2008-2009 Columbia College of P&S Secondary Application Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Hi, I'm curious if anyone else who sent a thank you card to their interviewer received a snail mail response. (Trying to figure out if its a good sign 🙂 )

Also, I interviewed here on the early side and they didn't have folders/student handbooks ready to give us, so I'm also curious if they have those ready yet (they said they'd send it to us by snail mail but I haven't received yet).

Thanks!
 
Hey Guys,

So I am interviewing at Columbia on Wednesday and I have a question about the questions they asked. I checked the interview feedback page and it seems like the interviews have been pretty chill. However, I just spoke to a TA (MD/PhD candidate) of mine and she said that when she interviewed at Columbia, they grilled her with ethical questions. Was this the case for anyone else?

Good luck to everyone!
 
Hey Guys,

So I am interviewing at Columbia on Wednesday and I have a question about the questions they asked. I checked the interview feedback page and it seems like the interviews have been pretty chill. However, I just spoke to a TA (MD/PhD candidate) of mine and she said that when she interviewed at Columbia, they grilled her with ethical questions. Was this the case for anyone else?

Good luck to everyone!

I definitely didn't get any ethical questions.
 
Last edited:
Same with mine -- no ethical questions at all. All questions were about my experiences and my family. My interviewer did seem curious what other schools I was applying to in NY, but he didn't press for specifics (and I think he just wanted to know because I'm living in NY and I volunteer at Mt. Sinai). Also, the other students on my interview day said their interviews were very relaxed as well.
 
Hi, I'm curious if anyone else who sent a thank you card to their interviewer received a snail mail response. (Trying to figure out if its a good sign 🙂 )

Also, I interviewed here on the early side and they didn't have folders/student handbooks ready to give us, so I'm also curious if they have those ready yet (they said they'd send it to us by snail mail but I haven't received yet).

Thanks!

I sent a thank you email to my interviewer (so he would get it sooner) and a thank you card to the dean for inviting me to interview. Apparently personalized responses to correspondence is standard fare at Columbia. In fact, one of the students at my interview said to not read into any responses you receive from them because people try to figure it out every year and it has no correlation to admissions decisions. Sorry if that's not what you wanted to here.

Also, the student handbooks are ready. We received them on my interview date (10/8) so they should be on their way to you shortly. We didn't get a folder or anything, but the student handbook has more than enough information about the school. The handbook is also available online at this website.

Hey Guys,

So I am interviewing at Columbia on Wednesday and I have a question about the questions they asked. I checked the interview feedback page and it seems like the interviews have been pretty chill. However, I just spoke to a TA (MD/PhD candidate) of mine and she said that when she interviewed at Columbia, they grilled her with ethical questions. Was this the case for anyone else?

Good luck to everyone!

Most of the applicants on my interview day said their interviews were very laid back and conversational. One of the applicants said that he was asked a few ethical questions but they weren't too difficult to get through. My interview was incredibly low-stress - my interviewer basically told me all about Columbia and what makes it so great. He only asked me a few questions throughout the entire interview.
 
and a thank you card to the dean for inviting me to interview.

why did you send one to the dean? did you talk to him at length or something? i didnt know this was standard...
 
why did you send one to the dean? did you talk to him at length or something? i didnt know this was standard...

I sent one to him because I just felt really really thankful and honored to have been invited and I wanted to show my appreciation. In addition, my entire visit left such a positive impression on me, due to the awesome students I met and the accomodating admissions staff, and I wanted to let him know how much I appreciated the hospitality.

It's definiitely not standard to do this, I wanted to do something to show my appreciation. :shrug:
 
Last edited:
what days of the week does columbia interview on? and has anyone sent an "im going to be in the area..." email?
 
what days of the week does columbia interview on? and has anyone sent an "im going to be in the area..." email?

I'm pretty sure they interview M-F. To interview 1200 people each cycle (and considering there were only 6 there on my interview day) it would certainly make sense.

I also sent a "going to be in the area" email on 8/25 when I received my invite to AECOM. I was complete on 9/10 and was invited for interview on 9/22.

Good luck! :luck:
 
I swear I see awkward twitchy people in suits walking around campus every single weekday.

I assume these are interviewees. 🙂
 
I swear I see awkward twitchy people in suits walking around campus every day of the week.

I assume these are interviewees. 🙂


:laugh: You're probably right. I know I'm that way on interview day.
 
So opinion question... My computer had a tragic accident a few weeks ago and was broken effectively deleting my 2 remaining applications, one of which was Columbia. Do you think it's worth applying now or should I just save my money? (I applied to 15 other schools before October.)
 
non-rolling and it started giving out interviews later. i say go for it.
 
I'm pretty sure they interview M-F. To interview 1200 people each cycle (and considering there were only 6 there on my interview day) it would certainly make sense.

I also sent a "going to be in the area" email on 8/25 when I received my invite to AECOM. I was complete on 9/10 and was invited for interview on 9/22.

Good luck! :luck:

so... what did you write on your 'area' email? ps ur avatar cracks me up 😀
 
And did you just send it to psadmissions?
 
So opinion question... My computer had a tragic accident a few weeks ago and was broken effectively deleting my 2 remaining applications, one of which was Columbia. Do you think it's worth applying now or should I just save my money? (I applied to 15 other schools before October.)

Go for it, dude. Some of my classmates submitted in October... some possibly later?
 
so... what did you write on your 'area' email? ps ur avatar cracks me up 😀

I basically just said that I would be in the area on a certain date for another interview and that I would appreciate it if they could let me know if there is an interview forthcoming so I could save on my travel expenses. When I received my invite it was an email and they let me schedule the date myself (most applicants receive a snail mail invite with an assigned date).

And I'm glad you get a kick out of my tap-dancer, although I've been thinking about changing my avatar for a while now...

And did you just send it to psadmissions?

Yes.
 
what days of the week does columbia interview on? and has anyone sent an "im going to be in the area..." email?

Good question, anyone? I am also considering sending one of these emails.
 
I got a "complete" email despite not having sent my picture. If they're willing to mark me complete without the picture, what role does the picture play? Or is this just a really bad sign re: my odds of interview at Columbia?
 
I got a "complete" email despite not having sent my picture. If they're willing to mark me complete without the picture, what role does the picture play? Or is this just a really bad sign re: my odds of interview at Columbia?
I think they want a picture before you interview (that is, if you interview). But it doesn't really matter before then.
 
I got a "complete" email despite not having sent my picture. If they're willing to mark me complete without the picture, what role does the picture play? Or is this just a really bad sign re: my odds of interview at Columbia?

As far as I know, the picture is just a security measure:

The admissions office wants to make sure that the person who took the MCAT is the person who applied is the person interviewing.
 
Does anyone know if Columbia interviews on Tuesdays? I got an invite to Columbia with a set date but will have to reschedule. I already have another interview in the NYC area on a Monday, so I was hoping to go to both in the same trip. Thanks!
 
Does anyone know if Columbia interviews on Tuesdays? I got an invite to Columbia with a set date but will have to reschedule. I already have another interview in the NYC area on a Monday, so I was hoping to go to both in the same trip. Thanks!

Yes.
 
Any cheap hotels nearby Columbia?

I'm looking for around $100.

I appreciate any help. 😀


Dr.oo😀
 
Any cheap hotels nearby Columbia?

I'm looking for around $100.

I appreciate any help. 😀


Dr.oo😀

For that price, you're probably going to be stuck with a communal bathroom (although you will get a private room). You might want to check out the Days Hotel (on W. 94th at Broadway). Their rates seem to fluctuate quite a bit depending on the dates of your stay, but I've stayed there for about $150 before.

Why don't you stay with a student host? I'm not sure if they have an official program or anything, but one of my fellow interviewees spent the night before with a student in Bard Hall. I would suggest emailing or calling the admissions office if you're interested in this. Good luck! :luck:
 
yeah, cheap hotels in manhattan are a problem.. unless you want to be in the depths of harlem, like malcolm x blvd and 110th or something
 
Sounds good! Thanks for the tip! 😀

I actually don't have an interview with Columbia. I have an interview AT Columbia for BGU-CU MSIH. It's a great program! 😀
 
I LOVED this school. Would do anything for an acceptance in March! Crossing fingers! 😀
 
When is the earliest that Columbia will notify of a post-secondary rejection? I was complete around mid-late August.
 
I've been complete since July 9! should i try emailing them to see what the status of my app is?
 
can you tellme about the program?

I'll take this is if you don't mind, since I don't think anyone else has.

The students all seemed very happy. The first years I talked to agreed that they have more free time now than they did during undergrad. Keep in mind they aren't doing research, but they are participating in clubs and working in a clinic at least 4 hours per week.

I get the impression there are lots of athletic people in the class. The students students definitely have work/fun balance down. It's pass/fail the first two years, and people send out outlines and study guides to the class constantly.

The school is most notable for matching into surgery. I was told that at a particular ortho residency (I think), they bring in 4 residents a year and last year 3 were Columbia grads. One cool thing they have going is a magic pager which goes off when a transplant surgeon is headed out to harvest the organs and bring them back for a transplant. Apparently, no other schools have anything like this for first years.

So great people, great program. Bard Hall, where most first years will live, along with all other health students (including nurses, dentists, etc.) is old and has communal bathrooms and showers, but the rent is very reasonable. The neighborhood is probably middle-lower class, and mostly(?) Dominican. It may not look great, but apparently it's safe and there is plenty of awesome Dominican food around.

The staff all seems really friendly and great, and in that way mirrors the student body. During the interview day they post a list of schools people are interviewing from, so lots of students drop by to see who's from their alma mater, and others come in just to say hi and to grab some free coffee.

I hope this is helpful. I know being there cleared up a lot of things for me, and made me very excited for the school. Ask questions if you have 'em.

EDIT: I've been told Yale also has a similar magic pager.
 
Last edited:
I've been complete since July 9! should i try emailing them to see what the status of my app is?
lol i was complete around mid July too! who knows what they've been doing with our apps, probably making paper airplanes with them 😀
 
I think Columbia is one of the schools that issues no official decisions until March.
 
i dont really understand when school says they're non-rolling, i guess i kind of do, but to me it seems like everything is rolling.

for schools that says they're non-rolling, do they like interview all the applicants n then put them in a separate pile and then when like a month before announcement day in march they get together n pick the hundred something. if they did do this then they need to spend a decent amount of time on it right before march xx and doesnt seem like they meet all that much or would meet all that much making the decisions even hasty if they interview up to 1000 people.

i dont know but to me that seems unlikely. it's hard to make a case for the applicant you interviewed if it was like 4 months ago and even if u did type up notes for it, the image is not as vivid as someone u interviewed a week ago. since everyone on the adcom votes or something. to me it seems like they review apps and prolly have a quota each time for how many to accept or something and the decision come out all at once is their definition of non-rolling? i m not sure just dont realli understand how they can put an app aside for as long as 4 months or more and make a good case about it and hard to believe that if they had adcom mtgs once a week that they dont talk about the applicants. just a thought, prolly wrong thou


to comment on what people say about admisions. I interviewed with the dean of diversity dr hutcherson who was amazing. Anyway she told me firsthand that the admissions committee does not even look at applications until february. all at the same time. To give everyone a fair shot. They are reviewed twice before final descisions are mailed out in march. Just thought I should throw that out there for those who were curious
 
Hey all,

I just got an interview at Columbia!

I am concerned, however, since I got it via snail mail with no email whatsoever (and nothing on the status page) (Yes, it is actually MY NAME on the letter!!)

Anyway - anyone else had this happen? I checked the website and the email address they have is correct...
 
Hey all,

I just got an interview at Columbia!

I am concerned, however, since I got it via snail mail with no email whatsoever (and nothing on the status page) (Yes, it is actually MY NAME on the letter!!)

Anyway - anyone else had this happen? I checked the website and the email address they have is correct...


I only received a surface mail as well, no email. I called them to re-schedule it and they acknowledged that I was, in fact, invited. So don't worry.
 
Hey all,

I just got an interview at Columbia!

I am concerned, however, since I got it via snail mail with no email whatsoever (and nothing on the status page) (Yes, it is actually MY NAME on the letter!!)

Anyway - anyone else had this happen? I checked the website and the email address they have is correct...

In general, I think most applicants get a snail mail interview invite only. Mine was different (email invite), probably because I sent them an email letting them know I'd be in the area on a specific date, and they were nice enough to let me schedule the interview rather than assigning my date for me. At my interview day I asked the other interviewees how they were notified of their invite, and all of them said that it was by snail mail only.
 
Thanks for the response..that's interesting..Do you know of any other schools that do this? If something gets lost in the mail, then you could be out of luck..
 
Thanks for the response..that's interesting..Do you know of any other schools that do this? If something gets lost in the mail, then you could be out of luck..

You could also be out of luck if your mother doesn't tell you about the small, white envelope because she assumes it's a rejection and doesn't want you to be sad. Not speaking from personal experience or anything...

I agree they should send emails as well.
 
Thanks for the response..that's interesting..Do you know of any other schools that do this? If something gets lost in the mail, then you could be out of luck..

hahah, I don't think I wanna hear that right now...or any of us for that matter. LOL
 
Once you've received your interview invite you have to confirm your scheduled date, so I'm sure if the admissions office doesn't hear from you after sending out the invite they will attempt to contact you via other means (phone or email).
 
hey, for those of you that just got interview invites, when did you send in your secondary? i've been complete for about a month and i'm anxious! although i know it's probably still too soon =/
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top