Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Even if this is the truth, I kind of feel like you're an egg that needs cracked at this point :/ While it'll suck to lose a villager, we're not losing a terribly important role at least.
WWho Let the Dogs Out? - Game Thread
Started by finnickthedog
Get help with your application
Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.
I have to go to a wedding in a few hours so I won't be around, not that I'm helpful in the first place, but I do need to put out a vote. I'm not feeling the sporty lynch but that's gonna make you all think I'm a wolf. soooo stuff and things
Let it also be known that I had precisely 1000 more likes than posts until this game, and I am highly offended.
I want cray to wake up and fix this injustice.
I want cray to wake up and fix this injustice.
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
It’s unlikely stagg is a wolf.
Okay then
Lynch sporty
I’m willing to believe there are reasons
Lynch sporty
I’m willing to believe there are reasons
I'm thinking that too, but I did want to acknowledge it as a possibility.
If sporty does flip wolf...I'm going to be looking at those who immediately jumped on her this morning, minus Stagg
On to the sporty iso I was doing
A few statements that were maybe a bit sharper than they should have been. Not necessarily indicative of affiliation, but in my experience wolves tend to be more prickly more quickly.
OTOH, the following felt more village to me:
Overall I'm not sure I would pursue a sport lynch on my own without the stated confidence of @Stagg737 . I suppose we'll see how it turns out (and also turn some discussion on to other candidates)
A few statements that were maybe a bit sharper than they should have been. Not necessarily indicative of affiliation, but in my experience wolves tend to be more prickly more quickly.
OTOH, the following felt more village to me:
The bolded reads as a relatively village move to me, especially because I think shelter would probably be an easy-to-justify lynch vote to place as a wolf
Most of this reads list isn't that important to me, but this last line I think stands out, as jboo had relatively little suspicion at this point and there's no way the wolves would have known at this point that she would be taken out during the night. A WIFOM argument could be made for laying out reads list credibility early on, but I think it would also look suspicious for a wolf to mention someone as suspicious and then drop it over time.
The bolded raised my hackles a little but I can't put a finger on why
Overall I'm not sure I would pursue a sport lynch on my own without the stated confidence of @Stagg737 . I suppose we'll see how it turns out (and also turn some discussion on to other candidates)
WildZoo
Noble Dubz Dictator, Unyeetable Phasing Wolf
Administrator
Volunteer Staff
Lifetime Donor
10+ Year Member
Day 3 Official Frolicking Through the Flowers Lynch Tally
Sporty (9) - Lawpy, dolphin, Stagg, capri, allie, paws, meats, mpm, barks
mpm (1) - pipperoncini
coop (0) -
10/20
Deadline: 10pm EST (~7.25 hrs)
@SportPonies You are winning!
Sporty (9) - Lawpy, dolphin, Stagg, capri, allie, paws, meats, mpm, barks
mpm (1) - pipperoncini
coop (0) -
10/20
Deadline: 10pm EST (~7.25 hrs)
@SportPonies You are winning!
Really? Sketch points for you...
This seems like an extremely convenient excuse to a role I've never heard of.
Dude you played smash. It was in smash. I think it was also in a game after that.
She probably won't see it until later but @Crayola227
Why would you be hesitant about stagg being wolfy?
My other top suspicions right now are coop and mom
Does anyone have other suspicious players they'd like to add to the discussion docket?
Does anyone have other suspicious players they'd like to add to the discussion docket?
Why would Sport lie about framing if they aren't a wolf?
Lawper. At some point today I'm going to iso him.
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Dude, what? I’m not asking “please tell me everything about everything.”
I’m asking if this is mod provided or based on her posts. That’s it. Not exactly what it is.
You’ve been very vague all game, said you had tin foil reasons why you think Sporty is a wolf, and now are refusing to say anything at all. That’s sketch.
Well this makes it seem like you were maybe seered then. Which would explain why stagg feels so confident...
Ugh sporty imma make you watch Elf so many times if I defended you and you’re a wolf.
Well in this post, jboozy shaded Pawsy pretty dismissively, but in comparison, she also criticized Caits, Coops and Pippy. But jboozy's tone was a lot harsher and more dismissive towards Pawsy.
Pawsy is my strongest village read.
Also, I'm an Icelandic Sheepdog.
Stagg was for me. But now this. I am torn.
By the way, this post rubbed me the wrong way. It felt like a fast flip to agreeing with me since these posts:While I do agree that soft clearing everyone may be a bit rash, especially since I am weirded out by Coopah too- I do think that Paws is safe because Jboo has been on Paw's lynch, and seemed pretty adamant... see Lawpy's posts from earlier where he quoted jboo's shenanigans... so if no one else, I do feel good about Paws... and for now...
Lynch Coopah because I don't like
1. the way she?? agreed with me so fast
B. how I actually feel there may be a wolf on the list... probs Coops
#. how coop still planning on lynching AM after the PR claim (I know that there was a defense given here, but it was just sketch. I have feels on this one)
(^^is this numbering thing cool? I can be sooooo cool lol)
Combined with the bolded, it makes me think you're a little too agreeable because you don't want to be leading on a lynch that turns up village
Something in the back of my mind is also telling me mpm is sketchy but I need to go back to pin down why
This reminds me, how has sporty seemed to you in the PM she opened with you?
My top suspicious players are coop, lawp, and I think I remember someone saying pip would be sus if sport flipped one way or the other (can't remember who said it tho...) but I'd like to talk about that.
Possible Cujo Discussion Docket
Coop
Mom (x2 votes to discuss)
Lawpy
Stagg
Pip (depending on how sporty flips)
Fine, I think?
We’ve been talking about what’s on thread. She hasn’t been trying to get info or trying to convince me she’s village or anything weird.
WildZoo
Noble Dubz Dictator, Unyeetable Phasing Wolf
Administrator
Volunteer Staff
Lifetime Donor
10+ Year Member
like
I also agree with your mpm, btw. In case that wasn’t obvious from my earlier post haha
The problem is we don't know if sporty is actually lying. If she is village, this may be her best attempt at explaining the certainty of other lynches while still knowing her own affiliation. If she is a wolf, well then she's obviously lying about it. Only a flip will clarify at this point unless a framer jumps on thread and outs themselves
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I've been using mom to refer to mpm because my autocorrect doesn't like mpm. Who is mom supposed to be?
I keep associating mom with @WildZoo for some reason
Mainly my suspect is Coops. Also interested in petmoosy and barky.
Didn't I start the mom thing?! 😱
Mom is me by cdo and dubz! And probably something else on here too ha
I think its kind of hilarious that I'm mom, bc im one of the newest people here
Lynch sporty
So much nonsense coming out of her mouth
So much nonsense coming out of her mouth
WildZoo
Noble Dubz Dictator, Unyeetable Phasing Wolf
Administrator
Volunteer Staff
Lifetime Donor
10+ Year Member
It's because I always scold you, isn't it?I keep associating mom with @WildZoo for some reason
You’re the one who said mom = caiter, ya goon
Probs because I call her that so oftenI keep associating mom with @WildZoo for some reason
Mainly my suspect is Coops. Also interested in petmoosy and barky.
Also, we can totally talk about me if you want, but I think its a little weird that suddenly so many people are jumping on this... and if there is anything I can do to help clear things up I'll do my best.
So here’s my thoughts. Either sporty or stagg is lying. If stagg hadn’t already been sketch to me, I’d have been more willing to jump on sporty without questioning him at all.
But he was. And sporty wasn’t setting off bells with me before, and the sporty lynch initially started off from AM. So I’m really torn.
If sporty flips village though, I think stagg needs to be next.
But he was. And sporty wasn’t setting off bells with me before, and the sporty lynch initially started off from AM. So I’m really torn.
If sporty flips village though, I think stagg needs to be next.
yes, could you explain?
If there really is a framer role though, it could just be that stagg got incorrect results.
Damn, you’re right. Well there goes that theory lol
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Umm, you'll have to go back and find the exact posts for yourself, but basically ziggy said sporty had PMed her using her role and had mentioned that she had feels for AM. So idk if it was just ziggy being an impressionable noob, but the aforementioned "PMing" was between sporty and ziggy and ziggy later said she regretted adding that bit to her post detailing her wolfy feels for AM.
why?
Either way, this is going to tell us something... Your way of thinking actually comes off as a little wolfy to me Cait- as I was writing this I saw you amended your thinking, but its still weird imo.
Why would Sporty as a villager who wants village to win try to claim there is a wolf framer? Sporty the villager is trying to save innocent Stagg the villager who actually got incorrect results because of the framing ability.
vs. Sporty the wolf who wants wolves to win claims there is a wolf framer so they won't get lynched. In this case, Stagg is correct and most likely village.
vs. Sporty the villager and Stagg the wolf... Stagg for some reason wants Sporty out of the game NOW, so makes a claim based on "reasons" that he knows exactly how everyone is going to interpret. This one doesn't make much sense, because then why would Sport defend him by claiming framing
Tinfoil below
vs. Sporty and Stagg the wolves... which would be dumb... gives one of them village cred maybe? Kind of early for a sacrifice bus like that tho
Regardless, the flip will tell us one way or another.
Edit: to fix typo, missed word in sentence so it didn't make sense
Just because someone has village feels about someone else does NOT make them trustworthy! Woofs know who is village too, and will use that knowledge to be like hey I don't think this lynch is a good idea then turn out to be right and gain all sorts of cred. Bad logic there. Pip needs to die ALWAYS if she hasn't caught a wolf by ~D5. Hard rule for me. She's too dangerous otherwise.
I fully acknowledge stagg was already giving me sketch vibes and that’s effecting how I’m thinking about this. To me it seemed his vote this morning was just going off of AM, not like he actually knew Sporty was wolf.
Also, last night I said it seemed sketchy to have two villagers with PM roles. Why would I try to get more info and not just go with the sporty lynch if I was a wolf? It seemed bandwagonny to me this morning and I didn’t agree with it, so I wanted more info. That would be idiotic to do if I wasn’t village.
