WWhy is Dexter a sociopath WW game

Veterinary Science Graduate Programs from U. of I.
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Members don't see this ad.
WhtsThFrequency said:
Because if they started "talking strategy" with DocE as he claims, then I assume they have a kill function. I would find it odd if a group of serial killers who were discussing strategy were trying to benefit the villagers.
Click to expand...

Just sirco. Could only talk to sirco. And the discussions were broad, because of pm timing issues and then I was cut off with my role stolen.
 
tropictuco said:
👍 I think we need to hold off on lynching the pinkies on purpose, and go after more likely wolves. Not that I even know where to start for this...

The evidence we have NOW leans towards the wolves wanting to kill pinkies, since they already did it once. So that's why I think we need to leave them alone.
Click to expand...

You assume that wolves know who they are killing every time, which is false. Unless they got very lucky and 1) have a wolf seer, 2) the wolf seer just happened to find a pink one, and 3) the wolves want to kill the pink ones.

I still maintain that a group of serial killers has a kill function. Seriously guys - we had someone burned to a crisp, remember? That was Lila, I'm almost 100% sure. Can't think of anyone else who would kill in such a fashion. And Lila is in this serial killer group, yes? WHy don't we go after whoever is Lila?
 
DocEspana said:
lynch that redhead. Because he (or she haha) keeps insisting I out who sirco is. Frankly you can't kill sirco, and tbey have a very useful role for villagers, until the new jurg is dead. I want him attacked by wolves because that does the villagers good. Giving the name does zero until the new jurg is dead, so it only benefits wolves to know who to avoid.

And the people who can talk with sirco are not jumping down my throat, either for the lynch or for the identity to be outed. Which makes me think that they are a ***** who misidentified themself and their allies as wolves, not an actual one. Plus the odds of them knowing four villager identities on day one is close to zero.
Click to expand...


Can you tell us what this role is? Does it really make a difference to the wolves to know what specifically the role does versus "it's very helpful" if they don't know who the person is?
 
Doc, you know who Lila is then, right? Is it possible she was the one that burned orcagirl at the beginning on Night 1 (I believe Lila is the one people were saying is a pyro)? If so, I think it is safe to say that we should not have someone that is killing people in the game.
 
WhtsThFrequency said:
You assume that wolves know who they are killing every time, which is false. Unless they got very lucky and 1) have a wolf seer, 2) the wolf seer just happened to find a pink one, and 3) the wolves want to kill the pink ones.

I still maintain that a group of serial killers has a kill function. Seriously guys - we had someone burned to a crisp, remember? That was Lila, I'm almost 100% sure. Can't think of anyone else who would kill in such a fashion. And Lila is in this serial killer group, yes? WHy don't we go after whoever is Lila?
Click to expand...

That's how Dexter disposed of Doomsday. Not disagreeing with it being Lila, just saying there's another option out there.
 
DVMDream said:
Doc, you know who Lila is then, right? Is it possible she was the one that burned orcagirl at the beginning on Night 1 (I believe Lila is the one people were saying is a pyro)? If so, I think it is safe to say that we should not have someone that is killing people in the game.
Click to expand...

Yes I do. This is partially yo play in why I figured they were all wolves and was shocked to see Miguel wasn't one. I do figure Lila was the cause of that kill.
 
RNG says

lynch WTF

At work and will be watching the lynch in case something new comes up.
 
DocEspana said:
I know their role ability. You do not want him lynched. I don't care how stupid he is. Others know it. They don't want him lynched. Maybe they are convertible. Idk. But of the roles listed (sirko, Hannah, Lila) I would suspect sirko the least because he isn't even a real villain in dexter. He dies as dexters friend. . Spoiler in white. Dexter has a much less friendly relationshopnwith the other two. But its equivalent to Miguel Prado who was not a wolf.

There are people who can work with sirco, and if they believe him, mistake and all, then I do.
Click to expand...

Sns was supposed to be bad though. I don't think the persons role on the show necessarily makes them the same thing in the game. So I'm not sold on sirko being good.

But if I'm trusting nohikas information that you aren't a wolf, I suppose I need to believe what you say about sirko. I don't like it though.
 
I might give DocE a chance.

***unlynch Doc E***
***lynch thatredhead***

carrottop_400x375_a.jpg
 
DocEspana said:
Yes I do. This is partially yo play in why I figured they were all wolves and was shocked to see Miguel wasn't one. I do figure Lila was the cause of that kill.
Click to expand...

Do you have any good reason why we should keep Lila in the game? If she is going around burning people, that is as good of a reason as any to lynch someone.
 
DVMDream said:
Doc, you know who Lila is then, right? Is it possible she was the one that burned orcagirl at the beginning on Night 1 (I believe Lila is the one people were saying is a pyro)? If so, I think it is safe to say that we should not have someone that is killing people in the game.
Click to expand...

👍 and orca was a villager, if we're going off color code...so Lila would be a bad person.
 
that redhead said:
Sns was supposed to be bad though. I don't think the persons role on the show necessarily makes them the same thing in the game. So I'm not sold on sirko being good.

But if I'm trusting nohikas information that you aren't a wolf, I suppose I need to believe what you say about sirko. I don't like it though.
Click to expand...

I wouldn't classify Miguel as bad, like I would classify Brian Moser or Trinity. I'd put him in an ambiguous category. And Sirko, with that power, makes it sound like he's in that ambiguous category too. I had forgotten that he had such a human side to him. I really think we need to leave the pinkies alone.

And I'm not even a pinkie...DocE can probs tell you that if he feels like it.

lynch WTF
 
tropictuco said:
I wouldn't classify Miguel as bad, like I would classify Brian Moser or Trinity. I'd put him in an ambiguous category. And Sirko, with that power, makes it sound like he's in that ambiguous category too. I had forgotten that he had such a human side to him. I really think we need to leave the pinkies alone.

And I'm not even a pinkie...DocE can probs tell you that if he feels like it.

lynch WTF
Click to expand...

And your motivation is what for lynching me?

That I believe the serial killer group has a kill function, as evidenced by a burned body and the presence of Lila in the group?

And how you suddenly became quite talkative when I threw in a vote for you?
 
WhtsThFrequency said:
That's a stretch. Comparing the single action of the protagonist to an established pyromaniac who is definitely evil in the story.....don't think so.
Click to expand...

But it IS specific to how Doomsday died. If orca was Doomsday, that's how the write-up might be.

And we need to remember we don't know orca's role to judge whether the kill was good or not.
 
I realize I am beating a dead horse over this point.

I realize I'm potentially putting myself out on a limb.

But with no other info right now I'm going to keep hammering on it.

A burned body + a Lila + a serial killer "group" containing Lila (even if they aren't a "wolf group", which evidently remains out there) just screams badness to me.
 
WhtsThFrequency said:
And your motivation is what for lynching me?

That I believe the serial killer group has a kill function, as evidenced by a burned body and the presence of Lila in the group?

And how you suddenly became quite talkative when I threw in a vote for you?
Click to expand...

I got suspicious of you when LIS did. I don't think it's DocE anymore, and I don't think we should go after Sirko. DocE is not going to give up Lila (looks like), who else?
 
that redhead said:
Why, because I'm suspicious of you?
Click to expand...

Are you that shallow?

BIM-BLD045148.jpg


Mainly because I want to see what DocE has to contribute, a lot of people are voting for you and I do not want to RNG 😛

Plus, the foxhunter rule is in effect. Kinda have to lynch someone ya know.
 
Last edited:
WhtsThFrequency said:
So you are suggesting Dexter killed orca?
Click to expand...

I'm suggesting it's a possibility. He IS a serial killer. Obviously we can't rule out Lila. Just don't want everyone to fall into the trap of running away with one option because they think it's the only one.
 
There's probably some reason SOV put the pinkies together. WTF could be right and they could have a kill function or it could be something else. Or he's just really messing with us 😛. But why would they be talking wolf strategy? I'm new to WW, but we're clear that resurrection is a villager ability? I'm not sure if we are safe to assume everyone in that group is a villager because of SnS.
 
DocEspana said:
No clue what any of the other "pink killers" do. Wasn't told before the role theft.
Click to expand...

But you do think Lila was responsible for orca's death. So why not lynch that player? I don't understand any reason to keep a player's identity a secret in the game that is potentially killing people. We are down to a few options....either lynch someone, like Lila, who may be responsible for killing a player or to keep at this random lynching crap and potentially lose someone with a more beneficial role.
 
tropictuco said:
I'm suggesting it's a possibility. He IS a serial killer. Obviously we can't rule out Lila. Just don't want everyone to fall into the trap of running away with one option because they think it's the only one.
Click to expand...

I would imagine that if Dexter was running around killing people, it would be according to his usual modus operandi. I would be very surprised to see a kill by Dexter involving fire. Yes, we don't know orca's allegiance. But the entire thing would seem like a huge stretch to me.
 
DVMDream said:
But you do think Lila was responsible for orca's death. So why not lynch that player? I don't understand any reason to keep a player's identity a secret in the game that is potentially killing people. We are down to a few options....either lynch someone, like Lila, who may be responsible for killing a player or to keep at this random lynching crap and potentially lose someone with a more beneficial role.
Click to expand...

Agreed x1000.
 
lynch vote for SOV

DocE 6 (Dev ,trem, WS, kaydubs, FFM, Escalla)
that redhead 4 (LIS, dyachei, DocE, trematode)
LabRat 1 (thatredhead)
FFM 1 (sheep's poo)
tropictuco 1 (WTF)
Escalla 1 (hedgie)
Lupin 1 (swings)
Hedgie 1 (DVMD)
WTF 2 (nohika, tropictuco)

5 (?) votes yet to be counted.

Deadline 7pm.
 
DVMDream said:
lynch vote for SOV

DocE 6 (Dev ,trem, WS, kaydubs, FFM, Escalla)
that redhead 4 (LIS, dyachei, DocE, trematode)
LabRat 1 (thatredhead)
FFM 1 (sheep's poo)
tropictuco 1 (WTF)
Escalla 1 (hedgie)
Lupin 1 (swings)
Hedgie 1 (DVMD)
WTF 2 (nohika, tropictuco)

5 (?) votes yet to be counted.

Deadline 7pm.
Click to expand...

Thanks. Yes....5 votes left. Very happy with participation everyone!
 
lynch vote for SOV

DocE 4 (Dev ,WS, kaydubs, Escalla)
that redhead 4 (LIS, dyachei, DocE, trematode)
LabRat 1 (thatredhead)
FFM 1 (sheep's poo)
tropictuco 1 (WTF)
Escalla 1 (hedgie)
Lupin 1 (swings)
Hedgie 1 (DVMD)
WTF 2 (nohika, tropictuco)
Kpowell 1 (FFM)

5 (?) votes yet to be counted.

Deadline 7pm.
 
The thinking behind not naming Lila: sirko seems like he would be good and it appears that they are a *****, not a wolf.

Lumen was never a villain. Just a killer in training and look. She dies as a pink.

Miguel was a season-wide villain, but wasn't a wolf.

Hannah is really shady. I could actually buy her being a wolf, but look at the company she is keeping. It seems like an innocent group.

Lila is the most suspicious as a character. But given what I saw already, I'm really hesitant to just share it given how two of the five have gone so far. But im considering it. Just on role alone. Let them defend themselves. Maybe. Idk.
 
I am always posting from my phone and can rarely ever see pictures that other people post, so I was just praying that they worked. 75% of photos come up as ? to me.

I need a hot nerd to give me some tech support.
 
Last edited:
DocEspana said:
The thinking behind not naming Lila: sirko seems like he would be good and it appears that they are a *****, not a wolf.
Click to expand...

I thought you had said that sirko said that SOV said (bahaha) that sirko is a wolf? Or did I misunderstand?

Fwiw, I think DVMD is right- probably safer to lynch someone suspicious like lilia than someone like you or me.
 
DocEspana said:
The thinking behind not naming Lila: sirko seems like he would be good and it appears that they are a *****, not a wolf.

Lumen was never a villain. Just a killer in training and look. She dies as a pink.

Miguel was a season-wide villain, but wasn't a wolf.

Hannah is really shady. I could actually buy her being a wolf, but look at the company she is keeping. It seems like an innocent group.

Lila is the most suspicious as a character. But given what I saw already, I'm really hesitant to just share it given how two of the five have gone so far. But im considering it. Just on role alone. Let them defend themselves. Maybe. Idk.
Click to expand...

Even if Lila is not a wolf, the fact still remains that there is a very decent chance she killed another player. Seriously. It makes zero sense to keep someone in the game that has the ability to kill unless you are trying to protect them for some reason. So, you really think it is better to randomly lynch another player? You would normally be all over lynching a player that has the ability or even possible ability to kill; I don't get why you are protecting them, just to randomly lynch someone else (especially, since you are very much against random lynching).
 
Also unless sov is pulling a fast one and making cops (besides prob deb) the wolves, there is a close to zero percent chance masuka is a wolf. And that's unlikely given the deaths are murders. The dude is a loveable perv. Most harmless person in the mythos.
 
DocEspana said:
Also unless sov is pulling a fast one and making cops (besides prob deb) the wolves, there is a close to zero percent chance masuka is a wolf. And that's unlikely given the deaths are murders. The dude is a loveable perv. Most harmless person in the mythos.
Click to expand...

Well. Here's the thing. I'm inclined to go with the evidence we <have>, which is that the serial killers aren't wolves. I think SOV spelled that out pretty clearly and that it jives with what DocE apparently knows.

I'm hard-pressed to think of any other "groups" in the show other than the cops.

I considered maybe that SOV took one group from one season (namely, the Lumen season that had 4-5 serial rapists) and made them the wolves, but ... I dunno. Possible, but it doesn't feel right that he'd use characters from all seasons but limit the wolves to one.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (OPEN)
2 3 4
Replies
153
Views
8K
RespectTheChemistry
R
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mystery WW Signs Ups - Game Start May 25th
2
Replies
79
Views
3K
KayJayQueue
KayJayQueue
kaydubs
Melee WW Game Thread-April 2024
27 28 29 30 31
Replies
2K
Views
29K
Sandy Dikson
Sandy Dikson
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
48K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
35K
Clem J
Clem J
Top