WWonderful WWorld of MMeat Game Thread

[PotentiallyEvil]

---

Members don't see this ad.

if we could get some more thoughts from you about players in this game, that would be great.

I don't have much to say, honestly. I skimmed basically everything up to this point because I have been struggling to stay active. The only person who stood out to me was KC, because her posts have come across as a bit heated. It could be normal for her - I don't know because I don't know the playstyles of most of the people in here, her included - but it just didn't sit right with me.

Once again, I apologize for my inactivity and for not having much to say in contribution. This is only my second game on SDN, so I just need to get into the habit of visiting every day again and being more active. It probably sounds sketchy to some, but I swear it's the truth.

 

[PotentiallyEvil]

I agree, I didn't have a problem with KC voting for Trilt in itself, but the reasoning felt fake, and the defensiveness towards Pippy earlier was weird. Being defensive now makes more sense considering we're ~75 minutes from lynch close and she's in the lead, but I still feel okay leaving my vote where it is. If she does flip village I'm aware that doesn't make me look great, but FWIW I didn't realize that she was the only one accumulating votes when I voted there, I was on my phone and she is/was genuinely the person I have the most feels for.


I agree with this. I've never modded except for a speed game, but as a player I wouldn't be annoyed by lying, but by coming up with a scheme to get away with not really playing the game. Anyway, clearly not what was happening with Trilt at this point.


Like I said earlier, I've had some feels for you, not quite as much today but you're not off my radar. YK, bryndi and capri have had some odd comments, but that could just be noobiness. I can never read Finn, Pippy or Dubz well. I agree I'd like to hear more from PotE. Cray has been a lot quieter than yesterday, not sure if it's just real life stuff, intentionally just trying not to annoy people, or intentional because her fellow wolves told her to back off. Basically, there are multiple other people I could go for.


... I don't think Sporty is actually going to do anything to Mel, it was just a funny drawing.

I know she isn't - it was just a joke that fell flat. I probably should've used an emote or something to better indicate that, because this is the third response that took it serious, lol.

 

[LyraGardenia]

Gotta go to work will give more tonight, but will have to be after lynch unfortunately.

(Pssst, don't forget no strategizing during Meat Locker time, if it's after lynch close/the writeup it'll have to wait until morning)

 

[bryndiana.jones]

That means I'm twice as sure as my vote because you aren't familiar with your namesake.

So this is a joke vote then? Or do you have anything more concrete than that?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Unofficial D1 Ready to Kill Tally

Pippy () -
Snowy () -
Finny () -
Trilt () -
Kcough (5) - cray, Lyra, yk, PotE, MixyMama
Ski (3) - AM, Sporty, genny
Sporty () -
AM (1) - WZ
PotE (1) - kc
bryndi (5) - dds, Kara, Ski, finn, jboo
capri (1) - Mel
Cray (1) - bryndi

17/21
Not Voting:
3. allie
19. capri
Pippy
Snowy


Unofficial Tenderizing Tally

Cray (11) - karabou, am, dds, MixyMama, allie, yk, capri, Mel, Snowy, bryndi, genny
Mj (8) - cray, jboo, WZ, ski, kc, Lyra, Pippy, Sporty
Mel (1) - PotE

20/21

Deadline 8:30 mst (~ 1 hour)

 

[PippyPony]

Just read through the whole thread - I don't think Bryndi is a wolf either. Just am not getting that vibe.

There is still weirdness with KC in my mind but I am willing to take people's word on that for now.

Lynch AM

I thought she had a lot more content posts than she actually does.

 

[bryndiana.jones]

Fine with sporty now. I can get on the ski train.

unlynch sporty
lynch ski

Gotta go to work will give more tonight, but will have to be after lynch unfortunately.



Oh geez don't make a tie please

unlynch ski

This looks sketch to me, pops on to switch votes, then takes away her vote all-together and dips out. She had enough time to say she will be back later but not enough time to type up a quick explanation?

 

[SkiOtter]

I don't have much to say, honestly. I skimmed basically everything up to this point because I have been struggling to stay active. The only person who stood out to me was KC, because her posts have come across as a bit heated. It could be normal for her - I don't know because I don't know the playstyles of most of the people in here, her included - but it just didn't sit right with me.

Once again, I apologize for my inactivity and for not having much to say in contribution. This is only my second game on SDN, so I just need to get into the habit of visiting every day again and being more active. It probably sounds sketchy to some, but I swear it's the truth.

going back now and reading the thread instead skimming would probably help you find more than just one person that you find sketchy.
pls dont try and play the noob card, it doesnt work and will not be accepted. 🙂

 

[jaboo]

Random reads in no particular order

Sporty: as mentioned before, she's making a lot of sense to me tonight. Sporty's gameplay has remained an enigma to me in the few games I've played with her, so the fact that her vibes are matching my vibes right now is confusing to me. Need more content to decide, but currently leaning slightly village to me.

Cray: read villager to me before she disappeared midday. Going to put that aside for now considering her personal life. Will revisit later.

Mel: not reading sketchy to me thus far. But sketchy is mel's meta, from what I've heard. Will need to keep an eye on.

Capri: has been less active than usual. Setting off feels slightly. Keeping tabs on.

 

[PippyPony]

pls dont try and play the noob card, it doesnt work and will not be accepted. 🙂

Eh, some merchants around here accept it. I'll take it until it gets declined due to fraudulent activity

 

[bryndiana.jones]

@genny you mentioned something about an item, I'm guessing you got one, so would you mind sharing the description with us?

 

[Animal Midwife]

@genny you mentioned something about an item, I'm guessing you got one, so would you mind sharing the description with us?

I'm not seeing a reason for this.

 

[PippyPony]

Umm let me get this straight. You think she’s suspect because she’s doing something that is the opposite of what she did as a wolf? Wut?



Okay I was all geared up to tear this apart but I went back and looked at the voting before you placed your vote. Yeah some of them were joke votes, but there are others who were discussing and actually advocating for logical votes:






You still bug me, and I’m watching you. Do you have anything to add to the KC discussion or any suspicions on anyone?

Remind me again why cray's posts bug you?

 

[ddstothecor]

So this is a joke vote then? Or do you have anything more concrete than that?

It's more random than anything else.

 

[genny]

@genny you mentioned something about an item, I'm guessing you got one, so would you mind sharing the description with us?

What are you fishing for?

 

[PippyPony]

I'm not seeing a reason for this.

what's the reason against it?

 

[Animal Midwife]

what's the reason against it?

I'm against it.

 

[PippyPony]

It's more random than anything else.

Lovely.

 

[youngkal]

Yeah, just iso'd Bryndy and I recall her posting plenty more paragraph analyses on D1 in other games compared to this one.

lynch bryndy

ETA: Whoops,

Unlynch snowy first sorry

BJones did this last game too! I remember cause i was worried about it. I’m not saying write it off but i was thinking of watching it before i go near this again

 

[KCgophervet]

MOAR QUOTES INCOMING! (I did warn you all)

Oh don't get me wrong -- I know she would come up with sneaky sneaky lies. I have wolfed with her a few times and have seen her make some absurd claims very successfully (e.g. claiming to be chaos in the lion king).

I just don't think she would come up with that particular lie, or ever ghost as a tactic.

But I dunno, I could be wrong. I suppose we shall see eventually 😉

She is now 100% going to do this sometime in the future just because you said she wouldn't ...

And to break this down a little more --
Just because I'm still voting for you doesn't mean I'm not evaluating other people. Please check my posts if you are concerned about that.

...this?

Again, I didn't have a problem with the single vote for trilt in and of itself. I thought your wording felt strange; it is early game and is appropriate to use feels to evaluate people, and so I voted for you to see where that would lead.

And your first post in response to me was defensive (when you only had one vote -- which, by your own insistence of your single vote for trilt not being a big deal -- should not have been a big deal). And that has only escalated since then, so I am wondering if I hit a nerve and I'm inclined to stick with it for the time being.

I
My earlier quoting-post of our back and forth negates this statement entirely. At least from my perspective, we were joking around until you answered my question with a question.

I didnt read it as a role, I guess I have only seen it happen when players die and such to watch who you are PM-ing with. If you think its a player ability what would be the benefit? Do you think the person moving would be able to move themselves? Or do you think its a different player?

I’m gonna tag @kcoughli too cause she mentioned something about T moving and thinking it was playing, I think? There may have been some subtext I didnt get correctly

Benefit to player-moving ability in a game like this is to change up PM partners and disseminate/acquire information. The power of PMs is especially impressive in the right hands (see @Lupin21 for examples)

Might be a dumb question but are you asking this question because you actually want an answer? You seemed to imply in your previous post that you already knew what the results of the tenderizing were:

Yes I really wanted an answer. From Mel. See previous post about why I thought tenderizing was more than just "send noods gifs"

I want to know KC’s answer to my question before I form an opinion about her but I know I posted that just after she said she was leaving the thread for a bit to cool off. So I’ll wait.

See above

I've had a stoopidly busy day and am attempting to catch up...

I agree with pippy that KC's trilt vote felt... weird? and then her replies to pippy calling her out for it have made her seem more sketchy.

I'd also love to hear something/some more from several players including sporty and potE.

Cray seems like shes being quieter than normal and the last time she did that she was a wolf, but I'm willing to give the benefit of the doubt for a day considering real life stuffs

I disagree. Not really sure what else I can say.

So I somewhat agreed that most likely it was just frustration (although it did make me side eye) until this, which felt like a mini-rage quit moment.

I feel like my biggest suspicion based on the mostly fluff and mechanics discussion that has happened today is still KC, but I don't love how votes kinda piled on there. I'm just gonna give it few minutes to see what anyone else has to say before i throw a vote on that pile.

JFC. I just calmed down. Repeat after me: KC - does - not - rage - quit. Ever.

Okay. Sorry guys, I've been quiet simply because I'm not used to being here. Gotta get used to playing these games here. The only other game I played was the Winter Wonderland one, and that was my first ever.

Anyway, after skimming everything, I'm gonna tenderize Mel again, because he's gonna need it after what Sporty just did.

As for my lynch vote today, I'm gonna lynch KC because something about her posts today rubs me the wrong way. It's just kind of a gut feeling, which could totally turn out wrong, but my gut was right about a few people in my last game so we'll see what happens.

Oh, and Mel:

Spoiler: AAAAAHHHHHH

Was it your "gut feeling" or was it the nice bandwagon forming and a retaliatory vote? 🙄

lynch KC

I am not all that convinced she's a woof but I have more reasons for her than I can come up with for anyone else.

Please, do share those reasons. Because I haven't heard any from you other than me sounding like a frustrated villager until I "rage quit".

Tenderize vote was confirmed to just be for fun. It was a joke that apparently didn't land.

Yes, I'm aware of that now. I was not when I "complained" about it this morning.

I also assumed it was a contest and was terribly disappointed when it wasnt something that could be won (even if the prize is just the acknowledgement that you won)

Because we are the same person.

I agree, I didn't have a problem with KC voting for Trilt in itself, but the reasoning felt fake, and the defensiveness towards Pippy earlier was weird. Being defensive now makes more sense considering we're ~75 minutes from lynch close and she's in the lead, but I still feel okay leaving my vote where it is. If she does flip village I'm aware that doesn't make me look great, but FWIW I didn't realize that she was the only one accumulating votes when I voted there, I was on my phone and she is/was genuinely the person I have the most feels for.
.

Spoiler

Edit: ty @SkiOtter

 

[PippyPony]

I'm against it.

...but it's (supposedly) an item? Generally items do not require secrecy?

 

[SkiOtter]

Because we are the same person.

This is true.
And spoiler tag click the little plus button by the film strip

 

[Animal Midwife]

...but it's (supposedly) an item? Generally items do not require secrecy?

Secrecy is OP.

 

[WildZoo]

I'm against it.

AM has decreed, therefore we must obey

 

[PippyPony]

@kcoughli what are your thoughts on Ski and Finn

 

[youngkal]

@genny you mentioned something about an item, I'm guessing you got one, so would you mind sharing the description with us?

I feel like if @genny is gonna post about it she should expect some more questions about it. If you don’t want to share than don’t poke the bear by posting about it

 

[PippyPony]

~ Reserved for Table of Contents ~

Hey head butcher - can we get these updated por favor?

 

[genny]

I feel like if @genny is gonna post about it she should expect some more questions about it. If you don’t want to share than don’t poke the bear by posting about it

Did you just call BJ a bear?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Unofficial D1 Ready to Kill Tally

Pippy () -
Snowy () -
Finny () -
Trilt () -
Kcough (5) - cray, Lyra, yk, PotE, MixyMama
Ski (3) - AM, Sporty, genny
Sporty () -
AM (2) - WZ, Pippy
PotE (1) - kc
bryndi (5) - dds, Kara, Ski, finn, jboo
capri (1) - Mel
Cray (1) - bryndi

18/21
Not Voting:
3. allie
19. capri
Snowy


Unofficial Tenderizing Tally

Cray (11) - karabou, am, dds, MixyMama, allie, yk, capri, Mel, Snowy, bryndi, genny
Mj (8) - cray, jboo, WZ, ski, kc, Lyra, Pippy, Sporty
Mel (1) - PotE

20/21

Deadline 8:30 mst (45 minutes)

 

[KCgophervet]

@kcoughli what are your thoughts on Ski and Finn

Cannot evaluate fairly at the moment. Am too grateful for support from those two to give unbiased opinion. Meaning to say they feel warm fuzzy village to me right now but I may be a victim of subtle pocketing.

Same goes for almost everyone right now, very few unbiased opinions. Seeing red (and feeling the need to defend self) all day today =/= good evaluations.

 

[KCgophervet]

Oh hey look a tie.

Unlynch Potty
Lynch bryndi

Purely self-preservation.

 

[WildZoo]

AM (2) - WZ, AM

Are you voting for yourself AM?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Are you voting for yourself AM?

I guess I am.

 

[bryndiana.jones]

What are you fishing for?

I'm just trying to gather information, the game I played with lots of items people would post what they did or how they worked.

 

[Crayola227]

I'm not feeling a KC lynch, I disagreed with her reasoning behind her original Trilt/Genny vote, but I don't think it's worth lynching her over. Cray has been pretty quiet comparatively to her last couple of games, so this might be a red flag. In the monster mash game she seemed off to me for similar reasons, her posts just seemed different to me, she wasn't posting as much, and she was wolfing. Cray may be where I place my vote. Pippy always stresses me out because she is such an excellent wolf, but I don't currently have much on her besides her back and forth with KC (perhaps a distraction?).

lynch Cray

(I know I voted to tenderized you as well, I wanted to show the love but also think you are acting like your wolfy self.)

kay, been playing for a few years now, maybe not more than 10 games, now, and 2 wolf outs only in the not distant past

you don't really know my village or wolf meta to say what you're saying

others have thrown suspicions, but this feels like the most out and out lying I've seen on here besides from Finn maybe

hedgy af, this feels like a wolf post and a throwaway vote

my most recent posts have been highly edited to say as little as possible because I am don't with shyte

so be prepared for everything for me to read totally different
or not, if I get pissed or excited or forget or something

 

[SkiOtter]

Are you voting for yourself AM?

Lis rule?!

 

[KCgophervet]

Thoughts (potentially admittedly biased by how today has gone):
1. Weim's, Pot's, and Lyra's justifications for me feel forced/fake. Particularly Lyra's.
2. AM is actually reminding me of her play while wolfing last game (when ski and I hydra'd), not as many questions, all the tallies
3. Has WZ posted much besides fluff? I thought she was going to keep those willies away from me...
4. I feel like genny said enough that needs to be said about the item. It doesn't bother me that people are asking about it though.

 

[youngkal]

Did you just call BJ a bear?

Lol not her specifically more like anyone on the thread but lol

 

[Crayola227]

unlynch KC

lynch BJ

Not really feeling the KC lynch now that others have jumped on. I've been asleep and have 3 pages to catch up on. Been skimming. I might not be fully informed, maybe this is retaliation, but in one post BJ has been sketchier to me than anything going on with KC so far so I'mma hop off that wagon.

 

[genny]

I'm just trying to gather information, the game I played with lots of items people would post what they did or how they worked.

... which is what I said. It's an item for movement, with an added bonus. The person who needed to know what that bonus was got the message, I think. Either you're being noobfully obtuse or you're doing some wolfy fishing.

 

[bryndiana.jones]

kay, been playing for a few years now, maybe not more than 10 games, now, and 2 wolf outs only in the not distant past

you don't really know my village or wolf meta to say what you're saying

others have thrown suspicions, but this feels like the most out and out lying I've seen on here besides from Finn maybe

hedgy af, this feels like a wolf post and a throwaway vote

my most recent posts have been highly edited to say as little as possible because I am don't with shyte

so be prepared for everything for me to read totally different
or not, if I get pissed or excited or forget or something

I never said I had a good meta on you at all, but I have to use the information that I have, with that being said, I guess I'll

lynch KC

Not because I think you're a wolf, but for self prez

 

[PippyPony]

I feel like bryndi is noob defending right now, and I am uncomfortable with the speed the lynch has swapped to her.

Have literally no evidence she is a villager, do not take this as anything resembling an actual vouch. But...this just feels off to me.

 

[bryndiana.jones]

I never said I had a good meta on you at all, but I have to use the information that I have, with that being said, I guess I'll

lynch KC

Not because I think you're a wolf, but for self prez

Did this wrong
unlynch Cray
lynch KC

 

[finnickthedog]

others have thrown suspicions, but this feels like the most out and out lying I've seen on here besides from Finn maybe

I don't currently have much reason to think you're a wolf, but I find it funny that you complain about someone mischaracterizing what you said but have no problem turning around and doing it to someone else. In no way have I "out and out" lied nor "twisted your words" as you said earilier. I may have interpreted your words in a way you didn't intend, but I don't read your mind so misinterpretations are bound to happen. I perceived your posts as asking why multiple times. That's not an unfair reading. You clarified you weren't actually asking repeatedly. I dropped it. So why casually sit there and make it seem like I was playing shady earlier and intentionally trying to make you look bad? Not appreciating it.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Unofficial D1 Ready to Kill Tally

Pippy () -
Snowy () -
Finny () -
Trilt () -
Kcough (5) - Lyra, yk, PotE, MixyMama, bryndi
Ski (3) - AM, Sporty, genny
Sporty () -
AM (2) - WZ, Pippy
PotE () -
bryndi (7) - dds, Kara, Ski, finn, jboo, kc, Cray
capri (1) - Mel
Cray () -

18/21
Not Voting:
3. allie
19. capri
Snowy


Unofficial Tenderizing Tally

Cray (11) - karabou, am, dds, MixyMama, allie, yk, capri, Mel, Snowy, bryndi, genny
Mj (8) - cray, jboo, WZ, ski, kc, Lyra, Pippy, Sporty
Mel (1) - PotE

20/21

Deadline 8:30 mst (30 minutes)

 

[finnickthedog]

I feel like bryndi is noob defending right now, and I am uncomfortable with the speed the lynch has swapped to her.

Have literally no evidence she is a villager, do not take this as anything resembling an actual vouch. But...this just feels off to me.

I'll be honest and tell you I have no good reason for thinking Bryndi is a wolf. I just also have no good reason to think she is a villager so it's hard to put my vote somewhere else right now.

 

[capri1722]

KC, thanks for responding to me. Hope you’re feeling better now. 🙂

Not feeling a KC lynch.

Would be ok with a Bryndy lynch.

Skimmed to catch up. Can’t be on much right now, at a study group for my take home exam. Anyone know anything about physical biochemistry?

Lynch Bryndy

 

[allieh8607]

Wowza that was a lot to catch up on.

lynch youngkal

I know people were pressing you to come up with legit reasons to vote rather than RNG, but your reasons for voting KC just seemed soo forced and like you were trying way too hard to come up with unique reasons for her that other people hadn't mentioned yet. I'm not particularly feeling the KC or Bryndi votes right now. KC reads as frustrated villager to me after reading her explanation for the tenderizing confusion, and I know that feeling all too well. So I'm willing to focus elsewhere, plus several people have spoken up about not feeling good about her lynch so for now I'd like to trust those reads.

 

[SkiOtter]

I feel like bryndi is noob defending right now, and I am uncomfortable with the speed the lynch has swapped to her.

Have literally no evidence she is a villager, do not take this as anything resembling an actual vouch. But...this just feels off to me.

I'll be honest and tell you I have no good reason for thinking Bryndi is a wolf. I just also have no good reason to think she is a villager so it's hard to put my vote somewhere else right now.

me as well. i feel like kc is village and i was the next highest option when i placed my vote, so this is where i ended up.

 

[PippyPony]

I'll be honest

...as opposed to how you usually interact with me? 😉