WWhere There's a WWhisk, There's a WWay! - Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
If I have time tonight I still want to go back and see who was pressuring me the most about the apron and "looking into my soul" before the whole thing with Bryndi's lie happened. I feel like the wolves would have known that they didn't try to kill me so they'd try extra hard to point out the sketchyness of a double kill night.
 
SnowshoeDog143 said:
Did you have it?
Click to expand...
It's all just too convenient. This was your last post of the lynch I think, at 8:45PM EST. 15 minutes later, Bryndi admits to using the boiler on me and **** hits the fan. You are no where to be found and it really looks as if you just let it all unfold. Granted, I don't think anything you would have said would have helped Bryndi in that case because she basically put the nail in her own coffin by lying, but...idk. Just weird timing and the fact that you've narrowly avoided a lynch before this game makes me think it's time for you to go.
 
Ugh I'm psyching myself out though, because if you were a wolf who knew that bryndi was lying all along about what she thought the item did, maybe you would have called her out on the thread right away.
 
allieh8607 said:
It's all just too convenient. This was your last post of the lynch I think, at 8:45PM EST. 15 minutes later, Bryndi admits to using the boiler on me and **** hits the fan. You are no where to be found and it really looks as if you just let it all unfold. Granted, I don't think anything you would have said would have helped Bryndi in that case because she basically put the nail in her own coffin by lying, but...idk. Just weird timing and the fact that you've narrowly avoided a lynch before this game makes me think it's time for you to go.
Click to expand...
I went back and looked. Technically, I think discussion only got to the broiler as a killing item around 8:30, but a 45min window is still small.

Snowy's sketchy logic had me considering a tin-foil theory that Bryndi and I were left alive to protect Snowy from lynch. Although, that + your theory would mean that Snowy deliberately let one defender die... maybe because they had a spare?

lynch snowy. Convenient absence for bryndi debacle + sketch logic today + tin foil + info about Mixy and allieh from the day 3 lynch.

nohika said:
(S)he hadn't started making sketchy af posts then. I think. It's mostly her recent stuff that has spiked her on my Sketch-o-meter.
Click to expand...
...That's unhelpful for my reads. Now I'm extra curious how Snowy flips - adding nohika to the list.

Good night, all. I've got an end-of-rotation presentation tomorrow that needs practice.
 
Actually, looking into nohika more tomorrow either way. Snowy's sketchier today, but I'm not happy nohika bandwagoned onto my logic when snowy's lynch picked up steam.
 
Glammyre said:
Actually, looking into nohika more tomorrow either way. Snowy's sketchier today, but I'm not happy nohika bandwagoned onto my logic when snowy's lynch picked up steam.
Click to expand...
Fwiw, probably didn't even read your posts. Started typing that after being sketched by snowy. So not bandwagoning, but.
 
allieh8607 said:
It's all just too convenient. This was your last post of the lynch I think, at 8:45PM EST. 15 minutes later, Bryndi admits to using the boiler on me and **** hits the fan. You are no where to be found and it really looks as if you just let it all unfold. Granted, I don't think anything you would have said would have helped Bryndi in that case because she basically put the nail in her own coffin by lying, but...idk. Just weird timing and the fact that you've narrowly avoided a lynch before this game makes me think it's time for you to go.
Click to expand...
allieh8607 said:
Ugh I'm psyching myself out though, because if you were a wolf who knew that bryndi was lying all along about what she thought the item did, maybe you would have called her out on the thread right away.
Click to expand...
Why would Snowy want to call out Bryndy on thread? You just said Bryndy put the nail in her own coffin, so we would have lynched her with or without Snowy’s input. Calling her out when someone else definitely would (and did) would probably just draw unnecessary attention.
 
SkiOtter said:
uh why should you be relying on someone else to tell you who to lynch today? specifically, someone who thinks youre sketchy, has thought you were sketchy for days, and is currently voting to lynch you.

what about my behavoir was odd?

all the lynches went towards bryndi because she kept lying about knowing it was a vig item. kept saying it sounded like a seering item. I wasn't the only one lynching bryndi for this and certainly wasn't the first to lynch her for this.

what would you like to hear from me? you never answered that yesterday either.
Click to expand...
I answered you yesterday. I asked you your thoughts on snowy at the time and also wanted to discuss why you were fighting with LIS first day. Between the fighting and your tin foil hat theories it just seems that you are making a lot of unnecessary distractions. And then the moment you're called out on it you acted frantic and immediately called on two people (Allie and bry). You also pushed at bry a lot.
 
Skyerien said:
I answered you yesterday. I asked you your thoughts on snowy at the time and also wanted to discuss why you were fighting with LIS first day. Between the fighting and your tin foil hat theories it just seems that you are making a lot of unnecessary distractions. And then the moment you're called out on it you acted frantic and immediately called on two people (Allie and bry). You also pushed at bry a lot.
Click to expand...
I was asked for who i thought was sketchy. i said who i thought was sketchy and for what reasons. i was also not the only one pushing bryndi. please go reread last night if you think i was the only one pushing bryndi.
also, why am i the only one getting **** from you about my tin foil hat theories?
 
nohika said:
Ugh it's cold for AZ today. I've become such a wuss.

I /am/ curious as to why I've stayed alive so long when several people pegged me villager-ish early on, so there's a decent chance I've been kept around to throw suspicion on later down the road because I'm naturally sketchy. So I'm kind of curious about the people now throwing shade on me, especially because I'm a super wolf or sommat.
Click to expand...
I feel like this is village. I wouldn't think a wolf would wonder this aloud. Granted anything could happen with a wolf, but this is like asking to get lynched, so I'm not really feeling Nohkia for today.
 
SkiOtter said:
I was asked for who i thought was sketchy. i said who i thought was sketchy and for what reasons. i was also not the only one pushing bryndi. please go reread last night if you think i was the only one pushing bryndi.
also, why am i the only one getting **** from you about my tin foil hat theories?
Click to expand...
All you said was multiple people were sketchy, but didn't go into much detail. You also didn't address the fighting with LIS. Then you pulled your theory out and when that crumbled you pointed to Allie and Bry. Yes, you were not the only person to push Bry, but you were the most erratic person I saw regarding it all.
 
Sorry, I'm having trouble keeping up with this game. I'll work on a lynch analysis soon.
 
Skyerien said:
All you said was multiple people were sketchy, but didn't go into much detail. You also didn't address the fighting with LIS. Then you pulled your theory out and when that crumbled you pointed to Allie and Bry. Yes, you were not the only person to push Bry, but you were the most erratic person I saw regarding it all.
Click to expand...
i prefaced KCOUGHLI'S tin foil hat theory with the fact that it was probably not true because more info had come out at that point. but when it was made, only asparagus had shared about the whisk. but i still wanted to share it because it hadnt been discussed and i also had a follow up theory that i had forgotten to copy and paste, WHICH I SAID. because, remember, i am having to go search through pages of PMs to find these things. I answered this all yesterday and i dont understand why you didn't understand it the first time and why youre making a big deal out of my tin foil hat theories. that literally is what they are. crazy as **** theories that most likely are not true. why are you so fixated on my theories and not anyone elses???
and possibly more erratic because i am having to go back to PMs to discuss things with my other head. its hard.
 
SkiOtter said:
I was asked for who i thought was sketchy. i said who i thought was sketchy and for what reasons. i was also not the only one pushing bryndi. please go reread last night if you think i was the only one pushing bryndi.
also, why am i the only one getting **** from you about my tin foil hat theories?
Click to expand...
I'm not the only one giving you **** for them. You were called out by multiple people yesterday, not just me.
 
SkiOtter said:
so is that a no, @Animal Midwife, orrrrrrr.....?
Click to expand...

No one has touched any of the lynches I started. They go stagnant and some other opposing bandwagon forms. It feels forced.

These are my other reads.

Skye - It seems like she's is lurking without contributing much.

nokia - Still don't think her vote for Mel was ever explained.

allie - Worried about how she seemed to drop interest in pursuing FTB just because she got a sub.
 
PippyPony said:
I feel like you're kind of agreeing with me, but also simultaneously putting the responsibility for her sketchiness on me. Her decision to be cagey with explaining her decision is not on me. It is on her.


Because there is WIFOM that is more "fluffy" and WIFOM that is actually thinking about optimal wolf behavior.

This is the latter. I'm arguing that it would be really kinda dumb for me from a strategic decision standpoint to push villager lynches multiple days in a row because eventually people would start to ask questions. Like they are doing today.

When I wolf, I would be weighing expectations along with risk. And I am very careful about where/how/when I push people as a wolf. And in my mind, the gain of two villager lynches would not be worth that kind of destruction of villager trust at this stage, in this game.

Also, bold wolf does not mean non-beneficial.


And on this...did you miss the part where I was the first person to start questioning her, and was the first person on that lynch?

How was bryndi an easy lynch target at that point?

Like, you're making my own argument for me about why we should maybe be looking at people who jumped on that lynch later once the confusion was turned up to 11.

Which -- by the way -- was driven by Bryndi.
Click to expand...
Not saying Brynd wasn't sketchy and didn't get herself lynched. I'm just trying to see things from a possibly different perspective considering she flipped village. Feel like the bolded is trying to build village cred, again not buying into anything that suggests one would align with village vs wolf. Also the expectations along with risk I feel like heading lynches as a wolf in this game has actually served well especially how lynches have thus far progressed. Never said a bold wolf doesn't mean non-beneficial. The italicized part I disagree with. Yes you were the first to lynch them, but definitely not the first to start asking questions. Things as far as clarification were starting to get hairy. Yes you immediately started questioning but definitely not first and bryndi at the point in the conversation was starting to be sketch so leading a lynch on her would be easy.
PippyPony said:
Ok, just kind of in the middle of catching up...but that item sounds like a vigilante item.

Which in my mind begs the question of why this is the first time we're hearing about it from Bryndi
Click to expand...

PippyPony said:
Lynch Bryndi
Click to expand...
Also if we recall how when we were pming and then I pm'd you then wrote pretty much everything on here you said I threw up village in pm and on thread. Reads I do not feel automatically make someone more village (ex LIS waffled off Mel lynch after Mel gave reads list but Mel was wolf in MI) and the only way you'd say I'm village is you know I am because you're wolf and know all the villagers. I just don't have a good feeling about this...I feel you've tried justifying your village affiliation through I would do this as wolf and it just doesn't sit well with me.
Lynch Pippy
 
SkiOtter said:
yeah but you are only giving ME **** for my tin foil theories. you are not giving **** to anyone else about their crazy theories. thats what im saying. WHY ONLY MINE.
Click to expand...
I'm not criticizing the theory really, more thinking it's odd you've cause two major distractions in this game (the theory and fighting with LIS). You're just awfully defensive about it all. Even now.
 
Animal Midwife said:
No one has touched any of the lynches I started. They go stagnant and some other opposing bandwagon forms. It feels forced.

These are my other reads.

Skye - It seems like she's is lurking without contributing much.

nokia - Still don't think her vote for Mel was ever explained.

allie - Worried about how she seemed to drop interest in pursuing FTB just because she got a sub.
Click to expand...
what are your reasons for lynching finn? because so far youve given "feelz" for like 3 days and "because mel said so" but no actual reasons you've come up with in the past three days that are making you lynch her???
 
Skyerien said:
I'm not criticizing the theory really, more thinking it's odd you've cause two major distractions in this game (the theory and fighting with LIS). You're just awfully defensive about it all. Even now.
Click to expand...
because im now annoyed that you keep asking me the same questions that i have answered multiple times now and are not answering my questions about "why are my tin foil theories the only ones you have problems with being on the thread and not everyone elses?"
you also have given approximately 2 reads of your own this whole game so you should probably start on that too.
 
SkiOtter said:
what are your reasons for lynching finn? because so far youve given "feelz" for like 3 days and "because mel said so" but no actual reasons you've come up with in the past three days that are making you lynch her???
Click to expand...

I. am. lynching. her. because. no. one. else. seems. to. get. how. sketchy. she. is.
 
capri1722 said:
Then. explain. it. please. because. clearly. we. don’t. understand.
Click to expand...

SkiOtter said:
please. explain. what. you. are. getting. from. her. that. is. sketchy.
why is she sketchy to you. please explain. thats what im asking for.
Click to expand...
Could .also. switch. my.vote. here. because. I've. been. asking. the. same. thing. from. the. beginning. and. keep. getting. the. same. lame. response.
 
capri1722 said:
Then. explain. it. please. because. clearly. we. don’t. understand.
Click to expand...
SkiOtter said:
please. explain. what. you. are. getting. from. her. that. is. sketchy.
why is she sketchy to you. please explain. thats what im asking for.
Click to expand...

I keep saying why. And then the next day someone asks why again. And then I explain. And then the next day someone asks why again. And then I explain. Why do you keep asking if you're not going to listen?
 
lynch snowy

I can get into the whys of it if y'all want but it's not anything new so probably doesn't need a rehash.

Animal Midwife said:
I. am. lynching. her. because. no. one. else. seems. to. get. how. sketchy. she. is.
Click to expand...

I don't even think you're wolfy, I just think this is bad play and kind of painful to watch.

So far your reasons provided for lynching me are, in no particular order:

Feels.
Mel said so.
No one else wants to lynch her.

That's some really powerful stuff ya got there.
 
Animal Midwife said:
I keep saying why. And then the next day someone asks why again. And then I explain. And then the next day someone asks why again. And then I explain. Why do you keep asking if you're not going to listen?
Click to expand...
because all you are saying is "feelz" and "because mel said so"
youre not giving YOUR reasons for thinking shes sketchy.
 
vetmedhead said:
**********
I. Am. Reading. All of. These. Posts. Like. William. Shatner.
**********
Click to expand...
William%20Shatner%20Deep%20Fried%20Turkey.gif
 
Okay.

finn had a really strange interaction with Paws on Day 1. It bothers me how hard she pushed she Mel lynch. She has pushed other lynches without seeming too aggressive. She's great at wolfing.
 
MixedAnimals77 said:
Not saying Brynd wasn't sketchy and didn't get herself lynched. I'm just trying to see things from a possibly different perspective considering she flipped village. Feel like the bolded is trying to build village cred, again not buying into anything that suggests one would align with village vs wolf. Also the expectations along with risk I feel like heading lynches as a wolf in this game has actually served well especially how lynches have thus far progressed. Never said a bold wolf doesn't mean non-beneficial. The italicized part I disagree with. Yes you were the first to lynch them, but definitely not the first to start asking questions. Things as far as clarification were starting to get hairy. Yes you immediately started questioning but definitely not first and bryndi at the point in the conversation was starting to be sketch so leading a lynch on her would be easy.



Also if we recall how when we were pming and then I pm'd you then wrote pretty much everything on here you said I threw up village in pm and on thread. Reads I do not feel automatically make someone more village (ex LIS waffled off Mel lynch after Mel gave reads list but Mel was wolf in MI) and the only way you'd say I'm village is you know I am because you're wolf and know all the villagers. I just don't have a good feeling about this...I feel you've tried justifying your village affiliation through I would do this as wolf and it just doesn't sit well with me.
Lynch Pippy
Click to expand...
Woah there nooblet. Slow down, take a deep breath.

You're not really making any sense right now.

I'm not going to address all of this now because I'm getting sick and need to go to bed, but do you really think the only reason someone might think you are village is because they know who all the villagers are? Think about that for a hot second.

You're reducing something much more nuanced down into one dimensional absolutes.
 
And I am being nice because you were one of my adopted wolf pups, but I'm telling you now that if you keep up this kind of oversimplification, I'm going to heavily reevaluate that village read I had on you from that PM conversation + the night cancel.
 
PippyPony said:
Woah there nooblet. Slow down, take a deep breath.

You're not really making any sense right now.

I'm not going to address all of this now because I'm getting sick and need to go to bed, but do you really think the only reason someone might think you are village is because they know who all the villagers are? Think about that for a hot second.

You're reducing something much more nuanced down into one dimensional absolutes.
Click to expand...
Didn't say that was only reason, also know there's not only one reason someone can be village, just seemed to be giving more credit to reads than I at least would've.
(BTW I hope you feel better. I really am a nicer and different person out of WW as many of us are)
 
Animal Midwife said:
Okay.

finn had a really strange interaction with Paws on Day 1. It bothers me how hard she pushed she Mel lynch. She has pushed other lynches without seeming too aggressive. She's great at wolfing.
Click to expand...
I don't like this. Paws and Finn thing seemed more like D1 lynch push and Fin was like what? I've been a wolf like one time I've voted early. Her and Mel went back and forth all day. She hasn't really pushed any other lynches. They've wanted to lynch snowy but have yet to get it pushed through and voted for Kski on a few occasions so don't really see how they've pushed lynches very well... just my 2 cents
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
27K
Clem J
Clem J
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
PokeWWon: A Wild Kanto Adventure - Champs Season 12 Practice Game Thread
87 88 89 90 91
Replies
5K
Views
44K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
supershorty
GGoats ThWWee: Here It GGoats Again - GAME THREAD
91 92 93 94 95
Replies
5K
Views
35K
chicandtoughness
chicandtoughness
Animal Midwife
Matrix - Game Thread
77 78 79 80 81
Replies
4K
Views
65K
samac
samac
kaydubs
Melee WW Game Thread-April 2024
27 28 29 30 31
Replies
2K
Views
23K
Sandy Dikson
Sandy Dikson
Top