WildZoo's WWildZoo- Game Thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Members do not see this ad.
genny said:
You conveniently glossed over the changing story part of my post. What villager does that?
Click to expand...
It wasn't relevant to what I was responding to, which was your comment about me asking her for more info. I didn't "gloss over" anything, and you starting to freak out a bit at me for something as dumb as that makes me squint at you a bit, tbh. You're starting to act like someone peed in your coffee this morning ☕

But since you're asking, I still think the inconsistencies are sketchy. I still think her first D1 post that I mentioned earlier was sketchy. The weaker incoherency of the tone of her responses to STL are sketchy. Her claiming an ability doesn't change any of that. But she is one of those people who I have stylistically clashed with a little bit in the past (see that same .ww game she's mentioning as evidence if you're curious), and given that she says she can prove the ability, I'd rather test that than my feels at this time.

Make sense?
 
genny said:
You could ask Hmoo for more info before just unlynching. 😵

But then again, it's not like she responded to my post earlier where I pointed out how her story keeps changing today. She's lying to the group, and that's never good as a villager.
Click to expand...

HOW HAS MY STORY CHANGED??? I haven't lied to anyone! I've been telling the truth this whole time and people aren't listening!!
 
hazelmoo said:
Fixed that for you... I'm not a wolf. Please, what could one night hurt?? Give me a CHANCE. If you really want, I can reveal my role. But why not let me live a night and then let me prove that I'm a villager? And if not, just lynch me tomorrow!
Click to expand...

This. This is the type of sentence that makes me gut grumble. There shouldn't even be that thought in my mind as a villager, because it wouldn't be a question that you proved yourself.
 
Lupin21 said:
This. This is the type of sentence that makes me gut grumble. There shouldn't even be that thought in my mind as a villager, because it wouldn't be a question that you proved yourself.
Click to expand...
I'm actually curious about your thought process here. Maybe I'm remembering things wrong, but I feel like you've been more on board with this kind of thing in the past. Is it just the wording in this case that's bugging you, or the whole premise?

Edit: Never mind-- I guess you already kind of answered this; on my phone and glossed over your earlier post:
Lupin21 said:
for me, if they seem like a wolf, Imma vote them. Hmoo can continue to change my mind with relevant appeals, but the let me prove my ability doesn't cut it because it could still be a villager seeming ability but she is still a wolf. Or something worse.
Click to expand...
 
Lupin21 said:
This. This is the type of sentence that makes me gut grumble. There shouldn't even be that thought in my mind as a villager, because it wouldn't be a question that you proved yourself.
Click to expand...
I'm on my hands and knees to try and convince you to give me a chance. And IF YOU ARE NOT SATISFIED WITH THAT TOMORROW, LYNCH ME THEN. Or if someone has any better information, then we can catch a real wolf. I'm trying to give myself time because I KNOW I'm innocent, and you people don't. I want to catch wolves, and I want to play WW. I don't want to be lynched. What else can I offer you besides the opportunity to kill me if you're not satisfied?
 
PippyPony said:
I'm actually curious about your thought process here. Maybe I'm remembering things wrong, but I feel like you've been more on board with this kind of thing in the past. Is it just the wording in this case that's bugging you, or the whole premise?
Click to expand...
It is the initial defense she put up. I think it was a huge whoops to use she wouldn't kill jojo on his first game back in a while as proof she couldn't be a wolf, only to have to admit she didn't have a clue that was the case. I am not willing to risk her being a wolf trying to use this prove ability ploy because the read is too strong. I am always for it if I don't have enough to put someone into a questionable category. It isn't the case here.
 
hazelmoo said:
HOW HAS MY STORY CHANGED??? I haven't lied to anyone! I've been telling the truth this whole time and people aren't listening!!
Click to expand...
When you were first asked, you initially said you didn't know rojo had been gone from WW. Over time, that story changed to you didn't know he had been in retirement, but you knew he hadn't played the last few games. A villager wouldn't have a changing story like that, because it wouldn't be a story, it would be the truth. A villager would stand by a statement that made them look bad, because villagers do make mistakes. Only a wolf would feel the need to alter something as trivial as that, to make themselves look better.
 
hazelmoo said:
Fixed that for you... I'm not a wolf. Please, what could one night hurt?? Give me a CHANCE. If you really want, I can reveal my role. But why not let me live a night and then let me prove that I'm a villager? And if not, just lynch me tomorrow!
Click to expand...
Well if you were a wolf, one night could hurt by an added conversion if you are the converter, an added kill if you are an even night killer, a Wolfy item if you are a wolf tinkerer, a lynch svoidance if you are the lawyer, a block of a villager if you are a blocker, a guaranteed kill if you are a strongman, etc.

By saying you have a role ability you have already placed a target on your back if you are not a wolf. Seering/tracking type roles are often not revealed to the user, so you can't bank on that. And tje ability doesn't indicate if someone is a villager. If you are claiming protector, you have entered into a cat and mouse game with the wolves the rest of the game (and it's not 100% that the person is a villager nonetheless) Blocking does not indicate at all villager status. If you can cancel a night, just say that and we will watch night be cancelled tomorrow. Pm ability wouldn't indicate wolf vs. villager. Resurrection could be useful, and if you had that wolves would be in a conundrum, as they could either try and kill you knowing you would likely be protected, try and indefinitely block you which would put that the blocker is a wolf if they have a blocker, or convert you knowing you will be investigated. I could keep going on with the list, but the point is that once you say "I have an ability", the damage is already done, especially if you are saying its able to be demonstrated.
 
hazelmoo said:
I'm on my hands and knees to try and convince you to give me a chance. And IF YOU ARE NOT SATISFIED WITH THAT TOMORROW, LYNCH ME THEN. Or if someone has any better information, then we can catch a real wolf. I'm trying to give myself time because I KNOW I'm innocent, and you people don't. I want to catch wolves, and I want to play WW. I don't want to be lynched. What else can I offer you besides the opportunity to kill me if you're not satisfied?
Click to expand...
Have you done any discussion about other people in the game that you think are off other than a quick blurb on MMM? Have you proven a pattern of my tunneling on you?
 
hazelmoo said:
I'm on my hands and knees to try and convince you to give me a chance. And IF YOU ARE NOT SATISFIED WITH THAT TOMORROW, LYNCH ME THEN. Or if someone has any better information, then we can catch a real wolf. I'm trying to give myself time because I KNOW I'm innocent, and you people don't. I want to catch wolves, and I want to play WW. I don't want to be lynched. What else can I offer you besides the opportunity to kill me if you're not satisfied?
Click to expand...
Usually, for someone to "prove" their ability, they have a PM partner they disclose to, who can then vouch for them tomorrow. How exactly do you prove it in a game with no group PMs?
 
genny said:
When you were first asked, you initially said you didn't know rojo had been gone from WW. Over time, that story changed to you didn't know he had been in retirement, but you knew he hadn't played the last few games. A villager wouldn't have a changing story like that, because it wouldn't be a story, it would be the truth. A villager would stand by a statement that made them look bad, because villagers do make mistakes. Only a wolf would feel the need to alter something as trivial as that, to make themselves look better.
Click to expand...
I haven't played WW with him in the last few games that I can remember. Therefor, knowing he hasn't played in a while but not thinking he hasn't played for a LONG while (aka, retirement)

SummerTheLynx said:
Well if you were a wolf, one night could hurt by an added conversion if you are the converter, an added kill if you are an even night killer, a Wolfy item if you are a wolf tinkerer, a lynch svoidance if you are the lawyer, a block of a villager if you are a blocker, a guaranteed kill if you are a strongman, etc.

By saying you have a role ability you have already placed a target on your back if you are not a wolf. Seering/tracking type roles are often not revealed to the user, so you can't bank on that. And tje ability doesn't indicate if someone is a villager. If you are claiming protector, you have entered into a cat and mouse game with the wolves the rest of the game (and it's not 100% that the person is a villager nonetheless) Blocking does not indicate at all villager status. If you can cancel a night, just say that and we will watch night be cancelled tomorrow. Pm ability wouldn't indicate wolf vs. villager. Resurrection could be useful, and if you had that wolves would be in a conundrum, as they could either try and kill you knowing you would likely be protected, try and indefinitely block you which would put that the blocker is a wolf if they have a blocker, or convert you knowing you will be investigated. I could keep going on with the list, but the point is that once you say "I have an ability", the damage is already done, especially if you are saying its able to be demonstrated.
Click to expand...

What else did you suggest I do to defend myself STL? Besides telling you what I've been telling you all day? I haven't gone through to analyze people yet besides feels because I've been trying to not get lynched.
genny said:
Usually, for someone to "prove" their ability, they have a PM partner they disclose to, who can then vouch for them tomorrow. How exactly do you prove it in a game with no group PMs?
Click to expand...

I haven't gotten that far yet. I figured if I could last another night and tell you what happens you'd believe me. And then maybe I could be protected after that.
 
hazelmoo said:
I'm on my hands and knees to try and convince you to give me a chance. And IF YOU ARE NOT SATISFIED WITH THAT TOMORROW, LYNCH ME THEN. Or if someone has any better information, then we can catch a real wolf. I'm trying to give myself time because I KNOW I'm innocent, and you people don't. I want to catch wolves, and I want to play WW. I don't want to be lynched. What else can I offer you besides the opportunity to kill me if you're not satisfied?
Click to expand...
sorry moo. I mean, I am willing to listen to your cases on other people and consider them if you make a good point, but I can't shake the wrongness you put off in your opening today. Maybe it was a villager mistake, and I will add it to my stats of reading people wrong for that kind of statement, but I can't recall ever being wrong on someone with that blatant a lie before.
 
Day 2 So Many Dicks At Once Lynch Tally

pippy (0) -
strider (0) -
LIS (0) -
hazel (5) - STL, lyra, ny, genny, Lupin
AM (2)- cheat, Coop
3M (3)- AM, hazel, DVMD
FS (1)- Pippy

@hazelmoo you are in the lead!

11/22 votes (woa so many votes needed!)

Deadline: 11pm EST (~5 hours)
 
SummerTheLynx said:
Well if you were a wolf, one night could hurt by an added conversion if you are the converter, an added kill if you are an even night killer, a Wolfy item if you are a wolf tinkerer, a lynch svoidance if you are the lawyer, a block of a villager if you are a blocker, a guaranteed kill if you are a strongman, etc.

By saying you have a role ability you have already placed a target on your back if you are not a wolf. Seering/tracking type roles are often not revealed to the user, so you can't bank on that. And tje ability doesn't indicate if someone is a villager. If you are claiming protector, you have entered into a cat and mouse game with the wolves the rest of the game (and it's not 100% that the person is a villager nonetheless) Blocking does not indicate at all villager status. If you can cancel a night, just say that and we will watch night be cancelled tomorrow. Pm ability wouldn't indicate wolf vs. villager. Resurrection could be useful, and if you had that wolves would be in a conundrum, as they could either try and kill you knowing you would likely be protected, try and indefinitely block you which would put that the blocker is a wolf if they have a blocker, or convert you knowing you will be investigated. I could keep going on with the list, but the point is that once you say "I have an ability", the damage is already done, especially if you are saying its able to be demonstrated.
Click to expand...
This was basically my thought process. I can't think of a way that hmoo could definitively prove her ability (and villager status) and also remain an asset to the village, but I can think of a lot of reasons a wolf would want to stick around one more night.
 
I'm going to feel really bad if not a wolf, but the wanting to prove an ability with no plan for how to prove that ability is enough to put me over the edge.

lynch hazelmoo
 
Does anyone remember the last couple of times hmoo was a wolf? I want to look back at those games briefly
 
hazelmoo said:
I haven't gotten that far yet. I figured if I could last another night and tell you what happens you'd believe me. And then maybe I could be protected after that.
Click to expand...

what...?? you're begging for everyone to let you prove your ability but haven't figured out how to prove it? you're banking on the people that are trying to lynch you today to take you at your word tomorrow?? I'm sorry, but this just doesn't make any sense to me.

lynch hmoo
 
LyraGardenia said:
This was basically my thought process. I can't think of a way that hmoo could definitively prove her ability (and villager status) and also remain an asset to the village, but I can think of a lot of reasons a wolf would want to stick around one more night.
Click to expand...

WW is about numbers. ANY villager is an asset to the village.

genny said:
Why should we take your word for it tomorrow, when before you said you could prove your ability?
Click to expand...

I WILL be able to prove it, if you let me. If I'm going to say it tomorrow, I might as well say it now... I'd rather be wolf killed than killed by MY OWN PEOPLE. I'm an elephant. An elephant who never forgets, I'm basically a reverse tracker. I figured someone would do something to me and I could say on the thread that SO AND SO did something to me without revealing what they did. Sorry I suck at WW, but at least I'm trying unlike the few people who haven't contributed s*** so far.
 
Hmoo, I'd like to hear some of your thoughts on other players this game (besides the STL always wanting to lynch you thing)
 
SummerTheLynx said:
Do you remember prior to that? ideally want to look at three games.
Click to expand...

I looked through my messages and that was the only time besides when I was converted in my noob game (child's play). Let me look again just in case I missed one so I'm not accused of lying.
 
raf2769 said:
Hmoo, I'd like to hear some of your thoughts on other players this game (besides the STL always wanting to lynch you thing)
Click to expand...

I am always suspicious of players who are silent. That's the easiest way to sneak by. LIS hasn't said anything besides throwing out random votes. I am sketched out by nohika who hasn't said much either, only voted for Jil "cause she can", (who is the one person I actually feel confident is village). And finnick. Literally 5 post and the first one was a throw away vote.
 
hazelmoo said:
I am always suspicious of players who are silent. That's the easiest way to sneak by. LIS hasn't said anything besides throwing out random votes. I am sketched out by nohika who hasn't said much either, only voted for Jil "cause she can", (who is the one person I actually feel confident is village). And finnick. Literally 5 post and the first one was a throw away vote.
Click to expand...

To be honest... none of that is abnormal for those players. LIS doesn't say things until he is off work or has time, then he posts a **** ton at once.
Nohika doesn't tend to say much unless necessary.
And Finn tends to be quiet as well.

Yes, makes it hard to read people, but this isn't abnormal for them. Of the 3, LIS should start posting more when he has the time just have to be patient for the LeTits Dump of Reads.
 
Looking through that game, hmoo was super quiet all game attributing it to actual real life stuff (where she apologized on thread to trilt about t after death). Not a good data point because activity was minimal. Did claim a compelling role and got a couple of people to switch off, but in the end got lynched. In that game she quoted role from trilt.

Reverse tracking is an interesting claim with elephant, would have expected something with more of a memory function. Also, saying that "I got blocked" or "I got _____" is self explanatory if people can see that that happened to them without the role. Hmoo, care to elaborate more on the role?
 
hazelmoo said:
WW is about numbers. ANY villager is an asset to the village.

I WILL be able to prove it, if you let me. If I'm going to say it tomorrow, I might as well say it now... I'd rather be wolf killed than killed by MY OWN PEOPLE. I'm an elephant. An elephant who never forgets, I'm basically a reverse tracker. I figured someone would do something to me and I could say on the thread that SO AND SO did something to me without revealing what they did. Sorry I suck at WW, but at least I'm trying unlike the few people who haven't contributed s*** so far.
Click to expand...
I'm a bit unsure of whether to take your word on this or not. Specifically because of the "an elephant never forgets" portion. I know in the trout's noob circus game, this exact same wording was used for the elephant, which COULD have been carried over to this game since cdo was playing that game and designed this one and trout is pseudomodding this one, but it could also just be looking back in the noob circus spreadsheet for something that sounds believable for an elephant to make up a fake claim. The elephant in that game wasn't a reverse tracker, so if you were looking for a fake role claim, you didn't copy completely, which could be to make your claim more believable, or an elephant reverse tracker COULD actually be your role and cdo just stole that bit of wording from that game.

Originally I was on Team Let-Hmoo-Prove-Her-Ability, but I'm a bit more concerned now because you said "let me prove my ability" but then said you didn't even have a plan for doing so...
 
hazelmoo said:
I am always suspicious of players who are silent. That's the easiest way to sneak by. LIS hasn't said anything besides throwing out random votes. I am sketched out by nohika who hasn't said much either, only voted for Jil "cause she can", (who is the one person I actually feel confident is village). And finnick. Literally 5 post and the first one was a throw away vote.
Click to expand...

so in 12 pages of the game, no one has actually said anything you think is sketchy? only the quiet people are suspicious?
 
SummerTheLynx said:
Looking through that game, hmoo was super quiet all game attributing it to actual real life stuff (where she apologized on thread to trilt about t after death). Not a good data point because activity was minimal. Did claim a compelling role and got a couple of people to switch off, but in the end got lynched. In that game she quoted role from trilt.

Reverse tracking is an interesting claim with elephant, would have expected something with more of a memory function. Also, saying that "I got blocked" or "I got _____" is self explanatory if people can see that that happened to them without the role. Hmoo, care to elaborate more on the role?
Click to expand...

It is a memory function lol. I "don't forget" what has been done to me, so I know the name of whoever has done what to me. For example: you've been seered by STL. No one has done anything to me yet so I don't know the exact working the mods would use.
 
hazelmoo said:
I WILL be able to prove it, if you let me. If I'm going to say it tomorrow, I might as well say it now... I'd rather be wolf killed than killed by MY OWN PEOPLE. I'm an elephant. An elephant who never forgets, I'm basically a reverse tracker. I figured someone would do something to me and I could say on the thread that SO AND SO did something to me without revealing what they did. Sorry I suck at WW, but at least I'm trying unlike the few people who haven't contributed s*** so far.
Click to expand...
Now I see why you're pleading for another night. You were hoping to catch the seer tonight.
 
raf2769 said:
so in 12 pages of the game, no one has actually said anything you think is sketchy? only the quiet people are suspicious?
Click to expand...
Of course I'm sketched out by certain people, especially the people voting for me or hopping on my bandwagon
genny said:
Now I see why you're pleading for another night. You were hoping to catch the seer tonight.
Click to expand...
No, genius. I was hoping for another night becuse I'm a villager and don't want to die. I know someone is going to do something to me, probably block, so I can see the name of who did it.
 
hazelmoo said:
It is a memory function lol. I "don't forget" what has been done to me, so I know the name of whoever has done what to me. For example: you've been seered by STL. No one has done anything to me yet so I don't know the exact working the mods would use.
Click to expand...
I mean, I feel like getting told the name and ability of someone who visits you would be a pretty powerful ability and essentially functions as a seer itself, not really a reverse tracker IMO
 
SkiOtter said:
I mean, I feel like getting told the name and ability of someone who visits you would be a pretty powerful ability and essentially functions as a seer itself, not really a reverse tracker IMO
Click to expand...

The mods didn't say "reverse tracker", that's just what I perceived it as
 
genny said:
Now I see why you're pleading for another night. You were hoping to catch the seer tonight.
Click to expand...
Isn't reverse tracker a lot more common as village?

Although it would actually be a pretty good ploy to try to get all actions thrown at her tonight, then be able to feed all that info back to the pack before she got lynched.

I'm kind of torn here on whether to switch back, because my early reads are typically my best reads, and I had more wolf marks for hmoo than anyone else as of earlier today.
 
SkiOtter said:
But if you're blocked, wouldn't a block trump your tracking?
Click to expand...
I would really hope not :laugh: especially since the point of my ability is to be able to see what's been done to me
 
PippyPony said:
Isn't reverse tracker a lot more common as village?

Although it would actually be a pretty good ploy to try to get all actions thrown at her tonight, then be able to feed all that info back to the pack before she got lynched.

I'm kind of torn here on whether to switch back, because my early reads are typically my best reads, and I had more wolf marks for hmoo than anyone else as of earlier today.
Click to expand...
I think Trilt calls the role "glean seer" and it can be either.
 
SkiOtter said:
So did they say you just get bits of information about whoever has visited you that night or did they specifically say what you got (name and ability as you're claiming)?
Click to expand...

My role said that I would be given the name of the player along with whatever was done to me.
 
SkiOtter said:
I sure as hell hope hmoo knows how a glean seer works since her noob in the circus ww was Dr. S, the glean seer.
Click to expand...

I honestly don't even remember what her ability was. And ski, I'm not a seer. A seer can pick a name each night and get their role. I can only get a name of whoever physically DOES something to me
 
Whatever you want to call it, now the usefulness of it for village is thoroughly shot, since I doubt anyone's going to take any actions on her for the rest of the game.

Although, flipside: usefulness also shot for wolves lol
 
You people are impossible. I get pissed off and make a mistake, but spend all day trying to defend myself and make up for it. Then, I finally have a way to prove my innocence, and you still shoot it down
 
hazelmoo said:
I honestly don't even remember what her ability was. And ski, I'm not a seer. A seer can pick a name each night and get their role. I can only get a name of whoever physically DOES something to me
Click to expand...
OMG hmoo.... you know I was in the PM between you and Dr. S, right? You want me to quote the part where you tell Dr. S she has seering powers?
 
hazelmoo said:
WW is about numbers. ANY villager is an asset to the village.
Click to expand...
Except you were arguing earlier that we should keep you around because of your ability (and I'm not sure I believe your claim, or that it's inherently village). If you truly want to help the village, give us some analysis of who you think is sketchy, because so far all you've done is call out quiet people when that's just their normal gameplay. If you're arguing that we should just keep you around for village numbers, again, that's a lame defense.

The way I see it, we caught you in a lie earlier today. You defensively claimed after one lynch vote for you that you wouldn't have killed rojo when he hadn't played in a while, then admitted you didn't know that until it was said on thread, then backtracked and said you DID know he hadn't played the last few games but not that he was in retirement. Maybe it was an innocent villager mistake, but I think you're an egg to crack.

hazelmoo said:
It is a memory function lol. I "don't forget" what has been done to me, so I know the name of whoever has done what to me. For example: you've been seered by STL. No one has done anything to me yet so I don't know the exact working the mods would use.
Click to expand...
So would you then out the seer (or tracker, blocker, etc.) on thread to prove your ability?? 😵
 
PippyPony said:
Whatever you want to call it, now the usefulness of it for village is thoroughly shot, since I doubt anyone's going to take any actions on her for the rest of the game.

Although, flipside: usefulness also shot for wolves lol
Click to expand...
Could still be useful for someone who wants to prove their ability, but that's pretty limited usefulness at this point.
 
genny said:
OMG hmoo.... you know I was in the PM between you and Dr. S, right? You want me to quote the part where you tell Dr. S she has seering powers?
Click to expand...

I'm capable of reading through, if I cared. I couldn't even remember what games I was a wolf in, I had to go through and look. I don't remember EVERY conversation I had with EVERY person related to WW. Sorry, I didn't remember my convo with her, but even if I did, it doesn't change the fact that my ability is my ability and I'm a villager, lol. I don't hand out the roles
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
64K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
48K
chicandtoughness
chicandtoughness
WildZoo
Supernatural: Angels & Demons WW Game Thread
121 122 123 124 125
Replies
6K
Views
80K
GoSpursGo
GoSpursGo
supershorty
GGoats ThWWee: Here It GGoats Again - GAME THREAD
93 94 95 96 97
Replies
5K
Views
68K
vampyrica
vampyrica
Animal Midwife
Matrix - Game Thread
77 78 79 80 81
Replies
4K
Views
94K
samac
samac
Top