- Joined
- Jan 23, 2016
- Messages
- 35,473
- Reaction score
- 43,322
Could you quote where he voted? I completely missed that.
Could you quote where he voted? I completely missed that.
Ah, is the dartboard thing typical for him? I went back to BoWWling because I didn't remember whether he typically does that (and the only other game I can think of that I played with him is Okami, and... Well.).Not sure if you saw my response to Santy about this but basically, Lawpy specifically said MK was on his "dart board". From experience with Lawpy, his dart board usually includes a couple names, and since he only voted for MK, without mentioning the other names, I was curious to see who else was on his "dart board" who he wasn't voting for.
@Animal MidwifeGood morning everyone!
Yeet Santy
Could you quote where he voted? I completely missed that.
...
Good morning everyone!
Yeet Santy
Ah okay. I wonder why Nate didn't ask about this vote.
Interesting ISO. I’m interested to see your thoughts on Santy tooZenge
p#6 is NAI, knowing that it is a joke. I like that Santy found it suspicious though as it's the same sort of thing I look for.
p#9 is town indicative I think. I think a wolf here with this kind of post would angle it more toward the fact that no one else was posting (I've seen wolves open in such a way a few times), but the center of gravity in Zenge's post is on himself. Like it doesn't have that forced pro-towny tone wolves have.
p#26 p#29 and p#31 do have an off vibe, but I'm not sure if they are off because of Zenge or Clem. But Zenge's tone here is different than his tone in his posts addressed toward others so far. I could see this interaction as either w/w or t who has more insight on Clem than me from previous meta, and thus genuinely finds Clem's opening suspicious. I will circle back to which way I lean after I read through Clem's posts.
p#61 this is another notable interaction. Lawpy is the first player Zenge has asked a question of. Why is Zenge interested in Lawpy's reads in particular at this time? @Zenge
p#75 Zenge asks AM about Lawpy. Is Zenge gearing up to push Lawpy. Let us see.
p#116 I find to be very town indicative. It makes a clarification that does not necessarily benefit wolf Zenge. Santy (I think) said that this could be wolf Zenge trying to tie himself to a towny, but I don't think so. It moreso looks unpairing in Zenge flipped wolf so I don't think w!Zenge makes that post in v!mkg world. Further, I don't think w!Zenge would feel the need to dismantle Santy's post unpairing he and his partner, so I don't think it's w!Zenge in a w!mkg world either. Hence, I think the post just comes from town.
I'm stopping the ISO here. I will do Clem and Lawpy next.
I think I see what you’re getting at but it feels like a stretch to view it as town aligning. Zenges lurking is a bit of a WW meme here which is why that post in itself looks NAI to me.p#9 is town indicative I think. I think a wolf here with this kind of post would angle it more toward the fact that no one else was posting (I've seen wolves open in such a way a few times), but the center of gravity in Zenge's post is on himself. Like it doesn't have that forced pro-towny tone wolves have.
Mkg and Zenge prob unpaired based on Mkg's vote too.
@Santygrass @Khepri i agree with the assessment that Zenges is unpaired with MKG especially with the above Zenges post. So we can rule out W/WNah. I bet Wolf MK would joke vote me D1 if we were packmates
I used a dartboard in CYO 3Ah, is the dartboard thing typical for him? I went back to BoWWling because I didn't remember whether he typically does that (and the only other game I can think of that I played with him is Okami, and... Well.).
Ah, fair enough.I think I see what you’re getting at but it feels like a stretch to view it as town aligning. Zenges lurking is a bit of a WW meme here which is why that post in itself looks NAI to me.
On the premise that the post truly indicates that Zenges is unpaired with MKG, my assumption is that w!Zenge would be aware enough to know that. Therefore, it would be against his interest to make that post as it narrows down the pool of possible teams. As town, however, he's just being honest. And I think the latter is more likely than the former.@Santygrass @Khepri i agree with the assessment that Zenges is unpaired with MKG especially with the above Zenges post. So we can rule out W/W
But help me understand how this post is AI? Because I don’t understand how this post helps Zenges regardless of his affiliation?
I don't disbelieve this.Hi guys I'm a wolf lol
I like the vibes of this post though. @Clem J are you Nanook or was that just some inside joke I'm not privy to?I think santy is town and I feel like seeing where it goes
Here I cite the VOTECOUNT , not mkg jokevote to make this read..
Mkg and Zenge prob unpaired based on Mkg's vote too
Zenge jumps up with this post, dismissing with the joke part, after True asks me for more insight on the read. So, here Zenge is jumping to a conclussion and already dismissing it for people to not discard a W!Zenge / W!MKG world.Nah. I bet Wolf MK would joke vote me D1 if we were packmates
Agreed
That was me answering True. It happened later and idk why I quoted it. Maybe to more insight for lawpy in regards to the zenge/mkg unpairingThe vote without context? Yeah super easy to fake.
Putting your partner at 4 votes? Zenge knowing how stubborn I was on Cray's ass D1? I dont think so much. It obviously depends on how theh fluctuate a little, but Im pretty sure that its unpairing.
On the premise that the post truly indicates that Zenges is unpaired with MKG, my assumption is that w!Zenge would be aware enough to know that. Therefore, it would be against his interest to make that post as it narrows down the pool of possible teams. As town, however, he's just being honest. And I think the latter is more likely than the former.
Absolutely. It's mostly a salt yeet to get things started, because one thing I disliked about my play last game was how long I sat on all of my votes. Trying to be intentional about overcoming that habit.
See above. Both were options, but I know Santy a bit less well.I haven't asked specifically but I've been treating it as a salt vote.
Although I guess that begs the question @Truenamer why Santy over AM, if it's a salt vote?
That is Nanook. Are you saying you're leaning into him being a wolf or village here?Clem
I don't disbelieve this.
I like the vibes of this post though. @Clem J are you Nanook or was that just some inside joke I'm not privy to?
Someone mentioned that Clem stating he is a wolf is just a joke about his animal. I like that idea. I think I lean town here despite the lack of content to go off of. I'm trying to get in the mindset of Clem having wolf flavor + randing wolf vs having wolf flavor + randing town. I think he would probably have a similar first post either way but would probably lean into it more with his subsequent posts and be quick to explain the joke. I know this is probably a weird read but it's just a feeling.
Very amused. Normally I like lurking around.
But since I’m just here with midwife I feel like I have to talk. Nothing but a sea of angry reacts though. Smh.
p#9 is town indicative I think. I think a wolf here with this kind of post would angle it more toward the fact that no one else was posting (I've seen wolves open in such a way a few times), but the center of gravity in Zenge's post is on himself. Like it doesn't have that forced pro-towny tone wolves have.
p#26 p#29 and p#31 do have an off vibe, but I'm not sure if they are off because of Zenge or Clem. But Zenge's tone here is different than his tone in his posts addressed toward others so far. I could see this interaction as either w/w or t who has more insight on Clem than me from previous meta, and thus genuinely finds Clem's opening suspicious. I will circle back to which way I lean after I read through Clem's posts.
Ah, is the dartboard thing typical for him? I went back to BoWWling because I didn't remember whether he typically does that (and the only other game I can think of that I played with him is Okami, and... Well.).
I don't recall if it's ever been replacated in wolf games, but she has done definitely looked at past games as village before.Also, I need someone from SDN to check how often PSV goes to other games to check this sort of stuff? Cause I feel like they are pocketing me with this intent and WIM of just looking at stuff ad trying to solve that just strike me as super villa and dont remember from their wolf game.
I think it's a matter of whether you think he made a level 0 or level 1 post."Oh they are unpairing me and MKG" > "If I post something dismissing it they would think that its true" .
When in that scenario, if they dont post something the read is going to stay either way?
Like, I think the line lf thought in where W!Zenge makes that post to put in doubt that read is just much more likely? Specially cuz they are pseudo-sheeping true read too?. Its also the direct intention of the post, so i dont think that townreading Zenge for it is.... A good idea tbh
VillageThat is Nanook. Are you saying you're leaning into him being a wolf or village here?
I'm not sure I follow your circular reasoning here. It all feels strongly WIFOM to me.I think it's a matter of whether you think he made a level 0 or level 1 post.
For reference,
Level 0: the perspective of their own alignment
Level 1: the hypothetical perspective of being townie
Level 2: the perspective of someone else as a scum player from the hypothetical perspective of being a townie
Examples:
Lv 0: I know x is town.
Lv 1: I don't know X is town; therefore, Y.
Lv 2: If X is scum, they would(n't) think Y; therefore, Z.
Applied to this situation,
Lv 0: I am a wolf. MKG is town. Santy doesn't think we are paired. I should disuade that.
Lv 1: I am a wolf. MKG is a wolf. Santy doesn't think we are paired. I should reinforce that by saying we actually could still be paired.
I think experienced scum players are more likely to react to posts from a lvl 1 perspective rather than a lvl 0. Zenge, I presume, is an experienced scum player. Therefore, I think if he is a wolf, he made that post from a lvl 1 perspective. However, due to the phrasing/tone (the "nah" especially), I don't think he and MKG are aligned. Therefore, I don't think he is a wolf.
It's not circular, but I did think someone would think so. It's more like sudoku. It's just hard to explain the tone part of the read.I'm not sure I follow your circular reasoning here. It all feels strongly WIFOM to me.
I mean, I get tone reads are hard to explain. It's when you start talking tiers and such that you lose me.It's not circular, but I did think someone would think so. It's more like sudoku. It's just hard to explain the tone part of the read.
This is town indicative to me. The tone of it. Although Lumi just made a post like this as mafia at the beginning of the Champs finale so maybe I shouldn't be reading into it. Actually, the context is somewhat different. The Zenge post really is quite NAI so this reaction feels real to me.Really? That looks NAI to me
Lawpy seems to be keen on in dismantling town reads of ZengeI think I see what you’re getting at but it feels like a stretch to view it as town aligning. Zenges lurking is a bit of a WW meme here which is why that post in itself looks NAI to me.
@Santygrass @Khepri i agree with the assessment that Zenges is unpaired with MKG especially with the above Zenges post. So we can rule out W/W
But help me understand how this post is AI? Because I don’t understand how this post helps Zenges regardless of his affiliation?
Pretty much, yes!I mean, I get tone reads are hard to explain. It's when you start talking tiers and such that you lose me.
But a tl;dr would be you are village reading Zenge because while scum might say the things he's said, they would say so differently?
Zenges appears to be the main discussion today and I don’t lean him either way right now. I wouldn’t say I’m dismantling anyone’s reads of him but rather asking for clarification because I want to understand how the posts that I’m viewing as NAI is AI to others, whether town or scum indicative.Lawpy
This is town indicative to me. The tone of it. Although Lumi just made a post like this as mafia at the beginning of the Champs finale so maybe I shouldn't be reading into it. Actually, the context is somewhat different. The Zenge post really is quite NAI so this reaction feels real to me.
Lawpy seems to be keen on in dismantling town reads of Zenge
@Lawpy why the preoccupation with Zenge reads?
Yes, I follow your reasoning here. But I still think you are assuming a less likely line of thought to apply a townread. Like, I am not disregarding Zenge's level of play, but it was a read in realtime and I just think that it just is more natural for them to have done so. Just because someone is experienced dismissing like, the level 0 approach which is the direct one is just... Wrong?I think it's a matter of whether you think he made a level 0 or level 1 post.
For reference,
Level 0: the perspective of their own alignment
Level 1: the hypothetical perspective of being townie
Level 2: the perspective of someone else as a scum player from the hypothetical perspective of being a townie
Examples:
Lv 0: I know x is town.
Lv 1: I don't know X is town; therefore, Y.
Lv 2: If X is scum, they would(n't) think Y; therefore, Z.
Applied to this situation,
Lv 0: I am a wolf. MKG is town. Santy doesn't think we are paired. I should disuade that.
Lv 1: I am a wolf. MKG is a wolf. Santy doesn't think we are paired. I should reinforce that by saying we actually could still be paired.
I think experienced scum players are more likely to react to posts from a lvl 1 perspective rather than a lvl 0. Zenge, I presume, is an experienced scum player. Therefore, I think if he is a wolf, he made that post from a lvl 1 perspective. However, due to the phrasing/tone (the "nah" especially), I don't think he and MKG are aligned. Therefore, I don't think he is a wolf.
Ok, I'm coming around to your point, like always.Yes, I follow your reasoning here. But I still think you are assuming a less likely line of thought to apply a townread. Like, I am not disregarding Zenge's level lf play, but it was a read in realtime and I just think that it just is more natural for them to have done so. Just because someone is experienced dismissing like, the level 0 approach which is the direct one is just... Wrong?
As a wolf it means that if you have more knowledge youbare totally capable of doing more level reads and stuff, but Occam's still is there for something and the level 0 stuff still applies ?
Thats where I go at least.
And If I flip and take it as Zenge Villa , the scenarios go like this
*Santy is doing an unpairing read which is correct. > I'll take it. (Doesnt happen here)
*Santy is doing an unpairing read which is correct. > I dont agree with the logic of it so I am going to question santy (Doesnt happen)
*Santy is doing an unpairing read which is correct. > I dont agree with that logic, so I am going to dismiss it and brush that solving path aside. (This is what happens, and its like the least pro-Villa of the three imo)
I decided to do Truenamer next because this post pinged me as it did Lawpy.I like this reaction from Zenge more than I like the votes on him.
But I actually think the explanation here is fine. That it was the crispness of it rather than the content itself (which as I stated before, I think is strikingly NAI).I'm sure wolf Zenge would say something similar, but I like the crispness. It's a very teensy tiny data point towards V!Zenge.
Just don't love that he's got three votes on him before everyone's even entered the thread. Not even necessarily any wolves on him, just don't like it.
EDIT- Four votes, now. Zenge apparently wore his wolf-scented cologne.
I also like the ease of this joke.But you can't be jailer this game, there's only one
Locked town. Also, you're very funny.Khepri is the fractal-clad hero and goddess who got Everyone to Work Together. Easy to remember 😍
Watch out for that. Truenamer is a great pocketeer with jokes. 😡I also like the ease of this joke.
And yet...I dont think its paricularly good for Zenge to be the only focus, even if I think they are a wolf.
Okay but seriously what are YOU doing to change that?While I like for Zenge to be lead wagon, I dont think its paricularly good for Zenge to be the only focus, even if I think they are a wolf.
Wowee this might be the most intense Zenge-angery that I have seen to date.Okay but seriously what are YOU doing to change that?
and again and more importantly, WHY DO YOU NOT TAKE ISSUE WITH CLEM SHEEPING YOU AND PROVIDING LITERALLY NOTHING OF VALUE?
I've tried to have discussions with multiple people but your endless non sense tunnel has dominated the thread. Maybe I should just shut the F up and sheep you like clem instead of actually trying to solve the game
Am I wrong though? Like I don't see how blindly sheeping Santy's incorrect read and literally providing no content gets a pass for Clem.Wowee this might be the most intense Zenge-angery that I have seen to date.
Yeah I agree. I want to see what JJJ said about it because I think I remember him mentioning Clem often sheeping people he found village but I also don't remember if he claimed that was AI.Am I wrong though? Like I don't see how blindly sheeping Santy's incorrect read and literally providing no content gets a pass for Clem.
And I still don't fully get why he's TRing Santy in the first place since iirc he made that decision after Santy made one post.
How are you reading True this game?Watch out for that. Truenamer is a great pocketeer with jokes. 😡
You have the answer to that in the same post you are quoting.Okay but seriously what are YOU doing to change that?
and again and more importantly, WHY DO YOU NOT TAKE ISSUE WITH CLEM SHEEPING YOU AND PROVIDING LITERALLY NOTHING OF VALUE?
I've tried to have discussions with multiple people but your endless non sense tunnel has dominated the thread. Maybe I should just shut the F up and sheep you like clem instead of actually trying to solve the game
Neutral currently. Haven't seen enough to lean him any which way. The comment about me having a crisis of faith about him felt somewhat pockety but maybe he's always going to look fuzzy after *that*How are you reading True this game?
I think there's literally nothing else being discussed on thread because of this discussion which I know is incorrect.Now, do you think that my suspicions on you are the thing that doesnt let you interact with other people and solve them? Have you seen me shut up someone cuz I sussed you ? I think not
Do you mean not re-evaluating and discussing other possibilities?first sus I got and acting accordingly.
>I literally just engaged with Seven to discuss their reads regarding you too.Do you mean not re-evaluating and discussing other possibilities?
I mean by all means leave your vote on me but I don't see you discussing literally anything else.
So I generally find him sort of wolfy, and have historically misread him as a wolf when he's been village. So I'm trying to get better at evaluating his wolfy aura as more village!True indicative.@Zenge142 what are your thoughts on Truenamer?