Aright thats fair enough haha!
OK- I need to find out more about the residency situation for AF. It seems that this the major drawback for AF that people cite, but I am having difficulty finding more info. Are there any students at USUHS who could put me in touch with an AF student? Does anybody on this forum know more?
What I have found out so far is that AF has the least number of spots in residencies in general, and particularly for the higher demand ones. How bad IS the situation? Does a significant percentage of seniors not get their chosen specialty, and if not, do they tend to settle for other specialties or do they go GMO and try again? Do they try again 1 year or 2 years later?
So many questions... If anybody has answers please feel free to share. But if you don't, it'd be great if you could PM me an email address for an AF doc or AF student. Thanks!
Google Military GME and you will find the website that lists the exact number of spots and the match stats for specialties for recent years.
From talking to people at USUHS, on SDN and my AMEDD HPSP recruiter as well as Milgme.com, here is how it works with residencies in the different services.
AF: smallest number of spots BUT 2nd smallest use of GMO, (much less than Navy, but more than Army).
AF is more likely to give you a civilian deferment,(alot of their residency spots are acutally civilian programs). If your specialty is highly competative, ie Derm, Ortho, EM or Anesthesiology, then you may end up spending 2 years doing Flight Surgery, (AF GMO), for Primary care, ie FM, Peds, Neuro, IM, Psych, its very rare.
Navy: Overall I have heard that 2/3 of total Navy med students end up doing GMO (not positive on this stat but its very high), less so for primary care specialties but still much higher than AF or Army, (where primary care almost never end up GMO). For competative specialties you are almost guaranteed GMO before you get it.
Army: Biggest branch by far and this results in almost no GMOs for Primary care and the less competative specialties. GMOs do occure for the more competative specialties but especially for surgical ones (my AMEDD recruiter told me Ortho has the worst of it).
What I love about the Army is that they actually have the the ratio of applicants/spot for all specialties from 2003-2007. This one spread sheet is what sealed the deal for me in making the switch from Navy to Army.
From this spreadsheet you can see the average ratio of applicants/spot is not that bad, even for specialties that are super competative in other branches or the civilian world.
For example, Derm is about 1.5 applicants/spot in Army, EM is 1.2, Diagnostic Rads is 1.25, Path 1.4, Ortho 1.6 but Neurosurgery is actually only .9.
Things like FM, IM, Neuro, Peds and Psych are all 1 or less meaning that everyone who applies for these residencies gets them.
If GMO is a concern for you then the branches rank as such, in terms of your probability of having to do one.
Navy>>>AF>>Army
Of course, if you've already interviewed and stated your branch preference I am not sure if you are allowed to change your mind and switch to another service. At the very least it would piss off the good folks at USUHS as they are busy filling up the class and organizing the waitlist and alternate list.