Once Upon A Time WW Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
TRH knew of DVMD's identity. If she was converted, it took her a bit to off Jimminy.
 
Dwindlin said:
So this has exactly nothing to do with the game. Have been watching season two with my day off. Snow/Charming/Good guys et. al. are really, really pissing me off. There comes a point when taking the higher ground is ignorant. I would have plunged that damn dagger straight into Cora's chest with a smile on my face as I gave the damn thing a little turn.

Just sayin'. . .
Click to expand...

I know I cringed the whole time! But snow is so good I mean her name is Snow White....
 
Dwindlin said:
So this has exactly nothing to do with the game. Have been watching season two with my day off. Snow/Charming/Good guys et. al. are really, really pissing me off. There comes a point when taking the higher ground is ignorant. I would have plunged that damn dagger straight into Cora's chest with a smile on my face as I gave the damn thing a little turn.

Just sayin'. . .
Click to expand...

:laugh:
 
If deadline isn't until 2:30pm tomorrow, I'm going to wait until as late as possible to role reveal in the hopes that the two people who know my identity (wld, nstarz) will vouch for me and some of you (the non-wolves, as I'm sure the wolves who are voting for me are happy for the attention to be on a villager) will start to think this through. This is a super-fast bandwagon and groundless - no one has any reason to be lynching me. I don't want to go down in a plurality vote, but since the mods have only done one plurality so far, I'm hopeful that I won't get lynched and die overnight. I would hope one of the two who know who I am would say something (wld, nstarz) ...
 
Dwindlin said:
So this has exactly nothing to do with the game. Have been watching season two with my day off. Snow/Charming/Good guys et. al. are really, really pissing me off. There comes a point when taking the higher ground is ignorant. I would have plunged that damn dagger straight into Cora's chest with a smile on my face as I gave the damn thing a little turn.

Just sayin'. . .
Click to expand...

👍 Charming/Snow have to be my least favorite characters in the show...
 
TRH, I know who you were originally were, but have no way of knowing if you were converted. You haven't given me any reason to think so in PM's, but I'm still not 100% sure.

Emma/SnS also knew of TRH's identity.
 
that redhead said:
If deadline isn't until 2:30pm tomorrow, I'm going to wait until as late as possible to role reveal in the hopes that the two people who know my identity (wld, nstarz) will vouch for me and some of you (the non-wolves, as I'm sure the wolves who are voting for me are happy for the attention to be on a villager) will start to think this through. This is a super-fast bandwagon and groundless - no one has any reason to be lynching me. I don't want to go down in a plurality vote, but since the mods have only done one plurality so far, I'm hopeful that I won't get lynched and die overnight. I would hope one of the two who know who I am would say something (wld, nstarz) ...
Click to expand...

Changing my vote so plurality isnt reached before wld or nstarz can show up and speak for TRH.

unlynch TRH
 
Current lynch tally:
Lupin 2 - cuit (contingency), Minnerbelle (contingency)
EC 0
SOV 0
TRH 7 - EC, tuckervet, rojo, Dwin, Fancy, wld, dyachei
FF 0
swings 1 - SOV

Waffles: 5

Votes: 10/18. Deadline 2:30 PM EST.
 
NStarz said:
TRH, I know who you were originally were, but have no way of knowing if you were converted. You haven't given me any reason to think so in PM's, but I'm still not 100% sure.

Emma/SnS also knew of TRH's identity.
Click to expand...

I understand. I think you have given what info you can to help vouch for my identity though, so thank you👍
 
Maybe I missed it somewhere, I have been working a lot off my phone recently, but have we heard anything from Lupin?
 
Unlynch TRH, lynch Tucker, agree with dyachei, betting we find a wolf amongst the newblets.
 
tucker told me her role and I have an idea of what she can do based on something she said. The action seems to fit with the role.
 
dyachei said:
unlynch TRH

what do people know about lupin and tuckervet?
Click to expand...

I also know Tucker's role, and unless she was converted (which she has given me no indication of) she is a villager.
 
that redhead said:
Thanks for unlynching (maybe ill be able to sleep tonight 😛) Lupin was the one to out fancy instead of herself, correct?
Click to expand...

I agree that's really weird.
 
Here's what Lupin had revealed right before the lynch of D8

Lupin21 said:
Well, I have a helpful power in which every fourth night I ask three questions and get one answered. That's why I knew who fancy was. You might loose valuable info In lunching me. I get to pm others along with moving people as well. You are looking for the original wolf Cora.
Click to expand...

She seems pretty powerful... knowing her abilities, does that give us any hint as to who she could be?
 
lynch dyachei

I don't know. Just a feeling right now.
 
I'm not super committed to that though. I don't like that lupin outed someone else's role as her defense and then keeps saying she's very helpful to the villagers so she can't tell us her name.
 
StartingoverVet said:
lynch TRH

She was awfully quick to try to lynch me as soon as the Gold news came out. How would she know who I am? I figure the wolves know from their failed attacks on me.

Still very suspicious of Swings.. But I followed her last night and she did nothing (but it doesn't absolve her).

I am also suspicious of FF.

I had a theory that when Swings accidentally complimented FF on her almost escaping lynch she was confusing 2 of her fellow wolves (FF and Allie). DVMD was also suspicious of these 2.

I know EC isn't a wolf. DVMD believed wld wasn't a wolf.
I trust Jojo for now and Nstarz.

So not counting conversions... nora and regina must be amongst:
3. dyachei
5. Alors
6. Dwin
8. cuit
4. FantasyFlyer
5. Hedgie
6. Tuckervet
7. bbeventer
2. that redhead
5. Minnerbelle
6. The LIS
1. Lupin21
2. Swings
6. Fancy

Fancy was the fairy so not a wolf.
I trust minnerbelle was telling the truth.
And since hedgie was DVMD's contact I trust her.

dyachei, Alors ,Dwin, cuit, FantasyFlyer, Tuckervet, bbeventer, that redhead , The LIS, Lupin21, Swings

So to me there are 2 (probably more) wolves in those 11
Click to expand...

I went through and reread the whole thread. Of everyone left rojo stated that he believes alors to be a villager. Cuit was kidnapped by a shadow (probs Peter Pan who I believe would be a wolf), FF was not an original wolf, tuckervet has bbeventer vouching for them, tucker has vouched for bb, and trh is not an original. That leaves dyachei, dwin, LIS, lupin, and swings.
 
hedgiehog said:
I went through and reread the whole thread. Of everyone left rojo stated that he believes alors to be a villager. Cuit was kidnapped by a shadow (probs Peter Pan who I believe would be a wolf), FF was not an original wolf, tuckervet has bbeventer vouching for them, tucker has vouched for bb, and trh is not an original. That leaves dyachei, dwin, LIS, lupin, and swings.
Click to expand...

By everyone left I meant everyone left on SOV's list of who has to be Regina and/or Cora.
 
hedgiehog said:
I went through and reread the whole thread. Of everyone left rojo stated that he believes alors to be a villager. Cuit was kidnapped by a shadow (probs Peter Pan who I believe would be a wolf), FF was not an original wolf, tuckervet has bbeventer vouching for them, tucker has vouched for bb, and trh is not an original. That leaves dyachei, dwin, LIS, lupin, and swings.
Click to expand...

You know I am inclined to believe Dwin has not been converted. I know their role as well, but I cannot be 100% of anything.
 
FantasyFlyer said:
Here's what Lupin had revealed right before the lynch of D8



She seems pretty powerful... knowing her abilities, does that give us any hint as to who she could be?
Click to expand...

unlynch TRH, lynch lupin

As far as I know, there has been no benefit from the information Lupin seemed to promise was coming after night 8 (when up for lynch, Lupin reminded everyone it was about to be night 8 and she would be able to get another question answered).
Since Lupin was willing to reveal Fancy's role, and gave us the information on the thread about being able to ask questions, it seems like revealing the role name would not make her any more of a target than revealing her ability.
 
Unless either have them been converted, I too can vouch for both tuckervet and bbeventer. I know who they are and they haven't given me any reason to doubt it.
 
tuckervet said:
unlynch TRH, lynch lupin

As far as I know, there has been no benefit from the information Lupin seemed to promise was coming after night 8 (when up for lynch, Lupin reminded everyone it was about to be night 8 and she would be able to get another question answered).
Since Lupin was willing to reveal Fancy's role, and gave us the information on the thread about being able to ask questions, it seems like revealing the role name would not make her any more of a target than revealing her ability.
Click to expand...

True point! She would have at least said that her efforts were fruitless - her silence isn't helping.

Reading back, the main reason why people (including myself) had voted for Lupin was because of her outing FML. Were there any other reasons?
 
hedgiehog said:
That leaves dyachei, dwin, LIS, lupin, and swings.
Click to expand...
Lupin then swings would be at the top of my list. They've both been giving me odd vibes... so I'll be staying with my contingency vote, mods.
 
FantasyFlyer said:
True point! She would have at least said that her efforts were fruitless - her silence isn't helping.

Reading back, the main reason why people (including myself) had voted for Lupin was because of her outing FML. Were there any other reasons?
Click to expand...

The night she almost died allie voted for her because she was quiet. I voted for lupin because of an inkling and no one had any concrete evidence about anyone. Then WS voted for her because she was quieter than usual. It just bandwagoned after that.
 
Lupin proceeded to out FML's role after she had quite a few votes for her.
 
unlynch dyachei, lynch lupin
 
Was sending off my fam. I really hate you guys can't move past me telling FancyPant's role. I gave my reasoning behind it and if it's not good enough for you, so be it. Also as I said previously, the wolves are quite pleased your attention is remaining on me. I am not a wolf.

I never said I was important to villagers, just occasionally helpful. As far as getting one of my questions answered N8, yes I have info. It is not great, but Fancy, DVMD and Rojo were all good as of that night. Which DVM is no longer here, so blah. I also sent rojo a PM from lsst night, but did't have anything substance and was just sent to establish that I have not been lying.
 
I think swings is more suspicious than Lupin atm, so lynch swings
 
Swings texted me and said she couldn't get on SDN until after her internship which would be at least an hour for her. At that point she said she can log on and give a defense.


This is not me defending swings. Just letting everyone know she can not get on to defend herself right now.
 
Lupin21 said:
I also sent rojo a PM from lsst night, but did't have anything substance and was just sent to establish that I have not been lying.
Click to expand...
Were you able to PM outside of your group or something?
 
cuitlamiztli said:
Were you able to PM outside of your group or something?
Click to expand...

AlorsOnDanse said:
Wondering the same thing...role ability?
Click to expand...

I realize the thread gets loaded' but this is exactly why wolves don't get lynched. Cuit, you are just going off a contingency and suspicion from how long ago? my abilities and what i have done with them have been laid out pretty much the last three lynches.
 
Lupin21 said:
I realize the thread gets loaded' but this is exactly why wolves don't get lynched. Cuit, you are just going off a contingency and suspicion from how long ago? my abilities and what i have done with them have been laid out pretty much the last three lynches.
Click to expand...

Okay do it's part of your role. We both must have missed it.
 
Lupin21 said:
Cuit, you are just going off a contingency and suspicion from how long ago? my abilities and what i have done with them have been laid out pretty much the last three lynches.
Click to expand...
No, I'm not... pretty sure my contingency vote for you is only 3 cycles old now. Admittedly, I'm also extremely busy (work, paperwork, and sleep) so I could easily have missed something. I'll flip back through your posts in a minute -- until then, all I recall you saying is that you can get a question answered every so many nights.... how does PMing a player not in your group play into that?

Anyway, I'm also curious as to why you think revealing your role name will make you more of a target than revealing your role ability.
 
Lupin21 said:
Well, I have a helpful power in which every fourth night I ask three questions and get one answered. That's why I knew who fancy was. You might loose valuable info In lunching me. I get to pm others along with moving people as well. You are looking for the original wolf Cora.
Click to expand...
Just found this. So you're saying that you can PM anyone, move players, and can get a question answered every 4 nights?

To be honest I'm not sure what to think of your and SOV's multi-power claims. Roles have a single ability in most games unless it's a "you can choose to move yourself or another player" type of thing... it's hard to make a balanced game if everyone has multiple abilities.
 
cuitlamiztli said:
Just found this. So you're saying that you can PM anyone, move players, and can get a question answered every 4 nights?

To be honest I'm not sure what to think of your and SOV's multi-power claims. Roles have a single ability in most games unless it's a "you can choose to move yourself or another player" type of thing... it's hard to make a balanced game if everyone has multiple abilities.
Click to expand...

I can definitely see Rumple as a neutral character having multiple powers (even more so if he has his own win condition) like I did when I was Grumpy Cat.

Lupin's description seems possible (coming from someone who's never modded/balanced a game herself), but contradictory:
Lupin21 said:
Well, I have a helpful power in which every fourth night I ask three questions and get one answered.
Click to expand...
Lupin21 said:
It is random on what I can do each night, so I'll let you know when/if I can again.
Click to expand...
 
equineconstant said:
I can definitely see Rumple as a neutral character having multiple powers
Click to expand...
I can, too. The point I was trying (and failed) to make was that it can be difficult to make a balanced game with one multi-powered role, so keeping it balanced with more than one of those gets progressively more difficult.
Lupin's description seems possible... but contradictory:
Click to expand...
Interesting catch.
 
I am hitting the hay.

There is no contradiction. Every fourth night I get to ask my questions. The other nights are random as far as send a PM or move a player. There have been a few nights I have no actions. The mods PM me with what I can do. There may be a pattern, but I haven't been looking for it.
 
that redhead said:
I'm getting ready to go bed soon and don't want to get plurality lynched in my sleep. I have until 2:30pm tomorrow anyway so I don't want to role reveal so soon.

WLD, I sent you the macklemore reference. I am still that character.
Nstarz, I am still who you know me to be.
SOV, I knew you were gold, which was why I jumped to lynch you.

There has not been an actual reason to lynch me, ffs. Think, people.
Click to expand...

So minus the chances of conversion and lying in a PM, trh would be a villager
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

WildZoo
Supernatural: Angels & Demons WW Game Thread
121 122 123 124 125
Replies
6K
Views
95K
GoSpursGo
GoSpursGo
WildZoo
HolloWW's End: A Spooky WW Game
108 109 110 111 112
Replies
6K
Views
72K
kaydubs
kaydubs
supershorty
The Good PWWace - GAME THREAD
79 80 81 82 83
Replies
4K
Views
42K
samac
samac
WildZoo
Halloween Horrors WW Game Sign Ups [CLOSED]
3 4 5 6 7
Replies
313
Views
7K
supershorty
supershorty
Animal Midwife
CHOOSE YOUR OWWN IV - Game Thread
112 113 114 115 116
Replies
6K
Views
52K
screamqueenbee
screamqueenbee
Top Bottom