Feel the same way. I loved the school...any more opinions on Rochester from people who lived there/near there? (the one above was helpful)
I have lived in Rochester for 4 years and here is my breakdown for everyone curious:
Area: The area right around the Rochester campus is not very great or very bad.. And that is because the school is there and security is very good. Its not somewhere where you would stumble around at 3 AM, but at the same time its quite safe and during the day you can go running and walking just about anywhere. The campus is quite nice and safe. The plus side of this is that you get cheap housing and the bad side is that when your friends come and visit, Rochester as a city is not going to blow them away.
Weather: This is a legitimate concern... some years, the first snow will be in October and the last snow will be in May. Summers are incredibly nice in Rochester but the winter is long and grueling. Its definitely better than Buffalo and Syracuse in my opinion, but the cold is there for awhile. You get used to it, however. The worst part is really that it rains and is overcast for most of the winter, and that can get really old really fast. I can't tell you how to feel about the weather, but you will definitely get into some winter sports! There are ski resorts within about an hour (Bristol) and like previous posters have said, you can go to Buffalo for a day trip pretty easily
Nightlife: The school itself (and the med school) seem to have a lot of opportunities to do things, and Rochester itself does have some activities. However, if you are into sports, there are not really any professional teams (Red Wings are semi pro baseball Amerks are semi pro hockey and the Rhinos are semi pro soccer).. Bars are cheap, but you'll find yourself frequenting the same ones again and again (isn't this true of anywhere?).. If you are into the fine arts or theater, its no NYC, but you can find ways to occupy yourself and there are plays and concerts through Eastman which is the school of music. If you have a question about a specific type of activity I can try to answer that directly.
Community Service: If you are into global health or free clinic duty, Rochester has a huge refugee population and poor community.. I won't dwell on this, but some people looking for global health opportunities think you have to go into the city and that is just not true.
Overall: IMO, Rochester is a smaller city and it isnt going to blow you away.. It is what you make of it... generally people follow the trend of hating it for a few months, then loving it, and finally growing a little tired of the same scene after a few years. Strong is an awesome hospital (as you have all seen) and for the free time you will have, you can find plenty to do at Rochester. If you have any questions let me know, but hope this helps.