StardeWW Valley - GAME THREAD

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
I'm so sorry, Barkley. I thought you were the wolf. I didn't know who else it could be, no one made sense.

I don't know what my POE looks like right now. I'm so sorry. I messed up.
 
Either the wolf's kill was blocked or there is no more wolf, only Cult.
 
Truenamer said:
I'm so sorry, Barkley. I thought you were the wolf. I didn't know who else it could be, no one made sense.

I don't know what my POE looks like right now. I'm so sorry. I messed up.
Click to expand...
It's okay it's a game, don't feel guilty. You may have put yourself in a treacherous position.
 
bluestoat said:
It's okay it's a game, don't feel guilty. You may have put yourself in a treacherous position.
Click to expand...
Hiding the fact that I did it would give the town bad information and make things even harder. I had to own this.
 
Truenamer said:
I'm so sorry, Barkley. I thought you were the wolf. I didn't know who else it could be, no one made sense.

I don't know what my POE looks like right now. I'm so sorry. I messed up.
Click to expand...
Ok but why did you aim for a wolf target when we need to kill Cult?
 
bluestoat said:
Trying so hard to not overthink this because talk about needless sharing of information, if Dubz wolf
Click to expand...
Actually I would share it regardless of affiliation because presumably whoever blocked me was going to come forward anyway
 
WildZoo said:
I was blocked last night, I think. Result said I could open my door so sounds like a block.
Click to expand...
Either there is no wolf, there is a wolf and they tried to kill you, or you're the wolf.

So... I don't know what. Just thinking aloud and feeling awful. I thought I had done a good. I thought I was helping.

I just wanted to be like Terminator!Sporty
 
WildZoo said:
Ok but why did you aim for a wolf target when we need to kill Cult?
Click to expand...
I thought about this a lot but I didn't want to waste my one shot and I thought if I picked the wolf it wouldn't "double up" on whoever the wolf picked. I thought myself into circles, I guess. In my head I thought we'd start the morning with the wolf NK on a cultist and my NK on the wolf and everyone would be happy and we'd win.
 
WildZoo said:
Actually I would share it regardless of affiliation because presumably whoever blocked me was going to come forward anyway
Click to expand...
For the record, and because the player count is small enough that I don't see the harm in talking about my role anymore, I'm not the blocker. Just a Pufferfish.
 
Truenamer said:
Either there is no wolf, there is a wolf and they tried to kill you, or you're the wolf.

So... I don't know what. Just thinking aloud and feeling awful. I thought I had done a good. I thought I was helping.

I just wanted to be like Terminator!Sporty
Click to expand...
So either you’re the wolf using an item to cover your kill, or Dubz is the wolf and I stopped her from killing.
 
genny said:
Yeah I blocked you. I needed to know you didn’t kill anyone.
Click to expand...
So if genny blocked Dubz and there was no NK except for my tool-assisted NK...

IDK. Doesn't clear Dubz either way, right? She's in my POE but...
 
Truenamer said:
I thought about this a lot but I didn't want to waste my one shot and I thought if I picked the wolf it wouldn't "double up" on whoever the wolf picked. I thought myself into circles, I guess. In my head I thought we'd start the morning with the wolf NK on a cultist and my NK on the wolf and everyone would be happy and we'd win.
Click to expand...
Yes but if the wolf hit village and you killed the wolf then Cult wins, I'm pretty sure?
And we already established that the wolf may not agree with the kill the cult plan given that would narrow misyeet pool.

Gah idk. I just don't understand not aiming for a Cult candidate.

Recalculating stuff now.
 
WildZoo said:
Yes but if the wolf hit village and you killed the wolf then Cult wins, I'm pretty sure?
And we already established that the wolf may not agree with the kill the cult plan given that would narrow misyeet pool.

Gah idk. I just don't understand not aiming for a Cult candidate.

Recalculating stuff now.
Click to expand...
I'm operating under the assumption that last night there was only the Cult Leader. Their conversion mechanic can't be every night unless genny has gotten ungodly good luck at choosing who to block.

Actually, genny, now that you're outed, who have you been blocking? It may be very important.

Did you use your PR on me on the second night? We never determined who went through my stuff. I guess it could have been Barkley, but she didn't take anything, so "Forager" doesn't quite fit.
 
genny said:
So either you’re the wolf using an item to cover your kill, or Dubz is the wolf and I stopped her from killing.
Click to expand...
We can also go ultra tinfoil and say "genny is the wolf, genny holstered her night action and blocked Dubz" but at this point I feel assured that your kds vote clears you from wolfing
 
Truenamer, Bluestoat, Sporty, Dubz, Genny

There has to be a Cult Leader unless wolves can somehow make cultists? We've been making assumptions, as Stoat said last night. Maybe too many assumptions.

The conversion mechanic is unknown. Could be tied to seasons. Could be daily but there's been a lot of interference.

There could be as many as four villagers if the wolves did the conversion but haven't had a success other than AM. I find this scenario super unlikely but it's possible.


There could be as few as two villagers if there's a Wolf, Cult Leader, and Cultist. In which case, I deserve to lose, I literally had a 50/50 shot at hitting scum and whiffed it.

At least in future WW games when people think I'm a wolf I can point to this game and be like "look, I was village the entire game and did more to assure a scum victory than most of the scum!"

I need to go for a walk.
 
bluestoat said:
We can also go ultra tinfoil and say "genny is the wolf, genny holstered her night action and blocked Dubz" but at this point I feel assured that your kds vote clears you from wolfing
Click to expand...
Either there is no more wolf or... I think it might have to be Dubz.

Idk. I still think I can read you. Guess we'll find out in a day cycle or two, huh?
 
Truenamer said:
Truenamer, Bluestoat, Sporty, Dubz, Genny

There has to be a Cult Leader unless wolves can somehow make cultists? We've been making assumptions, as Stoat said last night. Maybe too many assumptions.

The conversion mechanic is unknown. Could be tied to seasons. Could be daily but there's been a lot of interference.

There could be as many as four villagers if the wolves did the conversion but haven't had a success other than AM. I find this scenario super unlikely but it's possible.


There could be as few as two villagers if there's a Wolf, Cult Leader, and Cultist. In which case, I deserve to lose, I literally had a 50/50 shot at hitting scum and whiffed it.

At least in future WW games when people think I'm a wolf I can point to this game and be like "look, I was village the entire game and did more to assure a scum victory than most of the scum!"

I need to go for a walk.
Click to expand...
Too much WIFOM can make a smokescreen for others to use your logic against you. I would suggest focusing on information processing and asking questions seeking answers, and reserving this level of questioning for your role PM
 
bluestoat said:
Too much WIFOM can make a smokescreen for others to use your logic against you. I would suggest focusing on information processing and asking questions seeking answers, and reserving this level of questioning for your role PM
Click to expand...
I need a manator but I think my adoptive manator may be an awoo 😔
 
genny said:
Eh, Samac claimed village vig when she wolf killed me. It’s been done.
Click to expand...
Exciting thought.

"At least it was quick. He heard the whistle of something flying through the air, felt a sharp pain in his head, and everything went dark"

Breaks the pattern of the light people have gone towards in other kills. It also flavors what he said about using an axe. I bet there's easter eggs that are flying over my head in the other write-ups because I'm dense. It may not be AI but I will reread (as Dubz did earlier) and see if there's a thread connecting anything.
 
Boy I can’t wait for another 36 hours of anxiety with everyone well within the POE

I already mentioned this in a PM but I’m a little freaked out that True has lived this long as widely village read.
 
WildZoo said:
7 players

These are all predicated on one remaining wolf. Again, 3 wolves and a Cult Leader seems unlikely to me for a game this size, so I'm not considering it. Also leaning towards looking at worst case scenarios, of course there are others where the wolves kill the cult leader/cultist or recruitment fails or whatever.

If we misyeet, 4:1:1, risks losing a villager to wolf kill and to recruitment, making it 2:1:2 tomorrow, which is a fun situation because idk if wolf wincon necessitates getting rid of the Cult or just reaching parity with village.
If we yeet the wolf, then it would be potentially 4:2 tomorrow with successful recruitment.
If we yeet the Cult Leader, 4:1 tomorrow.
So in this scenario, we have some breathing room.

If we misyeet, a villager dies overnight, and another is recruited, 2:1:3 and cult wins
If we yeet the wolf and recruitment is successful, 3:3 and cult wins
If we yeet the Cult Leader and a villager dies overnight, 2:1:1 tomorrow or...something, idk what would happen to the Cultist
If we yeet the Cultist, a villager dies overnight, and successful recruitment, 2:1:2 tomorrow which is the same as scenario 1a

If we misyeet, Cult wins
If we yeet the wolf, Cult wins
If we yeet the Cult Leader and a villager dies overnight, 2:1:2 tomorrow, which is the same as scenario 1a.
If we yeet a Cultist, a villager dies overnight, and successful recruitment, 2:1:3, Cult wins.

Some things also depend on what happens to the Cultists if the Cult Leader dies...
I think these are correct.
Click to expand...
5 players
It doesn't make sense for there not to be a wolf left because Zenge and AM died after kdswg. There has to be at least one Cult because there had to be a Cult Leader to convert AM.
This math feels complicated.

If we misyeet --> 2:1:1. Overnight if wolf kills village and no recruitment --> 1:1:1 I don't know what this means for the game tbh but I think it means village can't win.
Overnight if wolf kills village and village recruitment --> 1:2 Cult wins
Overnight if wolf kills cult --> 2:1 and it's a normal f3.
If we yeet wolf --> 3:1. Overnight if no recruitment --> 3:1 tomorrow.
Overnight if recruitment ---> 2:2 Cult wins
If we yeet Cult ---> 3:1, wolf kill overnight makes 2:1 and normal f3 tomorrow.

If we misyeet ---> 1:1:2 I would assume Cult wins, but maybe a joint Wolf/Cult win if the Wolf wincon is still just parity with village.
If we yeet the Wolf ---> 2:2 Cult Wins
If we yeet Cult Leader ---> 2:1:1. Overnight if wolf kills village ---> 1:1:1 village can't win
Overnight wolf kills the cultist ---> 2:1 normal f3
If we yeet the Cultist ----> 2:1:1 Overnight if wolf kills village and no recruitment --> 1:1:1 village can't win
Overnight if wolf kills village and village recruitment --> 1:2 Cult wins
Overnight if wolf kills cult --> 2:1 and it's a normal f3.
 
WildZoo said:
I haven't decided if it is time to share that yet.
Click to expand...
But we know you have a PR now? Genny claims blocker, True claims vanilla turned 1x axe vig, I claim vanilla, Sporty claims vanilla
 
Truenamer said:
I need a manator but I think my adoptive manator may be an awoo 😔
Click to expand...
I'm not 🙁
If you misyeet me today the only shot we still have of winning is if it is 3:1:1 right now and the wolf kills Cult overnight. I don't like those odds.
 
bluestoat said:
But we know you have a PR now? Genny claims blocker, True claims vanilla turned 1x axe vig, I claim vanilla, Sporty claims vanilla
Click to expand...
I know, I just hate sharing my role info in general and I need a bit of time to think to make sure it's the right time. It probably is but it's something I like to be sure of.
 
And even in that circumstance, I’m concerned True is still scum.

I should be getting preapproved for a mortgage right now but instead I’m cycling through various panics.
 
SportPonies said:
I mean, I get wanting to wait but this feels…. Sketchy. Idk.
Click to expand...
We have a lot of time so yes I am going to take the time to think through things and make sure I'm not jumping the gun/that it might not be beneficial to see more discussion first.
 
SportPonies said:
I guess I’m not really seeing how Dubz isn’t scum UNLESS (and exactly unless) True is a wolf claiming the NK.
Click to expand...
I agree.

She keeps making me feel so bad and I keep not wanting to say this but... I think she just has really fuzzy pockets

Yeet Dubz
 
SportPonies said:
I guess I’m not really seeing how Dubz isn’t scum UNLESS (and exactly unless) True is a wolf claiming the NK.
Click to expand...
Well, there's the genny possibility. Feels less likely with the kdswg vote, but since I know I'm village I have to be open to shenanigans.
There's the possibility that the wolf decided not to submit a kill, to avoid an automatic Cult win.
 
Fine
I'm an even night seer (and a cute little goat).
I seered True N2 because Zenge was pretty convinced in our PM that he was a wolf, and I was worried I'd been pocketed by my adopted nooblet.
I was blocked last night, as you all know.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
58K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
42K
Clem J
Clem J
WildZoo
Supernatural: Angels & Demons WW Game Thread
110 111 112 113 114
Replies
6K
Views
60K
Clem J
Clem J
supershorty
StardeWW Valley - Sign Up Thread - Sign Ups CLOSED - Game Start 2/2
2 3 4 5
Replies
222
Views
7K
Melchizedek
Melchizedek
supershorty
StardeWW 2: Ginger Island - GAME THREAD
129 130 131 132 133
Replies
7K
Views
130K
Viscernable
Viscernable
Top