defense of staffy being a noob, reminded me too much of that other game (I know pips you gave an explanation for why you strongly defended paws that game, but I could see you doing that again if they were a noob in your pack)

Unlynch 3m
lynch pippy
Click to expand...

FTB is a she.... 😉
 
kcoughli said:
Yep, didn't see it cuz phone wwing sucks monkey butt.

###Lynch teep###

I'm off to watch episode seven (going to see the new one tomorrow). Will try to sneak on before close but no promises.



Sent from my [device_name] using SDN mobile
Click to expand...

This is a weird vote for someone who hasn't yet been on and is not on the lynch board yet. Seems like a throwaway vote. Why teep?
 
SnowshoeDog143 said:
This is a weird vote for someone who hasn't yet been on and is not on the lynch board yet. Seems like a throwaway vote. Why teep?
Click to expand...
Literally because only one who hasn't checked in yet. See conversations about willing to switch to inactive and discussion with AM about who qualifies as such.

Sent from my [device_name] using SDN mobile
 
Animal Midwife said:
Pippy literally wasn't a candidate until FTB poofed out of here.
Click to expand...

But she's had 2 votes on her since this morning which so far would make her a leading candidate with our spread of votes so far. And that I would expect a reaction of some sort, but she didn't even seem phased. Which is weird to me. I mean it would also be weird if she was a wolf because she seems to be a wolf a lot then, but rng is king.

DVMDream said:
FTB is a she.... 😉
Click to expand...

Whoops. My bad 😛

kcoughli said:
Literally because only one who hasn't checked in yet. See conversations about willing to switch to inactive and discussion with AM about who qualifies as such.

Sent from my [device_name] using SDN mobile
Click to expand...

Ah probably missed that in my skimming.
 
SnowshoeDog143 said:
I'm going to vote pippy today. She hasn't been defensive yet even with being a leading lynch candidate which is more like her wolf self then her village self.
Click to expand...
.
I know from Snapchat that Pippy is busy hanging out with people today, so probably not checking in as much as usual.
 
SnowshoeDog143 said:
But she's had 2 votes on her since this morning which so far would make her a leading candidate with our spread of votes so far.And that I would expect a reaction of some sort, but she didn't even seem phased. Which is weird to me. I mean it would also be weird if she was a wolf because she seems to be a wolf a lot then, but rng is king.
Click to expand...

So does around 50 percent of the roster. And note one of those votes is a throwaway by someone who isn't responding anymore.
 
Melchizedek said:
PM's make me think that Pippy isn't a good choice for lynch today.
Click to expand...

Okay I'll take this for now. Don't have time to look at other people closely because my breaks over so going back to 3m.

Unlynch puppy
Relynch 3m
 
Unofficial Day 1 Lynch Tally
kc (2) - Cray, jboo
DVMD (1) - Sporty
Coop (2) - AM, SoFlo
Kara () -
AM () -
vmh (1) - Coop
greeney (2) - Fern, Kara
Fern (2) - vmh, genny
Pippy (3) - staffy, dy, FTB
3m (1) - Snowy
Jil () -
Teep (1) - allie
SoFlo (1) - kata
dy () -
allie (1) - lyra
Cray (1) - cowgirl
Sporty (2) - 3m, DVMD
FTB (2) - Pippy, Paws
Teep (1) - kc
Snowy (1) - Mel

24/28
lynch close in 45 minutes
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
Supernatural: Angels & Demons WW Game Thread
117 118 119 120 121
Replies
6K
Views
64K
katiemcat
katiemcat
WildZoo
SDN Fairgrounds - 10th Annual Noob WW Game
86 87 88 89 90
Replies
4K
Views
51K
katiemcat
katiemcat
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
59K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
42K
Clem J
Clem J
WildZoo
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
2 3 4 5 6
Replies
250
Views
17K
supershorty
supershorty
Top