WWhere There's a WWhisk, There's a WWay! - Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Chill ya tits
I can't, I have a party boob.

612.png
 
D4 Procrastibaking Lynch Tally

cdo (3) - pippy, finn, bryndy
snowy (3) - paws, capri, kski
finn (1) - AM
VAsp (4) - skye, nohika, KL, cdo
capri (1) - glam, stella
am (2) - vmh, mixy
lis () -
mixy (2) - snowy, lis
glam (1) - allie

no tie 😢

missing: cray, VAsp

18/20

Deadline 10pm EST (~10 min)

d96819093142d6483a6c73d4619fc9be.jpg
 
Man, I've been telling myself to not go hard on you b/c I'm likely tunneling... but what?? Waffling off a villager would be suspicious? Okay then.
What I mean is wouldn't that make the waffler look indecisive? I've been trying to prove to you I'm not a wolf and if this doesn't do it then okay.
unlynch Cdo
lynch VA
 
unlynch egg

For the moment. I'm trying to work through this. I don't want to flop over to snowy because I think that would make it a tie. I'm displeased that egg waited as long as she did to share this information when she's been questioned all day.

I was waiting on it, if there was a rezzer I didn't want them to accidentally out them. And then when LIS was rezzed I really didn't want to do it because two rezzers in 2-3 days looks suspicious and I knew I would get backlash for it!

Again with the "I don't know that this is wolfy per se" but something about this is kind of off. Possibly just poor villager judgment. If there's a rez item it's unlikely there is a rezzer and even if there was, hiding the fact that you were behind the rez just makes it sound like you have something to hide. Either way isn't this something that should have at least come up earlier in the day?
 
I understand I made this into a tie, but knowing that I'm village and that I don't trust VA, hey if we both die at least I killed a wolf/ someone I could never read.

Apparently I was incorrect and it NOW is tied between va and snowy
I would actually be ok with this tie. VA is distracting and I would like to see the Snowy/Mel saga play out.
ETA: not sure why cdo's post was quoted. I'm over it.
 
unlynch egg

For the moment. I'm trying to work through this. I don't want to flop over to snowy because I think that would make it a tie. I'm displeased that egg waited as long as she did to share this information when she's been questioned all day.



Again with the "I don't know that this is wolfy per se" but something about this is kind of off. Possibly just poor villager judgment. If there's a rez item it's unlikely there is a rezzer and even if there was, hiding the fact that you were behind the rez just makes it sound like you have something to hide. Either way isn't this something that should have at least come up earlier in the day?
I'm sorry for displeasing you. I also feared that if I shared that, it would clear me as a villager to the point where wolves would have easy target.
 
At least we’re on the same page about SOMETHING.

(Still wish you would’ve brought up the Rez like two hours ago)
To be fair, I never intended on sharing it unless absolutely necessary. I didn't know if it was actually important, ya know?
Spoiler: you were already a lynch target all day 😉
Ah but lynch target is very different than wolf target.
 
Sadly just getting on real late and skimming

VA is likely an egg to crack, but I'm not convinced of wolfiness

With Trilt and Mel shown to be villagers, my suspicion of Capri and Snowy went up

Egg has also been on my watch list, but without another thread analysis like I did before, I'm willing to go with Snowy on this one
 
I'm sorry for displeasing you. I also feared that if I shared that, it would clear me as a villager to the point where wolves would have easy target.

I believe you enough to unlynch you. I'm just telling you that if you are in fact villager, which is where I'm leaning at this point, that I think you made some bad calls here and the big one was waiting so late to share this. I can understand, maybe disagree but understand, why you didn't come out with it right away. What I don't understand is why you waited as long as you did when you knew you were under fire.

Ah but lynch target is very different than wolf target.

You're right. Being a lynch target is worse. We're better off losing villagers to night kills (when it's inevitable) than to lynches.
 
Unofficial D4 Procrastibaking Lynch Tally

cdo (1) - pippy
snowy (5) - paws, capri, kski, vmh, crayons
finn (1) - AM
VAsp (5) - skye, nohika, KL, cdo, brunch
capri (2) - glam, stella
am (1) - mixy
lis () -
mixy (2) - snowy, lis
glam (1) - allie

A tie :heckyeah:

missing: finn, VAsp

18/20

Deadline 10pm EST (~1 min)

d96819093142d6483a6c73d4619fc9be.jpg

Edited to fix math error that was carried over from karabou’s tally that was bothering me
 
Last edited:
well that's all on Finn and her friend VA, whom I'm trying to spare, I'm going to stick with who I think is most likely wolf of our candidates, Snowy
 
The problem is that it's water: I was promised vodka.

Cdoc, do you have any more spreadsheets?
So, my thoughts after finding VA's posts:

VA comes on, talks about pack mentality but ultimately doesn't point fingers on a specific person, just in general directions and then posts mainly fluff on his last post before disappearing for the rest of the day.

Still seems like VA is decking out and avoiding confrontation.
 
Lol why would that prove you’re not a wolf
Because other players (someone did last night but need to look who) have been criticized for switching their vote at the last minute. And we still do not have actual confirmation that cdo is a villager, which means she could just be a good liar. I'm just trying to figure out how actions will affect me down the line.
 
Because other players (someone did last night but need to look who) have been criticized for switching their vote at the last minute. And we still do not have actual confirmation that cdo is a villager, which means she could just be a good liar. I'm just trying to figure out how actions will affect me down the line.
Usually more Wolfy to last minute change a vote because you don’t want to not change it and be caught on the villager lynch.
 
I was trying to break the tie, and then Otter posted that you and VA hadn't voted... could have got the tie off VA

I didn't even see you had voted until the deadline so if I'd voted then (since I didn't know you were going to vote or who for) then it looked to me like I would have done what you did and created a tie. So I don't see how this is on me at all. That's just a weird comment to make. There were 4 minutes between your vote and deadline. That's a pretty small window. Plus the tally wasn't even on this page so I couldn't know for sure where things were at without checking.
 
D4 Final Lynch Tally

cdo (1) - pippy
snowy (5) - paws, capri, kski, vmh, snowy
finn (1) - AM
VAsp (5) - skye, nohika, KL, cdo, bryndy
capri (2) - glam, stella
am (1) - mixy
lis () -
mixy (2) - snowy, lis
glam (1) - allie

:heckyeah: 😏 A tie! :heckyeah: 😏

missing: VAsp, finn

18/20
 
D4 Final Lynch Tally

cdo (1) - pippy
snowy (5) - paws, capri, kski, vmh, snowy
finn (1) - AM
VAsp (5) - skye, nohika, KL, cdo, bryndy
capri (2) - glam, stella
am (1) - mixy
lis () -
mixy (2) - snowy, lis
glam (1) - allie

:heckyeah: 😏 A tie! :heckyeah: 😏

missing: VAsp

19/20
(Finn is missing(unlynched) and it’s 18/20)
 
Top