Once Upon A Time WW Game Thread

Veterinary Science Graduate Programs from U. of I.
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Current lynch tally:
Dwin 6 - hedgie, SOV, EC, LIS, FF, tuckervet
WS 0
FML 2 - devyn, dyachei
tuckervet 2 - Lupin, SV88 (contingency)
nohika 7 - TRH, allie, FH, Minner, FS, WS, Alors
SOV 0
FH 2 - DVMD, wld
allie 1 - SnS
FS 1 - swings
Alors 1 - bb
Lupin 1 - cuit

Waffles w/ maple syrup: 6

Looking for 4 more votes! Deadline 6:30 PM EST.

If we get all the votes in, we could probably close day early....:naughty:
 
DVMD, can I get it, too? In the off chance that I get a chance to watch a couple more episodes this week.

I think both of my jobs have collaborated in trying to kill me this month with 25+ overtime every week. I finally only work 40 next week. Even if I'm dead, I still want to watch the rest of Season 2.
 
From my admittedly brief reading, I would guess Hook isn't an outright wolf. But I'm not sure he'd be considered villager, which lines up with the "neutral" descriptor.

In agreeance with LIS - I'm thinking the FFM lynch was good for the villagers. But I'm also thinking rojo may have given away something...will ponder and revisit.
 
that redhead said:
From my admittedly brief reading, I would guess Hook isn't an outright wolf. But I'm not sure he'd be considered villager, which lines up with the "neutral" descriptor.

In agreeance with LIS - I'm thinking the FFM lynch was good for the villagers. But I'm also thinking rojo may have given away something...will ponder and revisit.
Click to expand...

not sure what I may have given away, but I'm curious to see what you are referring to...

and I'll just put this out there as well, I am most certainly not hook... surprised no one accused me of that yet either. Would make sense the way I am blathering about, but nope, not hook.
 
TRH--any reason why you would think it would be alors or FS. I went with dwin because I thought he was a lounger.
 
Hmmm...

I have learned some info that makes me think that FFM could have been neutral, and perhaps did not have any "win" condition....

It would make sense if a number of characters had this kind of role if they were morally ambiguous... I could see Hook, Greg, Tamara, Gold.

My problem with thinking that is that leaves very few wolf candidates that make sense.

I am confused. :shrug:
I am using the shrug emoticon frequently this game.
 
What if the game started out with only 1 or 2 wolves, and they get an attempt to convert every other night? (It's been a mechanic in past games, every night or every other night conversion with very few [or 1] wolves starting the game)

And the blue characters are 100% convertible.
The wolves have an option to kill or convert, but not both. That would explain the two nights with no death. (even the every other night convert idea)
Just an idea. Cora would definitely have started out a wolf.
 
StartingoverVet said:
Hmmm...

I have learned some info that makes me think that FFM could have been neutral, and perhaps did not have any "win" condition....

It would make sense if a number of characters had this kind of role if they were morally ambiguous... I could see Hook, Greg, Tamara, Gold.

My problem with thinking that is that leaves very few wolf candidates that make sense.

I am confused. :shrug:
I am using the shrug emoticon frequently this game.
Click to expand...

🙄

Why do you keep putting gold in the ambiguous group... Am I missing something from season 2 that rump/gold, aka the dark one, isn't the most twisted and selfish person in the game and is the most likely chaotic character with their own win condition and really can'tbe cconsidered a villager?
 
thedrjojo said:
🙄

Why do you keep putting gold in the ambiguous group... Am I missing something from season 2 that rump/gold, aka the dark one, isn't the most twisted and selfish person in the game and is the most likely chaotic character with their own win condition and really can'tbe cconsidered a villager?
Click to expand...

IMO:

Gold is one of the good guys... Loves his son and trying to get him back. Loves Belle and is trying to get her back. When Belle is around he is almost always a good guy. He does a lot to help the town, although he does things mostly for selfish reasons. He opposes Regina, and Cora (to an extent)... and especially since at the end of season 2:

spoiler alert:
Since he is Henry's grandfather, he is now part of the "good" family of Snow/Emma/Prince Charming/Henry
 
Also, Gold is my favorite character in the show, so maybe I am biased.
I love his laugh. Makes me smile every time!!!!


ANd I think he is the best actor on the show as well.
 
Sorry I haven't been active. Try checking at hospital when it slows down though it doesn't slow down much.

Unfortunately don't have much to add at this point. I have an ability, it hasn't really yielded much yet. Though based on my ability I can surmise (as most of you already have) that there are a lot of people looking for a counterpart and I would guess that has some effect on what they can do.

Other than that I haven't role revealed to anyone at this point, and no one has reached out. I'll happily role reveal if necessary. If you decide to lynch I doubt I would be a big loss other than numbers. I also have the top hat item in my possession right now.
 
Dwin sounds sincere...

I will
unlynch Dwin

And I kind of feel bad I had to kill him in WWhores, he would have been a good PM partner if I was a villager.

Guess I will bandwagon and
lynch Nohika..
 
hedgiehog said:
TRH--any reason why you would think it would be alors or FS. I went with dwin because I thought he was a lounger.
Click to expand...

It's really just speculation, no information, but my thoughts:

Alors and FS are newer to the game and I think a bit more open (Alors shared info with dyachei in another game that dyachei and I were paired up in). Plus rojo denied others were Hook but never denied either Alors or FS were Hook. Not that I place all that much stock in that necessarily but for comparison's sake...

Dwin has been pretty absent so it may be he wants rojo to run interference if he gets lynched and he isn't around he doesn't die.

Devyn I don't think would blab her role so easily. Dyachei I think tends to play her cards to her chest a bit more than that, but she's also a lounger so not impossible.

:shrug:
 
And for what it's worth, I also love the Rumplestiltskin/Gold character, but I don't think there is any chance they are a villager. My bet is chaos.
 
that redhead said:
It's really just speculation, no information, but my thoughts:

Devyn I don't think would blab her role so easily. Dyachei I think tends to play her cards to her chest a bit more than that, but she's also a lounger so not impossible.
Click to expand...

yup, I sure do.
 
that redhead said:
Dwin has been pretty absent so it may be he wants rojo to run interference if he gets lynched and he isn't around he doesn't die.
Click to expand...

lolwut? The only reason I mentioned rojo at all is because my ability lead me to believe he was being honest about not being Greg, that's all. Again, I have talked with no one through PM's to this point.
 
Dwindlin said:
Sorry I haven't been active. Try checking at hospital when it slows down though it doesn't slow down much.
Click to expand...

I can't imagine how busy you must be 🙁

Unlynch Dwin and lynch nohika

As far as I know, nohika hasn't come up with any defense or whatnot...
 
FantasyFlyer said:
I can't imagine how busy you must be 🙁
Click to expand...

Lol. Thanks. It's honestly not too bad. Still terrifying every time I sign an order. But on the whole there are interns who have had it much worse than I have, and others who have come before me have survived, so too shall I.

And on the really plus side I only have to play the surgeon lifestyle for a year. 😎
 
Current lynch tally:
Dwin 3 - hedgie, EC, LIS,
WS 0
FML 2 - devyn, dyachei
tuckervet 2 - Lupin, SV88 (contingency)
nohika 11 - TRH, allie, FH, Minner, FS, WS, Alors, Dwin, SOV, tuckervet, FF
SOV 0
FH 2 - DVMD, wld
allie 1 - SnS
FS 1 - swings
Alors 1 - bb
Lupin 1 - cuit

Waffles w/ maple syrup: 9

Looking for 3 more votes! Deadline 6:30 PM EST.
 
Just got home from work and showered.... I am fecking exhausted... wow....

not sure why everyone is lynching nohika? ... and still confused after reading prob cause I am tired.... is it just because she is inactive? the only problem I see with this is wolves are usually a bit more active then that... I mean sure you can have an inactive person be a wolf but usually when we lynch the quiet we lynch villagers...
 
devyn said:
Just got home from work and showered.... I am fecking exhausted... wow....

not sure why everyone is lynching nohika? ... and still confused after reading prob cause I am tired.... is it just because she is inactive? the only problem I see with this is wolves are usually a bit more active then that... I mean sure you can have an inactive person be a wolf but usually when we lynch the quiet we lynch villagers...
Click to expand...

I have seen some REALLY inactive players as wolves last time I modded (last month)...

And I figure Nohika will be mod-killed soon. If she is going to be killed anyway, better to do it ourselves until we get better info and can lynch a sure wolf.
 
Final lynch tally:
Dwin 3 - hedgie, EC, LIS,
WS 0
FML 2 - devyn, dyachei
tuckervet 2 - Lupin, SV88 (contingency)
nohika 11 - TRH, allie, FH, Minner, FS, WS, Alors, Dwin, SOV, tuckervet, FF
SOV 0
FH 2 - DVMD, wld
allie 1 - SnS
FS 1 - swings
Alors 1 - bb
Lupin 1 - cuit
 
StartingoverVet said:
I have seen some REALLY inactive players as wolves last time I modded (last month)...

And I figure Nohika will be mod-killed soon. If she is going to be killed anyway, better to do it ourselves until we get better info and can lynch a sure wolf.
Click to expand...

The problem with Nohika is she is always quiet...whether wolf or not. Didn't she vote yesterday? Why would she be mod killed?
 
shortnsweet said:
The problem with Nohika is she is always quiet...whether wolf or not. Didn't she vote yesterday? Why would she be mod killed?
Click to expand...

Not that this matters now seeing as the deadline just came up...can't wait to be back on EST tomorrow....
 
Just to add my 2 cents on the Hook thing...I've only watched about halfway through season 2, but I can most easily see him as neutral. From what I've seen, he seems to be very much out for himself. I guess if we're going with the low number of wolves + many conversions, I feel like he would be convertible. There's a good number of ambiguous characters, though, I think, so that would be a lot of neutrals...in conclusion, I'm not really sure.
 
thedrjojo said:
FFM's communications to me he stated he was neither a wolf nor chaos. The different colors may indicate he was lying, or may indicate different things. None of us are sure yet. What I do know is that he was going to have some seer results from last night, and although I can't PM to have heard what they would have been anyway, it would have been information I would have wanted to have, and thus why I wanted to buy at least one more night of his presence... but none of that is going to bring him or his hypothetical results back, but why his death may not be considered entirely a victory... :shrug:
Click to expand...

Dude, I just can't figure out why you're so ambivalent about this. Let's look at the facts:

1) His character is one that virtually everyone familiar with the show says "definitely would be a wolf." I don't remember anyone having any hesitancy about it.

2) He's a different color than people who are known villagers.

Contrast that with the evidence that you're hung up on, which is:

1) He told you he's not a wolf.

I mean.... seriously, I just don't get your reticence. Is it simply because you made the decision he was a villager and now you can't get past that? Because everything says otherwise, and there's virtually nothing saying he was a villager other than you accepting what he told you.

I dunno. Maybe I'm missing something, but I just don't see what the issue is.
 
The players have decided to lynch nohika. Good call?

Belle-once-upon-a-time-33306192-500-280.png
l_969af090-21ce-11e2-81e9-0595db400008.jpg


She didn't even defend herself. You have killed nohika - Belle/Lacey. Guess she won't be doing much seering from the grave....

It is now Night 4. Night deadline is either 3am or 6amEST. Whenever we have everything.

There are 28 players in the game.

Clock Tower
1. Rojo
3. dyachei
5. Alors
6. Dwin
8. cuit

Mary Margaret's Apartment
2. Jamr0ckin
3. Allie
4. FantasyFlyer
5. Hedgie
6. Tuckervet
7. bbeventer

Sheriff's Department
2. that redhead
5. Minnerbelle
6. The LIS
7. devyn

Granny's Diner
1. Lupin21
2. Swings
3. WS
4. SV88
5. FH (I'm a foxy granny)
6. Fancy

Mr. Gold's Pawn & Antiques Shop
1.SnS
2. Wildcatj
3. DVM
4.wldlfstdnt
5. equineconstant
6. SOV
7. FS

Cemetery kayd:
Lissarae06 - Grumpy/Leroy
NStarz- Henry Mills
FFM - Tamara
nohika - Belle/Lacey
 
Last edited:
That sucks....
If you have an important role, and are not going to be around....PLEASE confide in someone. One person. Odds are they aren't a wolf, and then we don't have to lynch one of our seers.

I mean, you quiet people KNOW you are going to be quiet.

FRACKING FRACK!
 
Crap kind of feel bad, she was WAY more useful than me. She was ahead of me in votes to begin with but I didn't help matters.
 
I just caught up and see that the lynch closed... just to go slightly backwards: It sounds like a few people know who Hook is, and Hook has said Hook is neutral?

Am I reading that right? Or am I getting confused between what's speculated and what's known?

Because if we know of a neutral character and we're just out lynching villagers ... that's dumb. Priority #1 is lynching wolves, but if we can't do that we damn well shouldn't preferentially choose villagers over non-villagers (neutrals).

I feel like I'm living in some other world where the villagers don't actually want to win. Mainly because of Rojo's stubbornness over FFM, but....

Anyway.... back to daddy day-care.
 
StartingoverVet said:
That sucks....
If you have an important role, and are not going to be around....PLEASE confide in someone. One person. Odds are they aren't a wolf, and then we don't have to lynch one of our seers.

I mean, you quiet people KNOW you are going to be quiet.

FRACKING FRACK!
Click to expand...

I agree, SOV. If you have an important role, tell someone so this doesn't happen again.
 
LetItSnow said:
I feel like I'm living in some other world where the villagers don't actually want to win. Mainly because of Rojo's stubbornness over FFM, but....
Click to expand...

... add to that players who sign up for the game, get one of the most important roles, and then don't play, don't tell anyone their role, and take it to the grave with them.

Awesomesauce. <---- sarcasm, for the sarcasm-impared
 
Ugh, nohika. It frustrates me that a relatively less active player had such an important role - she may have been sharing her results with someone else though, SOV.

LIS, I agree that it's better to lynch a known "non-villager" than risk another. The only tricky part is, Hool may have an ability that could aid the villagers and I'd want to wait and see at least another round or two to see if that somehow surfaces. But yeah, after that, probably not worth keeping around.
 
LetItSnow said:
... add to that players who sign up for the game, get one of the most important roles, and then don't play, don't tell anyone their role, and take it to the grave with them.
Click to expand...

This is something I have never understood. I've had two games where I fell off the planet (one I was getting married...oops) but in general I try to be active. Why join if you know you're going to be super busy 😕
 
LetItSnow said:
Dude, I just can't figure out why you're so ambivalent about this. Let's look at the facts:

1) His character is one that virtually everyone familiar with the show says "definitely would be a wolf." I don't remember anyone having any hesitancy about it.

2) He's a different color than people who are known villagers.

Contrast that with the evidence that you're hung up on, which is:

1) He told you he's not a wolf.

I mean.... seriously, I just don't get your reticence. Is it simply because you made the decision he was a villager and now you can't get past that? Because everything says otherwise, and there's virtually nothing saying he was a villager other than you accepting what he told you.

I dunno. Maybe I'm missing something, but I just don't see what the issue is.
Click to expand...

About 5 of my posts later I have conceded that FFM must have left something out to me... then a few posts after that SOV admitted that maybe Tamara was a neutral character, similar to Hook.
 
that redhead said:
LIS, I agree that it's better to lynch a known "non-villager" than risk another. The only tricky part is, Hool may have an ability that could aid the villagers and I'd want to wait and see at least another round or two to see if that somehow surfaces. But yeah, after that, probably not worth keeping around.
Click to expand...

If that's the case, Hook should share it with the person(s) who know Hook's identity. And if not, we should lynch and preserve our villager numbers while we continue to gather info.
 
thedrjojo said:
About 5 of my posts later I have conceded that FFM must have left something out to me... then a few posts after that SOV admitted that maybe Tamara was a neutral character, similar to Hook.
Click to expand...

Ok, fair 'nuff. I prob missed that in my rush to catch up.

I don't have any problem with the idea Tamara may have been neutral (other than the fact that everyone familiar with the series says "not a chance") ... but it sounded to me like you were holding onto FFM being a villager, which just seems seriously unlikely. But even a neutral lynch is still better than a villager lynch in most cases!!
 
LetItSnow said:
I just caught up and see that the lynch closed... just to go slightly backwards: It sounds like a few people know who Hook is, and Hook has said Hook is neutral?

Am I reading that right? Or am I getting confused between what's speculated and what's known?

Because if we know of a neutral character and we're just out lynching villagers ... that's dumb. Priority #1 is lynching wolves, but if we can't do that we damn well shouldn't preferentially choose villagers over non-villagers (neutrals).

I feel like I'm living in some other world where the villagers don't actually want to win. Mainly because of Rojo's stubbornness over FFM, but....

Anyway.... back to daddy day-care.
Click to expand...

that redhead said:
Ugh, nohika. It frustrates me that a relatively less active player had such an important role - she may have been sharing her results with someone else though, SOV.

LIS, I agree that it's better to lynch a known "non-villager" than risk another. The only tricky part is, Hool may have an ability that could aid the villagers and I'd want to wait and see at least another round or two to see if that somehow surfaces. But yeah, after that, probably not worth keeping around.
Click to expand...

I disagree. I like to know as much as I can about the people playing. If I know something about someone playing, unless I know 100% they are a wolf, I like to keep them around. The game isn't ever won or lost when there are 29 players left (regardless if we lose a seer... I personally gave a great reason to why Dwindlin wasn't going to be that useful going forward and shouldn't have probably signed up), but when there are only a few people left it can be won IF enough knowledge has been garnered... I keep harping on this, but since Abbers trusted me in the SOV game (and thought I might still trust her), she told me information that lead to me knowing she was a wolf and letting me lynch her... Hook is out for revenge in the show, and does what he can to try to kill Rump. If part of his role is to kill Rump or find Rump (I don't know if it is, they didn't reveal all to me), then they are useful to keep around...
 
kaydubs said:
The players have decided to lynch nohika. Good call?

once-upon-a-time-season-2-spoilers-3.jpg


She didn't even defend herself. You have killed nohika - Belle/Lacey. Guess she won't be doing much seering from the grave....

It is now Night 4. Night deadline is either 3am or 6amEST. Whenever we have everything.

There are 28 players in the game.

Clock Tower
1. Rojo
3. dyachei
5. Alors
6. Dwin
8. cuit

Mary Margaret's Apartment
2. Jamr0ckin
3. Allie
4. FantasyFlyer
5. Hedgie
6. Tuckervet
7. bbeventer

Sheriff's Department
2. that redhead
5. Minnerbelle
6. The LIS
7. devyn

Granny's Diner
1. Lupin21
2. Swings
3. WS
4. SV88
5. FH (I'm a foxy granny)
6. Fancy

Mr. Gold's Pawn & Antiques Shop
1.SnS
2. Wildcatj
3. DVM
4.wldlfstdnt
5. equineconstant
6. SOV
7. FS

Cemetary kayd:
Lissarae06 - Grumpy/Leroy
NStarz- Henry Mills
FFM - Tamara
nohika - Belle/Lacey
Click to expand...

FIFY mod god... 28 players...
 
btw Mod God, what a horrible picture of belle you decided to use... one of the prettier womenz in the show and you pick that picture? I could barely tell it was her... lol... just saying
 
thedrjojo said:
I disagree. I like to know as much as I can about the people playing. If I know something about someone playing, unless I know 100% they are a wolf, I like to keep them around. The game isn't ever won or lost when there are 29 players left (regardless if we lose a seer... I personally gave a great reason to why Dwindlin wasn't going to be that useful going forward and shouldn't have probably signed up), but when there are only a few people left it can be won IF enough knowledge has been garnered... I keep harping on this, but since Abbers trusted me in the SOV game (and thought I might still trust her), she told me information that lead to me knowing she was a wolf and letting me lynch her... Hook is out for revenge in the show, and does what he can to try to kill Rump. If part of his role is to kill Rump or find Rump (I don't know if it is, they didn't reveal all to me), then they are useful to keep around...
Click to expand...

In my defense I've missed only one lynch. I've used my ability each night. It just hasn't given much useful information to pass along.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
SDN Fairgrounds - 10th Annual Noob WW Game
71 72 73 74 75
Replies
4K
Views
35K
katiemcat
katiemcat
Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
53K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
38K
Clem J
Clem J
WildZoo
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
2 3 4 5
Replies
229
Views
15K
vampyrica
vampyrica
kaydubs
Melee WW Game Thread-April 2024
27 28 29 30 31
Replies
2K
Views
31K
Sandy Dikson
Sandy Dikson
Top