Apologies, been trying to build this today but haven't had much time till now. Here are my current reads:
Animal Midwife - They lay out the logic behind their votes very easily. They also poke and ask good questions. Heavy town read for me.
Apoptosis09 - Slight wolf lean, see prior post.
CeeGee14 - Initially they called out Jay’s POE for being stacked with lurkers, questioning why Dya voted Genny instead of Beans to save Jay. Some of their reads are definitely on the safe/hedgy side, but overall they read more like a busy villager trying to piece things together rather than a wolf playing it cool. Neutral read.
Clem J - Leaning town on them. Their progression through Day 1 just doesn't feel performative. When they pushed dya, they were completely open about it being simple logic without getting defensive. Their reaction to Katie's treestump claim was pretty pragmatic instead of opportunistic too.
Katiemcat - Wolf lean here, more so than apop but I still have my suspicions. AMs analysis certainly helped here, as well as the prior noob game I played with Katie they did play very differently.
Beans2020 - I’m leaning town on beans right now, but keeping an open mind. Her play around EOD 1 felt pretty natural.
Genny - Neutral here, I am unsure how to really feel about them yet. I am struggling to read them fully.
HRH Queeb SAR - Neutral to maybe slight wolf lean? The conversation surrounding their post restrictions intrigues me. This is only my second werewolf game, and I already have a hard time reading quieter players let alone restricted ones.
Moonstermash - Neutral/wolf lean A lot of moonster’s posting leans heavily on setup logistics and role mechanics. The actual reads feel mostly reactive and heavily hedged with vibes and POE. What pings me most is the comment about being willing to "vote basille before katie though, for wagons if nothing else." This feels like passive wagon testing to me. Less like solving and more like positioning for an easy compromise vote without building a real case.
@moonstermash : what specifically puts my slot ahead of katie for you outside of wagon viability? If it's mostly POE, what are you actually looking for from me?
Alex_DVM: Neutral, mostly due to them being unable to post most so it is hard to get a good read here. I am interested in hearing from them more.
Black Kat - Town lean. Their progression across both days feels organic to me. They actively react to vote shifts and also ask good questions.
Chilly_md - Slight village lean. They aren’t forcing pushes or jumping on easy wagons. They are on the quieter side and mostly react to what is already happening, but overall as a confused noob myself I can relate.
Reddeadrobin - Neutral. They have been relatively low on proactive case building, but I am struggling overall to read them as well.
