Persistence of Minecraft WW Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Members don't see this ad.
StartingoverVet said:
OT: but calling someone's play style obnoxious is obnoxious. Maybe best to look inward and see if the fault lies not in SOV but in yourself. Attack content not personality.
Click to expand...

Sorry, I was being a dick.

My less tired/grumpy self rewords that as: You usually don't have such a strong appearance in the thread (which you explained is because you had time off work) but you are seeming more combative in your posts as well. The comparison being from games I have played with you, which is a very minimal amount.

Edited to add:
I was actually about to go get annoyed and ask where exactly I said that you were obnoxious, then went and looked at my post again and low and behold there it was. Whoops.
 
Last edited:
Devastating said:
Well I mean, villagers have never been allowed to discuss their death once dead...
Click to expand...

Unless I misinterpreted what you were saying there. Was in a hurry catching up before leaving lunch, lol
 
nyanko said:
The odds are not in your favor unless I have something to tell you or ask you personally. 🙂

I don't usually do a ton of PM communication in these games unless I've got good info.
Click to expand...
I think genny asked so that she could pass info to you if necessary since she can't open a pm with you.
 
BeautifulBritishColumbia said:
Sorry, I was being a dick.

My less tired/grumpy self rewords that as: You usually don't have such a strong appearance in the thread (which you explained is because you had time off work) but you are seeming more combative in your posts as well. The comparison being from games I have played with you, which is a very minimal amount.

Edited to add:
I was actually about to go get annoyed and ask where exactly I said that you were obnoxious, then went and looked at my post again and low and behold there it was. Whoops.
Click to expand...
ironically you weren't the main target of my post...
 
I am going to go back to
lynch dyachei

mainly because of her "i didn't even vote to lynch SOV" comment yesterday, when she was trying to show how unreasonable I was being. She knows as well as anyone that a smart wolf adds fuel to the fire and then sits back and watches it explode. And she is a smart wolf. Trying to act all innocent in that back and forth yesterday still doesn't sit well with me. Not as enthusiastic about it today, but I don't have anything better.
 
StartingoverVet said:
I am going to go back to
lynch dyachei

mainly because of her "i didn't even vote to lynch SOV" comment yesterday, when she was trying to show how unreasonable I was being. She knows as well as anyone that a smart wolf adds fuel to the fire and then sits back and watches it explode. And she is a smart wolf. Trying to act all innocent in that back and forth yesterday still doesn't sit well with me. Not as enthusiastic about it today, but I don't have anything better.
Click to expand...
I didn't vote you because I was trying to gain clarity by asking questions. It wasn't meant to be a distraction or any other nonsense.
 
SOV claimed to have lied to the wolf(ves) several times in the message that was sent out to them. And announced to everyone that messages would be sent via the write up. The message was indeed received, but all of that doesn't mean that SOV was lying about being chaotic when that was mentioned to the wolves. Something is bothering me about those shenanigans, and I can't exactly put my finger on what it is. Maybe that it is hard to imagine a villager who can contact all other groups in the game and send embedded messages... who squanders the potential of that ability by telling us all about it when there really wasn't much of a bandwagon against them to require so much revelation. SOV is a smart, experienced player, who I would have expected to have been more subtle in the use of that ability. Others have also mentioned that it seems like something is off about SOVs play... that it is maybe more involved than usual.

I don't know anything for sure, but something does seem strange. For now:

Lynch SOV
 
Promethean said:
Maybe that it is hard to imagine a villager who can contact all other groups in the game and send embedded messages...
Click to expand...
I know Trilt has used this ability before, I think it was in Rick & Morty. Might have been a neutral role though, I'd have to look back.
 
Promethean said:
SOV claimed to have lied to the wolf(ves) several times in the message that was sent out to them. And announced to everyone that messages would be sent via the write up. The message was indeed received, but all of that doesn't mean that SOV was lying about being chaotic when that was mentioned to the wolves. Something is bothering me about those shenanigans, and I can't exactly put my finger on what it is. Maybe that it is hard to imagine a villager who can contact all other groups in the game and send embedded messages... who squanders the potential of that ability by telling us all about it when there really wasn't much of a bandwagon against them to require so much revelation. SOV is a smart, experienced player, who I would have expected to have been more subtle in the use of that ability. Others have also mentioned that it seems like something is off about SOVs play... that it is maybe more involved than usual.

I don't know anything for sure, but something does seem strange. For now:

Lynch SOV
Click to expand...
TBH, I am not sure there was much to do with this role. When I have seen it before, it has mostly been toothless, especially since the messages are one way. Not really useful. I tried a ploy and so far it hasn't worked, but it was more than most would have gotten out of the role.

And it doesn't take much for a bandwagon against me to be irreversible. I am an easy person to lynch due to my "shenanigans". :shrug:
 
Ally (1) - Guis
Dy (1) - SOV
SOV (1) - Promo

3/20ish. Deadline 9pm EST.

PBC is not lynchable while in the nether.

The last paragraph of the write-up is referring to the image at the top, which is my Minecraft variation of the Dali painting... I was working on <2hrs of sleep in a moving vehicle, I apologize for being even less clear than I was aiming for. Both deaths were villagers.
 
StartingoverVet said:
TBH, I am not sure there was much to do with this role. When I have seen it before, it has mostly been toothless, especially since the messages are one way. Not really useful. I tried a ploy and so far it hasn't worked, but it was more than most would have gotten out of the role.

And it doesn't take much for a bandwagon against me to be irreversible. I am an easy person to lynch due to my "shenanigans". :shrug:
Click to expand...

I can see where that would be so. Heck, I think I'm in that glass house, too. I don't know where else to go, though. The person I most wanted to question is out in the nether. I'm really likely to look for a better target, as I'm not really convinced about you one way or the other. It is just good to get conversations going before 8pm. The lynch that doesn't start until the last half hour is almost always a bad lynch.
 
Are our starting numbers important? I notice that dead and nethered people keep their roster number. Is that for ease of reinserting those who return from the nether (and potentially any resurrectees) into their original locations?
 
Promethean said:
Are our starting numbers important? I notice that dead and nethered people keep their roster number. Is that for ease of reinserting those who return from the nether (and potentially any resurrectees) into their original locations?
Click to expand...
There is a small possibility it means something, but as someone who has modded from time to time, usually it is nothing more than either keeping bookkeeping simple, or laziness to renumber (or in this case making it easier to keep track of who to insert where for PM-ing purposes).
 
WildZoo said:
I know Trilt has used this ability before, I think it was in Rick & Morty. Might have been a neutral role though, I'd have to look back.
Click to expand...
Yep, it was neutral in R&M.

Lynch Crayola, she just seems quieter and less involved than she was in the jdh game.
 
BeautifulBritishColumbia said:
Mod question (apologies if this has been expressly stated/answered): in terms of PMing, if the person below you in roster dies, can you open a PM with the new living person under you?
Click to expand...

When DVMD was in The Nether I was told I could PM with the new person under me nyanko but if DVMD came back from The Nether and was placed below me again she would return the being my sole under me PM partner.
 
You may open a PM with the person below you, no matter what sort of contortions the roster does. Just keep a close eye for changes.

When I'm not running this from my phone I will be better about notifying people when people move, promise. 🙂
 
I'm still not feeling totally good about Ally. After I mentioned my suspicions of her D1, she seems to have gone very quiet on the thread strategywise. I could put another lynch vote that way if nothing better comes along.

SOV defense today has me less inclined to lynch, but he is still higher on my list of someone who may be chaos.

I have no feelings whatsoever on Genny. I would be willing to put a vote there if I agree with whatever WZ was getting feels from
 
What do people thing about people not wanting to talk on PMs? I think if someone is doing that they may not be a wolf because a wolf would want to be able to find out info about their PM partners that the partner may not out on the thread? Not sure.

***lynch ally*** because I still have feels about her.
 
BeautifulBritishColumbia said:
I'm still not feeling totally good about Ally. After I mentioned my suspicions of her D1, she seems to have gone very quiet on the thread strategywise. I could put another lynch vote that way if nothing better comes along.

SOV defense today has me less inclined to lynch, but he is still higher on my list of someone who may be chaos.

I have no feelings whatsoever on Genny. I would be willing to put a vote there if I agree with whatever WZ was getting feels from
Click to expand...
I have no communication ability / items / whatever that would give me any new info, and have developed no theory of game that's consistent with my old info. So quiet because I just have no clue.

Zen was chatty by PM, so I had a sense of her. Dy, not so much, but "she didn't talk to me so must be a wolf" is pretty bad logic. And SOV has been chatty all over the thread, but not in any sort of way that gave me insight into his villagery-ness or lack thereof.

So an early-forming bandwagon that might get me more info looks better to me than the alternatives. I anticipate being available we get closer to close, if I get waffle-worthy info.
 
guisantes said:
I'm sorry for disappearing yesterday, something came up last night and I'm probably going to be occupied with it again today. I will try to check in as often as possible. To get a vote in:

Lynch ally for minor feels but really nothing substantial.
Click to expand...

Still feeling guisantes is wolfy. D1 literally just voted for someone with no explanation. When asked for a reason, ignored the question and didn't respond. Today comes in with a vote and at least offers "minor feels" but that is obviously a non-committal "I wanna be able to defend this vote later" type of deal.

Super super sketchy play from guisantes so far.

StartingoverVet said:
confused.
We have n=2 of villager getting lynched but not dying till next day and saying nothing.
I will assume that this will continue and the mods must be telling them they can't discuss the fact that lynch deaths are delayed.

I will check back at lunchtime.

OT: but calling someone's play style obnoxious is obnoxious. Maybe best to look inward and see if the fault lies not in SOV but in yourself. Attack content not personality.
Click to expand...

Hey now - calling someone's play style obnoxious is calling their PLAY STYLE obnoxious, not their personality. And c'mon - your play style is crazy often. You know that. You pride yourself on it. And it makes you fun to play with.

dyachei said:
perhaps he was given info from the mods that he could share in image form?
Click to expand...

I established a permanent PM connection with MJ courtesy of an item. We only exchanged basic info, but in his response to me, he did identify his role ability: "I'm a Dali painting that can send a message or piece of media to someone each night."

morninqlory said:
she would return the being my sole under me PM partner.
Click to expand...

Sounds kinky.

allyphoe said:
I could go for that, more for getting a lynch going early enough for defense than because feels.

***Lynch genny***
Click to expand...

Third vote for genny, and a kinda weak feeling? Ally stays on the sketch list, too.

But guisantes is really who I'd like to lynch, so....

lynch guisantes
 
Also, the "Zen talked a lot so I had a sense of her" is why I moved my vote to Hmoo, despite not necessarily disbelieving moo's village claim (which was later revealed to be truthful). I wasn't willing to have someone I strongly believed to be village die to save someone I weakly believed to be village. Voting for someone with a higher odds of being a wolf wasn't going to save Zen at that point, at least from my perspective. Not that it helped in the end.
 
Ok so here is where my genny feels are coming from:

genny said:
I thought Zen's vote for BBC made sense when I first read it. It's hard to pick someone out on day 1, and when BBC posts that her role description is sketchy, then voting that way feels a little better than just RNG like so many day 1 lynches. I feel that BBC maybe jumped the gun a little, and came across as preemptively defensive, since no one was questioning whether her role was sketchy at that point or not. It does put her a little higher on my radar though.
Click to expand...

genny said:
I was thinking Ally or Hmoo, for starting up the Zen lynch.
Click to expand...
So this is from day 1. Genny was posting in support of Zen, and stated that she was suspicious of people who were voting for her.

genny said:
lynch finn

I agree with Jilary on this one. Finn stayed away from the Zen lynch, and has been pretty quiet.
Click to expand...
But then on day 2, her reasoning suddenly flips - now people who stayed away from the Zen vote are suspicious, even though Zen ended up being a villager. To me this really reads as reaching for a reason to get on the finn wagon. Along with the fact that she called finn "quiet" (I don't know if they have played together before, but finn is never the most talkative player) when genny herself had posted even fewer times than finn had at that point. Not to mention, as we have said before like...a lot, quiet does not equal wolf. In the absence of other wolfy evidence I find it a very, very weak argument.

Tenuous as always, search your own feelings before agreeing with me because I'm usually wrong about everything, but there ya go.

This did make me remember that we definitely shouldn't let BBC fall by the wayside, in case Zen was right about her. I don't remember if BBC ended up actually revealing to anyone or not.
 
Not getting any good lynch feels based on the chatter today. Minor pings on genny and wondering about this crayon person. Feel like I'm forgetting who else is playing so will re read and decide who to vote

Sent from my VS876 using SDN mobile
 
StartingoverVet said:
I am going to go back to
lynch dyachei

mainly because of her "i didn't even vote to lynch SOV" comment yesterday, when she was trying to show how unreasonable I was being. She knows as well as anyone that a smart wolf adds fuel to the fire and then sits back and watches it explode. And she is a smart wolf. Trying to act all innocent in that back and forth yesterday still doesn't sit well with me. Not as enthusiastic about it today, but I don't have anything better.
Click to expand...

Honestly, I think you kind of created a mountain out of nothing from the beginning.

I mean, how else should WZ have mentioned she was attacked? Should she not have mentioned it? I mean, I really can't pick up anything bizarre from WZ's post at all.

Then I had the same exact questions as dyachei asked yesterday of you, which basically boiled down to, we have evidence of no wolf kill and someone claiming an attack, so simplest explanation would be wolf attacked WZ so what would you be proposing happened if not that? Yes, I know you've already addressed all of this.

Then the lynch on dyachei here, I didn't see dyachei's questions odd yesterday. They were the same thoughts I had, just I couldn't ask them.

Honestly, I really do think you are over reading things and making mountains out of very insignificant things. But that's just my feeling on all of this.
 
LetItSnow said:
Still feeling guisantes is wolfy. D1 literally just voted for someone with no explanation. When asked for a reason, ignored the question and didn't respond. Today comes in with a vote and at least offers "minor feels" but that is obviously a non-committal "I wanna be able to defend this vote later" type of deal.

Super super sketchy play from guisantes so far.



Hey now - calling someone's play style obnoxious is calling their PLAY STYLE obnoxious, not their personality. And c'mon - your play style is crazy often. You know that. You pride yourself on it. And it makes you fun to play with.



I established a permanent PM connection with MJ courtesy of an item. We only exchanged basic info, but in his response to me, he did identify his role ability: "I'm a Dali painting that can send a message or piece of media to someone each night."



Sounds kinky.



Third vote for genny, and a kinda weak feeling? Ally stays on the sketch list, too.

But guisantes is really who I'd like to lynch, so....

lynch guisantes
Click to expand...

I also had guis feels yesterday with one of his erm her? posts. Then saw your comment yesterday saying you were suspicious because of it, I think I liked that comment. I'd have to go back to find the specific post that made me suspicious. But I'm ok with placing my vote here

Lynch guis
 
********lynch promo******

Something about his/her play style is rubbing me the wrong way, but then again, I guess this is the first time I have played with them (I think?)
 
morninqlory said:
What do people thing about people not wanting to talk on PMs? I think if someone is doing that they may not be a wolf because a wolf would want to be able to find out info about their PM partners that the partner may not out on the thread? Not sure.

***lynch ally*** because I still have feels about her.
Click to expand...
Some people just don't like PMing. I have games where I don't do it at all because I can't devote the time to making sure I'm not being played behind the scenes. Or they just have nothing to say that they don't think would be better put out in the open on the thread. You take a risk when you PM someone that you are giving a wolf info which might not reach the villagers, or might be damaging. So I wouldn't say it's indicative of wolfiness either way, in my opinion.
 
morninqlory said:
What do people thing about people not wanting to talk on PMs? I think if someone is doing that they may not be a wolf because a wolf would want to be able to find out info about their PM partners that the partner may not out on the thread? Not sure.

***lynch ally*** because I still have feels about her.
Click to expand...
It can go either way and usually is just based off play style. Also, depends on roles available in the game (wolves are less reliant on pms when they have a seer ie.)
 
WildZoo said:
Ok so here is where my genny feels are coming from:




So this is from day 1. Genny was posting in support of Zen, and stated that she was suspicious of people who were voting for her.


But then on day 2, her reasoning suddenly flips - now people who stayed away from the Zen vote are suspicious, even though Zen ended up being a villager. To me this really reads as reaching for a reason to get on the finn wagon. Along with the fact that she called finn "quiet" (I don't know if they have played together before, but finn is never the most talkative player) when genny herself had posted even fewer times than finn had at that point. Not to mention, as we have said before like...a lot, quiet does not equal wolf. In the absence of other wolfy evidence I find it a very, very weak argument.

Tenuous as always, search your own feelings before agreeing with me because I'm usually wrong about everything, but there ya go.

This did make me remember that we definitely shouldn't let BBC fall by the wayside, in case Zen was right about her. I don't remember if BBC ended up actually revealing to anyone or not.
Click to expand...

Hm....To me I am not getting much from that. Just seems like she was being wishy washy because she didn't know what she believed.

I would be more comfortable going with Guis, particularly after what LIS posted. I agree that Guis has been around long enough to explain votes each day.

Ally's defense isn't stellar, but then again it isn't incriminating.

I gotta book it now before I'm late to work #2, so I will make my vote today

lynch guis

Also WZ, no I have not role revealed to anyone. Just alluded to the unimportantness of my role to kcough.
 
dyachei said:
can someone review the case on guis? and genny?
Click to expand...

Case against guis is flimsy. D1 posted "lynch ....", gave no reason, didn't bother to respond when asked for a reason. D2 posted "lynch ... for mild feels". I just feel like it's pretty weak play - not giving any input at all, and throwing out pointless lynch votes. So I'm lynching because either guis is wolfy, or guis needs to step up his/her play.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
51K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
37K
Clem J
Clem J
WildZoo
Noob WW Game 2025 Sign Ups: All New WW Players Welcome! (CLOSED)
2 3 4
Replies
159
Views
10K
samac
samac
kaydubs
Melee WW Game Thread-April 2024
27 28 29 30 31
Replies
2K
Views
30K
Sandy Dikson
Sandy Dikson
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mystery WW Signs Ups - Game Start May 25th
2
Replies
79
Views
3K
KayJayQueue
KayJayQueue
Top