Carry on My WWayward Son - Supernatural WW Signups and Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Lupin21 said:
You're making me want a sub sammich.
Click to expand...
Who's the other bread? Dy? :naughty: @WildZoo

aWaWe.gif
 
Day 4 - We Have Work For You Lynch Tally

PBC (5) - raf, Ferny, lupachei, sobsob, vmh
BBC (1) - PBC
ski (1) - hyge

A disturbing lack of ties...and a disturbing lack of new votes
Waffles: 1
7/14 votes

Lynch deadline...7.5ish hours (9pm EST)

f652a497044b1e1cf558ecf9671ebaab.gif
 
Last edited:
WildZoo said:
Day 4 - We Have Work For You Lynch Tally

PBC (4) - raf, Ferny, lupachei, sobsob, vmh
BBC (1) - PBC
ski (1) - hyge

A disturbing lack of ties...and a disturbing lack of new votes
Waffles: 1
6/14 votes

Lynch deadline...7.5ish hours (9pm EST)

f652a497044b1e1cf558ecf9671ebaab.gif
Click to expand...
***********
I wanted to like this post but thought people might interpret it as strategy so instead I'll just say I appreciate this gif
***********
 
I don't want to forget the info we got from Gabriel, which may be bad, but 1/3 has already borne out.

- DocE had something up his sleeve worth being careful of
- PBC: "one powerful creature" who should not be bet against
- STL: hideous creature who wants both sides to lose

Both PBC and STL are described as creatures...fishy.
 
hygebeorht said:
For example: the Colt, which can kill almost anything.

Seriously, has anyone had any items yet at all?
Click to expand...
Yeah, but that could be used by anyone, no? I thought Cdo was asking about just a general hunter-only gun

And two people have gotten items. First one was Dad's Diary, written by the mods. Second was written last night by me. I don't know when people have to use my items, but if they have to use them immediately, then someone should be able to back up the diary. Since I don't know who got it, I don't really want to say what it was unless I have to.
 
StartingoverVet said:
If I were a seer, I would look into the under the radar people. RAF and SARS. Mainly because if you are a noob wolf with DocE you aren't going to say much or do much....you would defer to him I would think.
Click to expand...
Hey now, not a disease 😉

SkiOtter said:
Yeah, I know. I could have not told you this part at all and just left it, but I'm trying to be honest. I knew everyone would find it sketchy, but I put it out there anyway because it's kind of an important distinction if you knew what the actual item was. I don't know when my items have to be used (like if they have to use them within the next cycle or if they can save it and use it whenever during the game, mods wouldn't tell me when I asked, just got shrugging gifs back, thanks Subs) so I'm a bit wary of revealing what the item was.

It does when you have to find some object from the supernatural series that you could stretch to fit what you want it to do. My original attempt apparently was too far from what that object actually is used for, so it was rejected. At this point, I've seen maybe 8 episodes. I don't know the majority of the objects that are present in the series and had to google a list of spn objects and just start clicking links and reading.

Edit: spelling
Click to expand...

At first I read through this and didn't believe it because it seems unfair because if I'd gotten that role I'd literally make nothing every night because I've never seen an episode of supernatural in my life. But then I reconsidered and actually do think this sounds very villagery along with other things Ski has said.

As for items in general, I haven't received any.

I'm not sure about a lot of the discussion today since it has been so Supernatural-related but I'm trying to keep up with it all. For now, going to also

Lynch PBC

Since I've had wolf points for her since D1, and her defense has given me no reason to go elsewhere at this point. However, I also think that the STL/BBC thing needs to be cracked at some point. I do have village points for BBC though so I'm leaning towards a village win chaos or neutral there if we do think she is Crowley, simply based on my reads and not lore at all.
 
Ok then. Ski can have another day. I am tempted to jump on PBC but need to do more reading. Not on my phone though. My computer needs to charge. ***unlynch ski***
 
dyachei said:
this is super freaking wolfy if PBC does flip wolf.
Click to expand...
If you say so. No one has gainsaid my night cancel.

I have been super active on thread. The wolves have lost two powerful roles already. Wouldn't a smart wolf lay a little lower? Be a little less sketchy?

Both PBC and Ski are suspicious but the vote is solidly on PBC at the moment. I need to reread, analyze vote patterns.
 
hygebeorht said:
If you say so. No one has gainsaid my night cancel.

I have been super active on thread. The wolves have lost two powerful roles already. Wouldn't a smart wolf lay a little lower? Be a little less sketchy?

Both PBC and Ski are suspicious but the vote is solidly on PBC at the moment. I need to reread, analyze vote patterns.
Click to expand...
you do get that this will be the 2nd time you've held off on voting a wolf if PBC flips wolf, right? you don't see why that's wolfy?

and yes, no one has said anything about the night cancel which is why I'm not voting you. but damn, you've got to see how sketchtastic this is
 
dyachei said:
you do get that this will be the 2nd time you've held off on voting a wolf if PBC flips wolf, right? you don't see why that's wolfy?

and yes, no one has said anything about the night cancel which is why I'm not voting you. but damn, you've got to see how sketchtastic this is
Click to expand...
I get that. But I'd rather be thoughtful and join a wolf vote late, than be hasty and bandwagon a villager just so I don't look sketchy.
 
SummerTheLynx said:
So those familiar with lore, thoughts on a person that has "pets" available to them that they command to carry out their night actions?
Click to expand...
hygebeorht said:
Crowley the demon has hellhounds at his beck and call and they do his bidding. Anyone else with ideas other than that?

Generally, hellhounds are invisible to humans if that helps. You'd hear them, feel their breath, etc.
Click to expand...
Agree with this assessment. Lucifer also has control of the hounds if he's free, but Crowley would be the guy if not. And we've already had hellhound activity confirmed by multiple people.
 
Of note, Cas is the only angel/demon to ever be resurrected- generally their souls seem to be obliterated. Dead then back then dead for good... Sounds like Sam and Dean's dad. Can't think of anyone else off the top of my head that fits the bill.
 
Mad Jack said:
Cas was dead then back then dead then back.
Click to expand...
If you think reeealllly hard and re-read the writeups you'll understand why PBC is not Cas.

Also, on second thought, I doubt PBC is Dean. Sam's only ability was PMing with his brother. It would be weird for Dean to be able to PM Sam AND dodge a lynch.
 
Mad Jack said:
Of note, Cas is the only angel/demon to ever be resurrected- generally their souls seem to be obliterated. Dead then back then dead for good... Sounds like Sam and Dean's dad. Can't think of anyone else off the top of my head that fits the bill.
Click to expand...
Agreed. I bet John was the other shadowy figure in the truck...
 
hygebeorht said:
No. But it could count for Dean, although he has died and come back a few more times than that. It's possible PBC is Dean.
Click to expand...
My question is would it make sense for Dean to have additional powers given that Sam's ability was just being able to PM with his brother? That seemed like it could be a Mason role when I read the Sam description in Jil's death write up. Given that both died and came back multiple times in the series it would have made more sense to me for both to have a death avoidance rather than just the one.
 
hygebeorht said:
If you think reeealllly hard and re-read the writeups you'll understand why PBC is not Cas.

Also, on second thought, I doubt PBC is Dean. Sam's only ability was PMing with his brother. It would be weird for Dean to be able to PM Sam AND dodge a lynch.
Click to expand...
Oh, I was saying why PBC didn't fit for Cas- he's never been dead for good, he was being punished with life.
 
Well, if PBC is John with the power of one death avoidance, that sort of makes sense.

It would be a good lie, too. But I feel like a wolf would have been paying much closer attention to the vote last night than PBC did, especially since wolves are already down 2 strong wolf roles. Only a villager who doesn't particularly fear a lynch would have been so casual. Wouldn't a wolf have fought harder? Wolves are losing their members fast.

Still rereading and thinking.
 
hygebeorht said:
Well, if PBC is John with the power of one death avoidance, that sort of makes sense.

It would be a good lie, too. But I feel like a wolf would have been paying much closer attention to the vote last night than PBC did, especially since wolves are already down 2 strong wolf roles. Only a villager who doesn't particularly fear a lynch would have been so casual. Wouldn't a wolf have fought harder? Wolves are losing their members fast.

Still rereading and thinking.
Click to expand...
I honestly don't know if I buy it anyway. My rule in WW has always been if it doesn't die, kill it again, I'm not breaking it regardless of the role claim because 80% of the time that's a role that's going to flip wolf. If we're wrong, we're wrong, but it's better than being fools if it turns out PBC isn't a wolf and we let her walk.

Lynch PBC
 
Lynch PBC

With all the weird comments from last night (not being around but catching up but posting 5 minutes before close) and the way she was defending this morning and the lynch avoidance. It just doesn't make sense to be
 
Mad Jack said:
I honestly don't know if I buy it anyway. My rule in WW has always been if it doesn't die, kill it again, I'm not breaking it regardless of the role claim because 80% of the time that's a role that's going to flip wolf. If we're wrong, we're wrong, but it's better than being fools if it turns out PBC isn't a wolf and we let her walk.
Click to expand...

That is reasonable logic. And if her claim is true, she is a vanillager and we would not lose any vital abilities.

While I feel that PBC is likely village, I haven't played enough games to know how often this skill goes to village v. wolf. If it's true that 80% of the time that person flips wolf, I can't really ignore that.

Despite my hesitations, I will (sigh) lynch PBC.
 
As I said earlier, Lynch PBC

I am also a believer of "if it doesn't die, kill it again," but I did want to give PBC a chance to talk before voting for her again.
 
I am reasonably confident hyge is not villager...based on my reads....neutral or chaos...i just think there are too many of those types to waste time on them all right now..i distrust hyge's motives and would like to know her win condition..and trust which side she is playing for.
 
SkiOtter said:
I am also a believer of "if it doesn't die, kill it again,"
Click to expand...
completely unrelated, but as I'm dealing with the aftermath of this water bug extermination/ I've killed 70 water bugs today, I'm very pro "kill it as many times as needed until dead".

Sadly there is no wolf sized shoe as I've gotten good at squishing those water bugs with my shoe.
 
cdoconn said:
Lynch PBC

With all the weird comments from last night (not being around but catching up but posting 5 minutes before close) and the way she was defending this morning and the lynch avoidance. It just doesn't make sense to be
Click to expand...

I was around the last part of the day. (Never said I wasn't around, just that I wasn't on the most current page) Got home with <1 hr left. Checked the thread. I think I had one vote at that point (from BBC, iirc). Fed my dog, came back, started catching up in earnest with 20 min left. Saw the VMH shooter bit, went 'oh that's weird,' saw the Hyge ability reveal, went 'hmmmmm still want to lynch you.' Meanwhile everyone online was like 'VMH's shot made sense you dummy, lynch PBC!' and by the time I realized I was in the lead, lynch was over. So. I don't think there was weirdness around it, just poor timing.
 
Day 4 - We Have Work For You Lynch Tally

PBC (10) - raf, Ferny, lupachei, sobsob, vmh, SAR, MJ, cdo, hyge, ski
BBC (1) - PBC
ski (0) -

A disturbing lack of ties
Waffles: 2
11/14 votes

Lynch deadline...1.75 hours (9pm EST)

GET NIGHT ACTIONS IN

f652a497044b1e1cf558ecf9671ebaab.gif
 
Bottle of Bear said:
Day 4 - We Have Work For You Lynch Tally

PBC (10) - raf, Ferny, lupachei, sobsob, vmh, SAR, MJ, cdo, hyge, ski
BBC (1) - PBC
ski (0) -

A disturbing lack of ties
Waffles: 2
11/14 votes

Lynch deadline...1.75 hours (9pm EST)

GET NIGHT ACTIONS IN

f652a497044b1e1cf558ecf9671ebaab.gif
Click to expand...
I'm so popular!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
47K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mystery WW Signs Ups - Game Start May 25th
2
Replies
79
Views
3K
KayJayQueue
KayJayQueue
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
35K
Clem J
Clem J
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (OPEN)
2 3 4
Replies
151
Views
8K
chicandtoughness
chicandtoughness
kaydubs
Melee WW Game Thread-April 2024
27 28 29 30 31
Replies
2K
Views
29K
Sandy Dikson
Sandy Dikson
Top